Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

American food spots in Amity Harbor

American food that focuses on the basics done well instead of trying to reinvent the wheel with unnecessary additions.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Nyam Sum Jamaican Cuisine image 1
Nyam Sum Jamaican Cuisine image 2
Nyam Sum Jamaican Cuisine image 3
View all
Jamaican restaurant

Takeout-only spot offers authentic Jamaican cuisine with generous portions and natural seasoning. The atmosphere carries friendly vibes and the aroma of island spices. Food sells out early, so ordering ahead is common.

Food here features amazing portions and down home cuisine with simple, solid flavors. Service is fast and friendly, creating a clean and welcoming atmosphere.

Fried chicken appears often, served alongside rice and plantains. The jerk chicken also stands out as a favorite, with mac and cheese adding a creamy touch.

People are saying

"I thought the jerk chicken here was the best I had."

"The food here is authentic and tastes like a trip to Jamaica."

"The American Food here is so tender and flavorful."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is takeout only and does not offer dining in.

2

Parking can be difficult, so plan accordingly.

3

It's best to call in advance for the rasta pasta.

02
Peter's Diner image 1

Small diner with retro aspects and a vibe stretching from the 70s to now offers a cozy, quiet atmosphere. Regulars and staff appear happy, creating a classic neighborhood feel. The space feels warm and inviting, blending old-school charm with simple comfort.

Food comes out fresh and cooked exactly as requested. Dishes are consistently tasty and well-prepared.

Fried chicken specials come with soup, salad, a side, coffee, and dessert. The cheeseburger deluxe and Greek omelet with grits stand out as solid choices. Meatloaf dinner offers a unique flavor.

People are saying

"The diner food here is delicious and well-made."

"The American food here, especially the meatloaf, has a unique flavor."

"I found the food here to be delicious and great."

Good to know

1

The diner offers a kids menu perfect for toddlers.

2

Peter's Diner provides authentic Greek dishes.

3

There is plenty of parking available at the diner.

03
The Grand Lobby image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers cozy atmosphere with beautiful bar and French Louis XIV tapestry chairs. Space includes private room for events and two dining rooms catering to different moods. Decor features hand-painted mural and well-lit, inviting design.

Food here is consistently fresh and tasty with a focus on delivering a memorable dining experience. Dishes come out spectacular and delicious, backed by attentive ownership.

Brisket adds rich flavor to the French Onion Soup. The duck nachos stand out as a unique and tasty appetizer.

People are saying

"The food here was delicious and totally top-notch."

"It's a cozy and welcoming atmosphere."

"The American Food here is amazing; each item was better than the next."

Good to know

1

Making reservations is recommended to ensure an enjoyable experience.

2

There was convenient parking in the back.

3

The menu offers a great balance of creativity and comfort, with something for everyone.

04
Winnie's (Soul Food) image 1
Soul food restaurant

Soul food restaurant offers creamy baked Mac and Cheese and flavor-packed collard greens with a unique balance of spice and sweetness. Fried chicken and pork chops deliver tender, well-seasoned bites. Atmosphere feels welcoming with notably good service throughout.

Food here feels like homemade soul food with consistently delicious and amazing flavors. No information about food allergies is provided to customers.

Mac and Cheese comes out perfectly seasoned and creamy. Fried chicken offers a classic, crispy bite. Sweet potato cornbread tastes sweet and moist, winning over even picky eaters.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing."

"This American Food's collard greens burst with flavor and a unique zing."

Good to know

1

Customers should ask about food allergies before ordering.

2

There are no signs indicating allergens in sauces.

3

Staff may not mention allergens unless specifically asked.

05
Brownstones Coffee Amityville image 1
Breakfast restaurant

Rustic colonial decor with bright, open spaces and lots of windows creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Crowds gather quickly, making the vibe lively and sometimes loud, with seating that feels cozy but close. Seasonal decorations and sweet mimosas add festive touches to the breakfast experience.

Food here is consistently delicious and great during brunch. Service complements the meals well, making the overall experience solid.

Classic eggs Benedict stands out with a light, easy-to-eat texture. Homemade corned beef hash and breakfast potatoes add hearty, flavorful sides, while steak and eggs offer a solid, satisfying option.

People are saying

"I loved the coffee; it was so tasty and delicious."

"The food here is always fresh and delicious."

"Their American Food, especially the cornbread hash and eggs Benedict, is so good."

Good to know

1

Parking is difficult; seek spots elsewhere to avoid towing risks.

2

Arrive early to avoid long waits, especially on weekends.

3

Expect long wait times for seating during peak hours.

06
B & B Fish and Clam image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant combines fresh catch market with casual, family-friendly atmosphere featuring cozy, dim lighting. Seating blends with retail space, creating an open, lively environment that can get noisy during peak hours. Known for exceptionally fresh seafood and a welcoming vibe.

Fresh seafood stands out with consistently delicious and phenomenal flavors. The food maintains excellent quality and satisfies all family members.

Hot lobster rolls come buttery and packed with meat, offering a flavorful and appetizing experience. Clam chowder is rich and full of flavor, and the fries served alongside the lobster roll are great.

People are saying

"The seafood here is always fresh and delicious."

"The food here is delicious and cooked perfectly."

"The American Food here, especially the seafood, is so fresh."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for groups of 6 or more to ensure seating.

2

The $20 shrimp special includes two sides and multiple preparation options.

3

The seafood market offers fresh fish that can be cooked at home.

07
Pollo Campero image 1
Chicken restaurant

Chicken restaurant offers a pleasant atmosphere with busy energy and clean, comfortable seating. Music plays in the background, creating a lively vibe for families and friends. The place feels Americanized, resembling a fast food chain with reasonable prices.

Fried chicken stands out with its fresh, delicious taste. Sides like yuca fries, beans, and rice complement the meal well. Food quality is consistently excellent and flavorful.

Fried chicken stands out with its crispy texture and flavor. Sides include yuca fries, beans, and rice, while coleslaw comes drenched in vinegar. Nuggets come with a bun resembling a hot dog bun.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and fresh."

"It's really Kid Friendly; my kids loved their meals."

"The American food, especially the chicken, was pretty good."

Good to know

1

Parking can be difficult as handicapped spots are often occupied by unauthorized vehicles.

2

Expect long lines during peak hours, but they move at a reasonable pace.

3

Drive-thru is usually quick, with minimal wait times.

08
The Warehouse image 1
Live music venue

Large live music venue offers an elevated stage and fantastic sound system that supports local bands and intimate shows. The atmosphere is lively and fun, with plenty of space for dancing and mingling. Crowds gather for energetic performances, creating a vibrant and engaging experience.

Food comes fresh and tastes good with consistent quality. Good service complements the fresh food and adds to the overall experience.

Loaded Fries, Mac n Cheese Bites, and Grilled Chicken Salad come in huge portions and taste great. Cheeseburgers hit the mark, but fried chicken lacks seasoning and bold flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was delicious and freshly made."

"I found it's a great place for live music."

"The American food portions are huge, especially the appetizers."

Good to know

1

The cover charge is $18, which is higher than many other venues.

2

Parking is generally easy to find near the venue.

3

A two-drink minimum applies for entry, similar to comedy clubs.

Discover more

Amity Harbor, Amityville

Area guide
Loading Map...