Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in New York

Birthday cake

You need a birthday cake that respects the tradition of the occasion without relying on excessive, sugary gimmicks. A celebration deserves a centerpiece that actually tastes like it was made with intention.

Based on 739 Opinions
+736
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 1
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 2
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 3
View all

Cozy bakery offers custom birthday cakes with vibrant rainbow layers and fun themes like Minions. Friendly staff ensure orders are on time and delicious. Enjoy the warm atmosphere and relaxing outdoor seating for casual meetups.

Custom birthday cakes come in rainbow layers and themed designs like Minions. Coconut cakes taste just right, not too sweet. Orders complete on time with beautiful, tasty results.

People are saying

"This bakery made my daughter's birthday cake exactly as I requested."

"I found the cake to be beautiful and delicious."

"I thought the birthday cake was gorgeous and delicious."

Good to know

1

Visitors should get to the bakery early on weekends to try new items, as they sell out.

2

Ingredients could be modified due to allergens for special events.

3

Delivery from Crumbly is always on time.

02
Bizcocho Dominicano de Carmen image 1

Small bakery fills with warm aromas and butterfly decor. Carmen crafts last-minute birthday cakes with care. Spot offers authentic Dominican cakes in a cozy, stress-free space.

Carmen makes last-minute birthday cakes quickly and with care. She creates special cakes that people trust for important celebrations.

People are saying

"This Dominican cake is moist, delicious, and truly spectacular."

"This cake is so delicious, my kids haven't eaten cake from anyone else since."

"This Dominican Birthday Cake is moist, flavorful, and not too sweet."

Good to know

1

Place orders at least three days in advance for cakes.

2

Carmen specializes in authentic Dominican cakes with various fillings.

3

Cakes are popular for special occasions like gender reveal events.

03
Buttermilk Bakeshop image 1

Small bakery shines with custom birthday cakes like Spider-Man and Confetti themes. Interior is adorable and stunning, creating a charming vibe. Focus on takeout and special orders keeps space clean and organized.

Birthday cakes come in custom themes like Spider-Man and classic styles such as Confetti. Cakes serve groups up to 13 and are ordered repeatedly for family celebrations.

People are saying

"I found the cake to be beautiful and delicious."

"You'd never know the gluten-free cake was gluten-free; it's delicious."

"The birthday cake is beautiful and delicious."

Good to know

1

The cake is ready at the designated pickup time.

2

The ordering and pickup process are super easy.

3

Buttermilk Bakeshop accommodates vegan and gluten-free guests by clearly marking everything.

04
Frenchy's Cake Designs LLC image 1

Bakery offers meticulous craftsmanship with artistic birthday cakes featuring precise color matching. Cakes are moist and flavorful, perfect for celebrations. Ordering is easy with a seamless online system and smooth pickup.

Custom birthday cakes come with artistic designs and precise color matching. Cakes have been ordered repeatedly for multiple years, showing consistent quality and attention to detail.

People are saying

"The cake designs are amazing and the taste is delicious."

"The cakes here are stunning and taste amazing for kids' birthdays."

"This birthday cake was a work of art and tasted amazing."

Good to know

1

Frenchy's Cake Design creates monthly cakes for South Bronx Job Corps staff birthdays.

2

The cake was ready in time for the party.

3

The cake is affordable and reasonably priced.

05
ByClio Bakery image 1

Cozy bakery shines with natural light and a quiet vibe. Vegan mocha birthday cakes stand out for allergy-friendly options and beautiful presentation. Guests enjoy unique flavors while watching bakers at work in an intimate setting.

Offers vegan mocha birthday cakes and accommodates allergies for special dietary needs. Cakes are consistently beautiful and tasty, with options for advance ordering and pickup across cities.

People are saying

"The cakes here are amazing, beautiful, and delicious."

"The cakes here have unique flavors and gorgeous designs."

"This birthday cake was moist and had incredible flavor."

Good to know

1

No restroom is available for customers, so plan ahead.

2

The price of a slice of specialty cake is $12.

3

You can get a whole cake for any special occasion.

06
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 1

Cozy bakery offers custom birthday cakes with detailed designs like dinosaurs. Rustic wooden accents create a warm vibe, while beautiful decor adds charm. Cakes and desserts are delicious and memorable, perfect for celebrations.

Custom birthday cakes come with detailed designs like dinosaur themes and match exact requests. Cakes are beautiful and delicious, often ordered last-minute and loved by kids and adults alike.

People are saying

"The custom cake came out exactly how I imagined it."

"I thought the cheesecake here was great."

"I ordered a birthday cake that was stunning and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for custom cake orders, especially for weekends.

2

The bakery offers a variety of gluten-free and vegan options.

3

Cakes are prepared in advance and may not be freshly baked.

07
Cakes by Nerwan image 1

Offers custom designs with fresh, visually stunning desserts like cannoli cupcakes and kunafsicles. Atmosphere is chic but lacks warmth. Pricing is high, matching the elevated experience.

Birthday cakes come in unique flavors like cannoli and aperol spritz cupcakes with orange and vanilla. Custom designs are made from a single inspiration picture.

People are saying

"I found the cake to be beautiful and delicious."

"Their Dubai chocolate version was designed like an ice bar."

"The birthday cake here is just delicious."

Good to know

1

Cakes by Nerwan allows customers to select the design, flavor, filling, and color of the cake.

2

The best way to order cupcakes is through their website.

3

The cake was ready under a 24-hour timeline.

08
The Sweet Peace image 1

Bakery crafts nut-free treats with custom designs that impress. Cakes arrive on short notice, perfect for birthday celebrations. Atmosphere feels caring, focusing on detailed artistry and allergy safety.

Cakes come with short notice and are made with love. The team handles wedding and birthday cakes consistently.

People are saying

"Allison's custom cake designs are creative and perfectly match your vision."

"These cupcakes are moist, flavorful, and absolutely delicious."

"Allison made my vision for the birthday cake even better than I expected."

Good to know

1

Cakes require a two weeks advance notice for custom orders.

2

The bakery accommodates nut allergies and offers allergen-free options.

3

Prices are reasonable and reflect the quality of the baked goods.

09
Perfect Sweets in Auburndale image 1

Cozy cafe offers house-made pastries and exceptional coffee in a peaceful setting. Customizable birthday cakes impress with quality and design. Soft music adds to the charming interior atmosphere.

Customizable birthday cakes stand out here with beautiful designs. The cakes consistently impress with their quality and appearance.

People are saying

"These cookies are pillowy, chewy, and perfectly sweet."

"The bakery's pastries and cakes are amazing and flavorful."

"I loved how custom and beautiful my birthday cake turned out."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of 10-20 minutes during peak hours.

2

Credit cards are accepted, along with mobile payment options.

3

Special orders for events require at least 48 hours notice.

10
Butterly Bakeshop image 1

Cozy spot with moist cupcakes and rich banana pudding delights sweet lovers. Birthday cakes are fresh and attractive, perfect even on short notice. Limited seating and a warm vibe make it a charming choice for casual treats.

Birthday cakes come out fresh, delicious, and attractive even with short notice. They rank among the yummiest in the city and have been a reliable choice for multiple years.

People are saying

"They recreated my custom cake design perfectly."

"This cookie's texture is unreal, perfectly crisp outside and chewy inside."

"They recreated my custom Birthday Cake design perfectly."

Good to know

1

The bakery is closed on Mondays.

2

The bakery offers great vegan and gluten-free options.

3

There is not much indoor seating available as the space is very narrow.

11
LITTLE SHARK image 1

Bakery offers custom birthday cakes with quick owner contact and detailed designs like Numberblocks. Cakes are light and fluffy with intricate decorations matching customer ideas. Soft desserts like mochi and macarons add a modern, cute atmosphere.

Custom birthday cakes get made quickly with direct owner contact. Numberblocks themes and other designs come out well and please everyone.

People are saying

"You have to try the cake; it's delicious and beautiful."

"This place is so Kid Friendly; the cakes are amazing and not too sweet."

"I designed a custom birthday cake and they pulled it off."

Good to know

1

Delivery is available for an additional cost.

2

Delivery costs $10/15 for Flushing and $30 for LIC.

3

The prices of the macarons are reasonable.

12
Delicioustreats image 1

Beautifully decorated cakes here make birthdays special with perfect birthday cakes that impress guests. Rich, moist interiors deliver flavorful taste every time. Ordering is easy and prices are fair, with reliable last-minute fulfillment available.

Perfect birthday cakes come from here, making celebrations feel special. Cakes often receive compliments at parties, showing their appeal.

People are saying

"Their cakes are so moist and full of flavor."

"I got a perfect birthday cake that was beautifully decorated."

Good to know

1

Placing an order is straightforward and quick.

2

Pricing for cakes is reasonable and competitive.

3

Pickup of orders is convenient and hassle-free.

13
Oh.Sweet.Mason [Desserts, Custom Birthday Cake & Specialty Cupcakes] image 1

Cozy bakery offers custom birthday cakes with quick turnaround and great taste. Friendly staff create intricate fondant toppers like sushi and casino chips. Unique dessert jars include biscoff cookie cheesecake and cinnamon toast crunch cheesecake.

Custom birthday cakes come through even on short notice. Cakes impress with great taste and presentation.

People are saying

"I commissioned a masterpiece cake with a stunning theme."

"The desserts here are delicious and not too sweet."

"The birthday cake here is amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Oh.Sweet.Mason provides desserts and sweet treats for events.

2

They offer a variety of cake and cheesecake shooters.

3

Cupcakes are available but may be pricey due to special decorations.

14
Dog Cakes for Dogs image 1

Cakes feature edible pet portraits and arrive beautifully packaged. Birthday cakes suit special occasions like a dog's 5th birthday with options for multiple dogs. Varied treats like pizza cake and pup cupcakes create a memorable experience for dogs and owners.

Birthday cakes come with edible pictures and cater to dogs. Options include ordering multiple cakes for different dogs. Cakes suit special occasions like a dog's 5th birthday party.

People are saying

"My dog loved the cake and kept trying to get more."

"I ordered a dog-friendly cake for a special celebration."

"I got a birthday cake that looked just like my dog."

Good to know

1

Cakes are well-packaged and arrive safely from New York to Las Vegas.

2

Delivery is typically completed in less than a week.

3

The service ensures cakes arrive on time for celebrations.

15
Bakelicious By Chef Manny Inc image 1

Cozy bakery shines with custom birthday cakes that match any theme and boast strong flavor. Spotless decor creates a warm, inviting space where families enjoy authentic pastries. Every detail shows pride and dedication, making it a top spot for celebrations.

Custom birthday cakes feature detailed decorations and strong flavor that impress many. Cakes often match specific images or themes, like a Marshmello design or crema de leche flavor.

People are saying

"I found the cake here to be so moist and delicious."

"This family-owned spot's tres leches cakes are rich, moist, and perfectly balanced."

"This birthday cake was beautiful and delicious!"

Good to know

1

The bakery takes custom orders for cakes.

2

The tres leches cake costs $5.

3

The establishment is very clean.

16
Vilma's Bakery image 1

Bakery shines with moist tres leches and marble birthday cakes perfect for big celebrations. Warm, family-run hospitality creates a calm, welcoming vibe. Known for Delicious Dominican cakes, it feels like home with adorable decoration.

Birthday cakes come in moist tres leches and marble flavors with beautiful designs. Large cakes suit milestone celebrations like 70th birthdays and kids' parties.

People are saying

"I thought the cake was delicious and beautifully decorated."

"These empanadas are so delicious and flavorful."

"I thought the birthday cake was so delicious and beautiful."

Good to know

1

The ordering, payment, and pickup process are all easy and smooth.

2

Order was ready on time for my event.

3

They can deliver custom cake designs upon request.

17
Conti's Pastry Shoppe image 1

Bakery shines with custom birthday cakes like Boston Cream, perfect for celebrations. Italian pastries are neatly displayed in a vintage atmosphere with a modern twist. Outdoor seating and a full coffee bar make it inviting for all visitors.

Birthday cakes come in custom designs and are ordered repeatedly for family celebrations. Cakes like Boston Cream and other pastries appear regularly for birthdays and special occasions.

People are saying

"They executed the custom cake design exactly to my vision."

"The pastries here are beautiful, fresh, and delicious."

"This birthday cake is beautiful and absolutely delicious."

Good to know

1

You should preorder your custom cake in advance around the holidays due to high demand.

2

The bakery has a 2-day notice for placing cake orders.

3

Expect long lines on holidays like Christmas Eve due to high customer volume.

18
Patsy's and Son Italian Bakery image 1

Old school bakery offers classic Italian pastries and handmade cakes with authentic taste. Birthday cakes impress with exceptional detail and handle last-minute orders well. Friendly atmosphere makes it perfect for special occasions.

Delicious taste and exceptional attention to detail define the birthday cakes here. Cakes look amazing and come through well even with last-minute orders.

People are saying

"This bakery's cakes are stunning and taste incredible."

"Victoria brought my cake vision to life a million times better."

"This birthday cake tasted delicious and looked amazing."

Good to know

1

Patsy's offers a variety of pastries, cookies, and cakes.

2

Single-serving cakes are available in many flavors.

3

Metered parking is available out front.

19
Cream Espresso Bar & Bakery image 1

Small, clean bakery offers a quiet atmosphere perfect for family or friends. Cakes impress with beautiful designs and flavors like oreo mousse. Pastries are delicious and not overly sweet, making it a great spot for birthdays and casual treats.

Cakes feature beautiful designs and delicious flavors like oreo mousse. Orders for birthdays of all ages come out well and impress guests.

People are saying

"The cakes here are so delicious and fresh."

"The pastries here are so fresh, flaky, and packed with flavor."

"This birthday cake is delicious and perfectly moist."

Good to know

1

The bakery does special orders for cookies and custom cakes.

2

Parking is available, but the lot may not be desirable.

3

A round 10" cake feeds 15-20 people, perfect for events.

20
The Cake Lady Desserts and Cafe image 1

Moist cakes with balanced buttercream shine here. Birthday cakes get special care, perfect for any age, even an 80th birthday. Cozy spot with dim lighting invites you to enjoy cupcakes or carrot cake right away.

Beautiful and delicious birthday cakes come from here. Cakes for all ages, including an 80th birthday cake, get made with care.

People are saying

"They really understood my vision for the custom cake design."

"The cakes here are moist, delicious, and beautifully decorated."

"This birthday cake was so beautiful and delicious!"

Good to know

1

You can buy slices of cake or order whole cakes ahead of time.

2

The shop does not have ready-made whole cakes available for immediate purchase.

3

There are about 15 flavors of cakes, cookies, and pies to choose from.

21
Sweet Touch by Iva image 1
Wedding bakery

Rustic design and impeccable craftsmanship make every cake a standout. Birthday cakes are beautiful and reliable, perfect for special celebrations. Warm, inviting atmosphere adds to the charm, making it a true hidden gem.

Birthday cakes come out beautiful and consistently impress. Orders for daughters' birthdays happen repeatedly, showing reliable quality.

People are saying

"I thought the cake was beautiful and delicious."

"The cakes here are beautiful and perfect for kid-friendly parties."

"I found the birthday cakes here perfect in taste and appearance."

Good to know

1

The ordering process is easy and can be done online.

2

Delivery options are available and reasonably priced.

3

Custom cakes can be created in as little as 48 hours.

22
Dulce de Leche Cake Shop image 1

Beautifully crafted cakes with spectacular appearance and rich dulce de leche delight the taste buds. Well-made empanadas add savory balance in a lovely atmosphere. Perfect for birthdays, they offer beautiful designs and handle occasions with care.

Cakes here come with beautiful designs and delicious flavors. They handle all occasions from weddings to birthdays with care and discretion.

People are saying

"The cake here is so delicious and beautifully made."

"You have to try their empanadas, especially the corn and bacon ones."

"This birthday cake was so delicious and beautifully made."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay premium prices for high-quality baked goods.

2

The shop is known for its rich and flavorful Dulce de Leche cake.

3

Custom cake orders require at least a week's notice.

23
Wildly Cakes & Sweets LLC image 1

Custom cakes and cookies feature artistic design with themes like Mickey Mouse and Lego. Vegan and allergy-conscious options ensure special dietary needs are met. Birthday cakes shine with sparkling rose gold and detailed decorations, all easy to order and pick up.

Birthday cakes come in sparkling rose gold and red velvet with detailed decorations like orange musical notes and a 3D guitar. All cakes and treats are beautiful to look at and delicious to eat.

People are saying

"The cake here is stunning, creative, and delicious!"

"Their custom cakes are beautiful, delicious, and a hit with kids."

"The birthday cake here is beautiful and delicious."

Good to know

1

The bakery accommodates dairy-free and vegan cake requests.

2

Ordering from the bakery is easy and straightforward.

3

Pick-up of cakes is seamless and well-organized.

24
Nikkie's Devine Desserts image 1

Bakery shines with exquisite key lime birthday cakes that arrive fresh even on short notice. Custom designs offer moist, flavorful textures perfect for special occasions. Dairy-free and sugarless options taste authentic and balanced for all guests.

Exquisite key lime flavor stands out in the birthday cakes here. Orders get accepted on short notice, and the cakes come out absolutely amazing.

People are saying

"Nikki's cakes are amazing and she's so attentive to detail."

"Nikkie saved the day with an amazing birthday cake on short notice."

Good to know

1

Nikki can create custom cakes with short notice, often within three days.

2

The bakery offers dairy-free cake options for those with dietary restrictions.

3

Customization options are available, unlike many other bakeries in the area.

25
Sugar & Cake Fantasies Bakery image 1

Small, clean space with artistic style and creative cake designs. Talented bakers craft detailed, flavorful pastries that satisfy all ages. Prices are higher but quality and custom birthday cakes stand out.

Birthday cakes here satisfy different ages, from babies to adults. Both simple and special orders meet expectations with custom designs and fresh ingredients.

People are saying

"The cake was delicious, moist, and light."

"This bakery's cake was amazing and delicious."

"This birthday cake is delicious and everyone loved how it looked."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers creative and unique design options for cakes.

2

The price for a single cupcake is $10.

3

Don Bolivar offers a variety of flavors.

26
Carvel image 1
Ice cream shop

Huge shop offers many soft serve flavors like Coffee and Pistachio. Family-owned vibe makes it welcoming with custom photo birthday cakes and tasty sundaes. Locals love the friendly deals and consistent cake quality.

Birthday cakes feature custom photo printing and consistent quality. The shop handles birthday cakes reliably over many years.

People are saying

"The daily buy-one-get-one-free ice cream deals are amazing!"

"I ordered a custom cake and it was beautifully made."

"I've relied on their birthday cakes with the crunchies for years."

Good to know

1

This location offers a buy-one-get-one-free deal on large sundaes every day.

2

Ordering a large soft serve gets you another free every day of the week.

3

Wednesday's buy-one-get-one-free promotion is popular for filling the freezer.

27
Padoca Bakery image 1

Small bakery offers custom birthday cakes with fast turnaround and simple ordering. Cozy indoor seating and a bright outdoor patio create a welcoming spot for gatherings. Locals love the inviting space and relaxed energy throughout.

Custom birthday cakes come with a fast turnaround and a simple ordering process. Options include themed cakes like a fire truck design and deliver consistent delicious flavors.

People are saying

"Their cake designs are gorgeous, quirky, and fun."

"Their coffee, especially with house-made vanilla, is delicious."

"This birthday cake was truly delicious and looked fantastic."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted, and seating is limited.

2

The bakery does not have a restroom available for customers.

3

Customers can only submit or change orders via email.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...