Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of New York

Birthday cake spots

You need an Italian restaurant that can provide a birthday cake that actually tastes like it came from a bakery.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Leonetti Pastry Shop image 1
Leonetti Pastry Shop image 2
Leonetti Pastry Shop image 3
View all

Beautiful bakery with a modern, chic interior and cozy seating creates a warm, inviting atmosphere reminiscent of an Italian cafรฉ. The vibe is relaxing and classy, suitable for studying or casual conversation. Known for exceptional pastries and cakes, it stands out as a top-tier pastry shop.

Cannoli cake stands out as a special treat for celebrations. Focaccia bread offers a rich, flavorful bite. Desserts like tiramisu cake and lobster tails add variety to the Italian selection.

Birthday cakes come from here regularly. This spot serves as a go-to for special occasion cakes.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be the most delicious."

"I always got my birthday cakes here."

"The staff and atmosphere at this Italian Food place were amazing."

Good to know

1

Parking in the rear is limited due to the small mall.

2

The shop closes at 7 pm, so plan your visit accordingly.

3

They play music on some Fridays, creating a lively atmosphere.

02
Cafe Commerce image 1
Restaurant

Saffron-colored walls and a beautiful mural create a classic New York vibe in a small, cozy space. Warm lighting and excellent music at just the right volume set a charming atmosphere reminiscent of Parisian bistros. The bar offers a lively spot for two when booths are unavailable, while seating can feel snug.

Pasta dishes like carbonara and rigatoni stand out for their authentic flavors. The menu also features branzino and other Italian staples that complement the pasta well.

Sweet and delicious, the birthday cake dessert always comes with a candle. It stands out as a delightful way to end a meal and pairs well with other dishes like rigatoni and tortellini.

People are saying

"You have to try the coconut cake; it's a must-try."

"The rigatoni carbonara is creamy, rich, and a standout Italian dish."

"The birthday cake is moist, flavorful, and a delicious way to end a meal."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required and can only be made through email or Resy.

2

Expect long wait times due to the restaurant's popularity, especially on weekends.

3

The restaurant offers a complimentary bread service with every entrรฉe ordered.

03
Jhoanes Bakery & Coffee image 1

Bright, modern space with colorful decor and heart-shaped spoons adds charm. Atmosphere stays calm and cozy, inviting guests to relax or work with good outlet access. Live music and visible pastry crafting create a unique, artistic vibe that blends comfort with creativity.

Tiramisu stands out with its layer of creaminess and comes served in all chocolate latte cups. The dessert is consistently delicious and highly recommended.

Birthday cakes come out visually stunning and moist, flavorful, and sweet. Caramel tres leches is a popular choice. Many order cakes here every year for birthdays and special occasions.

People are saying

"I found the desserts here to be truly to die for."

"This birthday cake is gorgeous and delicious."

"I loved the tiramisu; it's the best Italian food I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The dessert menu does not have prices listed.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

3

Reservations are recommended for special occasions.

04
Gramercy Tavern image 1
New American restaurant

Contemporary interior combines warmth and natural floral decor with a layout that splits between fine dining and casual tavern areas. Atmosphere stays classy and quieter than typical city restaurants, supporting pleasant conversations despite occasional crowd noise. A sommelier and cozy outdoor seating enhance the dining experience.

Squid ink pasta with lobster stands out alongside the sea bass with an Asian flavor profile that balances delicate and bold. The menu also features cucumber soup and pesto focaccia, with risotto prepared by visiting chefs.

Surprise mini birthday cakes add a special touch to celebrations. The pastry chef crafts vegan cakes that fool even picky eaters with ingredients like carrots and bananas.

People are saying

"The food here is fantastic, with seasonal dishes and high-quality ingredients."

"The Italian food here is amazing, with thoughtful touches and unforgettable hospitality."

"They surprised me with an adorable mini birthday cake."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required, especially during peak times and special events.

2

Happy hour runs from 4pm to 6pm with $6 wine and beer and $12 cocktails.

3

The restaurant participates in NYC's summer restaurant week with special menus.

05
Buono Bakery image 1

Bakery offers authentic Italian pastries with amazing aroma and exceptional taste. Space feels outdated and atmosphere is unwelcoming. Cakes and baked goods attract attention for special occasions.

Freshly filled cannolis stand out with their crisp shells and creamy texture. The cannoli cake features mini cannolis on top, combining layers of flavor. Other pastries like lobster tails and seven-layer cakes also show solid Italian dessert craftsmanship.

Vanilla sponge with vanilla pudding and whipped cream forms the base of the birthday cake. Large strawberries add a fresh touch to this authentic Italian style old-world cake that many find delicious.

People are saying

"The bakery staff is so friendly and makes you feel at home."

"The cannolis here are freshly filled and delicious."

"This birthday cake was a hit with everyone; it was delicious."

Good to know

1

They charge a four percent surcharge if you use a credit card.

2

The bakery offers a variety of desserts including strawberry shortcake, rainbow cake, and cookies.

3

If you want a specific character on your cake, you will need to get an edible picture.

06
Tasty Pastry Shoppe image 1

Bright, clean bakery offers wide gluten-free and sugar-free selection alongside traditional treats. Space feels tight and busy, especially on weekends, but lines move quickly. Known for exceptional cheesecake and cakes, it caters well to diverse dietary needs.

Cannoli stand out with rich fillings and crisp shells. Chocolate mousse and chocolate covered cannoli add a sweet twist, while prosciutto bread and cake offer savory and dessert options.

Delicious birthday cakes come with beautiful designs that suit all ages. Cakes for first and third birthdays show consistent quality and care.

People are saying

"I thought their cakes and pastries were better than I could imagine."

"I thought the birthday cake was delicious and moist."

"The Italian Food here is phenomenal, so creamy and delicious."

Good to know

1

The shop gets really busy on weekends, but the line moves fast.

2

They offer a wide variety of gluten-free, sugar-free, and vegan options.

3

Small slices of pastries cost about $3 each.

07
Artuso Pastry Shop image 1

Spacious bakery with old-school charm and a family atmosphere offers a wide selection of colorful, fresh pastries and cakes. The place feels cozy and clean, inviting guests to enjoy the simple, delicious surroundings while exploring traditional treats.

Cannolis stand out as a signature item, often praised for their flavor and quality. The tiramisu and cheesecakes also receive consistent positive mentions for their taste and presentation.

Vanilla sponge birthday cakes come with chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Cakes are available for last minute orders and consistently delicious.

People are saying

"I found the cakes here to be so fresh and delicious."

"I loved the birthday cake; it tasted wonderful."

"I thought their Italian Food cannolis were delicious."

Good to know

1

You need to get a ticket as you enter.

2

The numbered ticket system should always be used.

3

Some items sell out towards the end of the day.

08
Fortunato Brothers image 1

Small Italian American bakery with authentic Italian charm and a classic 1980s mall food court vibe. Atmosphere feels like a cozy Napoli cafe with plenty of indoor seating and a chill, family-oriented energy. Known for unique Italian pastries and a well-kept, nostalgic environment.

Cannolis stand out with their authentic taste and variety, including mini versions popular for parties. Italian pastries like biscotti, rainbow cookies, and tiramisu complement strong espresso or cappuccino offerings.

Birthday cakes come fresh and include options like rainbow cookie cheesecake and rum cake. Cakes and sweets consistently please with their delicious taste.

People are saying

"I thought the espresso here was just like in Italy."

"You have to try the cannoli; they're the best Italian food I've ever tasted."

"The birthday cake here is delicious and not too sweet."

Good to know

1

They are completely peanut free, making it a great option for those with a peanut allergy.

2

The public bathroom is possibly the cleanest Iโ€™ve ever used.

3

The prices are very reasonable.

09
Rimini Pastry Shoppe image 1

Tiny, old-school Italian bakery with beautiful presentations and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Pastries and cakes are fresh and delicious, featuring standout items like cannoli and cheesecake. Space feels cramped on busy days, adding to a bustling, cozy vibe.

Cannolis stand out with perfect taste and beautiful presentation, though some can be a bit soggy. A variety of fresh Italian pastries like sfogiatellle, napoleons, tiramisu, and prosciutto bread complement the selection.

Birthday cakes come in medium sizes and include options like mouse-shaped and tres leches. Some cakes taste delicious, but others look soft and like shaving cream, which can be embarrassing to serve.

People are saying

"The cakes here taste amazing and look gorgeous."

"I always get the most delicious birthday cake here."

"Their Italian pastries, especially the cannolis, are so fresh."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a wide variety of fresh pastries, breads, and cakes.

2

Prices are reasonable compared to other bakeries in the area.

3

All products are made fresh daily, ensuring quality and taste.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...