Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Frozen yogurt and cookie spots in New York

A swirl of frozen yogurt topped with a crumbled cookie is the only thing that hits the spot right now.

Based on 727 Opinions
+724
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01

General store combines historic charm with modern design and thoughtful curation. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, attracting a diverse crowd including locals, artists, and beachgoers. Outdoor seating areas encourage gathering, enhancing the sense of community.

Extensive frozen yogurt flavors and a wide range of toppings create variety. The frozen yogurt pairs well with other items like biscuit bites and coffee.

Fresh-baked cookies fill the air with a warm aroma alongside rotisserie chicken. The bakery offers a great coffee bar and good cookies that parents enjoy.

People are saying

"The buttery biscuit breakfast sandwich melts in your mouth."

"This place feels like pure magic, you won't want to leave."

"The frozen yogurt here has the best flavors and toppings."

Good to know

1

The store sells out of breakfast sandwiches quickly, so arrive early.

2

The store functions as both a post office and a general store.

3

Expect a thoughtfully curated selection of local produce, flowers, and baked goods.

02
Fly Me To The Moon- Cafe image 1

Cozy cafe with modern, clean design and floral decorations creates a charming, intimate atmosphere. Small seating area suits quiet study or casual chats, enhanced by pleasant music and welcoming vibes. Space feels neat and inviting, making it a relaxing spot to work or unwind.

Frozen yogurt here is decadent and velvety with lavish flavors that stand out from other spots. The Mango Oolong Float pairs perfect tea with excellent frozen yogurt for a unique treat.

Warm, moist cookies feature a chewier texture from brown sugar and a subtle sweetness. The Moon Warm Cookies, a chocolate chip version, stand out alongside the delicious N.A. tarts.

People are saying

"You have to try their frozen yogurt flavors, especially white peach."

"The frozen yogurt here is so rich and velvety."

"The croffles are not too sweet, especially the mango and strawberry ones."

Good to know

1

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

2

The menu includes Korean-style croffles, fusion kimbap, and acai bowls.

3

The cafe has a good amount of seating available for customers.

03
Mrs.Fields, TCBY image 1
Cookie shop

Warm, cozy space filled with the smell of freshly baked cookies and rich ice cream creates a welcoming vibe. Soft, fresh cookies and creamy frozen yogurt attract those craving quality sweet treats. Family-run atmosphere adds a personal, heartfelt touch to the experience.

TCBY frozen yogurt draws attention with its variety and smooth texture. Many enjoy pairing it with smoothies for a refreshing treat.

Cookies come out fresh, soft, and full of flavor. Chocolate chip and white chocolate macadamia varieties stand out for their chewy texture and rich taste.

People are saying

"These cookies are warm, soft, and incredibly delicious."

"The ice cream here is super creamy and flavorful."

"I thought the frozen yogurt and cookies here were the best."

Good to know

1

The cookie cake can be prepared in under 10 minutes.

2

They offer different sizes of cookies, including small bite-sized and large ones.

3

Everything is fresh and made with quality ingredients.

04
Yogurt Club image 1
Frozen yogurt shop

Small storefront with a kiosk setup creates an intimate space. Atmosphere feels friendly and inviting, often getting quite crowded. Known for thick Greek yogurt, Dubai chewy cookies, and a vegan vanilla option, it offers a healthy sweet treat vibe with a focus on quality ingredients.

Frozen yogurt offers a tangy Greek tart flavor that stands out. Vegan vanilla and Dubai chocolate options add variety, with honeycomb toppings recalling a signature raw honeycomb from Korea.

Thick, gooey, and crunchy, the Dubai chewy cookies come in intense pistachio, chocolate, and Biscoff flavors. Made fresh daily, they have a perfect filling ratio and include a Hazelnut version stuffed with Nutella knafeh and coated with toasted almonds.

People are saying

"The Dubai chocolate cookie is insanely good and delicious."

"The Greek yogurt bowl with matcha shell is a must-try."

"The frozen yogurt here is thick with the right amount of flavor."

Good to know

1

The froyo costs around $10 for the smallest size with one topping.

2

Toppings cost between $1.50 and $3.00 each.

3

The Dubai chewy cookie is made fresh daily and is a must-try.

05
The Gyro Project image 1
Greek restaurant

Small cafe with beautiful decor and casual takeout style offers a warm, vibrant atmosphere that balances relaxed and lively energy. Seating feels comfortable without being cramped, and music stays upbeat but not overpowering. The space reflects a labor of love with attention to detail and a unique, fun vibe.

Frozen yogurt offers a light and indulgent dessert option that feels both nutritious and gluten-free. It tastes delightful and leaves a satisfying, fresh feeling after eating.

Lemon blueberry and orange pie cookies melt in your mouth. The cookie stands out as a crowning jewel with rich, fresh flavors.

People are saying

"The Greek food here is delicious and authentic."

"I thought the frozen yogurt was the best I ever had."

"I found the cookie to be a crowning jewel."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a variety of menu items including bowls, wraps, and lattes.

2

Expect a casual atmosphere with limited seating available.

3

The prices are considered high for the portion sizes offered.

06
Torrisi image 1
Italian restaurant

Space combines warm tones and vintage greens with high vaulted ceilings for a luxurious dining atmosphere. Music blends soul, jazz, and 70โ€™s R&B, creating a lively yet refined vibe. Cocktails and Italian dishes feature bold, unique flavors that match the elegant setting.

Frozen yogurt comes out with a fluffy texture like fresh-churned ice cream and features unique flavors like olive oil and Campari. It often includes toppings like pink-grapefruit pulp and is made fresh using liquid nitrogen.

Complimentary cookies include an almond cookie that tastes like cookie dough and a sesame cracker that is perfectly crunchy without breaking teeth.

People are saying

"The tortellini here is probably the best Iโ€™ve ever had."

"The cookies here are unreal and very delicious."

"The frozen yogurt's olive oil and grapefruit zest was so fluffy."

Good to know

1

Reservations open 30 days in advance but fill instantly.

2

Getting a reservation is super hard unless you want to wait in line right before they open at 5 PM.

3

If you canโ€™t get a reservation, arrive before 5 PM to wait in line for walk-in seating at the bar.

07
Anita La Mamma del Gelato image 1

Colorful gelato displays fill a beautifully decorated space with indoor and outdoor seating. The atmosphere blends sophisticated design with a fun, lively vibe, supported by loud music and energetic energy. Outdoor tables offer a pleasant spot for people watching and enjoying fresh air.

Frozen yogurt comes in a towering 15 cm high swirl with unlimited toppings allowed as long as it fits. It tastes very tasty and not too sweet, sometimes even better than the gelato offered.

Chocolate cookies stand out with a rich, memorable flavor. Cookies come paired with ice cream, including Cookie Monster and vanilla varieties that add variety to the experience.

People are saying

"This gelato is the best ice cream I ever had."

"The chocolate cookies here are amazing, I'd come back just for them."

"You can have unlimited toppings for the frozen yogurt."

Good to know

1

Expect a long line at night because it is a very popular place.

2

Anita's is open until midnight.

3

The gelato is very expensive at $9 after tax.

08
Zabar's image 1
Gourmet grocery store

Gourmet grocery store with old-world charm and an edgy omni-deli ambiance filled with the aroma of specialty cheeses and coffee. Crowded with serious shoppers, the atmosphere can feel tense but remains a local institution known for its unique bakery and extensive gourmet cookwear upstairs.

Tart frozen yogurt stands out with a proper coffee flavor in the soft serve version. A small serving costs $3.99, offering a reasonable price for a very good frozen yogurt experience.

Black and white cookies stand out for their soft texture and balanced icing. Chocolate chunk cookies also appear alongside a fantastic array of jams and cookies.

People are saying

"I thought the bagels here were the greatest ever."

"I had a black and white cookie that was very good."

"I found the frozen yogurt here to be very refreshing and superior."

Good to know

1

Parking is abysmal, so plan accordingly.

2

There is no restroom available for customers.

3

The #1 subway stop is right next to Zabar's for easy access.

09
Culture An American Yogurt Company & Juice Bar by Culture image 1

Frozen yogurt made on premises appears behind a large glass window, creating a fresh, authentic feel. Indoor seating is cozy but limited, with a few outdoor seats available. The atmosphere is chill and comfortable, attracting those who appreciate tart, healthy flavors without excessive sweetness.

Frozen yogurt here is simple, plain, and probiotic-rich with a tart, not too sweet flavor. Fruit toppings stay very fresh, and sugar-free options are available.

Biscoff and oatmeal raisin cookie crumbs add distinctive flavors to desserts. Yogurt cookie sandwiches and frozen yogurt come with toppings like dark chocolate sauce and Oreo cookie crumbs.

People are saying

"The mochi here is really good and not too sweet."

"I thought the frozen yogurt here was the best and tasted so fresh."

"The yogurt tasted authentic and not overly sweet."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of 10-15 minutes during peak hours.

2

Prices for frozen yogurt start at $10 for a medium cup with toppings.

3

There is no bathroom available for paying customers.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...