Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of New York

Cookie and sorbet

You want the contrast of a warm cookie and a cold sorbet. You know exactly how the two should balance each other out.

Based on 690 Opinions
+687
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream image 1
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream image 2
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream image 3
View all
Ice cream shop

Spacious ice cream shop with a warm, welcoming vibe and bright, clean interior. Offers a flavor lab for creating unique, experimental flavors and a wide variety of vegan options. Seating includes a large circle table inside and pleasant outdoor seating.

Brown sugar cookie dough brownie stands out with its rich, brown sugar and cookie dough chunks. Vegan options like the cookies and cream flavor include big cookie pieces and balance sweetness well.

Mango sorbet stands out with its fresh flavor and suits a hot day well. Rose sorbet offers a pleasant taste alongside other tasty sorbet options.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was the best I ever had."

"You have to try the mango sorbet; it tastes so fresh."

"The vegan cookie and cream ice cream has amazing big chunks of cookie."

Good to know

1

They offer a variety of vegan and gluten-free ice cream options.

2

The shop makes exclusive flavors and fresh batches on site.

3

Expect to pay extra for toppings beyond the base price.

02
Rito Gelato image 1
Ice cream shop

Gelato shop with clean layout and clearly labeled flavors offers a cozy, welcoming vibe. Staff prepare gelato and sorbet on site using traditional Roman recipes. The place draws a steady crowd seeking premium quality gelato with a variety of creative flavors.

Lotus cookie flavor stands out with its Biscoff wafer taste and is consistently described as incredible and tasty. Orange cookie and walnut fig flavors also appear as notable options.

Sorbet here tastes just like in Italy, with creamy texture and authentic fruit flavors. Mango and coconut sorbets stand out for their rich, real fruit taste.

People are saying

"The gelato here is amazing, rich, and perfectly creamy."

"The sorbet here is delicious and creamy."

"The lotus cookie flavor is fantastic and tasty."

Good to know

1

Rito Gelato just opened, offering a fresh selection of gelato.

2

The owner makes gelato and sorbet on-site using traditional recipes.

3

Rito Gelato offers about 11 flavors of gelato and many creative sorbet options.

03
Avrilililly's Creamery LLC image 1

Vibrant ice cream shop features original murals and a family-friendly vibe with comfy seating. Amaretti cookies offer a distinct flavor, while passion fruit sorbet delivers a perfectly balanced taste that refreshes.

Amaretti cookies stand out with their distinct flavor and texture. Chocolate chip cookies balance crispy yet chewy qualities, and the sugar cookie is notably huge.

Sorbet here offers subtle and sophisticated flavors with a slightly grainy texture. The passion fruit sorbet stands out with a perfectly balanced taste, neither too sour nor too sweet, and delivers a refreshing experience.

People are saying

"The owner's warm greetings make the ice cream experience special."

"The chocolate chip cookies here are fresh and hand-made."

"The passion fruit sorbet is so refreshing and perfectly balanced."

Good to know

1

They offer a 10% discount for students, teachers, and first responders.

2

To get the college student discount, you need to print your ID card.

3

Gelatos from the day before are discounted.

04
Duchess Cookies - Garden City image 1

Bright, clean space with a fun and lively atmosphere. Known for kosher options and gourmet cookies that many find exceptionally delicious. Pricing is on the higher side, but the attentive service and quality ingredients stand out.

Cookies come out soft and gooey with flavors like cotton candy and cookies and cream standing out. The Cookie Monster Cookie scores a perfect 10, showing the range of delicious options available.

Sorbet flavors change weekly with options like mango and strawberry. Samples are offered, and the sorbet ice cream tastes heavenly and delicious.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be amazing and delicious."

"The sorbet here is always so delicious."

"I was so happy to find a kosher option here!"

Good to know

1

The cookies cost around $5-$6 each, totaling about $11 for three cookies.

2

Duchess Cookies is the only kosher option in the mall.

3

The store has a no exchanges, no refunds, and no returns policy.

05
Duchess Cookies - Smith Haven Mall image 1

Warm and cozy bakery with a friendly, lively staff who sing and dance, creating a cheerful atmosphere. Known for creative, delicious cookies and great ice cream, it attracts those seeking unique treats. The space feels inviting and well-designed, making it a standout in a mall setting.

Soft and gooey textures define the cookies here, with standout options like the cookie croissant that is warm and chewy. Varieties include cinnamon roll, peanut butter chocolate, rainbow, and cotton candy cookies, all served with friendly, quick service.

Mango, pineapple and cream, and lemon and vanilla sorbets stand out with fresh, vibrant flavors. Free samples of strawberry and vanilla sorbet often accompany visits, highlighting their variety.

People are saying

"These cookies are an experience of scrumptiousness."

"The chocolate cookie croissant is warm, gooey, and amazing."

"The staff's enthusiasm makes the sorbet experience so fun."

Good to know

1

The cookies are priced around $3 each, with a buy 6 get 1 free deal.

2

Expect a wait of up to 40 minutes for orders during busy times.

3

The store offers allergen-safe options for those with nut allergies.

06
Lost Borough Ice Cream image 1

Small ice cream shop offers unique homemade flavors with a fun, eclectic vibe and bright, cheerful decor. Space is crowded and compact, mostly for takeout with limited seating. Music selection adds to the lively atmosphere.

Cookies offer a heavenly taste and texture with generous mix-ins like in the Taro monster. They pair perfectly with ice cream and cold milk, creating a delicious a la mode experience made with care.

Offers vegan sorbet options like blackberry and coconut. Flavors include Dominican Vanilla, Mango, and a mango-chinolada mix that balance sweet and sour well.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is so creamy, rich, and delicious."

"These cookies are amazing, especially the double chocolate and chocolate chip walnut."

"The Dominican Vanilla and Mango Sorbet were so refreshing."

Good to know

1

Lost Borough Ice Cream is only available for takeout.

2

They offer a variety of unique and homemade ice cream flavors.

3

Vegan options are limited, with only one available at times.

07
Figo il Gelato Italiano image 1

Small gelato shop offers authentic Italian flavors with vibrant, creamy gelato displayed in a clean, modern space. Outdoor seating includes comfortable tables and heaters, complemented by a live DJ that creates a lively atmosphere. The spot blends Little Italy ambiance with a relaxed yet energetic vibe.

Complimentary cookies come with gelato, sometimes served right on top. They taste like treats from high-end Italian bakeries and pair well with flavors like cookies and cream and coffee gelato.

Fruit-based sorbets stand out with intense mango flavor and natural produce quality. Vegan options like the dark chocolate 80% nerone sorbet avoid excess sugar and deliver rich taste.

People are saying

"This is the best gelato I've ever had."

"The gelato here is amazing, especially the San Valentino Tiramisu."

"The lemon and strawberry sorbet here is insanely good and perfectly tangy."

Good to know

1

There is no public bathroom at this gelato shop.

2

Prices for gelato start around $6 for a single scoop.

3

Vegan and dairy-free options are available.

08
Sundaes Best image 1
Ice cream shop

Small ice cream shop with Korean decor and Asian fusion flavors offers a cute, boutique-like vibe. Limited indoor and outdoor seating creates a cozy but often crowded atmosphere with loud music. Unique gelato flavors and Instagram-worthy design attract a lively crowd.

Cookies and milk come together here in a way that stands out. A small cookie often tops the sundaes, adding a sweet touch.

Offers a wide range of fruit sorbets like strawberry, guava, passion fruit, lychee, and calamansi. The Jeju Mandarin sorbet stands out with a strong, unique flavor that challenges typical ice cream tastes.

People are saying

"The ice cream flavors here are so unique and delicious."

"You'll find so many creative, Asian-inspired sorbet flavors here."

"The Korean flavored cookies here are nostalgic and authentic."

Good to know

1

Be sure to come early to try the popular flavors before they sell out.

2

It is best to go at odd times to avoid long lines.

3

Customers can sample a few flavors to decide what they want.

09
Gramercy Tavern image 1
New American restaurant

Contemporary interior combines warmth and natural floral decor with a layout that splits between fine dining and casual tavern areas. Atmosphere stays classy and quieter than typical city restaurants, supporting pleasant conversations despite occasional crowd noise. A sommelier and cozy outdoor seating enhance the dining experience.

Chocolate chip cookies come warm and gooey with a crunchy texture. The chocolate chunk variety is a nice touch for take-home treats.

Strawberry Sorbet comes with Ginger Foam Ice Cream, adding a creative twist. Grape sorbet offers a refreshing finish to desserts.

People are saying

"The food here is fantastic, with seasonal dishes and high-quality ingredients."

"The chocolate chip cookie here is excellent and a must-try."

"The fruit sorbets here are super-concentrated yet light."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required, especially during peak times and special events.

2

Happy hour runs from 4pm to 6pm with $6 wine and beer and $12 cocktails.

3

The restaurant participates in NYC's summer restaurant week with special menus.

10
Anita La Mamma del Gelato image 1

Colorful gelato displays fill a beautifully decorated space with indoor and outdoor seating. The atmosphere blends sophisticated design with a fun, lively vibe, supported by loud music and energetic energy. Outdoor tables offer a pleasant spot for people watching and enjoying fresh air.

Chocolate cookies stand out with a rich, memorable flavor. Cookies come paired with ice cream, including Cookie Monster and vanilla varieties that add variety to the experience.

Sorbet flavors taste exactly like freshly cut fruit, with standout options like strawberry, pineapple, and mango that are very refreshing and authentic. Vegan sorbets avoid icy textures and use high-quality plant-based ingredients like coconut cream and cocoa butter.

People are saying

"This gelato is the best ice cream I ever had."

"The chocolate cookies here are amazing, I'd come back just for them."

"The sorbet tastes just like fresh fruit."

Good to know

1

Expect a long line at night because it is a very popular place.

2

Anita's is open until midnight.

3

The gelato is very expensive at $9 after tax.

11
Ci Siamo image 1
Italian restaurant

Open kitchen with visible ovens and chefs creates an engaging atmosphere. Lounge-like setting combines comfortable seating, complimentary wine elevator, and a private outdoor terrace. Energy ranges from intimate and warm to lively and touristy, with friendly staff enhancing the experience.

Rainbow Cookies come with desserts and are a common choice. Almond cookies taste delicious but are not always available for sale. Staff often pack extra cookies to take home.

Lemon sorbet tastes tangy and fresh. Dark chocolate sorbet comes salted and rich.

People are saying

"The rigatoni alla Gricia was perfect, the best pasta I've ever had!"

"The service here is impeccable and attentive."

"You have to try the dark chocolate sorbet; it's salted and special."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially for brunch and dinner.

2

Claim a spot by 5pm to avoid long wait times.

3

Happy hour is lively and popular, especially leading into dinner.

12
Caffè Panna image 1
Ice cream shop

Outdoor setup with limited standing space creates an intimate, warm vibe that highlights top-tier gelato craftsmanship. Lines can be long, but heated areas and self-serve water add comfort. The atmosphere stays soft and inviting, making it a popular spot for casual outings and dates.

Cookies here beat those from Leavain, especially the Red Flag and Cookies n Panna varieties. The special Leavain black and white cookie affogato sundae combines classic flavors in a unique way.

Sorbet options include vegan choices like guava and rainbow citrus, both intensely flavorful. Chocolate sorbet comes with a generous serving of whipped cream, drizzle, and toppings.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was amazing and some of the best I've ever tasted."

"Their hot chocolate is seriously amazing and so delicious."

"I waited less than 15 minutes for this Cookie."

Good to know

1

Caffè Panna opens at 1:30 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

2

Expect wait times of 30 to 45 minutes for ice cream after 7 PM.

3

There is no seating available at Caffè Panna; it's takeout only.

13
Spot Dessert Bar East Village image 1

Basement dessert café with tiny seating and tight spacing creates a crowded atmosphere. Loud pop music fills the space, making conversation difficult. Known for Asian-inspired desserts with a modern twist, it draws long waits and a lively crowd.

Cookies arrive warm and fresh with standout options like the Matcha Lava cookie, Cookie Camp, and Miso caramel cookie. These treats blend classic Asian flavors with creative twists, often enjoyed with ice cream or reheated at home.

Raspberry sorbet appears in several desserts, pairing with rich chocolate in the Matcha Lava and with cheesecake and Earl Grey milk tea in The Harvest. Coconut sorbet offers a tropical island flavor that stands out.

People are saying

"The desserts here are amazing, creative, and beautifully decorated."

"The cookie camp here is out of this world."

"The raspberry sorbet with the Harvest dessert is a nice touch."

Good to know

1

Be prepared to wait at least 30 minutes for a table.

2

You must order at least one dessert per person to dine in.

3

Reservations are required to avoid long wait times.

14
Torrisi image 1
Italian restaurant

Space combines warm tones and vintage greens with high vaulted ceilings for a luxurious dining atmosphere. Music blends soul, jazz, and 70’s R&B, creating a lively yet refined vibe. Cocktails and Italian dishes feature bold, unique flavors that match the elegant setting.

Complimentary cookies include an almond cookie that tastes like cookie dough and a sesame cracker that is perfectly crunchy without breaking teeth.

Green apple and cherry sorbets serve as refreshing finishes to meals. Both flavors offer a light, crisp sweetness that cleanses the palate.

People are saying

"The tortellini here is probably the best I’ve ever had."

"The cookies here are unreal and very delicious."

"The tortellini here is the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations open 30 days in advance but fill instantly.

2

Getting a reservation is super hard unless you want to wait in line right before they open at 5 PM.

3

If you can’t get a reservation, arrive before 5 PM to wait in line for walk-in seating at the bar.

15
Spot Dessert Bar Flushing image 1

Small dessert shop with cramped seating and chic decor creates a cozy, intimate atmosphere. Jazz music plays softly, adding to the chill vibe. Unique dessert presentations and a busy, lively energy define the experience.

Cookies here stand out for their freshly made quality and unique flavors like miso caramel and Oreo chocolate. Warm options like the Nutella cookie balance sweetness well and pair nicely with drinks such as Oreo bubble tea.

Raspberry sorbet stands out with its light and tart flavor that balances sweetness well. It pairs nicely with desserts like cheesecake and Earl Grey milk, adding a refreshing touch without overpowering.

People are saying

"These creative desserts are delicious and beautifully presented."

"I thought the cookies here were very good, especially the matcha."

"The raspberry sorbet in the Harvest dessert was light and tart."

Good to know

1

You need to order and pay on the Apollo app, and you must register as a member to order.

2

There is an 18% tip minimum, and a 20% automatic gratuity is added.

3

Only one payment card is accepted per table; splitting the bill is not allowed.

16
L'industrie Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small space fills with crowds and energy, creating a lively and chaotic vibe. Standing room dominates both inside and outside, with unique school bus seating offering sheltered outdoor dining. Guests watch pizza-making up close while enjoying heated outdoor areas and a bustling atmosphere.

Soft serve gelato includes a cantaloupe sorbet flavor made in house that stands out. Large pizzas come with free gelato or sorbet, featuring options like mandarin sorbet with olive oil and sea salt.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be the best in town."

"This pizza slice is amazing and worth the wait."

"This cantaloupe sorbet with olive oil and sea salt is amazing."

Good to know

1

Customers may wait about 20 minutes in line on a Saturday at 4:30 pm.

2

There was already a line forming just 10 minutes after opening on a Sunday.

3

There is no inside eating area; expect to eat standing or takeout.

17
ChikaLicious Dessert Bar at Astor Pl,by appt. only image 1

Cozy space with intimate bar seating invites watching desserts crafted live, creating an upscale yet relaxed atmosphere. Small groups gather for unique Japanese-French dessert omakase, enjoying artfully presented sweets that balance delicate flavors and textures.

Cookies come with custom photo prints that add a unique touch. Small cookies taste okay but offer limited value for the price.

Sorbet here offers refreshingly sweet and sour flavors like Meyer-Lemon and grapefruit that add vibrancy and a surprising finish. Pineapple sorbet balances sweetness well, while creative dishes combine sorbet with elements like white chocolate mousse and frosted pistachios for layered tastes.

People are saying

"I loved the dessert omakase experience and watching the chefs."

"The dessert omakase experience here is an imaginative culinary journey."

"The omakase dessert tasting menu is an intriguing experience."

Good to know

1

Reservations are encouraged but not required.

2

A fixed-price tasting menu is available for $26 per person.

3

Chika and her team provide a three-course dessert tasting experience from Thursday to Sunday.

18
Ferrara Bakery & Cafe image 1

Elegant bakery with classic Italian style and richly decorated interiors offers both indoor and sheltered outdoor seating. Atmosphere feels traditional and cozy, filled with the aroma of freshly baked pastries and lively energy. Known for exceptional cannoli and gelato, it blends old-school charm with a vibrant street presence.

Rainbow cookies stand out with their tricolor layers and authentic Italian style. Other options include pignolia cookies and a variety of traditional Italian cookies that pair well with iced mocha.

Mango sorbet blends the texture of ice cream with the taste of sorbet, creating a unique hybrid. About 15 gelato flavors include 4 vegan sorbets, all delivering good quality.

People are saying

"I thought the New York cheesecake here was the best I ever tasted."

"I couldn’t stop eating the rainbow cookies."

"The sorbetto here is so creamy, smooth, and quenching."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to avoid long wait times during busy hours.

2

Expect long lines, especially during holidays and special events.

3

National Cannoli Day offers a free plain Cannoli with any purchase.

19
The Fulton by Jean-Georges image 1

Restaurant offers stunning waterfront views of city skyline and Brooklyn Bridge with outdoor seating that captures the breeze. Atmosphere stays calm and low noise, enhanced by occasional live jazz music. Space includes multiple floors and a glass bar where oysters are shucked fresh.

Simple looks hide a heavenly taste in the Fulton cookie. It balances sweetness well, not too much but just right for dessert.

Multi-flavored sorbet stands out with its plain scoops served simply on a plate. It takes about half an hour to arrive and helps cool down spicy heat effectively.

People are saying

"The panoramic view across the river is stunning."

"The seafood here is so fresh, especially the oysters."

"I highly recommend the multi-flavored sorbet, it's amazing."

Good to know

1

Check your bill for accuracy before paying, as mistakes can happen.

2

There is a 2-hour wait for a table with a reservation.

3

Request a table by the water for a better view.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...