Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to New York

Pie and gyro

A menu that manages to serve both a decent gyro and a proper slice of pie without compromising the quality of either.

Based on 567 Opinions
+564
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Zaros Cafe image 1
Zaros Cafe image 2
Zaros Cafe image 3
View all
Greek restaurant

Family-owned Greek restaurant with a cozy dining room and white privacy curtains creates a comfortable, community-oriented atmosphere. Known for authentic gyros and fresh salads, it balances takeout convenience with a welcoming space to eat in.

Spinach pie comes right out of the oven with the flakiest coating. It stands out as an unbeatable choice compared to other falafel or spinach pies.

Gyros feature moist, flavorful lamb meat with crisp toppings and come with red and white tzatziki sauces. They maintain a juicy texture without being dried out.

People are saying

"I thought the gyros here were the best I've ever had."

"The salmon with rice and tzatziki is outstanding Greek food."

"I believed this place offered some of the best Greek food I ever had."

Good to know

1

They offer 2 Gyro sandwiches for the price of one on Wednesday and Thursday.

2

Zaros Cafe is mainly a takeout place with some tables for dine-in.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but cash is recommended for quick takeout.

02
Nโ€™MELI GREEK GRILL image 1
Greek restaurant

Greek restaurant offers a spotless, beautiful setting with Greek tunes creating an authentic vibe. Small tables fill the space divided by a simple wall, enhancing a cozy atmosphere. Generous portions and fast casual style make it a standout for Greek cuisine.

Spinach pie stands out with its perfect baking and delicious flavor. It pairs well with the gyro and Greek salad for a solid meal.

Gyros here feature perfectly cooked and seasoned meat with soft, warm pita bread. Portions come massive and fully loaded, often served as a platter with sides like Greek salad and spinach pie.

People are saying

"The gyro meat here is the best Greek food I've had anywhere."

"The gyro meat here is the best I've had anywhere."

"The spinach pie was baked perfectly and delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers great lunch specials that change daily.

2

Expect generous portions at reasonable prices for all menu items.

3

They have a selection of Greek snacks and groceries available for purchase.

03
Uncle Leo's South Shore Pita Grill image 1

Greek restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere with friendly, smiling staff and customers creating a homey, nostalgic vibe. The space feels pleasant and relaxing, reflecting a strong sense of community and happiness.

Spinach pie stands out with a great, consistent flavor. It pairs well with dishes like moussaka and souvlaki, making it a solid choice for pie lovers.

Chicken, lamb, and BBQ gyros offer a perfect blend of toppings and rich flavors. The lamb gyro stands out as particularly sinful, while the BBQ gyro delivers a distinctive taste.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and flavorful."

"The Greek food here is delicious and flavorful."

"I found the spinach pie to be great."

Good to know

1

Uncle Leo's offers a variety of Greek grocery items alongside its menu.

2

The restaurant does not offer delivery service.

3

Portions are large and can easily be shared or last for two meals.

04
Olives & Pita image 1
Greek restaurant

Small Greek restaurant with cozy backyard seating and simple decor creates a friendly, relaxed vibe where people seem familiar with each other. Music features auto-tune pop with techno beats, adding an unusual touch to the atmosphere. Known for flavorful gyros and authentic dishes, it offers a casual dining experience with a family feel.

Flaky crust and excellent seasoning define the spinach pie here. The spanakopita stands out as a tasty appetizer option.

Lamb Gyro stands out with its excellent seasoning and rich flavor. Gyro pita sandwiches come with well-seasoned meat that many find unmatched in the area.

People are saying

"I found the best gyro pita sandwich with thick slices of seasoned meat."

"I found the best gyro, it's delicious."

"The spinach pie here is delicious."

Good to know

1

The chicken gyro platter costs $13 with fries, baked potato, or rice.

2

The vegan gyro platter and falafel platter cost over $60, totaling $75 with tip.

3

The restaurant is accommodating to those with peanut allergies.

05
Greek City Grill image 1
Greek restaurant

Small, cozy eatery with warm lighting and a family-run atmosphere creates a welcoming, authentic Greek vibe. The space feels like dining at home, with clean, intimate seating and friendly staff enhancing the inviting mood.

Flakey and flavorful, the spinach pie stands out with a texture and taste reminiscent of homemade recipes. It pairs well with other dishes like lemon chicken soup and souvlaki.

Huge portions define the gyro offerings here, challenging diners to finish one. The mixed gyro platter includes soft rice and pairs well with the dip trio and chicken gyro.

People are saying

"This Greek food is authentic and packed with flavor."

"My gyro sandwich was packed with flavor and huge."

"The spinach pie was excellent and made the way I grew up having it."

Good to know

1

Parking at Greek City Grill can be challenging, so plan accordingly.

2

Reservations are recommended for large groups to ensure seating.

3

The restaurant offers catering services for events and large gatherings.

06
Lucky Boy image 1
Greek restaurant

Small restaurant with a charming exterior and sunny, pleasant atmosphere. It fills up quickly with a friendly, fun vibe and offers a diverse menu of original Mediterranean dishes. Portions are large and prices reasonable, making it a hidden gem for Greek food.

Spinach Pie stands out as a fresh, made-to-order option. Chocolate cream and coconut cream pies match homemade quality and offer rich, comforting flavors.

Skewered gyro meat comes tender, juicy, and perfectly cooked with no freezing involved. Warm tomatoes, semi-crisp iceberg lettuce, and fresh onion add crispness and freshness to the gyro special.

People are saying

"The Greek food here is top-notch, especially the gyro meat."

"I thought the spinach pie was the best I had."

"The gyro meat here is tender, juicy, and perfectly cooked."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant fills up quickly.

2

The restaurant locks the door at 8 PM, so arrive before then.

3

Expect large portion sizes; salads come in mixing size bowls.

07
The Casual Greek image 1
Greek restaurant

Greek restaurant offers a cozy, family-like atmosphere with ambient lighting and tasteful decor featuring light neutrals and Santorini photos. The space feels like a small, clean tavern with a mini-bar and a cool bar design. Guests enjoy a calming vibe that transports them to Greece.

Flaky phyllo crust wraps a creamy spinach filling in the spinach pie. It offers an authentic Greek taste with a rich, savory interior.

Gyros feature authentic Greek flavors with lamb, chicken, and pork options. Platters offer a variety of meats including bifteki and souvlaki, served in a relaxed setting.

People are saying

"The salads here are fresh, perfectly spiced, and full of flavor."

"I found the gyro platter to be delicious and the meat was plentiful."

"The spinach pie has a flaky phyllo shell and creamy interior."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers takeout for those on the go.

2

Prices are affordable, making it a great option for families.

3

The restaurant accommodates larger groups comfortably.

08
Greek Cove - Long Beach image 1
Greek restaurant

Small space with few tables focuses on takeout and generous portions. Atmosphere feels cozy and casual, suited for quick bites or parties. Menu offers fresh, well-seasoned Greek dishes with many vegetarian and healthy options.

Spinach pies stand out with their excellent flavor and consistent quality. The combination of lemon potatoes and spinach pie offers a delicious twist that many enjoy.

Gyros come huge and very tasty, with options like chicken gyro and platters that include soup and stuffed grape leaves. They cook the gyros exactly as requested, making them consistently delicious.

People are saying

"The Greek food portions are so generous, I always have leftovers."

"I found the gyro here to be huge and very tasty."

"I loved the spinach pie with lemon potatoes."

Good to know

1

Greek Cove offers generous portion sizes, ensuring good value for your money.

2

Delivery is reliable through Grubhub or Uber Eats, with timely service.

3

The establishment maintains a high level of cleanliness throughout.

09
Twisted Greek image 1
Greek restaurant

Modern, clean space with bright white and blue decor creates a casual yet homey atmosphere. Friendly, lively vibe fills the room with uplifting Greek music enhancing the experience. Spacious layout includes a cute bar area, making it suitable for both casual meals and dates.

Thick, crispy, flaking fillo dough holds a perfectly balanced mix of feta and spinach. The Greek lamb and spinach pie combines rich flavors with a tasty, balanced filling that stands out.

Gyros here feature exceptionally tender and juicy meat with perfect seasoning that packs a lot of flavor. Lamb and chicken options stand out as fresh and tasty, making the gyro a highlight.

People are saying

"The Greek food here is incredible, especially the fresh salads."

"I thought the gyro meat was top quality and packed with flavor."

"The spinach pie's pastry dough was unreal and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Ordering through their website for pick up is easy, with Apple Pay accepted.

2

Expect generous portions at reasonable prices for all menu items.

3

Takeout is currently the only available service option.

10
Gus and Marty's image 1
Greek restaurant

Modern dining space centers on a large wood stove and features outdoor seating by a park. Atmosphere balances warmth and sophistication with a lively, inviting energy. Guests enjoy authentic Greek cuisine paired with a notable selection of Mediterranean wines and cocktails.

Spinach pie stands out with rich flavor and tender texture. The meat pie offers a hearty, satisfying bite that complements other dishes like lamb riblets and octopus.

Petite gyros stand out with their delicious flavor and come paired well with fries. They join other highlights like whipped feta and octopus souvlaki on the menu.

People are saying

"The pita bread was crazy soft and piping hot."

"The spinach pie and meat pie here were incredible."

"The petite gyros were delicious and standout."

Good to know

1

Getting a last minute reservation is fairly easy at the moment.

2

The restaurant requires you to submit your whole order at one time.

3

There are many gluten and dairy-free options available for those with restrictions.

11
Kavos Grill 2 image 1
Greek restaurant

Small, casual space with loud noise levels and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Frequented by groups enjoying authentic Greek cuisine with generous portions and a diverse menu. Clean and well-lit interior supports a friendly, family-like vibe.

Spinach pie often serves as a vegan option but sometimes has an old oil taste in the phyllo dough and could use more dill. Cheese pies and zucchini cakes also appear as popular choices.

Gyros feature tender, flavorful meat grilled just right with rich Mediterranean seasoning. Options include chicken, beef, and lamb, all soft and well-seasoned without excess salt.

People are saying

"The Greek food here is so fresh and flavorful."

"The gyro here is packed with so much flavor."

"I tried the spinach pie and it was delicious."

Good to know

1

There is ample parking available right out front in their dedicated parking lot.

2

The menu offers a diverse selection, including seafood and vegetarian options.

3

Portions are generous, often enough for two people to share.

12
Athens Diner image 1

Diner inside a strip mall offers a family-run atmosphere with old-school values and a clean, homey space. The vibe is simple and welcoming, attracting those who appreciate classic diner experiences with a local touch.

Spinach pie has a very dry texture with a thick dough casing. It contains insufficient spinach and feta cheese compared to the crust.

Gyros here come with rich flavor and a perfect lunch special option. The gyro platter and gyro with Greek salad both stand out as delicious choices.

People are saying

"I loved the Greek food, especially the amazing gyro and white sauce."

"I thought the gyro was a work of art and delicious."

"I had the most delicious spinach pie."

Good to know

1

Parking is limited and can be tricky to access.

2

Prices are reasonable, making it a budget-friendly option.

3

Portion sizes are generous, ensuring good value for money.

13
Greek from Greece image 1
Greek restaurant

Greek restaurant offers a clean, bright setting with cozy indoor tables and a small outdoor terrace. The atmosphere feels tranquil and inviting, with a relaxing decor that transports diners to Greece. It attracts those seeking authentic flavors in a neat, casual environment.

Cheese pie stands out with its exceptional flavor and rich phyllo crust. Spinach pie and bougatsa also offer perfectly balanced fillings that highlight traditional Greek recipes.

Gyros come with fresh ingredients and incredible flavor, especially the pork and pulled lamb options. Tzatziki sauce adds a memorable touch, and the falafel gyro stands out as well.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, fresh, and served in generous portions."

"I found the gyro to be great, like straight from Greece."

"The staff here is so friendly and quick with the pie."

Good to know

1

Brunch is available before the holiday markets.

2

Baklava French toast may be added to the menu soon.

3

The lamb gyros cost $12, with an extra $2 for lamb.

14
Opa Grille image 1
Greek restaurant

Small Greek restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere with traditional Greek music enhancing the vibe. The space stays clean and inviting, attracting diners who appreciate authentic Greek flavors and generous portions like fresh Greek salad and tender octopus.

Spinach and cheese pies come in large portions with a rich filling. Some find the spinach pie less appealing, but it remains a notable option among other dishes like calamari and gyros.

Gyros come with good flavor and fresh ingredients. The gyro platter offers healthy portions and pairs well with Greek salad and other classic sides.

People are saying

"I thought the gyro and spanakopita were both excellent."

"I thought the gyro platter was the best I ever had."

"The spinach pie here is fantastic."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times for takeout orders, often over 45 minutes.

2

An automatic 18% gratuity is added to all bills.

3

A 3.5% surcharge applies for debit card payments.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...