Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
New York's best

Soup and historical sites

You want to enjoy a bowl of soup in a place that carries the weight of history.

Based on 727 Opinions
+724
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
The Old '76 House image 1
The Old '76 House image 2
The Old '76 House image 3
View all
American restaurant

Historic tavern filled with American mementos and military paraphernalia creates a warm, cozy atmosphere rich with history. Live jazz music plays during dinner, adding to the unique vibe. Signature ales and classic American dishes complement the authentic setting.

Onion soup stands out with its smooth, flavorful profile and careful preparation. Butternut squash soup also offers an incredible taste experience.

The space holds rich American history where founding fathers once ate and talked. The atmosphere feels alive with stories, making it easy to imagine figures like George Washington nearby.

People are saying

"The live music here feels like stepping back into history."

"The food and drinks here were fantastic."

"I thought the onion soup was perfection."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for the brunch buffet on special occasions.

2

Jazz night happens every Wednesday, featuring local musicians.

3

Live music is scheduled on Mondays, enhancing the dining experience.

02
Gallagher’s Steakhouse NYC image 1

Steakhouse features an enormous dry aging room and an open kitchen where chefs prepare meals in view. Atmosphere blends old-school jazz with classy, buzzing energy, creating a lively yet refined dining experience. Seating is crowded, with tables close together, enhancing a bustling vibe.

French onion soup stands out with its rich, savory flavor and perfectly melted cheese. The soup offers a deep broth and generous toppings that make it memorable.

Stepping inside feels like entering a living piece of history with a strong sense of elegance and class. The place has a long history and has welcomed many famous visitors, making it a landmark for steakhouses.

People are saying

"The porterhouse steak was flavorful and cooked to perfection."

"The French onion soup was wonderfully cooked and tasted great."

"The steak was cooked perfectly and tasted great."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for lunch courses on weekends.

2

Lunch course is available until 4pm on weekends.

3

Expect around $130 per person for a meal with drinks, tips not included.

03
Tweed's Restaurant image 1

Historic architecture combines with leather seating and classic saloon decor to create a cozy, old-school vibe. Soft melodies from a live pianist enhance the quiet, charming atmosphere. The place offers an impressive bourbon selection that complements its mid-20th century ski cabin feel.

Soups here feature bison cabbage and French onion varieties. The bison cabbage soup is hearty with meat, cabbage, mushroom, and tomato, while the onion soup comes served hot and flavorful.

Rich historical notes and old-fashioned leather seating create a unique atmosphere. Walls display historical pictures, articles, and a mounted bison head, highlighting the deep history of the place.

People are saying

"I've never tasted a better steak; it was seriously amazing."

"It's a cozy place with a warm, ski lodge atmosphere."

"The soup here feels like a journey back in time."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner service, especially on weekends.

2

The kitchen closes at 8pm, so plan your visit accordingly.

3

Parking is free in the public lot behind the restaurant.

04
Lady Mendl's Tea Salon image 1

Historic brownstone setting features Victorian decor with mismatched china and vintage furnishings creating a Gilded era atmosphere. The mood is elegant and cozy, often quiet on weekdays and suited for formal tea occasions. Guests enjoy a classic high-tea experience with carefully curated ambiance and service.

Refreshing watermelon and coconut cold soup starts the meal. It comes with unlimited tea and several courses including soup or salad, tea sandwiches, and fresh scones.

Located in a historic brownstone, the tea salon offers a strong sense of historic New York ambiance. The setting highlights the building's historic value and creates a unique atmosphere.

People are saying

"The tea salon's decor is thoughtful and charming."

"The historical sites here offer an elegant, charming step back in time."

"The potato leek soup was hot and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for afternoon tea to secure your spot.

2

The five-course high tea includes unlimited tea with each course.

3

The price for the five-course tea service is around $120 per person, including tip.

05
Fanelli Café image 1
Traditional American restaurant

Historic bar and café with old-school wooden counter and pressed roof designs creates a nostalgic, artistic vibe. Outdoor seating with heated booths offers a cozy spot for conversation and people watching. Walls lined with vintage boxer photos add to the timeless, laid-back atmosphere.

Soups here stand out for their creamy tomato soup and homemade chicken and Moroccan lamb varieties. The outdoor soup kiosk offers a cozy spot for lunch, especially in cooler months.

An iconic bar and cafe dating back to 1847, it carries a strong sense of history in its walls. The place offers a glimpse into New York's past with its old regulars and timeless atmosphere.

People are saying

"It's an old school, busy bar with an institutional atmosphere."

"It's a true historic gem with an authentic, vintage charm."

"I loved the creamy tomato soup."

Good to know

1

The bar gets too packed during happy hour.

2

The restaurant does not have gluten-free options on the menu.

3

The restaurant is open late, serving food at 12:45 AM on Saturday night.

06
Russ & Daughters image 1

Narrow, small shop with no indoor seating and often crowded atmosphere. The vibe is old school, evoking a sense of history and tradition with a calm, unhurried pace despite the crowd. Outdoor benches offer brief respite while enjoying classic bagel and lox combinations.

Matzo ball soup features tender dumplings in a flavorful broth and is available by the quart. Whitefish chowder offers a surprisingly good alternative. Traditional Jewish soups like these stand out here.

Smells of history, family, and legacy fill the air, creating an atmosphere rich with cultural heritage. The place stands as a true landmark offering an immersive taste of New York's past.

People are saying

"I thought the salmon bagel was the best I ever had."

"This place is a historic icon, like stepping into living history."

"The matzo ball soup is comforting with tender dumplings."

Good to know

1

You must take a number when you first enter to be served.

2

There is no dine-in option; it's takeout only.

3

Expect long wait times, often over an hour, especially after 10am.

07
Old Town Bar image 1
Gastropub

Vaulted tin ceilings and a 55-foot mahogany bar create a historic atmosphere filled with old-school charm. The space feels cozy and woody, offering both indoor booths and outdoor sidewalk seating. Regulars enjoy classic draught beers and a menu featuring standout items like steak sandwiches and buffalo wings.

French Onion Soup stands out with its rich flavor and solid preparation. Corn soup comes off as lukewarm and watery, lacking depth and seasoning.

The building holds rich history and classic old-time Irish bar character. It stands as a neighborhood landmark with a fascinating past and a lot of atmosphere.

People are saying

"This bar has such an authentic, historic New York vibe."

"I felt the history and classic New York character the second I walked in."

"I had the French Onion Soup and it was outstanding."

Good to know

1

The seating is first come, first served, rather than reservations.

2

Visitors need to plan accordingly due to the crowd on weekends.

3

The price for 2 Bud beers and chicken fingers is $32.00.

08
Conwell Coffee & Cocktail Hall image 1

Converted bank with art deco design and high ceilings creates a spacious, cozy atmosphere. Soft jazz music and comfortable couches invite relaxation and quiet conversation. Original architectural details like the old cashier counter add a unique historic charm.

Chilled pea soup offers a fresh taste with a hint of olive oil and Black Sea salt. Roasted pepper soup stands out as a must-try. Squash soup pairs well with a grilled cheese croissant for a delicious combo.

Former bank building features charming teller signs above barista stations. Soft lighting and historical murals add to the café's historical charm.

People are saying

"The coffee here is served in a stunning, cozy space that feels like a sanctuary."

"The historic architecture and decor here are jaw-dropping."

"The soup here feels like a warm hug in a cozy, nostalgic spot."

Good to know

1

The kitchen closes at 4:30 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

2

The coffee hall serves bar snacks until 9 PM when it turns into a bar.

3

No hot sandwiches are available during special events.

09
The Landmark Tavern image 1
Irish restaurant

Historic Irish pub with original mahogany interiors and a pressed metal ceiling creates a classic atmosphere. Live Celtic music and local musicians add vibrant energy, especially in the back room. Comfortable bar seating invites quiet pints, while the space accommodates lively crowds during events.

Creamy and flavorful potato and leek soup stands out here. The soup pairs well with lemony, tenderly dressed greens for a smooth, comforting meal.

Original fixtures and decor create a wonderful historical ambiance that feels like stepping back in time. The pub offers a quiet, charming atmosphere perfect for enjoying a beer while soaking in its long history.

People are saying

"The pub's food was so good, especially the crispy fish and chips."

"It feels like stepping back in time at this historic gem."

"The leek and potato soup is creamy and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Live music is available on Monday nights from 8 to 11 PM.

2

The restaurant has been around for 153 years.

3

A mandatory 20% tip is included in the bill.

10
Minetta Tavern image 1
French restaurant

Old speakeasy layout with 1930s style, soft lighting, and antique wooden furniture creates a cozy, retro vibe. Warm, bustling atmosphere feels like classic New York City dining with a friendly bar near the entrance. Outdoor space and coat check add practical charm to the inviting setting.

French onion soup stands out with rich, savory flavors and a perfectly melted cheese topping. It consistently earns praise for being exceptionally tasty and satisfying.

Dark, full of character, and old school cool, the place holds a palpable history with a beautifully kept, classic atmosphere that reflects its long past.

People are saying

"The Black Label Burger is juicy, tender, and perfectly cooked."

"The food here is excellent, especially the bone marrow."

"The French onion soup has an amazing depth of flavor."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to dine at Minetta Tavern.

2

The black label burger costs $38.

3

Last call for the soufflé happens quickly, so decide fast.

11
Temple Court image 1
Fine dining restaurant

Venue showcases 19th century Manhattan architecture with an intimate, relaxed atmosphere enhanced by live jazz music during brunch. Seating can be close, creating a cozy but sometimes cramped feel. Signature cocktails like Coco's Old Fashioned add to the elegant, swanky vibe.

Starters include a sweet pea soup with lobster that highlights the pea flavor in every bite. A chilled corn soup also stands out, and a small taste of soup comes with a roll and butter.

Elegant architecture captures the essence of 19th-century Manhattan landmarks. Unique ambience reflects deep historical roots and distinctive design.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and the service is impeccable."

"The chilled corn soup was amazing."

"You'll love the beautifully restored historical building and its architecture."

Good to know

1

Jazz brunch is available on Sundays from 12-3 PM.

2

During restaurant week, a 3-course dinner is offered for $60.

3

Expect a 45-minute wait for drinks on Saturday nights around 9 PM.

12
O'Hara's Restaurant and Pub image 1
American restaurant

Walls and ceiling display thousands of first responder badges and 9/11 memorabilia, creating a space rich with history and tribute. Atmosphere feels authentic and friendly, with a steady flow of people connected to public service. Rock music plays, adding to the lively yet respectful vibe that sets it apart from typical pubs.

French onion soup stands out with rich flavor and hearty portions. Other soups like Guinness and Onion Soup and Irish Stew offer tasty, generous servings that complement the menu well.

Rich 9/11 history fills the atmosphere with authentic New York vibes. Photo albums and the pub's heritage highlight its historical significance next to the World Trade Center memorial.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and perfectly cooked."

"You can see the historical sites and their 9/11 scrapbook."

"I found the French onion soup to be delicious."

Good to know

1

You cannot get a table unless you order food, even if the place is empty.

2

The pub does not do split checks, which is important for large groups.

3

They charge a 3.5 percent surcharge for using a credit card.

13
P.J. Clarke's Third Avenue image 1
American restaurant

Historic pub with 19th-century interiors and a 150-year-old bar creates an authentic old New York vibe. Atmosphere shifts from quiet dining to lively, crowded bar with classic jukebox tunes and live music. Walls display photos of legendary bartenders, adding to the timeless local charm.

Tomato soup stands out as excellent while clam chowder appears as a common choice, served with Parmesan Truffle Fries. Soup quality varies, with some finding it just okay.

The spot oozes history with a building that is both beautiful and authentic inside. It holds nearly 140 years of character and preserves its historical roots consistently.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers here were fantastic and great."

"This place is packed with history and old-school NYC vibe."

"The chicken soup here is a standout, with a comforting, homemade quality."

Good to know

1

Reservations are advisable, especially for dinner service.

2

Expect a 20-40 minute wait during peak hours.

3

The bar area operates on a first-come, first-served basis.

14
La Lanterna di Vittorio image 1
Italian restaurant

Historic brownstone hosts a cozy Italian restaurant with low lighting and an intimate atmosphere. A garden oasis and covered outdoor patio add unique charm. The space feels both spacious and intimate with high ceilings and quiet corners.

Minestrone soup stands out with a plentiful bowl and fresh ingredients, sometimes prepared in a Genovese style with pesto and no tomato. The soup of the day varies, including options like gazpacho, with mixed results in taste.

Building's history shapes the atmosphere with drinks named after it. Warmth from the woman who established the place adds to its family-owned charm.

People are saying

"The lasagna flight was playful and comforting, offering a range of flavors."

"It's a charming historic brownstone with an amazing ambiance."

"The minestrone soup here is prepared Genovese style with pesto."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for the garden room seating.

2

The restaurant features live jazz on select nights.

3

Valentine’s Day fixed menu includes a glass of champagne and dessert.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...