Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Vintage jewelry shops in New York

Digging through a vintage shop for jewelry feels like uncovering a story that has been waiting to be told.

Based on 825 Opinions
+822
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Mottive Jewelry image 1
Mottive Jewelry image 2
Mottive Jewelry image 3
View all
Jewelry store

Cozy boutique filled with unique handmade jewelry and beautiful displays creates a warm, welcoming atmosphere. The selection ranges from accessible to high-end pieces, appealing mostly to wealthier shoppers seeking elegant, one-of-a-kind designs.

Offers a great selection of beautiful, well-priced jewelry with a lovely antique section. Staff provide friendly customer service and the pieces maintain quality over time.

Unique collections include sterling silver, vintage jewelry, and custom pieces. The shop also offers vintage glassware and china alongside fine jewelry.

People are saying

"I found the jewelry selection at this Jewelry Store to be beautiful and amazing."

"I found the jewelry here to be beautiful and affordable."

"The staff at this Vintage Shop are so kind and helpful."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide assortment of jewelry at various price points.

2

All jewelry is carefully designed and handmade for quality.

3

They have a beautiful selection of vintage and fine jewelry.

02
Doyle & Doyle image 1

Jewelry store offers a gorgeous selection of unique vintage and antique pieces with heirloom quality craftsmanship. Atmosphere feels carefully curated, showcasing both exquisite new designs and rare finds. Customers encounter efficient service with quick alterations and secure transactions.

Jewelry features unique vintage pieces with outstanding quality. Staff helps find or create one-of-a-kind earrings and rings.

A treasure trove of vintage and antique jewelry offers unique vintage rings and one-of-a-kind pieces that stand out for their beauty and craftsmanship.

People are saying

"I found their vintage and estate jewelry selection to be top notch."

"I found their vintage jewelry selection to be amazing and unique."

"I found their vintage jewelry selection to be amazing and unique."

Good to know

1

Doyle & Doyle ships items insured by UPS for safe delivery.

2

You can buy jewelry in person or via a Zoom appointment.

3

The secure payment process is quick and easy for all transactions.

03
Good Old Gold image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry store offers an elegant layout with a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels like part of a family. The environment balances comfort and sophistication, making it approachable despite the luxury setting. Customers find a wide selection of custom and estate jewelry that stands out for quality and design.

Trusted for decades, this jewelry store handles buying, designing, and custom work with care. It offers a personalized experience and creates pieces like diamond earrings from family jewelry.

A beautiful assortment of vintage and estate jewelry fills the shelves. The selection includes new, antique, and unique pieces not found in other shops.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are incredibly friendly and helpful."

"It's family owned and treats you like family."

"I found the most gorgeous vintage jewelry selection here."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for special events like estate sales.

2

The store offers a trade-in program for old jewelry.

3

Expect personalized service from the family-owned staff.

04
Leigh Jay Nacht Inc. image 1

Diamond dealer offers an unmatched selection of vintage and vintage-inspired rings, including retro and art deco styles from the 1920s to 1950s. The atmosphere is family-run and accommodating, making the custom design process seamless and inspiring even for those new to buying diamonds.

Several ring options stand out, making it easy to find something special. Staff remain patient and helpful without pushing beyond your budget, keeping the process simple and stress-free.

An unmatched selection of vintage and antique rings spans retro and art deco styles from the 1920s to 1950s. Services include resizing, engraving, and shipping for rings like wedding bands and engagement settings.

People are saying

"Shopping for a ring here felt personal, fun, and pressure-free."

"This Vintage Shop experience was so easy and fun, with zero pressure to buy."

"This jewelry store makes the process easy and fun with zero pressure."

Good to know

1

Make an appointment first; they're very accommodating.

2

You don't need to worry about booking far in advance.

3

Leigh offers great options for engagement rings.

05
The Antique Parlour image 1
Jewelry store

Office space glows with natural light that highlights antique jewelry featuring old-cut engagement rings and art deco wedding bands. Atmosphere feels warm and inviting, with a focus on unique, authentic pieces. Selection attracts those seeking exceptional vintage designs and expert curation.

Several unique antique rings feature old cuts and intricate settings not common in modern shops. Owners Natasha and Shawn provide expert knowledge and offer only exquisite vintage jewelry pieces.

Offers an extensive and unique selection of antique rings and Art Deco pieces. Staff are knowledgeable experts providing exceptional customer service and detailed responses.

People are saying

"I found the most unique and gorgeous antique engagement rings here."

"This vintage shop's owners are experts and so accommodating."

"The staff at this jewelry store are so helpful and knowledgeable."

Good to know

1

Shipping is fast, ensuring quick delivery of your purchases.

2

Complimentary resizing is available for all jewelry pieces.

3

The owners are experts in authentic antique jewelry.

06
AJ's Jewelry Since 1988 image 1

Jewelry store offers beautiful displays and high-quality craftsmanship with reasonable prices. Atmosphere feels welcoming and peaceful, attracting those seeking exceptional service and reliable repairs.

Wedding rings and engagement rings come with high-quality craftsmanship and precise repairs. Staff offers knowledgeable, professional service and handles jewelry care with great attention.

Resizing and re-enameled work on vintage rings happens here with care and precision. Staff explain the resizing process clearly and handle delicate pieces like gold and enamel rings expertly.

People are saying

"The service at this jewelry store is amazing and personable."

"They fixed my broken necklace clasp super fast."

"The staff at this vintage shop are so pleasant and helpful."

Good to know

1

AJ's Jewelry offers on-site repairs with a starting price of $25.

2

Engraving services are available for tungsten rings with many character options.

3

The store provides a quick turnaround, often completing repairs by the next day.

07
Louis Martin Jewelers image 1

Family-owned jeweler offers a warm atmosphere with expert appraisals and a tremendous inventory of vintage and estate pieces. Staff share deep knowledge of diamonds and watches, creating a personalized experience that values integrity and craftsmanship.

World-class jewelry offers keepsakes meant to last generations. Repair work shows true artistry and care, while the staff builds trust and a family atmosphere.

Beautiful and gorgeous vintage jewelry fills the shelves. A wide variety of vintage and recent watches includes pieces in pristine condition at reasonable prices.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so welcoming and knowledgeable."

"This family-owned place makes you feel like longtime friends."

"The staff here are so nice and professional."

Good to know

1

The store offers quick watch repair services, typically completed in one day.

2

Customers can expect personalized service and assistance with jewelry and watches.

3

The boutique features a variety of vintage and recent watches for sale.

08
Thea Grant | Antique, Vintage & Custom Jewelry image 1

Shop combines vintage jewelry with a speakeasy bar in a cozy, art deco setting. Atmosphere feels frosty yet enjoyable, with jazz music adding to the vibe. Space offers an authentic experience blending unique pieces and lively back-bar energy.

Unique art deco vintage rings and a large variety of vintage charms stand out in the jewelry selection. The shop offers stamped jewelry and fixes jewelry problems at normal prices.

Shop offers a cool selection of vintage finds with a focus on art deco vintage rings and vintage charms. Items feel beautiful, chic, and retro, appealing to those who appreciate genuine vintage pieces.

People are saying

"I found the jewelry store's collection to be beautiful and unique."

"This vintage shop has beautiful, unique jewelry and decorations."

"I found the most beautiful vintage jewelry and unique finds here."

Good to know

1

The shop has a beautiful assortment of vintage charms and jewelry at different price points.

2

There is a large variety of trinkets, jewelry, and home goods.

3

Prices vary in the store.

09
Unearth Vintage image 1
Vintage clothing store

Vintage clothing store offers a brightly lit, well curated space with a gallery feel and comfortable fitting rooms. The atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, with a relaxed vibe and intentional, unique presentation. A vintage gaming setup adds an interactive element, making shopping more engaging.

Jewelry options include unique vintage pieces and gemstone rings with a bespoke feel. Staff assist with selections and polish chosen rings, offering affordable prices and fancy displays.

A well curated vintage shop with a constantly changing selection of high-quality pieces. Prices stay fair and surprisingly great for authentic leather and unique patterns.

People are saying

"The staff at this Vintage spot are so friendly and kind."

"The staff at this vintage shop are so kind and friendly."

"I found the jewelry prices unbelievably reasonable."

Good to know

1

Unearth hosts pop-up events regularly, check their schedule for details.

2

The shop is size inclusive, offering a wide range of clothing sizes.

3

Unearth Vintage features unique, one-of-a-kind items not found elsewhere.

10
A.S. & Sons Pawn Shop image 1

Pawn shop offers a cozy, friendly atmosphere with a wide selection of jewelry, vintage items, and collectibles. The space feels professional yet homey, attracting those looking for affordable watches and unique pieces. Staff provide quick, fair transactions in a well-maintained setting.

Michail greets immediately and shares deep knowledge about high-end rings, necklaces, and watches. The store offers a great selection of vintage jewelry and handles repairs with fair pricing.

Unique vintage jewelry stands out, especially a great selection of vintage earrings. The shop also offers collectibles like coins, vinyl records, and Rock n Roll memorabilia alongside fashion and decor.

People are saying

"Mike at the Jewelry Store was so professional and gave me a fair price."

"I found a great selection of vintage jewelry and decor here."

"I found the jewelry here to be affordable and high-quality."

Good to know

1

The shop offers quick cash services for items like jewelry and collectibles.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted, but cash is preferred.

3

The store has a wide variety of items including jewelry, high-end watches, and collectibles.

11
K & D Jewelry & Gold Buyers image 1

Shop offers an eclectic, rare, and modern selection of jewelry and watches with a vast watch collection and estate pieces. Atmosphere feels authentic and family-owned, with honest pricing and skilled repairs completed quickly. Regulars appreciate affordable, professional service and a safe, welcoming environment.

Eclectic, rare, and modern selection of rings, watches, and jewelry stands out here. On-the-spot repairs and resizing happen quickly, with knowledgeable service even near closing time.

Collectibles and trinkets fill the shelves alongside beautiful jewelry. The team handles everything from ring resizing to antique bracelet repairs with care.

People are saying

"I had my jewelry repaired here and the craftsmanship was excellent."

"Steve and the team at the Ring Store were super helpful and courteous."

"I found the art deco ring of my dreams at this vintage shop."

Good to know

1

The jewelry store offers quick watch repairs and battery replacements.

2

Pricing for repairs is very reasonable compared to other stores.

3

They provide services like ring resizing and jewelry cleaning.

12
VintageDiamondRing image 1
Jewelry store

Collection centers on unique vintage rings with a strong emphasis on Art Deco styles. Atmosphere feels trustworthy and personalized, reflecting a family-run small business vibe. Delivery and sizing services are fast and reliable, supporting a smooth buying experience.

A fabulous collection of vintage diamond rings stands out here. Stuart presents each piece with care, sharing detailed information and letting you try them on while answering all questions.

Many unique vintage rings fill the collection, including antique diamond guard bands and art deco diamond and emerald rings. Each piece feels special and one of a kind.

People are saying

"Stuart and Suzanne were so helpful finding the perfect ring."

"Stuart and Suzanne were so helpful finding the perfect ring."

"Stuart made the Vintage Shop experience memorable with his amazing rings."

Good to know

1

Free resizing is included with every purchase.

2

Overnight shipping is available at no extra cost.

3

All rings come with a 30-day full refund guarantee.

13
Awoke Vintage Brooklyn image 1
Vintage clothing store

Colorful, vibrant space with color-coded sections and a curated selection of vintage and trendy pieces creates a welcoming atmosphere. Crowds gather consistently, drawn by unique accessories like jewelry and cowboy boots alongside standout vintage jeans. Strong presence of women-led ownership adds character to the energetic vibe.

Jewelry section features beautiful, colorful, and vibrant pieces. The store offers a variety of items beyond jewelry, including cowboy boots and vintage Levi's, with several locations providing wide options.

Offers a huge selection of vintage Levi’s jeans with color-coded sections for easy browsing. Staff are helpful and the shop features a variety of items like jewelry and cowboy boots at great prices.

People are saying

"I found this vintage shop to be really cute and full of great options."

"I found the atmosphere and the unique items here to be super cool."

"I found amazing jewelry here, it's super cute."

Good to know

1

You can reserve and buy items if you watch their Instagram stories.

2

The store has good quality vintage pieces.

3

You don’t have to dig for items because everything is perfectly curated.

14
AuH2O image 1
Second hand store

Small shop offers a curated vintage selection with very affordable prices ranging mostly from $3 to $25. Atmosphere feels kind and welcoming, enhanced by sustainable packaging and thoughtful decorations. The vibe supports accessible thrifting with a feminine focus and inclusive sizing.

A wide range of vintage jewelry offers many styles and affordable options. The collection is nicely curated and draws attention with its variety and attentive service.

Offers a beautiful selection of vintage jewelry and true vintage items with really good quality that often look almost new. Prices stay insanely fair compared to other thrift or vintage shops.

People are saying

"This thrift store has a beautiful selection of jewelry."

"I loved the beautiful selection of vintage jewelry here."

"You'll find insanely fair prices on gorgeous vintage pieces here."

Good to know

1

The prices on vintage pieces are fair, starting as low as $3 for jewelry.

2

Clothing prices range from $10 to $25, making it very affordable.

3

The store has a great selection of stylish items at reasonable prices.

15
Second Chance Shoppe image 1
Second hand store

Secondhand store offers a well-curated selection of vintage clothing and accessories sorted by size. Atmosphere feels charming and lovely with good music enhancing the vibe. Prices stay reasonable while items maintain excellent quality and uniqueness.

Offers a variety of vintage jewelry pieces including affordable earrings priced around ten dollars. Also features unique housewares alongside the jewelry.

Unique and affordable vintage clothing stands out here. The shop offers a great selection of vintage toys, dresses, jewelry, and housewares with many cute finds.

People are saying

"I found so many fun and unique things here."

"The staff here is so kind and welcoming when you're looking for Women's Clothing."

"The staff at this vintage shop have such a welcoming energy."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a well-curated selection of secondhand items for all ages.

2

Prices are reasonable, making it a budget-friendly shopping option.

3

The store is organized by size, making it easy to browse.

16
avntgrdny image 1
Jewelry store

Small space with a beautiful setup and lounge chairs creates a cool vibe and authentic, welcoming atmosphere. Offers additional services like sneaker cleaning and features a rare collection of sneakers and garments. Prices are reasonable with a smooth transaction process and fast shipping.

Offers a rare collection of selected pieces with a wide variety of items. Provides quick deals and a smooth buying process for rings and jewelry.

Selection focuses on retro shoes and vintage shirts priced around $25. Staff shows deep knowledge of Jordan Retros and curates pieces with clear passion.

People are saying

"Andrew at the Footwear Store is such an amazing, trustworthy person."

"I found the best selection of Chrome Hearts jewelry here."

"The owner of this Vintage Shop is so knowledgeable and helpful."

Good to know

1

The store has super competitive prices on high-end brands like Chrome Hearts and Versace.

2

Online purchase and in-store pickup are available for quick access to items.

3

The Sole Broker has all the latest Jordans and hard-to-find older models.

17
Purdy Girl image 1
Clothing store

Boutique space offers a sparkly and fun atmosphere with a chic, trendy vibe. It attracts a diverse crowd looking for unique, well-curated clothing and accessories at great prices. The environment feels welcoming and lively, blending SoHo style with Upper West Side charm.

A beautiful store offers a big variety of pretty pieces in different styles and price ranges. Friendly staff help find bracelets, earrings, and more that suit all tastes and sizes.

Selection includes unique vintage designer finds like Hermès scarves and pre-owned designer bags. Vintage pieces show unmistakable character, including a vintage wool silk coat and a vintage-inspired fur vest.

People are saying

"I found the women's clothing here to be so beautiful and unique."

"I found the jewelry and accessories to be really cute and unique."

"The staff at this Vintage Shop were so helpful and sweet."

Good to know

1

The store has a great selection of on-trend clothes and accessories.

2

Purdy Girl offers excellent prices for women of all ages.

3

The boutique has a well-curated assortment of trendy clothing.

18
Kathe's Jewelry image 1
Jewelry store

Small family-owned jewelry store offers a welcoming atmosphere with unique vintage and new pieces. Skilled craftsmen provide quick, fair-priced repairs and custom work. The shop maintains a strong community connection and values customer care.

Unique vintage and new jewelry fill the selection, with expert repairs on rings, necklaces, and earrings. The team offers quick service, fair prices, and craftsmanship that restores pieces to better than new.

Unique vintage jewelry and gemstones stand out here. Staff show care and attention to detail with both vintage and newer pieces, offering expert resizing and knowledgeable service.

People are saying

"This jewelry store's staff are so kind and helpful."

"They fixed my watch quickly and effectively."

"I found unique vintage jewelry here."

Good to know

1

Pricing for repairs and services is very reasonable.

2

Turnaround for resizing services is about 48 hours.

3

The store offers unique jewelry designs not found in other stores.

19
Tarin Thomas image 1
Jewelry store

Shop offers an elevated, unique curation of jewelry and vintage items with a stylish, cool vibe. Space feels like an oasis with a wide selection including custom pieces and home goods. Atmosphere attracts those seeking chic, timeless designs and personalized options.

Offers a huge selection of high-quality jewelry including timeless vintage pieces and unique designs. Staff provide helpful service while shopping for bracelets and accessories.

Selection includes unique vintage watches, high-quality jewelry, and stylish clothing. Staff offers helpful guidance when choosing vintage pieces.

People are saying

"I found their vintage jewelry selection to be beautiful and unique."

"The jewelry here is beautiful, high-quality, and has unique designs."

"I found the vintage jewelry selection to be beautiful and unique."

Good to know

1

Tarin Thomas hosts pop-up events for small businesses on weekends.

2

The store is the only place in Manhattan to find ArtAche Hotel candles.

3

Tarin offers a wide variety of items, from candles to vintage clothes.

20
17th St by ColaKicks image 1

Boutique space offers a warm, vibey atmosphere with clean, welcoming design. It features an amazing selection of vintage luxury bags, shoes, and accessories at fair prices. The environment feels authentic and inviting, attracting those seeking unique, quality pieces.

Offers a great selection of vintage and pre-owned jewelry with luxury pieces from old and new designers. The store feels clean and welcoming with top-notch staff and a variety of unique items.

Offers a wide range of vintage designer bags and shoes with many unique and authentic pieces. The shop features vintage luxury finds including brands like Dior and FENDI at good prices.

People are saying

"The vintage staff here is so helpful and knowledgeable."

"The staff at this Vintage Shop are amazing and super helpful."

"I found the jewelry selection to be amazing and unique."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a curated selection of vintage designer bags, shoes, and apparel.

2

Expect to find many unique pieces of vintage fashion.

3

Prices are competitive, making it a great place for vintage finds.

21
Upper EastSide Thrift shop image 1

Shop offers vintage and designer pieces packed into a tight, boutique-style space. Atmosphere feels quiet and uninviting without background music, contrasting with nearby busy spots. Prices remain surprisingly low for high-quality, unique items.

Wide selection of vintage jewelry and custom pieces stands out. Prices stay low while offering branded items alongside unique finds.

Shelves overflow with vintage clothing, unique jewelry, and antique housewares. Art, pictures, and designer pieces fill the space alongside books, CDs, and handmade items.

People are saying

"I found this thrift store to be the best I'd ever been to."

"I found so many unique vintage pieces and handmade items."

"I found an amazing selection of vintage jewelry here."

Good to know

1

Thrift prices are $5 or less for most shirts and pants.

2

The thrift store offers a wide selection of jewelry, clothes, shoes, and home goods.

3

The selection includes vintage, unique, handmade, and designer pieces.

22
28 Scott Vintage image 1
Vintage clothing store

Vintage clothing store offers a beautifully curated collection with handcrafted goods and sterling silver jewelry. Warm, inviting atmosphere features incense from Bali and music that creates a relaxed vibe. Space feels spacious and welcoming, reflecting careful attention to detail.

A lovely selection of sterling silver earrings, rings, bracelets, anklets, and chains fills the shelves. The store offers handcrafted artisan jewelry alongside vintage pieces, all curated with care.

A beautiful curation of vintage treasures from around the world fills the shop. The home decor and vintage pieces show impeccable taste, and prices stay extremely reasonable.

People are saying

"I found beautiful, curated vintage pieces from all over the world."

"This vintage shop has a beautiful, curated selection of global treasures."

"I found a nice selection of jewelry and vintage goods here."

Good to know

1

The vintage store is super close to the L train and other bars and lunch places.

2

The prices for the suits are exceptional, with a gorgeous Italian wool suit costing $45.

3

The prices at the vintage store are amazing, especially for the high quality of the items.

23
Brooklyn Vintage Company image 1
Vintage clothing store

Vintage clothing store offers an extensive, well-curated selection of unique items including clothes, furniture, and vinyl. Spacious layout creates a pleasant, warm atmosphere with occasional live music enhancing the vibe. Prices range from reasonable bargains to high-end treasures, attracting a diverse crowd.

Silver jewelry stands out with a well curated selection. Staff offers good knowledge to help find pieces among a wide array of objects.

Offers an extensive, tastefully curated vintage selection including clothes, records, and furniture. The space features unique, high quality treasures and a wide range of historical style fashions.

People are saying

"This thrift store is a must-visit, I would live here if I could."

"I found this vintage shop's curated collection to be stunning and unique."

"I found so many well-curated items, including jewelry, at great prices."

Good to know

1

The store has a large selection of vintage home items and clothing.

2

Prices at the vintage store are generally fair and reasonable.

3

Expect to find beautiful vintage shoes, handbags, and vinyl records.

24
Pippin Vintage Jewelry image 1

Vintage jewelry store with impeccable organization and a wide selection spanning 19th-century to mid-20th-century pieces. Atmosphere feels lovely and inviting, attracting fashion enthusiasts and collectors seeking authentic costume and fine jewelry. Store offers both affordable and high-end items, including men's and women's accessories, with a steady flow of visitors requiring some patience.

A wide range of Art Deco jewelry and vintage pieces from the 20s to 60s fills the shelves, including rhinestone, enamel, and silver items. Staff are knowledgeable and helpful, making it easy to find unique antique and estate jewelry.

Authentic vintage jewelry fills the shelves, all impeccably organized and well-stocked. The collection includes antique and estate pieces that range in price, with some stunning finds under $100.

People are saying

"I found a beautiful selection of vintage jewelry at this vintage shop."

"I found a beautiful selection of vintage jewelry here."

"The staff at this jewelry store are so helpful and professional."

Good to know

1

The store has a beautiful selection of vintage jewelry, including gold and silver pieces.

2

Prices range from $20 for buttons to hundreds for antique jewelry.

3

The shop offers fast and well-crafted repair services for jewelry.

25
SSS DVD Video Corp image 1

Video store filled with antique collectibles and vintage electronics creates a slow-paced, nostalgic atmosphere. Services include watch and jewelry repair, alongside media formats like Blu-rays and DVDs. Regulars appreciate the affordable prices and the store's role as a neighborhood gem.

Greg handles jewelry repairs with clear expertise and years of experience. Quick fixes on items like gold-plated chains happen efficiently, making it a reliable spot for watch and jewelry maintenance.

Shelves hold a wide range of antiques and collectibles including signs, patches, and memorabilia. Walls display vintage travel posters and colorful, unique items that stand out.

People are saying

"The staff at this Watch Store are so friendly and welcoming."

"I found amazing vintage and collectible items here."

"This jewelry store's repair guy is a true artist who fixes watches."

Good to know

1

Prices for watch repair are affordable and competitive.

2

The store offers VHS tape conversion services.

3

They provide jewelry repair, cell phone repair, and computer repair.

26
This & That Unique Boutique image 1

Boutique blends vintage and modern clothing with affordable prices and a wide selection for men, women, and children. Music and occasional dance parties create a lively, positive vibe. The space feels charming and well organized, offering unique, stylish pieces beyond typical thrift stores.

Bracelets and costume jewelry stand out among the accessories. The store offers a variety of jewelry pieces alongside shoes and bags.

Offers a mix of vintage and modern clothing with a strong focus on the men's department featuring many vintage labels.

People are saying

"The owner here is so sweet and helpful finding great items."

"I found amazing designer labels and unique stylish pieces at this vintage shop."

"I met the owner; she's the sweetest woman."

Good to know

1

The boutique offers a wide selection of men's, women's, and children's clothing.

2

Prices are very affordable, making it a great spot for bargains.

3

Unique items include shoes, bags, jewelry, and formal dresses.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...