Lobster roll spots in New York

Seafood shines with generous lobster portions in a quiet, relaxed atmosphere. Lobster rolls come cold on textured bread with chips and a pickle. Space feels crowded at peak times but offers plenty of seating off-peak.

Generous lobster portions fill a textured bread roll that holds up well. The roll comes with chips and a pickle and offers a memorable, high-quality taste, though it might be better served hot.

Seafood market and grill offers fresh lobster in rolls served hot or cold with homemade chips. Casual, laid-back vibe with seating overlooking water creates a relaxed atmosphere. Prices beat Maine, making it a great spot for high-quality seafood and easy takeout.

Fresh lobster shines in the roll, served either hot or cold. Comes with homemade chips and costs less than in Maine.

Seafood market shines with fresh local catch and a lobster roll that is clean and satisfying. Cozy outdoor patio with hydrangeas offers a quiet, relaxed vibe. Casual, clean space includes gluten-free options and warm atmosphere.

Freshness stands out with the lobster roll containing no unnecessary ingredients. It offers a clean, tasty bite that energizes and satisfies seafood cravings.

Tiny space creates a loud, rushed atmosphere with cozy seating and a friendly vibe. Lobster roll features chunks of lobster served warm or cold with very little mayo and pairs with amazing slaw. Nautical and American themes add quaint charm attracting many locals.

Chunks of lobster come in a warm butter or cold style with very little mayo. The roll is made to order and pairs well with amazing slaw. It stands out as a delicious, well-crafted option on the menu.

Elegant space with dimmed lights and an octopus mural sets a cozy vibe. Spicy Maine Lobster Roll offers a notable spicy kick and fresh lobster. Atmosphere stays warm and inviting, perfect for a refined yet friendly sushi experience.

Spicy Maine Lobster Roll features a good portion of lobster and avocado. It stands out as a must-try with a notable spicy kick.

Seafood market shines with fresh fish and shellfish on ice and a phenomenal raw bar. Outdoor seating offers waterfront views and a relaxed vibe. Lobster rolls are meaty and well priced, making them a popular choice.

Meaty lobster rolls come fresh and plentiful, with a well priced menu offering. Staff actively suggest the lobster roll, highlighting its popularity alongside a phenomenal raw bar.

Seafood market offers fresh local catch and a relaxed vibe with outdoor seating surrounded by flowers. Lobster rolls are insanely well prepared and stand out for their flavor. Prices match the quality and freshness of the seafood.

Lobster rolls come insanely well prepared with a focus on fresh, flavorful lobster. They stand out as outstanding and consistently delicious among other seafood options.

Seafood market offers freshest seafood with unique dishes blending coastal, Jewish, and Asian flavors. Lobster rolls feature fresh lobster meat on a soft bun, delivering rich taste. Small seating and family-like vibe create a warm, casual atmosphere.

Two types of lobster rolls come with fresh lobster meat and a soft bun. Both versions offer a rich, satisfying flavor that stands out among other seafood options.

Enjoy fresh lobster roll with truffle fries in a cozy spot blending rustic charm and modern style. Relax outdoors by the water or inside with live acoustic music creating a lively vibe. Perfect for dates and family meals with a welcoming atmosphere.

Lobster roll features fresh lobster meat served in a soft bun. It pairs well with sides like truffle fries and offers a delicious, satisfying flavor.

Seafood market offers fresh fish selection and a casual, dog-friendly atmosphere with outdoor seating. Enjoy a toasty, buttery lobster roll packed with succulent meat, served with fries and coleslaw. Local canned wine adds a relaxed, affordable touch to the meal.

A toasty, buttery roll holds a generous amount of succulent lobster meat, including claws. The lobster roll comes with fries and coleslaw, making it a complete and satisfying meal.

Pier-side setting offers spectacular waterfront views and a lively yet relaxed vibe with live DJ music. Lobster rolls are a highlight, known for being delicious and well-priced. Perfect for groups seeking a vibrant social scene and casual gatherings.

Offers lobster rolls that are consistently delicious and well-priced. The rolls stand out as a highlight among the menu items.

Grand decor with Versailles-style ceilings sets an elegant scene for girls' nights and holiday parties. Spacious private rooms offer perfect spots for celebrations. Mini lobster rolls shine with juicy lobster and rich garlic butter, matching the upscale vibe.

Mini lobster rolls come with juicy lobster and rich garlic butter flavors. They appear alongside other premium items like wagyu kalbi and fried rice.

Compact seafood truck offers award-winning lobster rolls with whole lobster pieces on homemade brioche buns. Oceanfront dining creates a warm, relaxing vibe with reasonable prices. Steady crowd enjoys fresh meals and beach views.

Whole lobster pieces fill a buttered brioche bun for a fresh and incredibly delicious bite. This lobster roll wins awards and stands out as the best hot lobster roll in the area.

Food court offers fast casual dining with a variety of styles near Battery Park. Lobster roll shines with freshness and packed lobster, perfect with indulgent cocktails. Atmosphere suits quick meals, not leisurely dining.

Freshness stands out with packed lobster and flavorful taste. The roll pairs well with indulgent cocktails.

Seafood restaurant shines with spacious interior and impeccable cleanliness. Lobster rolls feature fresh chunks in a perfectly toasted bun. Cajun spice aroma fills the air, matching well with their soju and beer selection.

A perfectly toasted bun holds generous, fresh chunks of lobster in the roll. The $20 lobster roll and soda lunch deal offers a good value with really delicious taste.

Elegant 80s-inspired decor sets a lively yet balanced vibe with carefully curated lighting and DJ music. Mini lobster rolls offer rich, intense flavor in snack-sized portions. Bar program shines with well-crafted cocktails and expert sommelier picks.

Mini lobster rolls come in very small portions, more like a snack size. The lobster roll has a rich, intense flavor that stands out as insane and delicious.

Seafood market offers fresh fish displays and a laid-back atmosphere with picnic tables for casual dining. Lobster rolls come packed with chunks of lobster mixed with mayo and celery, making them very filling. It pairs well with seafood sides like shrimp and crab.

Chunks of lobster fill the roll, mixed with mayo and celery for texture. The warm lobster roll is very filling and pairs well with seafood sides like shrimp and crab.

British restaurant buzzes with a lively atmosphere and live singing that energizes the space. Hot, buttery Connecticut style lobster roll shines with garlic-butter sauce, paired perfectly with salad and fries. Friendly vibe and happy hour crowd make it a casual, fun spot.

Hot and buttery Connecticut style lobster roll comes with a garlic-butter sauce that adds rich flavor. The burger and lobster roll combo highlights the lobster roll as a signature dish, served alongside salad and fries.

Casual spot serves fresh lobster roll with buttery, soft bread. Known for smash burgers and a relaxed atmosphere with great music. Perfect for quick bites or small groups, it stays busy but clean and welcoming.

Fresh lobster fills a soft, savory, and buttery roll. The lobster roll offers a great taste that hits the spot every time.

Seafood market offers fresh, minimally processed seafood and a wide variety of fish. Lobster rolls feature toasted baguette and come with fries or chips at a good price. Atmosphere is warm and welcoming, perfect for both shopping and dining.

Lobster rolls come freshly prepared with lettuce on a perfectly toasted baguette instead of a typical roll. Portions are decent-sized and often served with fries or chips at a good price.

Bright, clean space with a marine vibe offers quick, friendly service. Warm lobster rolls feature buttered, seasoned lobster with mayo-free and spicy honey grilled cheese options. Casual spot perfect for fresh, authentic seafood lovers.

Warm lobster rolls come perfectly toasted with buttered, seasoned lobster. Options include versions without mayo and a spicy honey lobster grilled cheese with pickles on the side.

Waterside setting offers stunning views and a relaxing atmosphere. Lobster rolls are buttery and rich, topped with truffle or caviar. Creative drinks and desserts shine, while private spaces and a DJ add versatile energy for events.

Lobster rolls come buttery and rich, with options like truffle and caviar toppings. The bisque served alongside adds an extra layer of flavor.

Waterfront setting offers beautiful bay views and a large sandy play space for kids and pets, creating a dog-friendly vibe. Fresh lobster roll stands out for its delicious freshness, paired well with raw clams and shrimp cocktail. Inside gets loud and crowded during live DJ or band shows.

Freshness stands out with the lobster roll here, offering a delicious and yummy taste. It pairs well with other fresh seafood like raw clams and shrimp cocktail.

Enjoy fresh lobster rolls made daily in a charming cottage-style market. The mom-and-pop feel creates an authentic, inviting atmosphere. Cash-only, takeaway spot offers smoked fish spread and great value with a two-for-$30 lobster roll deal.

Lobster rolls come super fresh, prepared the same morning. They offer a two for $30 deal that many find affordable and a great value. The rolls are consistently described as phenomenal and delicious.

Basement setting offers a low key vibe with views of Little Island and south Manhattan. Vietnamese style lobster roll delivers fresh, crunchy texture and bold flavor. Creative seafood dishes with South Asian and Vietnamese flavors shine alongside fresh lobster and oysters.

Vietnamese style shapes the lobster roll with fresh, crunchy texture and bold flavor. Generous portions deliver a phenomenal taste that stands out as legendary.

Seafood shines with fresh lobster rolls packed with lobster and light mayo. Bright, open-air seating creates a baby-friendly vibe amid lively, noisy crowds. Bar offers well-crafted cocktails and a solid beer selection that pairs perfectly with seafood.

Lobster rolls come with lots of lobster and not too much mayo. They stay super fresh and work well for any meal.

Huge venue offers a nostalgic vibe with chic, trendy decor and upbeat energy. Caviar lobster rolls deliver luxurious flavor that pairs well with other favorites. Polished setting creates a refined ambiance perfect for reservations.

Caviar lobster rolls stand out with rich, luxurious flavor. The lobster roll pairs well with other favorites like the French dip and pizza rolls.

Cozy Korean spot shines with intimate atmosphere and unique cocktails. Lobster roll offers rich flavor and perfect balance, with mini versions perfect for sharing. Warm vibe suits both dates and group dinners.

Lobster roll stands out with its rich flavor and perfect balance of ingredients. Mini versions offer a delicious bite-sized experience that guests often order more than once.

Small seafood spot offers fresh lobster rolls packed with lobster and served on buttery bread. Cozy, Maine-themed decor creates a warm vibe despite tight seating. Free chips add a nice touch to the warm butter lobster experience.

Lobster rolls come overstuffed with lobster and feature a great roll with minimal mayo. The warm butter version is very delicious and not soggy, served with free chips.

Seafood spot offers fresh lobster rolls with big chunks of meat served warm in buttered bread. Spacious indoor and outdoor seating creates a laid-back dockside vibe. Atmosphere suits quick bites more than long meals, making it ideal for grab-and-go dining.

Lobster rolls come with big chunks of lobster meat served warm in buttered bread. The rolls are simply seasoned with butter and offer a spicy honey option alongside the classic.