Compact seafood truck offers oceanfront dining with warm, relaxing vibe and reasonable prices. Lobster rolls stand out as award-winning and fresh, served on homemade brioche buns. The setting draws a steady crowd seeking quality meals with a beach view.
"The lobster roll here has whole lobster pieces, not mayo."
"I kept the ocean-side location of this beach to myself."
"The lobster roll food here has whole lobster pieces on a buttered brioche bun."
Good to know
The food truck operates daily from 11am to 7pm.
Expect a casual atmosphere with beach views while dining.
Prices are reasonable, with most items under $20.
Small standing-room sushi bar offers fresh, creative rolls with exceptional presentation. Casual, charming vibe shines through outdoor seating and quality control by staff. Hidden gem perfect for quick bites or takeout.
Food arrives fresh and delicious with exceptional presentation, even for takeout. Staff focus on quality control enhances the dining experience.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended, especially during peak summer months.
Takeout orders are available and usually ready within 20 minutes.
Parking is limited, so arrive early or consider carpooling.
Ocean views create a quiet atmosphere perfect for relaxing. Fresh dishes like Duck and clam chowder impress with flavor. Staff offer attentive service that enhances the experience.
Food delivers fresh cuisine with impeccable service. Dishes like Duck, Sauerbraten, and clam chowder stand out for their quality and flavor.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended, especially for ocean view tables.
Children must remain seated at all times per house rules.
Expect higher prices due to the quality of food and location.
Motel offers a peaceful setting with weekly live music and an outdoor bar for a laid-back vibe. Rooms are newly renovated and comfortable. Menu features fresh seafood salad and authentic Italian dishes at good prices.
Fresh seafood salad and meatballs stand out as exceptional specials. The menu offers authentic Italian dishes with reasonable prices in a relaxed, old-school sailor vibe.
Good to know
The Sail Inn offers accessible rooms with features like grab bars and roll-in showers.
Handicap parking is available right near the entrance.
Food portions are tapas-sized but priced as full entrees.
Courtyard offers fire pits lit every evening and a clean, inviting pool near the beach and downtown. Rooms feature coastal decor with comfy beds and kitchenettes. Food impresses with gourmet selections and great presentation.
Excellent food quality stands out with varied gourmet selections and nice presentation throughout the menu.
Good to know
The motel is dog-friendly, allowing pets during your stay.
It's just a short walk to the beach, making it convenient for beachgoers.
The motel is located near downtown Montauk, close to shops and restaurants.
Historic charm meets 5-star quality food with dishes like swordfish meatballs and orecchiette with sausage. Cozy, intimate seating and classic crooner music create a romantic vibe perfect for a warm, nostalgic night out.
Food features 5-star quality with standout dishes like swordfish meatballs and orecchiette with sausage and broccoli rabe. Options like linguine and clams, Milanese, and carbonara offer great taste at a good price.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended, especially for dinner service.
Parking is available, but it may require a short walk to the restaurant.
Expect higher prices for cocktails, as they may include additional charges.
Seafood market offers fresh lobster rolls and smoked fish spread with great value. Family-run, it has a cute cottage design and an authentic, inviting atmosphere. Operates cash-only with no seating, keeping a mom-and-pop feel.
Food here is consistently freshly made and offers great value. Lobster rolls and other dishes come from a beautiful home setting, delivering excellent quality and quantity.
Good to know
Bennett Shellfish is takeout only and accepts cash only.
There is no seating area available at Bennett Shellfish.
The lobster rolls are priced at a fraction of the tourist spots in Montauk.
Hotel offers gorgeous views and spacious rooms with unique layouts. Grounds feel like a luxury Caribbean resort with well-kept landscapes. Meals are a highlight with delicious food that makes dining enjoyable.
Delicious food stands out here, making meals enjoyable. The quality of dishes consistently compensates for other less comfortable aspects.
Good to know
Murder Mystery weekends are popular and require advance reservations.
Oktoberfest events feature fireworks and are held annually.
Dinner service is available after obtaining a liquor license.
Outdoor seating with shaded benches creates a relaxed spot near the beach. Menu offers large portions and unique burritos with fresh, hot Latin flavors. Prices are reasonable with a cash discount, giving good value for quality food.
Food features fresh, hot dishes with a strong focus on high quality Latin and Mexican options. Prices reflect the quality, offering good value for the area.
Good to know
Bring cash for a discount on your total bill.
The restaurant's prices may differ from what's listed on the menu.
Quincho's is open year-round for dining.
Overlooking a marina, this spot offers scenic water views and a local yacht club vibe with live music and family fun. Food is fresh and generous, featuring mouthwatering cuisine and large rice portions. Open-air seating with ceiling fans keeps it cool and pet-friendly.
Food features freshness and great quality with mouthwatering cuisine. Portions include rice that can feed groups with leftovers.
Good to know
Cash is needed for tipping as credit card payments do not allow tips.
The restaurant is pet friendly and welcomes dogs on the patio.
Expect a quieter atmosphere on weekdays compared to weekends.
Bar and grill offers harbor views and a casual pub vibe with quirky signs and dim, cave-like lighting. Menu features fresh seafood like tuna melts and soft shell crabs at good prices. Atmosphere feels down to earth and lively, popular with locals and blue-collar workers.
Food features fresh seafood like tuna melts and soft shell crabs, capturing coastal flavors. The menu offers wide variety with high-quality, freshly made dishes at reasonable prices.
Good to know
The restaurant is closed on Mondays.
Expect long wait times during lunch hours due to popularity.
They do not allow dogs inside or outside the restaurant.
Oceanfront setting offers breathtaking views and a quiet beach with no busy roads. Food truck serves outstanding meals with amazing quality. Fire pits add a unique touch to the relaxed, peaceful atmosphere.
An on-site food truck serves outstanding meals with a consistently amazing quality.
Good to know
Wavecrest offers complimentary umbrellas and lounges for guests.
The resort is located on a secluded section of beach adjacent to a state park.
The rooms are clean and comfortable with stunning ocean views.
Oceanfront setting offers stunning views and a serene atmosphere with cozy spots for relaxation. Enjoy Michelin star chef meals and great coffee, plus heated pool and fire pits with s'mores for a calm retreat feel.
Breakfast and lunch feature great coffee and incredible food prepared by a Michelin star chef. The chocolate chip cookies and vegetable platters stand out for their quality and flavor.
Good to know
The resort charges a daily resort fee of $182.60 per accommodation.
The hotel offers daily activities like yoga and creative workshops.
Nightly bonfires with s'mores are hosted for guests.
Stylish hotel grounds boast a beautiful pool and garden areas with an onsite bar and restaurant. Pool food is excellent and staff deliver attentive service. Rooms offer cozy decor and quiet spaces, blending a relaxed vibe with an adult pool party energy.
Excellent pool food and a wonderful bar complement the dining options. Staff provide attentive and knowledgeable service that enhances the overall food experience.
Good to know
Happy hour features $10 drinks, making it a great deal for guests.
The hotel hosts art and music events regularly for guests to enjoy.
The pool area is accessible to non-guests during the day, limiting guest access.
Tiki bar offers a laid-back vibe with live classic 60s and 70s soft rock sets. Adults-only after 6pm ensures a relaxed atmosphere by the marina. Food stands out with delicious flavors and consistently amazing quality that matches the lively music.
Food stands out for its delicious flavors and consistently amazing quality. Dishes deliver more than expected, matching the lively atmosphere and great music.
Good to know
Lynn's Hula Hut welcomes kids until 9 pm Monday–Thursday and until 5 pm on weekends.
No children are allowed after 6 pm, creating an adult-only atmosphere.
Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends to avoid long wait times.
Deli opens at 5am with fresh eggs and monster sandwiches. Offers fair prices and hearty portions. Some meals arrive exactly as ordered, but occasional issues like finding a hair have occurred.
Food offers amazing quality and fair prices with items like the Viking Panini providing a large portion. Some meals arrive exactly as ordered, but occasional issues like finding a hair in the food have occurred.
Good to know
M&R DELI opens at 5am, making it a great early breakfast option.
The deli offers a variety of sandwiches, including Buffalo Chicken and turkey.
Breakfast is served all day, providing flexible dining options.
Classic drive-in with a vintage 1980s diner vibe offers fast, hot food served personally by the owner. Cash-only and lively, it attracts a laid-back beach-town crowd seeking simple, authentic American fare. Both indoor and outdoor seating add to its straightforward charm.
Food arrives fast and stays hot, with consistently great taste and inexpensive prices. The owner personally serves the meals, adding a personal touch to the quick service.
Good to know
It's cash only; bring cash or use the onsite ATM.
The parking lot is small and often full during peak hours.
Be prepared for long lines, especially at night.
Resort hotel offers modern luxury and rustic charm with a large infinity pool and beachfront dining. Food shines with the crispy Frito Misto and friendly service. Atmosphere stays laid-back with calming sea breezes and fun family features like pool games and fire pits.
Food features delicious flavors with the Frito Misto standing out as crispy and perfect for sharing. Service complements the outstanding food well.
Good to know
The onsite restaurant offers a diverse menu with excellent reviews.
Expect additional charges for amenities like a small refrigerator in the room.
The hotel is close to the beach and main attractions in Montauk.
Casual spot with fresh seafood and authentic Chinese dishes like duck buns. Food is flavor-packed with generous portions and friendly service. Highlights include scallion pancakes and spicy shrimp lo mein.
Food here is flavor-packed and high quality with generous portions like lobster. Service is consistently friendly and outstanding.
Good to know
There is plenty of parking available nearby.
Expect to pay around $24 for a beef fried rice dish.
Online prices may not reflect current menu pricing.
Old school Italian spot shines with homemade lasagna and traditional tomato sauce. Cozy vibe and outdoor seating make it great for family dinners. Background Van Morrison tunes add a warm, nostalgic touch.
Food features fresh ingredients and authentic flavors with dishes like lasagna that taste homemade. Tomato sauce stands out with a traditional Italian style.
Good to know
Expect a cozy, old-school Italian atmosphere perfect for family dinners.
Prices may be higher than average for Italian cuisine in the area.
Reservations might be a good idea during busy weekend dinner hours.
Store offers great views and a wide range of products like a mini mall. Food includes fast foods and fresh-cooked items, with many frozen beforehand. Atmosphere is quiet at night with quick lines for fast service.
Food includes fast foods and health essentials with some items cooked fresh when ordered, despite many being frozen beforehand.
Good to know
This 7-Eleven offers a wide variety of fast foods and essentials.
Expect quick lines for checkout, making it convenient for a quick stop.
Prices are generally higher than average, reflecting the convenience factor.
Mexican spot offers fresh ingredients and standout fish tacos in a cozy, relaxed vibe with both indoor and outdoor seating. Friendly staff handle allergies well, keeping meals affordable and enjoyable.
Delicious Mexican food stands out here with friendly service that accommodates food allergies well. Prices stay affordable while delivering consistently good meals.
Good to know
The restaurant offers good vegetarian and vegan options.
You can eat outside on the patio.
Expect to pay around $71 for five tacos with chips and guacamole.
Half bar, half restaurant space features underlit blue bar and nice decor. Food is healthy portions with delicious flavors and fair prices. Atmosphere shifts from laid back to lively with live music, creating a beach town vibe.
Outstanding food offers healthy portions at fair prices. Dishes come with delicious flavors and consistent quality.
Good to know
Happy hour offers $1.00 oysters, making it a popular choice.
Reservations are accepted for private events, but not always communicated.
Expect high prices; drinks can cost $18 each.