Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Montauk

Seafood and fish

You want a meal where the fish is the only thing that matters.

Based on 579 Opinions
+576
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
TailWrapped Sportfishing: Tuna Fishing Montauk, Shark Fishing, Charter Fishing, Fluke Fishing image 1
TailWrapped Sportfishing: Tuna Fishing Montauk, Shark Fishing, Charter Fishing, Fluke Fishing image 2
TailWrapped Sportfishing: Tuna Fishing Montauk, Shark Fishing, Charter Fishing, Fluke Fishing image 3
View all

Boat offers plenty of space and stays impeccably clean throughout the trip. Atmosphere feels like a big family fun trip filled with excitement and friendliness. Crew uses top notch equipment and knows exact fishing spots, delivering a memorable fishing experience.

An experienced skipper and crew lead directly to fish hotspots from the start. Trips result in catching huge fish, with everyone going home with a catch.

Captain Jim and the crew lead straight to fish from the first drop. Lines hit the water and fish bite immediately.

People are saying

"The captain knows the exact spots to find fish."

"This place is so Kid Friendly; the captains are great with kids."

"The captain and crew really know where to find the fish."

Good to know

1

Captain Jim is known for his expertise in Striped bass, Fluke, and sea bass fishing.

2

The boat is well-maintained and kept clean throughout the trip.

3

Sean and his crew are knowledgeable about local fishing spots.

02
My Joyce Charters- Montauk Fishing Charters image 1

Boat offers spacious, clean, and organized surroundings with perfect gear ready for fishing. Energy stays high with immediate action responding to changing conditions, ensuring consistent catches. Knowledgeable captain guides a safe and comfortable experience suitable for all skill levels.

Fishing trips deliver huge hauls and a wide variety of fish. The captain and crew stay on the fish and provide constant assistance to ensure plenty of catches.

Catching a huge variety of fish happens regularly, with many being oversized and released. The captain and crew stay right on the fish and help reel them in, making sure everyone catches plenty.

People are saying

"Captain Ken and his mate kept us on the fish all day."

"Captain Ken and Mike made sure we had the best time possible."

Good to know

1

Booking in advance is recommended to secure your spot on the charter.

2

The charter is suitable for both beginners and experienced anglers.

3

Safety gear is provided on board for all passengers.

03
Kopis Charters image 1
Fishing charter

Grady White boat offers a smooth, comfortable ride through choppy waters with an intimate setting for up to five people. The atmosphere stays casual and serene, enhanced by a customizable music playlist and family-friendly environment. Trips include knowledgeable guidance on local waters and dining, creating a relaxed and memorable fishing experience.

Fishing yields fluke, dog fish, mackerel, and black sea bass. Guests can use their own gear and cook their catch right on the boat's grill.

Fishing here lets you use your own gear with no hassle. The boat has a grill for cooking fish immediately, creating a sea to table experience with plenty of fish caught.

People are saying

"Captain Anthony made our fishing trip fun and educational."

"Captain Anthony's patient guidance made fishing feel comfortable and fun."

"Anthony is a knowledgeable and friendly guide for a great day fishing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to secure your spot on the fishing charter.

2

The charter allows you to bring your own beverages on board.

3

The boat is family-friendly and suitable for children.

04
Fin Chaser image 1
Fishing charter

Fishing charter boat offers an immaculate, comfortable setting with luxury touches like clean, flushing bathrooms. The atmosphere is friendly and lively, enhanced by on-point music that keeps energy high. The captain maintains nonstop action, consistently finding fish spots for a rewarding experience.

Captain Keith works hard to keep the boat on the fish all day. He is persistent and makes sure everyone goes home with plenty of fish.

Captain Keith consistently positions the boat where fish are abundant and moves around to keep the catch steady. Crew members help load buckets and ensure everyone is catching fish without wasting time.

People are saying

"The captain and crew here are so friendly and helpful when you fish."

"The boat and restrooms were clean."

"The crew made sure everyone went home with plenty of seafood."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required in advance for fishing trips on the Fin Chaser II.

2

The boat is clean and comfortable for all passengers.

3

The captain is well-known for his skills and knowledge of fishing spots.

05
The Dock Bar & Grill image 1

Bar and grill with harbor views and quirky, unapologetic atmosphere featuring humorous signs and casual pub vibe. Lighting is dim and cave-like, creating a laid-back, friendly environment popular among locals and blue-collar workers. Place feels no-frills and down to earth, with a fun, upbeat energy especially on busy nights.

Fresh seafood stands out with scallops on roll and soft shell crabs cooked perfectly. Fish tacos and zuppa de clams add variety, while the special horseradish fish offers a unique flavor.

Fish dishes feature fresh seafood with highlights like fish tacos and a special horseradish fish. Shrimp appetizers and fried fish also appear regularly on the menu.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh, especially the scallops and flounder."

"It's a super chill spot for a casual, no-frills waterfront bite."

"I found the fish tacos to be very good."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is closed on Mondays.

2

Expect long wait times during lunch hours due to popularity.

3

They do not allow dogs inside or outside the restaurant.

06
Bennett Shellfish image 1
Seafood market

Takeaway-only seafood market with a cute cottage design and mom-and-pop feel. Atmosphere is authentic and inviting, reflecting a family-run tradition spanning generations. Known for fresh lobster rolls and smoked fish spread, it operates on a cash-only basis with no seating available.

Fresh wild oysters and shellfish get shucked and plated on the spot. Owners prepare seafood boils and offer smoked fish spread and ready-to-eat lobster rolls.

Freshness stands out with fish meant to be eaten the same day. The smoked fish dip shines as a notable item, alongside local oysters and ready-to-eat lobster rolls.

People are saying

"The seafood here is always so fresh, especially the oysters."

"I had the best lobster roll Iโ€™ve ever tasted here."

"I found the fish here to be the freshest of the fresh."

Good to know

1

Bennett Shellfish is takeout only and accepts cash only.

2

There is no seating area available at Bennett Shellfish.

3

The lobster rolls are priced at a fraction of the tourist spots in Montauk.

07
El Taco Ole Montauk image 1
Mexican restaurant

Mexican restaurant with casual, relaxed vibe and chilled atmosphere featuring both indoor and outdoor seating. Space feels cozy but well-arranged to accommodate guests comfortably. Known for fresh ingredients and standout fish tacos that exceed expectations.

Fish tacos stand out with excellent corn tortillas and crispy batter. The beer-battered fish bowl offers a fresh, large portion. Shrimp dishes, especially the shrimp tacos, are flavorful and well-sized.

Fish tacos feature excellent corn tortillas, fresh fish, and a crispy batter. The beer-battered fish bowl stands out as a favorite dish.

People are saying

"I thought the fish tacos were the best I've ever had."

"I thought the fish tacos were the best I ever had."

"The fish tacos here are amazing."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers good vegetarian and vegan options.

2

You can eat outside on the patio.

3

Expect to pay around $71 for five tacos with chips and guacamole.

08
Viking Fleet image 1
Fishing charter

Fishing charter features a comfortable heated boat with adjustable seating and an onboard galley serving breakfast sandwiches. The atmosphere is calm and scenic, with frequent sightings of whales and dolphins enhancing the experience. Captains use local knowledge to find productive fishing spots, making it suitable even for beginners.

Trips yield loads of fish, often over 40 caught. Crew members like Roland and Theo offer fishing tips and help with unhooking. Fish can be filleted on site for a fee or taken home in large quantities.

Loads of fish show up during trips, making it easy to catch an abundance even for beginners. The captain and crew work hard to keep you on the fish, and they offer filleting services plus recommendations for nearby spots that cook your catch.

People are saying

"You'll catch so much fish your hands will get tired."

"I caught so much seafood, my hands were tired."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to secure a spot on the fishing trip.

2

The trip costs $142, with additional fees for fish cleaning and tackle.

3

Arrive on time; the boat departs promptly at the scheduled time.

09
Star Island Grill image 1

Restaurant overlooks marina with scenic water views and an open-air breeze from ceiling fans and windows. Atmosphere blends relaxed charm with live music and family-friendly entertainment. Space welcomes pets and offers a local yacht club vibe away from tourist crowds.

Fresh fish like flounder and striper can be cooked on site with a "you hook-we cook" service. Dishes include fish tacos with varied textures, tempura, and a balanced white chowder blending fish, vegetables, and cream.

Fish dishes come with diverse textures like soft fish, crunchy vegetables, and smooth sauce. The kitchen offers a you hook-we cook service, preparing fresh catches into global dishes such as tempura, fish tacos, and Chinese-style rice. Fish tacos stand out with full flavor and varied textures.

People are saying

"The food here is phenomenal, full of flavor and fresh."

"They cooked my catch into amazing dishes like tempura and fish tacos."

"They prepared my catch into tempura, fish tacos, and bang bang salad."

Good to know

1

Cash is needed for tipping as credit card payments do not allow tips.

2

The restaurant is pet friendly and welcomes dogs on the patio.

3

Expect a quieter atmosphere on weekdays compared to weekends.

10
Montauk Seaside House sushi Bar image 1

Small standing-room sushi bar with plenty of outdoor seating creates a casual, charming atmosphere. Chefs prepare fresh, creative sushi rolls that attract many takeout orders. The place feels like a hidden gem with a relaxed vibe and easy access.

Fish comes in super fresh and offers incredible quality at a fair price. The Rainbow Nanuto roll skips rice and combines vegetables with fish, while the Sashimi Deluxe includes 18 assorted pieces featuring salmon, octopus, and tuna.

Fish here is mostly fresh and offered at a fair price. The Rainbow Nanuto roll features fish without rice, and the Sashimi Deluxe includes assorted sashimi pieces like salmon, octopus, and tuna, though some fish have a slight smell.

People are saying

"The sushi here is outstanding and creative."

"The fish rolls here are so creative and delicious."

"The seafood here is so fresh."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially during peak summer months.

2

Takeout orders are available and usually ready within 20 minutes.

3

Parking is limited, so arrive early or consider carpooling.

11
MTK Lobster House image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant offers casual, family-friendly atmosphere with indoor and outdoor seating, including a patio overlooking Main Street. Ambiance stays quiet and restful, attracting a great crowd for relaxed dining.

Freshness stands out with very fresh oysters and seafood. Shrimp dishes feature well-cooked shrimp and sauces with the right texture. Fish and chips also appear on the menu.

Fish dishes include fish and chips, a lobster roll, and mixed tacos with fried and blackened fish. The fish and chips and lobster roll come across as average, while the lobster melt adds some variety.

People are saying

"The lobster roll here is sweet and plentiful."

"The seafood here is so fresh and delicious."

"The fish and chips here were okay."

Good to know

1

Caution is advised for those with dietary restrictions due to potential contamination.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted, but check for Apple Pay compatibility.

3

Outdoor seating is available for guests with pets.

12
Shagwong image 1
Seafood restaurant

Dark interior with rustic fisherman-style decor and near-ocean vibes creates a lively, vibrant atmosphere filled with locals and live music. Spacious seating includes large family tables and a bar area with sports on TV. Outdoor area feels neglected, contrasting with the energetic indoor scene.

Seafood here stands out for its freshness and local catch. Dishes like the crispy fish and chips and blackened fish sandwiches deliver solid flavor and texture, while the seafood paella and tower offer generous portions.

Fish comes fresh and local with a crispy batter that avoids oily residue. Options include blackened fish sandwiches and crispy fish and chips that satisfy salty cravings.

People are saying

"The American Food here has a really fun, jamming atmosphere."

"The seafood here is so fresh, I've never had anything fresher."

"The fish and chips here are the real deal."

Good to know

1

The kitchen and bar are open from 12pm to 12am every day.

2

Expect large portions; come hungry.

3

A 20% gratuity is automatically added to bills.

Discover more

Montauk, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...