Boat feels like a big family trip with a friendly crew. Skipper leads to fish hotspots using top notch equipment. Trips end with huge fish caught by all, making it a fun and memorable experience.
An experienced skipper and crew lead directly to fish hotspots from the start. Trips result in catching huge fish, with everyone going home with a catch.
"The captain knows the exact spots to find fish."
"This place is so Kid Friendly; the captains are great with kids."
"The captain and crew really know where to find the fish."
Good to know
Captain Jim is known for his expertise in Striped bass, Fluke, and sea bass fishing.
The boat is well-maintained and kept clean throughout the trip.
Sean and his crew are knowledgeable about local fishing spots.
Boat offers spacious, clean gear and a knowledgeable captain for safe trips. Fishing yields huge hauls with constant crew help. Energy stays high with quick action for consistent catches.
Fishing trips deliver huge hauls and a wide variety of fish. The captain and crew stay on the fish and provide constant assistance to ensure plenty of catches.
Good to know
Booking in advance is recommended to secure your spot on the charter.
The charter is suitable for both beginners and experienced anglers.
Safety gear is provided on board for all passengers.
Grady White boat offers a smooth ride and cozy space for five. Guests catch fluke and sea bass, then grill fresh seafood onboard. Music and expert tips create a family-friendly and relaxed atmosphere for fishing and dining.
Fishing yields fluke, dog fish, mackerel, and black sea bass. Guests can use their own gear and cook their catch right on the boat's grill.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended to secure your spot on the fishing charter.
The charter allows you to bring your own beverages on board.
The boat is family-friendly and suitable for children.
Fresh wild oysters and lobster rolls shine at this family-run seafood market with a cozy cottage vibe. Cash-only, no seating, it offers authentic smoked fish spread and quick seafood boils. The inviting, mom-and-pop feel makes every visit special.
Fresh wild oysters and shellfish get shucked and plated on the spot. Owners prepare seafood boils and offer smoked fish spread and ready-to-eat lobster rolls.
Good to know
Bennett Shellfish is takeout only and accepts cash only.
There is no seating area available at Bennett Shellfish.
The lobster rolls are priced at a fraction of the tourist spots in Montauk.
Ocean views create a quiet atmosphere perfect for relaxing. Lobster cake and fried scallop basket highlight fresh seafood options. Staff provide attentive service, making every visit enjoyable.
Fish specials stand out with options like lobster cake and fried scallop basket. Shrimp appears in several dishes, including shrimp pasta, paired with linguini and clams for variety.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended, especially for ocean view tables.
Children must remain seated at all times per house rules.
Expect higher prices due to the quality of food and location.
Fishing trips stay lively with nonstop action and upbeat music. Captain Keith's persistence ensures plenty of fish for everyone. Enjoy a comfortable setting with clean, flushing bathrooms on board.
Captain Keith works hard to keep the boat on the fish all day. He is persistent and makes sure everyone goes home with plenty of fish.
Good to know
Reservations are required in advance for fishing trips on the Fin Chaser II.
The boat is clean and comfortable for all passengers.
The captain is well-known for his skills and knowledge of fishing spots.
Outdoor seating with shaded benches creates a relaxed lunch spot near the beach. Shrimp burritos deliver rich flavor and freshness, while fish tacos offer a tasty blend of fresh ingredients. Large portions and reasonable pricing make it a great choice for seafood lovers.
Shrimp burritos stand out with rich flavor and freshness. Fish tacos offer fresh ingredients and a tasty blend, while shrimp and chicken tacos add variety.
Good to know
Bring cash for a discount on your total bill.
The restaurant's prices may differ from what's listed on the menu.
Quincho's is open year-round for dining.
Bar and grill offers fresh seafood like scallops on a roll and soft shell crabs. Harbor views add charm to the casual pub vibe with dim, cave-like lighting. Humorous signs create a quirky atmosphere loved by locals and blue-collar workers.
Fresh seafood stands out with scallops on roll and soft shell crabs cooked perfectly. Fish tacos and zuppa de clams add variety, while the special horseradish fish offers a unique flavor.
Good to know
The restaurant is closed on Mondays.
Expect long wait times during lunch hours due to popularity.
They do not allow dogs inside or outside the restaurant.
Fresh seafood stands out with spicy shrimp lo mein and crisp fish and chips. Casual vibe suits those craving authentic Chinese dishes like duck buns and fried rice. Don't miss the scallion pancakes for a tasty twist.
Fresh seafood shines with an Asian twist in dishes like spicy shrimp lo mein and tuna bites. Fish and chips come out crisp and not greasy, while clam chowder and shrimp and vegetable dumplings add variety.
Good to know
There is plenty of parking available nearby.
Expect to pay around $24 for a beef fried rice dish.
Online prices may not reflect current menu pricing.
Mexican spot offers a casual vibe with cozy indoor and outdoor seating. Fresh ingredients shine in fish tacos with crispy batter and excellent tortillas. Shrimp tacos deliver flavorful portions that satisfy seafood lovers.
Fish tacos stand out with excellent corn tortillas and crispy batter. The beer-battered fish bowl offers a fresh, large portion. Shrimp dishes, especially the shrimp tacos, are flavorful and well-sized.
Good to know
The restaurant offers good vegetarian and vegan options.
You can eat outside on the patio.
Expect to pay around $71 for five tacos with chips and guacamole.
Small standing-room sushi bar offers a casual vibe with plenty of outdoor seating. Chefs serve fresh fish in creative rolls like the Rainbow Nanuto and generous Sashimi Deluxe platter. Popular for takeout, it feels like a hidden gem with great quality at fair prices.
Fish comes in super fresh and offers incredible quality at a fair price. The Rainbow Nanuto roll skips rice and combines vegetables with fish, while the Sashimi Deluxe includes 18 assorted pieces featuring salmon, octopus, and tuna.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended, especially during peak summer months.
Takeout orders are available and usually ready within 20 minutes.
Parking is limited, so arrive early or consider carpooling.
Enjoy heated boat comfort while spotting whales and dolphins. Captains use local knowledge to find great fishing spots, perfect for beginners. Catch over 40 fish with help from crew like Roland and Theo, who offer tips and assist with unhooking.
Trips yield loads of fish, often over 40 caught. Crew members like Roland and Theo offer fishing tips and help with unhooking. Fish can be filleted on site for a fee or taken home in large quantities.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended to secure a spot on the fishing trip.
The trip costs $142, with additional fees for fish cleaning and tackle.
Arrive on time; the boat departs promptly at the scheduled time.
Historic charm meets fresh pasta with juicy clams and unique seafood like Shrimp Montechina. Cozy, intimate seating and classic crooner tunes create a romantic vibe perfect for a warm, nostalgic night out.
Fresh pasta dishes like linguine with clams come with juicy clams and are cooked perfectly. Unique seafood options include the Shrimp Montechina and baked oysters, though portions tend to be small.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended, especially for dinner service.
Parking is available, but it may require a short walk to the restaurant.
Expect higher prices for cocktails, as they may include additional charges.
Overlooking a marina, this spot offers scenic water views and a cool breeze from ceiling fans. Enjoy fresh fish like flounder with a unique "you hook-we cook" service. The vibe is relaxed and family-friendly with live music and a welcoming yacht club feel.
Fresh fish like flounder and striper can be cooked on site with a "you hook-we cook" service. Dishes include fish tacos with varied textures, tempura, and a balanced white chowder blending fish, vegetables, and cream.
Good to know
Cash is needed for tipping as credit card payments do not allow tips.
The restaurant is pet friendly and welcomes dogs on the patio.
Expect a quieter atmosphere on weekdays compared to weekends.
Seafood shines with fresh oysters and perfectly cooked shrimp. Casual, family-friendly vibe offers patio seating overlooking Main Street. Quiet ambiance makes it ideal for relaxed dining with loved ones.
Freshness stands out with very fresh oysters and seafood. Shrimp dishes feature well-cooked shrimp and sauces with the right texture. Fish and chips also appear on the menu.
Good to know
Caution is advised for those with dietary restrictions due to potential contamination.
Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted, but check for Apple Pay compatibility.
Outdoor seating is available for guests with pets.
Dark interior with rustic fisherman-style decor sets a lively vibe filled with locals and live music. Fresh, local seafood shines in dishes like crispy fish and chips and seafood paella. Spacious seating includes large family tables and a bar with sports on TV, balancing energy and comfort.
Seafood here stands out for its freshness and local catch. Dishes like the crispy fish and chips and blackened fish sandwiches deliver solid flavor and texture, while the seafood paella and tower offer generous portions.
Good to know
The kitchen and bar are open from 12pm to 12am every day.
Expect large portions; come hungry.
A 20% gratuity is automatically added to bills.
Classic drive-in offers fried shrimp and flounder with chips in a vintage 1980s diner vibe. Cash-only spot buzzes with a laid-back beach-town crowd enjoying simple American fare. Indoor and outdoor seating add to its colorful, retro atmosphere.
Shrimp and flounder come fried and paired with chips. Fish sandwiches and fried fish stand out alongside French fries and jalapeno poppers.
Good to know
It's cash only; bring cash or use the onsite ATM.
The parking lot is small and often full during peak hours.
Be prepared for long lines, especially at night.