Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Dinner spots in Montauk

Made for those who prioritize a sit-down evening meal as the anchor of their day.

Based on 493 Opinions
+490
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Surfside Inn image 1
Surfside Inn image 2
Surfside Inn image 3
View all

Ocean views create a quiet atmosphere perfect for dinner. Staff offer VIP treatment with attentive, positive energy. Over 30 years of reliable service make it a trusted spot welcoming walk-ins even when busy.

Dinner here features engaging service with staff treating guests like VIPs. The spot offers a reliable dining experience for over 30 years and welcomes walk-ins even when fully booked.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, delicious, and top-notch."

"The ocean views here are spectacular."

"Devon's service made my dinner experience so memorable."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for ocean view tables.

2

Children must remain seated at all times per house rules.

3

Expect higher prices due to the quality of food and location.

02
Daunt's Albatross Motel image 1

Courtyard shines with fire pits and a clean pool for relaxing. Rooms mix coastal decor with cozy beds and kitchenettes. Dinner serves gourmet meals that satisfy every time. Location is just blocks from beach and downtown, perfect for a laid-back stay.

Dinner offers excellent food with gourmet selections. Meals are consistently delicious and satisfying.

People are saying

"The beds here are super comfy and you'll sleep well."

"The Hotel staff was so friendly and welcoming during my stay."

"The dinner here is delicious and worth trying."

Good to know

1

The motel is dog-friendly, allowing pets during your stay.

2

It's just a short walk to the beach, making it convenient for beachgoers.

3

The motel is located near downtown Montauk, close to shops and restaurants.

03
Monte's At the Manor image 1

Historic building offers a warm, cozy atmosphere with classic crooner music setting a romantic vibe. Dinner features fresh oysters and steak served with attentive care, perfect for special occasions. Seating is intimate but can feel cramped.

Elegant and tranquil setting creates a special atmosphere for dinner. The menu features oysters, clams, and steak, with attentive service that enhances celebratory occasions.

People are saying

"The pasta sauce here is superb, truly the best I've ever tasted."

"I loved Monte's for special occasions and family dinners."

"I thought the fried calamari appetizer was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for dinner service.

2

Parking is available, but it may require a short walk to the restaurant.

3

Expect higher prices for cocktails, as they may include additional charges.

04
Montauk Manor image 1

Hotel boasts gorgeous views and spacious rooms with unique layouts. Grounds feel like a luxury Caribbean resort with well-kept landscapes. Dinner offers delicious meals and cocktails in one convenient spot.

Dinner features delicious meals served on site with a varied menu including cocktails. The setting offers convenience by serving multiple meal times in one spot.

People are saying

"This historic hotel is beautiful and the rooms are clean."

"The scenic views from the room were amazing."

"The staff here is so nice and helpful for dinner spots."

Good to know

1

Murder Mystery weekends are popular and require advance reservations.

2

Oktoberfest events feature fireworks and are held annually.

3

Dinner service is available after obtaining a liquor license.

05
Sail Inn image 1

Set among trees, this motel offers a peaceful setting with newly renovated rooms that are clean and accessible. Dinner features a full menu perfect for both lively and relaxed nights. Weekly live music and an outdoor bar add a laid-back vibe to the stay.

Dinner offers a great variety with a full menu to explore. Meals suit both lively and relaxed evenings.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the fresh seafood."

"The renovated rooms are so clean and comfortable for Date Spots."

"The new owners and bartender are super friendly and welcoming."

Good to know

1

The Sail Inn offers accessible rooms with features like grab bars and roll-in showers.

2

Handicap parking is available right near the entrance.

3

Food portions are tapas-sized but priced as full entrees.

06
Sole East Resort image 1
Resort hotel

Resort hotel offers beachfront dining with meals served all day. Guests enjoy a large infinity pool and a spa for relaxation. Family-friendly features include fire pits for s'mores and pool games, creating a lively yet laid-back vibe.

Dinner includes options served alongside breakfast and lunch menus. After dinner, a fire pit with music creates a relaxing atmosphere for winding down.

People are saying

"The food here is so delicious and thoughtfully crafted."

"The staff here are so friendly and attentive, making it a truly relaxing spot."

"The dinner spots here have great food, service, and drinks."

Good to know

1

The onsite restaurant offers a diverse menu with excellent reviews.

2

Expect additional charges for amenities like a small refrigerator in the room.

3

The hotel is close to the beach and main attractions in Montauk.

07
The Montauket image 1
Restaurant

Waterfront setting offers breathtaking sunset views and live music that energizes the atmosphere. Dinner draws a crowded scene with a lively vibe. Comfortable space suits casual drinks and meals.

Dinner time draws a crowded scene here. The spot stays busy because dinner is a popular choice.

People are saying

"The sunsets here are spectacular and beautiful."

"The live music brought amazing energy and a fun atmosphere."

"The dinner spots here have outstanding, breathtaking sunset views."

Good to know

1

Expect a $20 cover charge per person to enter.

2

Reservations are recommended in summer due to high crowds.

3

Arrive at least an hour before sunset for a good seat.

08
Muse @ The End image 1
New American restaurant

Half bar, half restaurant with underlit blue bar counter offers both indoor and outdoor seating. Dinner is satisfying and suits a relaxed evening or second meal. Live music creates a beach town vibe that shifts atmosphere from laid back to lively.

Dinner here offers a pleasant atmosphere and satisfying meals. It works well for a second dinner or a relaxed evening out.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, simple, and delicious."

"The bar staff are super friendly and attentive."

"The dinner spots here are delicious, especially the pasta and steak."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $1.00 oysters, making it a popular choice.

2

Reservations are accepted for private events, but not always communicated.

3

Expect high prices; drinks can cost $18 each.

09
Shagwong image 1
Seafood restaurant

Dark interior with rustic fisherman-style decor sets a lively tone. Big grilled pork chop dinners offer great value for walk-in diners. Spacious seating and live music create a vibrant atmosphere loved by locals.

Offers big grilled pork chop dinners with great value for a sit-down meal. Welcomes walk-in diners and draws people from nearby areas for dinner.

People are saying

"The American Food here has a really fun, jamming atmosphere."

"The seafood here is so fresh, I've never had anything fresher."

"You should come hungry; the dinner spot portions are big."

Good to know

1

The kitchen and bar are open from 12pm to 12am every day.

2

Expect large portions; come hungry.

3

A 20% gratuity is automatically added to bills.

Discover more

Montauk, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...