Motel set back off the road among trees offers a peaceful, serene setting with a down-to-earth, inviting atmosphere. Weekly live music and an outdoor bar create a laid-back vibe, while newly renovated rooms provide clean, comfortable, and accessible accommodations.
Fresh seafood salad and meatballs stand out as exceptional specials. The menu offers authentic Italian dishes with reasonable prices in a relaxed, old-school sailor vibe.
Surprisingly accessible for wheelchair users, this spot offers comfortable beds and pillows that help couples sleep well. It creates a relaxed setting that supports a memorable time together.
"The food here is amazing, especially the fresh seafood."
"The renovated rooms are so clean and comfortable for Date Spots."
"The live music here makes you feel like family."
Good to know
The Sail Inn offers accessible rooms with features like grab bars and roll-in showers.
Handicap parking is available right near the entrance.
Food portions are tapas-sized but priced as full entrees.
Courtyard features fire pits lit every evening and a clean, inviting pool with plenty of seating. Rooms blend coastal decor with comfortable beds and thoughtful touches like igloos and kitchenettes. Location sits just blocks from beach and downtown, creating a laid-back, relaxed vibe with peaceful common areas.
Excellent food quality stands out with varied gourmet selections and nice presentation throughout the menu.
Cozy atmosphere makes it easy to feel like family, thanks to the owner Leo. It suits quick weekend getaways for special occasions like birthdays.
Good to know
The motel is dog-friendly, allowing pets during your stay.
It's just a short walk to the beach, making it convenient for beachgoers.
The motel is located near downtown Montauk, close to shops and restaurants.
Hotel offers gorgeous views and spacious rooms with unique layouts. Grounds resemble a luxury Caribbean resort with meticulously maintained landscapes. Lobby features a fireplace creating a cozy, inviting atmosphere.
Delicious food stands out here, making meals enjoyable. The quality of dishes consistently compensates for other less comfortable aspects.
Rooms offer a romantic setting ideal for couples. Many choose to stay for special occasions like weddings. The atmosphere encourages return visits for memorable experiences.
Good to know
Murder Mystery weekends are popular and require advance reservations.
Oktoberfest events feature fireworks and are held annually.
Dinner service is available after obtaining a liquor license.
Historic building hosts an old school Italian restaurant with a warm, cozy atmosphere and elegant, romantic vibe. Music from classic crooners adds to the nostalgic feel. Seating is close, creating an intimate but sometimes cramped setting.
Food features 5-star quality with standout dishes like swordfish meatballs and orecchiette with sausage and broccoli rabe. Options like linguine and clams, Milanese, and carbonara offer great taste at a good price.
Warm welcome and cozy ambiance set the tone for dates here. Dishes like linguine and clams, Milanese, and carbonara offer great date foods at a good price.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended, especially for dinner service.
Parking is available, but it may require a short walk to the restaurant.
Expect higher prices for cocktails, as they may include additional charges.
Takeaway-only seafood market with a cute cottage design and mom-and-pop feel. Atmosphere is authentic and inviting, reflecting a family-run tradition spanning generations. Known for fresh lobster rolls and smoked fish spread, it operates on a cash-only basis with no seating available.
Food here is consistently freshly made and offers great value. Lobster rolls and other dishes come from a beautiful home setting, delivering excellent quality and quantity.
A sweet couple runs the place with care, setting up tables outside for a relaxed seafood experience. It serves as a weekly stop for couples looking to enjoy fresh shellfish together.
Good to know
Bennett Shellfish is takeout only and accepts cash only.
There is no seating area available at Bennett Shellfish.
The lobster rolls are priced at a fraction of the tourist spots in Montauk.
Stylish hotel grounds feature beautiful pool and garden areas with onsite bar and restaurant. Atmosphere blends a relaxed, boujee beach vibe with a shift toward an adult pool party energy. Rooms offer cozy, tasteful decor and quiet spaces for relaxation.
Excellent pool food and a wonderful bar complement the dining options. Staff provide attentive and knowledgeable service that enhances the overall food experience.
Quick service supports a smooth experience for couples. Celebrations like birthdays fit well here, adding to the special moments. The atmosphere encourages quality time with a partner.
Good to know
Happy hour features $10 drinks, making it a great deal for guests.
The hotel hosts art and music events regularly for guests to enjoy.
The pool area is accessible to non-guests during the day, limiting guest access.
Oceanfront setting offers stunning views and quiet, serene atmosphere with cozy secluded spots for relaxation. Heated pool near the beach and fire pits with complimentary s'mores create a relaxing outdoor experience. Yoga sessions and bicycle rentals add to the calm, retreat-like vibe.
Breakfast and lunch feature great coffee and incredible food prepared by a Michelin star chef. The chocolate chip cookies and vegetable platters stand out for their quality and flavor.
Good to know
The resort charges a daily resort fee of $182.60 per accommodation.
The hotel offers daily activities like yoga and creative workshops.
Nightly bonfires with s'mores are hosted for guests.
Oceanfront setting offers breathtaking views and a quiet, peaceful beach with no busy roads nearby. The atmosphere stays relaxed and tranquil, with complimentary lounges and umbrellas enhancing comfort. Fire pits and an onsite food truck add unique touches to the experience.
An on-site food truck serves outstanding meals with a consistently amazing quality.
Balconies offer intimate moments like proposals. Beachfront rooms and updated efficiencies create a cozy, no frills setting ideal for couples. The vibe suits both quiet getaways and special occasions.
Good to know
Wavecrest offers complimentary umbrellas and lounges for guests.
The resort is located on a secluded section of beach adjacent to a state park.
The rooms are clean and comfortable with stunning ocean views.
Resort hotel blends modern luxury with rustic charm amid gorgeous landscaped grounds by a serene coastline. Atmosphere stays laid-back and welcoming, with calming sea breezes and lively poolside scenes. Amenities include a large infinity pool, spa, beachfront dining, and family-friendly features like pool games and fire pits for s'mores.
Food features delicious flavors with the Frito Misto standing out as crispy and perfect for sharing. Service complements the outstanding food well.
Crowds can make moving around tough during busy times, which might affect privacy and ease. The resort offers a mix of options for couples, with a family-friendly and diverse atmosphere.
Good to know
The onsite restaurant offers a diverse menu with excellent reviews.
Expect additional charges for amenities like a small refrigerator in the room.
The hotel is close to the beach and main attractions in Montauk.