Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
New York's best

Pie

Made for those who treat a market as a destination for pie and refuse to leave until they have secured a slice.

Based on 505 Opinions
+502
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
NoFo Pot Pies Country Market image 1
NoFo Pot Pies Country Market image 2
NoFo Pot Pies Country Market image 3
View all

Small market with a cozy, charming atmosphere and a fresh farm food vibe. Shelves are beautifully organized and spotless, offering a unique selection of prepared meals and desserts. Quiet and inviting, it feels like a hidden gem with standout pot pies and comfort foods.

Fresh food and gourmet ingredients fill the shelves. Many grab-and-go meals and homemade pot pies offer convenient, tasty options for home chefs.

Pot pies feature tender meat and poultry, fresh vegetables, and a perfect crust. Mini pot pies offer a quick and easy option, with every variety tasting consistently delicious.

People are saying

"I loved their pot pies; the chicken pot pie was delicious."

"The spinach, feta, and tomato quiche was consistently good and fresh."

"The Market's pot pies are amazing and so yummy."

Good to know

1

The market offers a variety of prepared foods, including pot pies, salads, and desserts.

2

Prices for prepared meals are reasonable, making it a good option for takeout.

3

The store has a points program that rewards customers with discounts on future purchases.

02
Dukan SYKO Marketplace image 1

Market blends Middle Eastern and Korean groceries with authentic, made-from-scratch foods like Syrian pies and spicy hummus. Atmosphere feels warm and family-like, inviting shoppers to explore unique culinary treasures not found in typical supermarkets.

Offers a variety of unique items not found in standard supermarkets. Serves as a convenient local market option in the neighborhood.

Made-from-scratch Syrian pies burst with genuine Syrian flavors. Fresh Middle Eastern hand pies and pastries offer perfect seasoning and rich taste.

People are saying

"The Korean food here is amazing, and the staff are so kind."

"I found the fresh Syrian pies bursting with genuine flavors."

"The Market's food is out of this world, especially the Middle Eastern pizzas."

Good to know

1

The marketplace offers a fantastic selection of prepacked traditional items from Syria and Korea.

2

Expect reasonable prices for high-quality products throughout the store.

3

This place has a perfectly curated selection of Korean and Syrian groceries and prepared foods.

03
Herb&Olive image 1
Greek restaurant

Greek restaurant combines rustic modern decor with soaring ceilings and a mini marketplace selling unique Greek items. Atmosphere stays calm and cozy with friendly staff and live band music. Guests enjoy fresh ingredients and authentic Greek wines in a beautiful, market-style setting.

A small market inside offers unique items not found elsewhere. The setting has a clean and charming vibe with an upscale market-type atmosphere that adds to the ambiance.

Greek Milk Custard Pie stands out with a rich, creamy texture. The custard cinnamon pie offers a sweet, spiced flavor that pairs well with savory dishes.

People are saying

"The Greek food here, especially the tender pork and flavorful falafel, is amazing."

"The Greek food at this Market is authentic and delicious."

"You have to try the custard cinnamon pie; it's delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant can get busy.

2

The prices are on the expensive side, so plan your budget accordingly.

3

Credit card payments incur a convenience fee unless paid in cash.

04
Union Square Greenmarket image 1

Farmers' market boasts organic produce and many local vendors. Homemade pies shine with fresh apples and natural flavors. Lively park setting hosts street performers and a chess area, blending food and fun perfectly.

Offers a wide variety of local, organic produce and fresh vegetables. Serves as a large outdoor farmers market with many purveyors providing diverse products.

Homemade pies feature prominently, made with locally sourced products like apples and squash. Varieties include apple pie and other fresh, natural flavors alongside organic ingredients.

People are saying

"I found the market offered a wide variety of top-quality produce and meats."

"The Farmer's Market has a huge selection of fresh produce, baked goods, and flowers."

"I found delicious homemade pies and fresh produce."

Good to know

1

The farmers market operates on Mondays, Wednesdays, Fridays, and Saturdays from 8am to 6pm.

2

Food vendors stay open until 10:00 pm on Thursdays and Fridays.

3

Bring cash as some vendors do not accept credit cards.

05
Mediterranean Foods II image 1

Supermarket offers extensive Mediterranean selection with varieties of feta cheese and an exquisite olive bar. Atmosphere feels authentic with homemade Greek specialties like spanakopita and fresh tzatziki. Small parking area exists, sometimes requiring luck or valet assistance.

Offers a huge array of feta cheeses, olives, and olive oils alongside house-made butter and tzatziki. Stocks many imported Greek goods like Greek Coffee and Greek Mountain Tea at human retail prices.

Small counter offers hot cheese and meat pies alongside Spanakopita, a Greek spinach pie with feta cheese.

People are saying

"This grocery store has a huge array of Greek products and imported goods."

"This market has a huge array of Greek feta cheeses, olives, and olive oils."

"I loved the spinach pie and feta cheese here."

Good to know

1

Prices at the market are fair, with 1/4lb of fresh feta costing $3.

2

The supermarket has an excellent selection of products, especially Greek items.

3

The Greek supermarket has a huge array of various feta cheeses, olives, and olive oils.

06
Westville Dumbo image 1
American restaurant

Modern space combines indoor and outdoor seating with a plant-filled courtyard that feels like a garden patio. Atmosphere stays cozy and welcoming with retro music playing softly. Guests enjoy a spacious, elegant setting that blends inside-outside dining.

Market plates feature a mix of fresh vegetables and proteins like grilled chicken. Specials change often, with dependable, flavorful options and occasional misses like missing chicken in the bowl.

Pecan pie stands out when available, offering a rich, nutty flavor. The apple pie adds a classic, sweet touch to the dessert options.

People are saying

"The brunch here is tasty with decent portions and fresh ingredients."

"The market bowl Carlos suggested was super special and filling."

"I loved the homemade apple pie; it was amazing."

Good to know

1

Happy hours are until 7 PM with great drink promotions.

2

Tuesday cocktails are $10, making it a budget-friendly option.

3

Reservations are recommended for weekend brunch to avoid long waits.

07
Mercado Little Spain image 1
Spanish restaurant

Food court combines market stalls and restaurant seating with live flamenco music creating a lively, upscale yet approachable vibe. Decor features vibrant colors and decorative ceramics evoking Spanish warmth and vitality. Visitors find a unique atmosphere reminiscent of bustling Spanish mercados.

A vibrant market with several stalls offering different food options creates a fun vibe. The atmosphere stays good and not too noisy despite many people, combining a terrace, market, and skyscraper in one spot.

Tuna pie and Basque pie stand out with rich, satisfying flavors. The Crema Calan pie offers a unique, amazing taste, while egg pies with onions and potatoes come with bread for a simple meal.

People are saying

"I loved the authentic Spanish food and the wide variety of options."

"This market feels like a lively spot with many small restaurants."

"The tuna pie here is better than many I've tasted in Spain."

Good to know

1

Plan ahead to see the Flamenco dancing show, which runs from 6-8 PM on Thursdays.

2

Wednesdays offer half-priced bottles of wine during happy hour.

3

Happy hour features a great selection of options at the Food Hall.

08
Bayview Market & Farms image 1
Farmers' market

Indoor-outdoor market blends farm-market charm with sections resembling a supermarket. Bright, cozy atmosphere feels warm and homey with a wide selection of fresh, locally grown produce and locally made baked goods. Picnic area adds a relaxed spot amid lively, friendly energy.

A huge market offers a wide selection of fresh produce, including an abundance of tomatoes, fruits, and vegetables. Shelves hold local refrigerated and frozen items, dairy, spices, pastries, and fresh meats, all in a cozy, bright atmosphere with a picnic area nearby.

Apple crumb pies stand out among the baked goods. Other pies have a 'comstock' quality filling but often do not justify the price or a special stop.

People are saying

"This market has a wide selection of super fresh produce."

"I found the local produce here to be amazing and so fresh."

"I loved the great pies, especially the apple crumb."

Good to know

1

Parking is ample, but exiting the lot can be tricky during busy hours.

2

They offer different prices for cash and card payments, with card prices being higher.

3

Restrooms are available for customer use on-site.

09
Auntie El's Farm Market image 1

Farmers' market combines vintage general store charm with a large fresh bakery and extensive produce selection. Atmosphere feels fun and quirky, attracting a community-oriented crowd. Features include homemade pies and baked goods alongside unique gifts and a small playground.

Offers a warm, community-oriented shopping experience with a charming, local feel. Features a variety of items including fresh produce, baked goods, pies, and ice cream.

Pies here feature fresh, seasonal fruits and a homemade touch. Apple Caramel Chocolate and Strawberry Rhubarb Wildberry pies stand out, with apple pies made from real apples, not jam or jelly.

People are saying

"This local spot has an amazing bakery with fresh produce and cute gifts."

"I found the donuts here to be delicious."

"You'll find amazing baked goods and fresh produce at this Market."

Good to know

1

They are open on Christmas Day from 8 AM to 4 PM.

2

Parking can be limited on weekends due to high visitor volume.

3

They do not allow dogs inside the farm market.

10
Bennett Shellfish image 1
Seafood market

Takeaway-only seafood market with a cute cottage design and mom-and-pop feel. Atmosphere is authentic and inviting, reflecting a family-run tradition spanning generations. Known for fresh lobster rolls and smoked fish spread, it operates on a cash-only basis with no seating available.

Family-run market offers fresh local fish with some of the freshest tuna available. Seafood selection reflects generations of experience in selling quality fish.

Clam pies stand out as a Montauk delicacy here, made homemade and offered alongside other seafood items. Many pies and shellfish cakes come prepared and flash frozen for convenience.

People are saying

"The seafood here is always so fresh, especially the oysters."

"You have to try the clam pie; it's full of flavor."

"I found the fish and shellfish at this market to be the freshest."

Good to know

1

Bennett Shellfish is takeout only and accepts cash only.

2

There is no seating area available at Bennett Shellfish.

3

The lobster rolls are priced at a fraction of the tourist spots in Montauk.

11
Parrot Coffee Market Place 2 image 1

Supermarket occupies a clean, modern space with old-time deli counter charm and intuitive layout. It offers a wide selection of European and Mediterranean specialties, including fresh baked goods like spinach pies. Prices vary but the store maintains a well-stocked and organized environment with accessible aisles.

Offers a wide range of European products and goods. Combines variety and quality in a marketplace setting.

Fresh Spinach pies stand out with their rich flavor. A wide selection of pastries and pies offers plenty of variety.

People are saying

"The Deli staff's knowledge of meat and cheese is superior."

"I considered this my favorite grocery store in NYC."

"I loved the fresh spinach pies and baked goods."

Good to know

1

Ezekiel Bread is priced at $7, compared to $4 at other locations.

2

Kerrygold Grass fed Cheese is $7, while it is $4.99 at Whole Foods.

3

Vital eggs are overpriced at $8.99 compared to Target's price of $5.89.

12
Under Pressure Coffee image 1

Half European market and half Greek cafรฉ, the space features chic design and a covered outdoor patio that feels like a different country. Loud train noise and DJ music create a lively but pretentious atmosphere not suited for work or quiet conversation. The spot attracts a friendly, casual crowd who come to hang out and enjoy quality pastries and coffee.

A Greek market sits next to a cafรฉ, offering rare specialty items and a variety of feta cheeses. The market blends European and Greek influences in its selection.

Spinach pie stands out with its delicious flavor. An array of pies, pastries, and danishes includes raisin danish and custard cheese pie. Orange pie dome offers a unique dessert experience but leans sweet and soggy.

People are saying

"I thought the coffee here was amazing and perfect."

"I really enjoyed the spinach pie; it was delicious."

"I loved the European and Greek specialty items at this market."

Good to know

1

Parking is available, but it can be limited in front of the establishment.

2

The establishment opens at 6 am, making it a great early stop.

3

They offer several milk alternatives for coffee drinks.

13
Orchards of Concklin image 1
Farmers' market

Farmers' market combines vast orchard with well-maintained apple and pumpkin selection. Atmosphere feels family-run and scenic, attracting cyclists regularly. Fresh fruit, baked goods, and jams offer variety, with apple cider donuts and pies standing out.

Small size and basic selection define the market. It includes a garden center and a store called Orchards but lacks standout features compared to other shops in the region.

Cherry pie features a perfect balance of sweet and tart with lots of fruit and a hint of almond extract and honey. Some pies like apple and peach crumble can taste raw and underbaked, with little reaction from staff when mentioned.

People are saying

"I found the apple cider donuts to be the best."

"This cherry pie is perfectly balanced with lots of fruit."

"This market shop is nothing special, I've seen better."

Good to know

1

The farm offers a variety of fresh fruits, vegetables, and baked goods.

2

Apple picking is available with numerous varieties to choose from.

3

Parking is ample and easily accessible for visitors.

14
Down Under Coffee image 1

Coffee shop in an underground market offers wide vegan and gluten-free options alongside traditional choices. Atmosphere feels warm and fragrant, though seating is unavailable. Location is hard to find, attracting those seeking specialty dietary treats.

An underground market offers different kinds of cuisine with a few restaurants and very limited seating. Down Under Coffee is one of the options available in this subway station food market.

Vegan pie tastes like a sausage empanada and works well for a quick bite before the train. Ham & cheese pie offers a classic savory option alongside other sandwiches.

People are saying

"They have so many tasty vegetarian options, both sweet and savory."

"This Market has so many incredible vegan and gluten-free treats."

"I tried the vegan pie; it was convenient for a quick bite."

Good to know

1

The shop has many vegan and gluten-free treats available.

2

There are no chairs for seating, so plan to take your food to go.

3

The shop is located in the Underground Market by the subway.

15
Ayhan's Mediterranean Marketplace image 1

Open, airy dining space features stunning water views and Mediterranean-style decor with hanging plants and arches. Atmosphere feels warm and relaxed, suited for casual meals or small gatherings. Guests enjoy authentic Greek and Turkish vibes with a deli-style setup offering unusual foods.

Shelves hold unusual foods from the Mediterranean region. Spinach and meat pies stand out among the fresh offerings.

Spinach pies come with a flaky crust and rich flavor. Both spinach and meat pies are available at the Mediterranean market, though simple spinach pies may require a long wait.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, delicious, and reasonably priced."

"The lemon chicken soup from the Market was amazing and comforting."

"I loved the spinach pie; it was perfectly flaky and flavorful."

Good to know

1

The marketplace opens early for breakfast.

2

There is a large parking lot at the side of the building.

3

Lunch specials are available and highly recommended.

16
White Post Farms of Melville image 1

Children's farm offers spacious grounds with friendly animals including giraffes and lorikeets that visitors can feed and pet. The atmosphere is safe and welcoming, with kid-friendly activities like pony rides, playgrounds, and magic shows. Open-air aviary and tractor rides add to the engaging experience.

Excellent produce and fresh pies stand out in the market. Staff inside are friendly and helpful, creating a welcoming atmosphere.

Apple pies come with a rich crumb topping and a sweet, tart filling. Prices reach around $30, reflecting the high quality of the pies.

People are saying

"It's so Kid Friendly; the animals are awake and eager for attention."

"I loved the apple crumb pie; it was the best I ever had."

"You can get up close and feed most of the animals at this market."

Good to know

1

Admission is $30 in cash; no debit or credit cards accepted.

2

Parking is free and plentiful at the farm.

3

Children can feed the animals during designated times.

17
Clinton St. Baking Company image 1
American restaurant

Small, busy restaurant with cramped seating and wrap-around windows offering city views. Atmosphere is warm and noisy, with fans instead of air conditioning and frequent interruptions. Popular spot known for best pancakes and a message-alert system for table readiness.

Breakfast options include blueberry pancakes and dishes from a well-known bakery. The market hosts a branch of a popular baking company serving brunch.

Banana chocolate cream pie stands out with its rich flavor and pairs well with a jumbo latte. The apple pie appears in different forms like waffles and pancakes, offering a sweet, soft texture with toppings like apple crumble and maple butter, though freshness varies.

People are saying

"These pancakes are fluffy, flavorful, and worth the price."

"The blueberry pancakes at the Market were so good."

"I enjoyed the banana chocolate cream pie very much."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required on weekends and highly recommended during the week.

2

Expect wait times of up to an hour during peak hours.

3

Get there early to avoid long lines, especially for breakfast.

18
Westville Long Island City image 1
American restaurant

Bar area offers comfortable seating with hooks for purses and a well-crafted cocktail selection. Dimmed lighting creates an intimate atmosphere with music at a level that allows easy conversation. Space feels beautiful and thoughtfully designed, providing a distinct vibe in the neighborhood.

The market offers a market platter that stands out alongside the cobb salad. Market sides come highly recommended compared to other options like battered French fries.

Apple pie and pecan pie stand out with rich, classic flavors. The Milton lava cake offers a warm, gooey texture that complements the pies well.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be fresh and tasty."

"I loved the generously laden market plate."

"I thought the apple pie was amazing and very satisfying."

Good to know

1

This restaurant is takeout only while the location is under construction.

2

Happy hour offers discounted drinks and appetizers from 4-6pm daily.

3

Reservations are recommended for dining, especially during busy hours.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...