Dining room offers an upscale experience with a warm, family-owned feel and a clean, cozy atmosphere that encourages lingering. Music plays consistently, enhancing the great vibes throughout the space. The setting welcomes groups and children, blending a small coastal town charm with affordability.
Lunch here offers an excellent meal that impresses with its quality. The spot consistently wows diners during midday visits.
Crab cake sandwiches come perfectly seasoned and beautifully presented. Fried chicken sandwiches feature crispy, flavorful chicken with aioli or juicy thighs.
"The fried chicken sandwich here is crispy, flavorful, and deeply satisfying."
"The crab cake sandwich at this Lunch Spot is perfectly seasoned and delicious."
"The fried chicken sandwich was crispy, flavorful, and deeply satisfying."
Good to know
Reservations are not required, but advisable for larger groups.
Parking can be challenging; expect to walk from nearby side streets.
The restaurant offers a variety of vegetarian options on the menu.
Retro diner design creates a cozy, intimate atmosphere with dim lighting and an open kitchen that invites watching the cooking action. The space feels warm and welcoming, blending nostalgic 60s decor with modern touches in a small, busy setting. Guests often enjoy lingering in the lobby or bar, adding to the relaxed, fun vibe.
Serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner with consistent quality. Meals fit well for a quick stop or a longer sit-down.
Egg sandwiches stand out with simple, classic flavors and pair well with sides like pancakes or French toast. Options include sausage and egg combinations that offer a hearty start.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended to secure a seat due to limited space.
Evening reservations are available exclusively through Resy.
I was advised to order ahead because the place was super busy.
Cozy deli with authentic, nostalgic atmosphere and friendly vibe in a small-town setting. Seating is available both inside and outside, accommodating locals and tourists alike. Known for exceptional sandwiches and reasonable prices, it draws groups of all sizes without feeling busy in the afternoon.
Specialty sandwiches stand out with delicious flavors for lunch. Options include eat-in or take-out, with consistently amazing sandwiches.
Egg sandwiches stand out with classic preparation and fresh ingredients. Specialty options like the Rocky Balboa and Bobo sandwich offer unique combinations including roast beef, Swiss cheese, and hot sauce on rolls or bagels.
Good to know
Sterlington Deli offers catering services for events and parties.
The deli has a great variety of options on the menu.
Prices at Sterlington Deli are very reasonable.
Bright, elegantly designed café with large windows that fill the space with natural light creates a cozy, soulful atmosphere. Seating is comfortable, attracting a relaxed but vibrant mix of locals and visitors. Decor includes vintage records and sleek display shelves, giving a creative, chic vibe.
Lunch includes breakfast sandwiches and pastries paired with smooth, earthy iced matcha lattes. Coffee options complement the light, fresh menu well.
Breakfast and lunch sandwiches feature fluffy, buttery eggs and a variety of fillings like prosciutto, turkey with spicy pickles, and bacon on a milk bun. The Cubano sandwich stands out with tender ham, melted cheese, dill pickles, and mustard pressed perfectly.
Good to know
Reservations are not required, but arriving early is recommended for limited items.
They make a limited batch of donuts each day, so arrive early to get some.
Expect higher prices for drinks and food compared to other cafes in the area.
Classic diner style combines with eclectic retro decor and unique mugs to create a cozy, homey vibe. Big windows bring in sunlight and views, while the space fills with loud, lively energy and steady crowds. Booths feel cramped but add to the old-school charm.
Lunch includes Gouda sandwiches and French fries available for takeout. The diner closes at 3 pm, serving breakfast and lunch with good options and friendly service.
Crab cake sandwich stands out with lots of crab meat. Options include a Cuban sandwich, pulled pork panini, and wraps. Sandwiches cost around $13-15 without sides, with fries priced separately.
Good to know
The diner closes at 3 pm, making it suitable for breakfast, brunch, or lunch.
There is often a long wait during peak hours; arrive early on weekends.
A sandwich without sides costs around $13-15, and sides like fries are $7.
Bar with many TVs and arcade games offers a chill, dive bar vibe with a family-friendly atmosphere. Complimentary popcorn and live music add to the relaxed, fun setting. Outdoor patio welcomes dogs, making it a casual spot to hang out and watch sports.
Offers a solid spot for lunch and a drink with a relaxed vibe. Suitable for family gatherings on weekends.
Fried chicken sandwich and BLT come out perfect while the Reuben is solid. Some chicken sandwiches vary, with one noted as excellent and another less impressive, plus fries sometimes lack crispiness.
Good to know
Reservations are required for parties over 30 people.
Dogs are welcome on the outdoor patio area.
Credit card payments may incur an upcharge without prior notice.
Dining inside a converted trolley car with train-themed decor creates a unique vintage vibe. The atmosphere stays quiet and cozy, with bright, airy spaces and a friendly, unhurried pace. Outdoor seating on a deck offers a relaxed spot for people watching and enjoying cool breezes.
Lunch offers home cooked delicacies served in a relaxed setting. Seating on the porch provides cool breezes and good people watching.
Fresh Soft Shell Crab sandwich stands out with its crisp texture. Other options include a fried flounder sandwich and a triple decker club with cole slaw.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended, especially during peak dining hours.
The restaurant is located near the Shelter Island Ferry and Greenport station.
Expect higher prices, with items like potato skins costing $22.
Waterfront setting offers unbeatable views and a vibrant yet relaxing atmosphere with a light breeze through open windows. Live music energizes the space, often featuring excellent bands that draw attention. Retractable walls adapt the space to weather, enhancing outdoor enjoyment on the pier.
Lunch happens right by the water with quick seating even when busy. Servers like Vincent and Victoria make the meal fun and attentive, creating a memorable family-friendly vibe.
Steak sandwich stands out with its incredible flavor. More lunch options include varied sandwiches and salads. Staff quickly replace dishes when issues arise, like with the dry chicken sandwich.
Good to know
Live music happens on Sunday afternoons, perfect for a relaxed vibe.
The restaurant transforms into a bar with a DJ after dinner, attracting a younger crowd.
Reservations are recommended to avoid long wait times, especially on weekends.