Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in New Rochelle

Cake spots

Made for those who view a slice of cake as a non-negotiable requirement for any celebration or afternoon break.

Based on 530 Opinions
+527
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
D'Bay Cafe, Inc image 1
D'Bay Cafe, Inc image 2
D'Bay Cafe, Inc image 3
View all
Jamaican restaurant

Jamaican restaurant serves authentic flavors with plentiful portions and lightly seasoned dishes. Chocolate cake is rich and moist, perfect alongside curry or jerk chicken. Pastries and vegan options add tasty variety for takeaway or catering.

Chocolate cake stands out with its rich flavor and moist texture. It pairs well with hearty dishes like curry chicken and jerk chicken.

People are saying

"The Jamaican food here is the best and freshest I've ever had."

"The jerk chicken here is tender, flavorful, and perfectly spiced."

"I had the most delicious chocolate cake."

Good to know

1

D'Bay Cafe offers small, medium, and large serving sizes for catering.

2

Parking is available in two municipal lots on either end of the block.

3

The cafe provides vegan options on the menu for diverse dietary needs.

02
El Trigal Bakery image 1

Bakery shines with fresh pastries and authentic Mexican breads made from homemade ingredients. Cakes boast moist textures and intricate designs with fresh fruit fillings that balance sweetness. Atmosphere feels like a community staple focused on traditional flavors.

Cakes here feature moist textures and fresh fruit fillings like pineapple that balance sweetness well. Intricate designs with delicate fondant and light, smooth frosting make them both visually stunning and delicious.

People are saying

"This cake is visually stunning and tastes delicious."

"The pastries here are always so fresh."

"The pastries and bread at the Bakery were so good."

Good to know

1

Parking is available right across the street in the lot.

2

They use real homemade ingredients in their products.

3

Bread prices change daily, so check before ordering.

03
VIP Country Club image 1
Event venue

Spacious halls and immaculate views create an elegant setting. Outdoor rooftop with fire pit and sofas invites relaxed mingling. Food and wedding cake come directly from the venue, with a floating cake stand available on request.

Food and beverage, including the wedding cake, come from the venue, making the process seamless. They provide a floating cake stand on request without extra purchase.

People are saying

"The staff here makes you feel like family, truly."

"This party staff made the whole process easy and stress-free."

"The venue's outdoor space is stunning and beautiful."

Good to know

1

Parking is available, but the lot is unpaved and in poor condition.

2

The venue hosts themed weddings, such as a Star Wars celebration on May 4th.

3

The Viennese hour is a popular addition to events and well-received by guests.

04
Mario's Metro Pizza & Pasta image 1

Local spot serves New York style pizza with thin, crispy crusts and fresh toppings in a cozy atmosphere. Desserts shine with rich tiramisu and creamy cheesecake. Prices are fair, balancing slightly pricey slices with generous portions and catering deals.

Dessert options include carrot cake, tiramisu, and Creme Brule Cheese Cake. The tiramisu and cheesecake stand out for their rich flavor and texture.

People are saying

"I found the pizza amazing, delicious, and cooked to perfection."

"I found the food here to be amazing and flavorful."

"The pizza crust here is thin, crispy, and folds beautifully."

Good to know

1

Slices cost around $17 each, which is on the pricier side.

2

The restaurant offers a variety of pizza styles and toppings.

3

Expect a good wait time during peak hours.

05
Alicia's Bakery image 1

Small bakery offers a family-friendly vibe with beautiful decoration. Known for delicious breakfast like huevos rancheros and Strawberry Shortcake cakes that look great and taste fresh.

Cakes here show beautiful designs and come in flavors like Strawberry Shortcake and Red Velvet. Some cakes taste fresh and delicious, but others have issues with flavor and frosting quality.

People are saying

"I thought this bakery had the best food I visited."

"I found the cake here to be delicious and beautifully designed."

"I found the food here super delicious."

Good to know

1

Alicia's Bakery offers a variety of pastries and breakfast items.

2

Expect a casual atmosphere; it's not ideal for working or studying.

3

The bakery is small and may feel crowded during peak hours.

06
Cafe Haven @ Stella image 1

Cozy cafe offers a warm atmosphere with comfy seats and a modern look. Enjoy 3 leches cake and other pastries like tiramisu and red velvet. Board games at every table add a kid-friendly vibe, while lively college students bring an energetic social scene.

3 leches cake stands out with a full rating. Pastries include Dubai chocolate cake, cheesecake, tiramisu, and red velvet. Small slices sometimes come free.

People are saying

"The Cafe staff are so friendly and helpful, it makes you want to visit more."

"You have to try the amazing crepes and coffee here."

"The coffee here is great."

Good to know

1

Cafรฉ Haven is open until midnight, making it a late-night option.

2

The cafรฉ offers a wide variety of food and drink options.

3

Cafรฉ Haven has a dog-friendly environment.

07
Surf Club On The Sound image 1

Venue offers breathtaking views and a picturesque beach ceremony spot. Atmosphere blends luxurious elegance with spacious indoor and outdoor areas. Wedding cakes impress with stunning design and delicious taste, with custom options available.

Wedding cakes stand out with their stunning design and delicious taste. Custom cakes are available upon request and receive positive feedback.

People are saying

"I thought the food was delicious and exceptional."

"The scenic views of the Long Island Sound are breathtaking."

"The team's communication made planning our wedding a pleasure."

Good to know

1

The venue can accommodate 400-500 guests for events.

2

Parking is very limited, so plan accordingly.

3

Cocktail hours include drinks, crudites, cheeses, fruit, and appetizers.

08
New Rochelle Bakery image 1

Cute bakery offers custom cakes with fresh, flavorful options like tres leches and chocolate mousse. Early buyers love the wide assortment of pastries. Clean, inviting atmosphere makes it a neighborhood favorite.

Cakes come with custom birthday messages at no extra cost and can be made from photos. The freshness and flavor stand out, especially in the tres leches and chocolate mousse varieties.

People are saying

"I thought the cake was beautiful and delicious."

"The staff here are so friendly and helpful with the pastries."

"The coffee here is served with such friendly and kind service."

Good to know

1

A minimum $10 spend is required to use a debit card.

2

Many cakes are available for same-day pickup.

3

Expect a busy morning with many customers buying pastries as early as 10AM.

09
C A F E T E R O Coffee Company image 1

Modern coffee shop offers carrot cake in slices and loaf, perfect with coffee. Spacious layout with high ceilings and plants creates a bright, airy vibe. Comfortable seating and soft lighting foster a calm, creative energy ideal for work or chats.

Cakes here come in several varieties including carrot cake and marble cake. The carrot cake appears in both triangle slices and loaf form, all tasting good alongside coffee.

People are saying

"The coffee here is delicious and fresh."

"It's a great work-friendly spot with plenty of seating."

"I loved all the cakes they offered."

Good to know

1

Access to the bathroom is located in the lower level of a very nice apartment complex.

2

Prices at C A F E T E R O Coffee Company are very high.

3

Parking was limited on the curb, so we used the lot across the street.

Discover more

New Rochelle, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...