Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Bay Ridge

Pizza spots

Pizza that is made with a clear point of view instead of being just another generic, forgettable pie.

Based on 690 Opinions
+687
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Frankie's of Bay Ridge image 1
Frankie's of Bay Ridge image 2
Frankie's of Bay Ridge image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Cozy spot with a homey atmosphere welcomes families and casual diners. Brooklyn-style pizza shines with fresh ingredients and tasty sauce. Playful tables with crayons add charm, making it great for all ages.

Brooklyn-style pizza features fresh ingredients and quality sauce with a mouthwatering taste. Vegan gluten-free options and calzones offer variety while maintaining consistent quality.

People are saying

"I considered their pizza among my top personal favorites."

"Their vegan pizza and calzones are amazing."

"It's a cozy place with a warm, inviting atmosphere."

Good to know

1

Ordering ahead online allows you to get a freshly baked pie made to perfection.

2

The 12" Brooklyn Style pie costs around $14, which is about $7 per person.

3

The restaurant has good vegan options.

02
Peppino’s Pizza & Restaurant image 1

Small space centers on a woodfired brick oven that fills the air with warmth and aroma. Pizza boasts a perfectly crisp Margherita crust and unique options like vodka sauce with prosciutto. Atmosphere feels warm and inviting, like dining with family.

Pizza features a perfectly crisp Margherita crust and includes unique options like vodka sauce with prosciutto. The brick oven style delivers top-notch Italian flavors with every bite.

People are saying

"The brick oven pizza here is perfect and old school."

"The calamari here is fantastic and tender."

"It's a really welcoming and cozy atmosphere here."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant is always crowded.

2

The restaurant is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays.

3

The hours of operation are from 4 PM onwards.

03
Mancini’s Wood-Fired Pizza image 1

Wood-fired oven crafts best pizza by the slice with a standout Margherita. Family-friendly vibe shines through spacious seating and a mini aquarium adds charm. Clean, relaxed, and welcoming for strollers and wheelchairs.

Best pizza by the slice in the neighborhood offers a standout Margherita pizza with amazing taste. Options include a half and half pizza for those who want variety.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was delicious and super tasty."

"I thought this pizza was the best I had in New York."

"I've never had a Chicken Parmigiana hero with vodka sauce this good."

Good to know

1

The price for a pizza is over $30.

2

You get 6 mozzarella sticks for $10, which is almost $2 a stick.

3

Delivery is always fast.

04
Birria Mania image 1
Mexican restaurant

Vibrant murals of Frida Kahlo and Biggie set a lively tone. Birria pizza with layers of tortilla and beef offers a filling, sharable meal. Upbeat music fuels an energetic vibe perfect for enjoying authentic Mexican flavors.

Birria pizza stands out with layers of tortilla, birria beef, and cheeses, making it filling and easy to share. Other pizza options include a halal Mexican pizza and dishes paired well with Mac and Cheese or poutine.

People are saying

"The Mexican food here is delicious and packed with flavor."

"I loved their halal Mexican pizza."

"You have to try the Birria pizza; it's juicy and flavorful."

Good to know

1

The restaurant serves halal food, which is a rare find for a Mexican restaurant.

2

The price of the quesadillas is $17.

3

The total bill for two burritos ended up being $49.

05
Bella Roma image 1
Pizza restaurant

Old school New York style pizza shines with crispy crust and fresh Margherita slices. Cozy seating invites locals into a family-friendly and lively spot. Classic recipes create an unpretentious vibe that feels like home cooking.

Pizza features a crispy crust, tasty sauce, and melted cheese that blend well. Basic slices cost 3 dollars and include fresh Margherita options with harmonious flavors.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best."

"I found the pasta here to be good and not dry."

"The meatballs have a delicious natural Italian flavor."

Good to know

1

The cost is $6.00 for two slices and a coke.

2

A large pizza costs $16.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but be cautious of scams.

06
Original Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Corner spot serves thin crust pizza with fresh mozzarella and standout garlic knots. Loud Mexican music adds an unusual vibe. Easy access by subway and bus makes it a convenient stop in a busy area.

Pizza here features a Supreme Pizza with fresh garlic and an extra cheese pizza that stands out. The place keeps high standards and serves consistently great pizza.

People are saying

"I've been enjoying this pizza for over a decade."

Good to know

1

The price for 1 cheese slice is $3.

2

The price for 1 pepperoni slice is $3.50.

3

The price for 6 garlic knots is $2.

07
Bay Ridge Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Old school pizzeria offers authentic Italian pizza with a standout Grandma Square topped with Broccoli Rabe and Sweet Sausage. Simple decor and good natural light create a warm, lively, family-friendly vibe. Known for gluten-free options, it feels like a true community staple.

Authentic Italian pizza shines here, especially the Grandma Square pizza with Broccoli Rabe and Sweet Sausage. Preparation before baking is done by hand, keeping the pizza fresh, hot, and tasty.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and amazing."

"I found the gluten-free pizza here to be the best I've ever tried."

"I thought the pizza here was amazing."

Good to know

1

The pricing for a slice is fair at $3 and they don’t charge extra for square slices.

2

Bay Ridge Pizza offers gluten-free pizza options.

3

You can eat in or take out at Bay Ridge Pizza.

08
Zio Toto image 1
Italian restaurant

Small, intimate space offers a warm atmosphere with wood oven pizza that boasts classic Italian flavor. Guests enjoy fresh, high-quality ingredients in authentic dishes while taking in stunning views. Perfect for romantic dinners or casual meals with friends.

Wood oven pizza stands out with its classic Italian style and brick oven flavor. Pizzas come in small, shareable sizes with options like margherita, four cheese, and grilled vegetables.

People are saying

"I loved the delicious brick oven pizza."

"The fried calamari here is perfect!"

"The service at this Lunch Spot was really sweet and friendly."

Good to know

1

Expect higher prices than those listed on the menu; verify before ordering.

2

The restaurant gets very busy, especially by 8 pm when all tables are full.

3

Pack a snack if you're hungry, as portion sizes are small.

09
The Brooklyn Firefly image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza shines with unique toppings like figs and vegan options. Live jazz fuels a lively atmosphere with vintage decor. Outdoor patio with picnic tables offers roomy seating for groups.

Offers square and circle pizzas with vegan and gluten-free options. The pizza features unique toppings like figs and has excellent taste and service.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be delicious and elevated."

"I enjoyed the live music and the nice outdoor area."

"It's a cool spot with a great vintage atmosphere and lots of seating."

Good to know

1

The establishment closes at 10 PM and does not seat customers after 8:45 PM.

2

Live music at Brooklyn Firefly starts at 7pm on Saturdays.

3

The kitchen closes and seating stops at 9 PM.

10
Amuni image 1
Sicilian restaurant

Backyard patio with Sicilian-style plants creates a cozy, home-like vibe. Sfincione palermitano shines with seasoned bread crumbs and tomato sauce on unique dough. Small, casual setting feels like a neighborhood spot offering authentic Sicilian pizza flavors.

Sfincione palermitano stands out with its seasoned bread crumbs and tomato sauce on a unique dough. Sicilian pizzas often feature anchovies and sautéed breadcrumbs, offering a classic taste different from typical pizza.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the pasta and pizza, was delicious and fresh."

"The fennel and blood orange salad was a Sicilian classic."

"The Sicilian pizza with anchovy and breadcrumbs was classic."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers authentic Sicilian and Italian specialties.

2

Reservations are recommended for large groups or special events.

3

The restaurant has a lovely patio for outdoor dining.

11
Luliano’s image 1
Italian restaurant

Cozy Italian spot shines with woodfired pizza like Grandma's and pepperoni. Traditional dishes add depth to the menu. Bright, comfortable lighting sets a quiet, elegant vibe perfect for intimate meals or friendly chats.

Wood fire cooking creates a distinct flavor in the pizzas. Options include Grandma's pizza, broccoli rabe pizza, and classic pepperoni pizza. Personal pizzas are available alongside daily specials.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and delicious."

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta, is amazing."

"I found the pizza here to be delicious and fresh."

Good to know

1

Brunch includes a drink, entree, dessert, and coffee for only $23.95.

2

You cannot order off menu items in the restaurant, only to go.

3

The deal for 2 large pies for $36 is great for the family.

12
Elegante Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Old-school pizza spot with nostalgic decor and a classic vibe. Known for high-quality mozzarella and New York style pizza with a great cheese pull. Small, clean space with about 12 tables and one TV offers a cozy, authentic experience.

Pizza here has a New York style with a great cheese pull and is seasoned well. The slices offer excellent taste and texture that remind of authentic Italian and old-school pizza.

People are saying

"I considered this one of the best pizza spots in Brooklyn."

"The pizza here is great, with big slices and a fluffy yet crispy crust."

"This place has a great vintage vibe, like the pizza spots I loved as a kid."

Good to know

1

A large pizza costs $20.

2

Food is served quickly.

3

Expect oil to soak through the bag when taking pizza to go.

13
Mussels & More image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood shines with white clam pizza as a standout. Cozy, family-friendly atmosphere invites long, relaxed visits. Outdoor seating and a great bar add charm, while occasional live bands create a romantic vibe.

White clam pizza stands out as a masterpiece. Other pizzas like the margarita, lobster, and veggie pizzas are crispy, well-made, and delicious. Variety includes options like chicken buffalo and vodka pizzas.

People are saying

"The seafood here is rich and creamy, with fresh, plentiful ingredients."

"The Italian food here feels like family, thanks to the friendly staff."

"I thought the pizza here was great."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required to dine at the restaurant.

2

The pricing at the restaurant is great and reasonable for the quality.

3

There are no happy hours available.

14
Gino's image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant buzzes with a boisterous crowd and old New York decor. Grilled pizza shines, especially the mushroom and arugula combo. Valet parking adds ease, while tables sit close for an intimate yet energetic vibe.

Grilled pizza stands out with a mushroom and arugula combo that balances flavors well. Sicilian slices like the Marina and Italian Eggland Pizza offer distinct tastes crafted by skilled pizza makers.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is amazing and delicious."

"The calamari here is perfectly crispy and flavorful."

"I thought the pizza here tasted like it was made in Italy."

Good to know

1

Making reservations is recommended due to the crowd.

2

Wednesdays are 20% off on all menu items.

3

Reservations are recommended at Gino's because it gets packed on Friday-Sunday.

15
Pete's Pizzeria & Restaurant image 1

Enjoy classic thin crust pizza with a soft, chewy crust and gooey mozzarella. The spot offers a simple, clean setting with an old-fashioned TV and self-serve drinks. Great value with deals like two slices plus soda for $5.99.

Classic thin crust NY style pizza features a soft, chewy crust with a nice balance of cheese and sauce. The Margherita slice stands out with gooey mozzarella, fresh tomatoes, and a hint of herbs like oregano in the sauce for unique flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza tasted really, really good."

"The Italian food here is cheesy with a nice chewy crust."

"The food here was delicious and hit the spot."

Good to know

1

The website states that delivery starts at 11:30.

2

They have a 2 slice + soda special for 5.99.

3

The restaurant is affiliated with Grubhub.

16
Port Sa'id Seafood Restaurant image 1

Market-style seafood restaurant offers a fresh seafood display and a relaxed vibe with bright LEDs and air conditioning. Seafood pizza features generous toppings but sometimes arrives with raw dough, affecting quality. Friendly staff and authentic design enhance the experience.

Seafood pizza stands out with generous fresh toppings on a tasty crust. Some pizzas arrive with raw dough and are not hot, affecting the overall quality.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh and perfectly prepared."

"I loved the Greek-style branzino, it was buttery and amazing."

"Their seafood pizza was delicious and juicy."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a wide variety of seafood, including branzino, striped bass, and lobster.

2

Prices are fair for the quality and variety of seafood offered.

3

The total bill for a meal is typically less than $70.

17
Rocco's Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Old school pizza shop offers generous portions with a thick Sicilian crust that balances salty sauce perfectly. Family-friendly vibe shines through its spacious layout and casual atmosphere. Reasonable prices make it a favorite among locals and pizza lovers alike.

Pizza features a perfect portion of ingredients with a crust that is not doughy. The regular Sicilian slice has a thicker crust balancing a salty sauce and offers large portions compared to nearby spots.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best on the block."

"The Italian food here is served by such friendly and helpful staff."

"I loved their Vodka pie delivery."

Good to know

1

The price for one potato croquette is 5 dollars.

2

The price for a bottle of water is 3 dollars.

3

The restaurant is very clean.

18
Vesuvio Restaurant & Pizzeria image 1

Italian restaurant blends charming decor with a friendly atmosphere that suits both formal dining and casual pizza booths. Sicilian slices shine with a thick crust and rich toppings, while soft background music keeps the mood relaxed. Spacious private room adds a touch of exclusivity.

Sicilian slices stand out with a thick, satisfying crust and rich toppings. The pizza offers a great balance of flavors and a crispy yet soft texture that compares well to authentic Italian pies.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and always top-notch."

"The pizza here is amazing; I had the best slices in years."

"I thought the pizza here was very good and authentic."

Good to know

1

A reservation is a must for dining, especially on weekends.

2

Expect long wait times, often over an hour for food.

3

Parking is difficult; only street parking is available.

19
Leo's Casa Calamari image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza spot offers Brooklyn style pies with hearty toppings like chicken and sausage. Indoor and outdoor seating create a community vibe where big screens show sports games. Menu blends authentic Italian dishes with seafood, making it great for casual dining or takeout.

Authentic Brooklyn style shines through with loaded toppings like chicken, sausage, and pepperoni that require a fork to eat. Specialty pizzas include a notable vodka sauce pizza and a variety of options at a great price.

People are saying

"I thought Leo's pizza was the best among outstanding places."

"The food here is delicious and nourishing."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is primarily a takeout.

2

The order is ready within 10 minutes on average.

3

There is a wide variety of food available on the menu.

20
Ben's Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza shines with authentic taste and Grandma slices. Crispy crusts and large portions offer great value. Seating mixes indoor and outdoor benches for a casual vibe. Quick delivery keeps meals hot and fresh.

Pizza here stands out for its authentic taste and consistent quality. The Grandma Pizza is a favorite, and pizzas reheat well, showing their solid craftsmanship.

People are saying

"I found the best pizza, it's a hidden gem."

"The food here is authentic and delicious, especially the pizza."

Good to know

1

The restaurant charges $43 for 2 slices of pizza and a soda.

2

The place closes at 7 PM.

3

Ben's Pizzeria offers quick delivery.

21
Three Jolly Pigeons image 1

Old school bar offers a laid back vibe with affordable prices and a great jukebox. Frozen and mini hot pizzas provide a tasty snack option, perfect for casual bites. Friendly atmosphere draws a younger crowd on weekends, making it a cozy spot for drinks and socializing.

Frozen pizza gets heated up right at the bar, offering a convenient and delicious option. Mini hot pizzas serve as a tasty snack, with pizza being the only food served here.

People are saying

"This bar feels like a welcoming time capsule."

"It's a cool local watering hole with a laid-back crowd."

"The frozen pizza they heated up right there was super convenient."

Good to know

1

Karaoke night is expected to return soon, so check for updates.

2

Live bands perform for birthday celebrants on special nights.

3

Prices are very affordable, making it a budget-friendly spot.

22
Launch Family Entertainment Brooklyn image 1

Huge trampoline park buzzes with energetic fun and has a dedicated toddler area for little ones. Fresh, tasty pizza delights kids during birthday celebrations. Activities like dodgeball and laser tag keep everyone active and entertained.

Wonderful pizza comes out fresh and tasty. Kids enjoy eating pizza while singing happy birthday and having cake.

People are saying

"The staff here are so helpful and made sure my kids had the best time."

"The staff here make the fun activities really great."

"I enjoyed the wonderful pizza they make."

Good to know

1

The park offers a variety of trampoline activities for families.

2

There is a separate playground for younger kids to enjoy.

3

Expect limited arcade game options, with only four available.

23
Brooklyn Kabab House image 1
Halal restaurant

Spacious halal restaurant offers halal pepperoni pizza with Middle Eastern meats like lamb shawarma. Private seating and family lounge create a comfortable atmosphere. Live music and Quran recitation add a peaceful vibe for a cozy dining experience.

Offers halal chicken Kabab pizza and halal pepperoni pizza with strong flavors. Combines pizza with Middle Eastern meats like lamb and beef shawarma for unique toppings.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, flavorful, and delicious."

"The freshly baked Yemeni bread from the tanoor is amazing."

"I found the halal chicken kebab pizza to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Takeaway orders should be checked before leaving the store.

2

An obligatory 15% gratuity is added to all bills.

3

Expect a wait time during peak hours, especially on weekends.

24
Rocky's & Nicky's image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy corner spot offers crispy pizza fresh from the oven and a classic look that feels authentic. Wings and calzones are standout items. Quick bites fit well with the lively vibe near the park and pier.

Pizza comes out fresh out of the oven, hot, crispy, and perfectly seasoned. Options include a wide variety like Sicilian and garlic bread pizza, all with a unique flavor that stands out.

People are saying

"I thought their pizza was the best I had in a long time."

"I thought the food here was great tasting and inexpensive."

Good to know

1

The pizzeria offers pizza, heros, and salads.

2

The location is great next to the park for a quick slice.

3

The total bill for takeout was $10.00, and after tipping, it should have been $12.00.

Discover more

Bay Ridge, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...