Open market space offers fresh groceries, house-made antipasti, and rare Italian items. Atmosphere feels authentic Italian with a lively energy from nearby spots like a sports bar and cigar shop. Variety includes fresh meat, cheese, and specialty foods reflecting traditional flavors.
Italian foods stand out with excellent quality and authentic flavors. The food consistently impresses during events like the San Ferragosto Festival with great variety and enjoyable atmosphere.
Hand rolled cigars stand out here, available fresh at the market's cigar shop. The selection includes fresh rolled cigars alongside other specialty items like duck fat and house-made antipasti.
"I found hand rolled cigars to be of high quality here."
"You have to try the butcher at this market; it's the best."
"I found the food here to be great."
Good to know
Peter and Mikes Meat Market is a popular butcher known for quality meats.
Arthur Ave Market features a variety of food vendors and products.
The San Ferragosto Festival offers live entertainment and local food options.
Cigar bar with state-of-the-art ventilation and dim lighting creates a luxurious yet low-key atmosphere. Multiple TVs show sports while R&B music and a DJ add to the vibe. Offers well-priced cigars and a cozy space with open French doors option.
Excellent food pairs well with a relaxing dinner atmosphere. The menu offers great food and drink options that complement cigars perfectly.
Offers a wide selection of house branded cigars known for their quality. Spending over $30 waives the cigar cutting fee. Staff provide helpful recommendations for both novices and enthusiasts.
Good to know
This is the only store in all of New York where you can smoke your cigar inside.
The air system works extremely well, resulting in little to no smoke even when the place is at capacity.
There is a $10 cutting fee if you bring your own sticks.
Small, quaint market with an old-world Italian atmosphere and hand-rolled cigars on display. Social and friendly vibe with a cigar bar and a café offering wine and coffee. The place turns into a lively bar at night, blending authentic Italian flavor with a neighborhood feel.
Offers a wide variety of authentic Italian foods with consistently excellent quality. Fresh ingredients and high-quality options make it a reliable spot for Italian cuisine.
A corner offers freshly handmade cigars with a shop where cigars get hand-rolled right in front of you. The selection includes hand-rolled cigars alongside food and drinks.
Good to know
Go during off-hours to avoid the wait.
Most places only accept cash.
Limited parking is available due to the restaurant being located on a one-block street.
Dark, intimate cigar lounge with excellent ventilation allows smoking without heavy smoke buildup. Live jazz music with a smooth, mellow singer creates a relaxed, sophisticated vibe reminiscent of a 1920s speakeasy. Spacious, elegant decor with comfortable seating supports socializing and unwinding.
Food here matches the class and elegance of the setting, with dishes served alongside drinks and cigars. Comfortable seating with small tables supports a relaxed dining experience.
Extensive cigar selection with great descriptions suits those who enjoy smoking in company. The lounge offers a relaxed atmosphere ideal for pairing cigars with cocktails or whiskey.
Good to know
Sinatra night on Saturdays starts at 8:00pm and requires reservations.
A cover charge of $40 per person applies for the Sinatra show.
Expect a two-drink minimum for entry to the show.
Upscale cigar lounge with old school vibes and gold wallpaper sets a refined tone. State-of-the-art ventilation keeps air clear despite cigar smoke. Space feels more like a restaurant with tables than a casual lounge, attracting cigar enthusiasts and those seeking a polished atmosphere.
Excellent food includes Buffalo shrimp and a great menu of drinks. The setting pairs well with cigars, creating a classic vibe with friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere.
An extensive collection of whiskies and cigars pairs well with the old school cigar bar vibes. The selection includes signature cigars like Partagas P2 series, perfect for enjoying with drinks and food indoors.
Good to know
You won't be able to get a table without a reservation.
There is a mandatory $20 cigar purchase at the restaurant.
Gentlemen must wear collared shirts; no athletic attire or shorts allowed.
Pizza restaurant offers Old World charm with walls covered in nostalgic pictures and a quaint, small hole-in-the-wall feel. Atmosphere blends historic vibes with lively music and comfortable outdoor seating. Known for authentic New York-style pizza and standout dishes like gnocchi and eggplant parm.
Food comes out quickly and tastes fantastic with a variety of options. Drinks like cold Peroni complement the great food and contribute to a wonderful atmosphere.
A cigar humidor is available for buying cigars. The staff encourages guests to sit down and enjoy their cigars comfortably inside. The atmosphere includes a Sopranos decal on the mirror, adding a specific vibe to the smoking experience.
Good to know
A 20% service charge is automatically added to all bills without prior notice.
Prices on the menu are often lower than what you actually pay due to extra fees.
Karaoke night happens every Thursday at 10pm with a two-drink minimum.
Bar tabac with an old-school library vibe and semi-private cigar lounge offers a cozy, sophisticated atmosphere for whiskey and cigar enthusiasts. Outdoor seating and a no-smoking room provide options for different preferences. The space attracts a mostly male crowd and features classic cocktails like Vodka Martinis and Old Fashioneds.
Food shows sophistication and excellence with a decent menu and great cocktails.
A small but exclusive cigar selection blends quality and uniqueness. The lounge offers cool cigar cutting methods and a library vibe at the back, creating a relaxed spot to enjoy cigars and drinks.
Good to know
Reservations are not required, but it's best to arrive early due to limited seating.
Expect to pay a cutting fee of $12 if you bring your own cigars.
Cigar prices are generally high, with house specials costing $18 per drink.