Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Little Italy's best

Italian food sandwiches

You want a sandwich that respects the traditions of Italian cooking.

Based on 678 Opinions
+675
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Casa Della Mozzarella image 1
Casa Della Mozzarella image 2
Casa Della Mozzarella image 3
View all

Small, narrow deli packed with Italian delicacies and handcrafted mozzarella creates a warm, old-world atmosphere. Space feels claustrophobic and busy, with tight seating and crowded aisles. Energy is lively, reflecting passion for authentic Italian food.

Mozzarella stands out with its fresh pulled quality and authentic Italian taste that rivals even Italy. Sandwiches like the Bronx Tale add variety alongside excellent handcrafted cheeses.

Slabs of homemade mozzarella make the sandwiches stand out with rich, fresh flavor. These sandwiches deliver an extraordinary taste experience that many consider among the best ever.

People are saying

"The fresh mozzarella on this sandwich is the best I've ever had."

"I thought their deli sandwiches were the best I've ever had."

"This Italian food's fresh mozzarella is the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Prepare to wait outside on Saturdays due to high demand.

2

Expect long lines during holiday times.

3

Call ahead to place your order for quicker service.

02
No Fork image 1
Fast food restaurant

Fast food restaurant offers spacious seating inside and outdoors under a terrace with hanging lights. Atmosphere feels casual and welcoming with pleasant, varied music and a fresh bread aroma. Sidewalk tables add to a chill, upbeat vibe perfect for quick bites.

Prosciutto sandwiches stand out with soft and crispy bread, amazing sauce, and perfectly sliced prosciutto. Grilled options like chicken and beef prosciutto also offer distinct, delicious flavors.

Toasted sandwiches feature soft and crispy bread with perfect prosciutto and amazing sauce. The Famous No Fork sandwich includes mushrooms and fries, making it filling and flavorful.

People are saying

"The sandwiches here have amazing flavors and fresh ingredients."

"I considered No Fork the best fast food place in Bronx."

"The Italian food here, especially the prosciutto sandwich, is like heaven on earth."

Good to know

1

They accept cash and Apple Pay.

2

The hygiene level is high.

3

There is no bathroom at the restaurant; use the one on the corner.

03
Calabria Pork Store image 1

Salami and sausage hang from the ceiling in sausage chandeliers and a salami roof, creating a space that feels like stepping into Italy. The air carries the aroma of cured meats and authentic Italian products, reflecting craftsmanship and tradition. The shop draws those seeking artisanal, old-world quality with a wide selection of cured meats and fresh sausages.

Freshness stands out with mozzarella and sausage that taste very fresh. The selection includes house-made sausages, dry-cured specialties, and various salamis like soppressata and fennel salami.

A huge sandwich packed with meat and cheese stands out here. The prosciutto and mozzarella hero matches its $16 price with solid quality.

People are saying

"I thought their sweet sausage was almost as delicious as the hot fennel."

"Their Italian cured meats, like soppressata and salami, are incredible."

"I found the soppressata sandwich solid and rated it 10/10."

Good to know

1

The delicatessen has an extensive selection of high quality sausages and salamis.

2

The store offers a huge selection of fresh meats and cheeses.

3

You can try their excellent products before purchasing.

04
C. Di Palo image 1
Wine bar

Cozy wine bar with warm, authentic atmosphere and spacious, comfortable seating. Offers exceptional Italian charcuterie and paninis paired with carefully selected wines and cocktails. Quiet semi-private area suits intimate gatherings or relaxed conversations.

Delicate bruschettas and specialty cured meats like prosciutto and soppressata pair well with aged cheeses from cow and sheep. The focaccia, dolcezza, and mozzarella complement the classic prosciutto panini, creating an authentic Italian food experience.

Panini sandwiches have an exceptional crust and generous fillings. Options like the Piccante and Il Lombardo offer good flavor at a reasonable price.

People are saying

"They helped pair the perfect wine with knowledgeable, warm hospitality."

"The wine selection here is excellent, with prestigious Italian labels."

"The Piccante and Il Lombardo sandwiches were so good."

Good to know

1

They are only open for weekend evenings at the moment.

2

The value for bar snacks is fantastic, with $25 for five meats/cheeses of your choice.

3

The prices for house wines are $9 and 4 pieces of crostini are $6.

05
Arthur Avenue Market Pasticceria image 1

Open market space offers fresh groceries, house-made antipasti, and rare Italian items. Atmosphere feels authentic Italian with a lively energy from nearby spots like a sports bar and cigar shop. Variety includes fresh meat, cheese, and specialty foods reflecting traditional flavors.

Offers fresh pasta, house-made antipasti, and sandwiches with unique ingredients like duck fat and organ meats. Eggplant parmigiana stands out as a notable dish, while mozzarella sticks do not impress.

Sandwiches include duck fat, organ meats, and house-made antipasti. Some sandwiches have prosciutto and cheese but can be dry and pricey compared to typical New York options.

People are saying

"I found hand rolled cigars to be of high quality here."

"I remembered truly delicious sandwiches from my past."

"I remembered truly delicious Italian food sandwiches from my past."

Good to know

1

Peter and Mikes Meat Market is a popular butcher known for quality meats.

2

Arthur Ave Market features a variety of food vendors and products.

3

The San Ferragosto Festival offers live entertainment and local food options.

06
Arthur Avenue Retail Market image 1

Small, quaint market with an old-world Italian atmosphere and hand-rolled cigars on display. Social and friendly vibe with a cigar bar and a cafรฉ offering wine and coffee. The place turns into a lively bar at night, blending authentic Italian flavor with a neighborhood feel.

Fresh mozzarella and ricotta get made daily, offering handmade quality. The market stocks juicy Italian sausages, mortadella, and a wide range of meats alongside Apulian bread and pizza slices.

Super sandwiches get made fresh on the spot, including options like mortadella and broccoli raab. Several vendors offer many pre-made sandwiches for quick grabs, with a few tables near the bar and restaurant area for seating.

People are saying

"You can watch cigars being hand-rolled right in front of you at the Market."

"You can find the freshest handmade mozzarella and ricotta for Italian food here."

"I found the sandwiches here to be amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Go during off-hours to avoid the wait.

2

Most places only accept cash.

3

Limited parking is available due to the restaurant being located on a one-block street.

07
Onieal's Grand Street | Restaurant & Bar image 1

Cozy bar with red velvet theme and classic old building decor offers outdoor seating beyond rooftop options. Loud music creates a high-energy atmosphere where conversations require shouting. Bartenders craft notable cocktails like Espresso Martinis and Cosmopolitans.

Rigatoni comes with a very tasty sauce. Penne vodka hits the mark. Chicken can be blackened on pasta with no extra charge. Pasta sometimes arrives cold.

Steak sandwiches stand out with rich flavor and satisfying portions. Meatball sandwiches and burgers also deliver solid, hearty options.

People are saying

"The cocktails here are really good."

"I had the best Italian food meal I ever ate in NYC."

"I dream about how delicious the steak sandwich is."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 3-7 PM on Mondays and Wednesdays.

2

There is no happy hour on the weekends.

3

Expect a 20% 'Large Party Gratuity' for large groups.

08
Mezza Luna Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers a cozy and inviting atmosphere with a lively vibe and classic Italian ambiance. Space feels tight but warm, often crowded with locals enjoying large, satisfying portions. The setting evokes an authentic Little Italy experience.

Marinara sauce stands out as rich and savory, especially on hot, crisp pizza with melty cheese. Pasta options include penne with chicken and veggie lasagna, both flavorful and satisfying, alongside dishes like eggplant parmigiana hero.

Chicken parm sandwich stands out with its rich flavor. Meatball hero and stuffed sandwiches offer delicious, hearty options alongside classic slices.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was the best I'd ever had."

"The pizza here is amazing, with a light, crispy crust."

"I thought the chicken parm sandwich was great."

Good to know

1

The price for a slice of pizza is $6.50.

2

You need to park on the street and it is metered.

3

They allow you to pick different toppings for the left or right side of the pizza.

Discover more

Little Italy, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...