Small space with modern cozy decor and outdoor seating creates a warm welcoming vibe. Background music adds to the relaxed atmosphere where families and friends gather. The place offers excellent value with fresh ingredients and a variety of craft beers complementing artisanal pizzas.
Closest thing to original New York pizza with a classic NY style crust and authentic flavor.
Delivery arrives hot and fresh with consistently fast and reliable service. Receipts and delivery times come through Toast, keeping the process clear and efficient.
"I thought the pizza here was amazing and the best I had."
"This New York Style Pizza has a perfect, crunchy crust."
"The delivery arrived hot and fresh, just like dining in."
Good to know
Lunch deals offer two slices for $7 from 12 PM to 6 PM.
Prices are reasonable, with two slices costing $7.
Delivery is fast after placing an order online.
Small sit-down pizza spot with indie beers on tap and TV screens for entertainment creates a friendly, lively atmosphere. Clean, airy space includes a private group area and walls where patrons can write. Pizza pairs well with a variety of craft beers and hard cider.
Classic slices feature a thin crust with a crisp edge and a balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio. The pizza captures the authentic New York style with a foldable, chewy texture.
Delivery arrives with fastest speed compared to other services. An old school delivery person handles orders directly. Slices come in a good size and taste very delicious.
Good to know
The pizza making class takes place once a month.
From 2-5pm, you get 2 slices and a free soda.
Wings are discounted on Wednesdays.
Renovated space combines exposed brick and clean benches with a classic New York slice vibe. Warm, homey atmosphere feels like a neighborhood pizzeria with a contemporary old-school touch. TVs often show games, adding casual energy to the setting.
Classic old school New York pizza style defines the slices here. The pizza features a traditional thin crust with simple, straightforward toppings.
Delivery comes with super fast speed and arrives promptly. Pizza stays hot upon arrival.
Good to know
Garlic knots are only available on GrubHub and DoorDash.
The classic slice does not use sweet pizza sauce.
Prices start at $10 for a pizza.
Counter-style setup with no seating creates a quick takeout vibe. Atmosphere feels casual and cozy with an authentic Italian touch and a slightly messy but clean interior. Offers diverse pizza choices that capture classic New York style.
Authentic New York style pizza shines here with a phenomenal crust and classic toppings. It serves as a solid introduction to the traditional NY pizza experience.
Delivery shows fast service at times but also includes unexpected delays without notification. Orders placed through Slice arrive quickly or nearly an hour late with no clear reason.
Good to know
The restaurant does not offer dine-in service.
The plain cheese slice costs $3 plus tip.
There is a 4% credit card fee that is not disclosed.
Old-school pizzeria with a homey feel and no-frills seating area including a TV in the back. Atmosphere stays casual and welcoming, suited for late-night bites and relaxed meals. Known for authentic New York-style pizza with flaky, buttery crusts and a loyal local following.
Offers authentic New York pizza with a classic taste that satisfies both locals and visitors. Combines great flavor and affordable prices for a true New York pizza experience.
Offers fast delivery and only takeout or delivery options. Phone ordering can be difficult due to poor phone service and staff not listening well.
Good to know
Prices are very reasonable for New York, with a traditional slice at just $3.25.
Delivery is fast and food is always hot when it arrives.
The pizzeria offers a wide variety of pizzas.
Small, unassuming pizza joint with a traditional neighborhood pizzeria vibe and welcoming atmosphere. The space feels comfortable and chill, attracting a steady local crowd. Known for generous toppings and reasonably priced New York-style pizza, it offers a solid, no-frills dining experience.
Slices come 33% larger than typical New York pizza slices with an old school New York pizza taste. Delivery is quick and prices stay reasonable for authentic New York style pizza.
Delivery arrives pretty fast and usually fresh. Sometimes orders come wrong, and calling about delivery can lead to bad treatment.
Good to know
The restaurant offers classic New York-style pizza, authentic tacos, burgers, and salads.
Prices are reasonable for New York-style pizza.
They could usually prepare two pies for pickup within 15-20 minutes.
Glass doors on pizza ovens reveal pies cooking in a cozy, beautifully decorated space with bright lighting and no TVs. The atmosphere feels friendly and romantic, with a perfect playlist setting a casual, welcoming vibe. It attracts a neighborhood crowd that values quality and a relaxed pace.
Pizza blends Neopolitan and New York styles with a crust that is both doughy and crispy. Starters are fresh and the menu includes a natural wine list.
Delivery arrives with consistent quality and meets expectations. Ordering from here offers a reliable experience that impresses.
Good to know
Happy hour starts at 5 PM.
The square slices are only available from 5-7 PM during weekday happy hours.
It is strongly recommended to get a reservation ahead, especially after 7pm on weekends.
Small space with a congested layout and late hours creates a focused, busy vibe. Local crowd favors takeout and appreciates NY style pizza with standout garlic knots and buffalo wings. Pricing varies depending on staff, with cash payments often cheaper.
Slices feature thin crust and a foldable structure typical of New York style. Toppings are classic and the pizza offers a chewy yet crispy texture.
Quick delivery brings piping hot food right to the door. Delivery times can vary, sometimes longer than the estimated half hour, and staff may handle challenges like walking up three flights of stairs when elevators are out.
Good to know
Paying cash is cheaper than using a card.
It is recommended to call about 5 minutes before arriving to have the pizza ready right away.
The price of a slice of buffalo chicken pizza varies depending on who serves you on Monday and Tuesday.
Tiny pizza spot operates as a doorway operation with no indoor seating, offering a covered outdoor standing area with bar counters. Atmosphere captures an authentic New York street pizza vibe with friendly energy and a crowded, lively pace. Customers often eat standing outside, enjoying fast, flavorful slices in a casual, no-frills setting.
Slices feature a thin crust with simple toppings that deliver a crispy and flavorful bite. The pizza captures the classic New York style with an authentic taste and texture.
Delivery arrives very fast and is free. The process is convenient and works well for hotel orders. Including paper plates and napkins with deliveries would improve the experience.
Good to know
The restaurant does not offer dine-in service.
There are no seats, so you just grab your slice.
Four people can eat for less than $30 in New York.
Brightly lit pizzeria with counter service and garage door seating creates an open, spacious feel. Atmosphere stays friendly and welcoming, with comfortable seating and good music. Outdoor seating faces a noisy street, which can affect the vibe.
Slices show quintessential New York style with a truly authentic taste. The pizza offers a very good balance of crust and toppings that captures the classic New York pizza experience.
Fast delivery brings hot food right to the door. Prices stay low, even with delivery included.
Good to know
The price for one plain slice is $3.50.
Ordering ahead of time is recommended for a better experience.
They have halal options available.
Small dining area with classic New York look and old Italian movie decor creates a family-owned, lively atmosphere. Booth seating and neon sign add to the simple, no-frills vibe. Pizza quality peaks fresh from the oven, drawing a steady local crowd.
Slices showcase quintessential New York style pizza with a thin, foldable crust and balanced toppings. The setting mimics a classic New York pizza joint with booth tables and a clean environment.
Delivery runs fast except on busy weekend nights. Pizza often arrives tilted, causing toppings to slide off and leave oily boxes. Staff remake pizzas kindly when issues happen, but ordering by phone or picking up is recommended over apps.
Good to know
Customers can bring their own booze.
The pizza place requires a minimum purchase of $10 to use a credit card.
You get a free can of soda if you buy two slices.
Clean, bright space offers unpretentious New York-style pizza with generous portions and a wide variety of options. The atmosphere feels cozy and friendly, attracting a neighborhood crowd. Delivery runs smoothly without extra fees, supporting local business.
Large pies come with a classic thin crust and a foldable slice style. The pizza matches the authentic New York flavor that fans seek.
Delivery arrives fast with the pizza still hot. The delivery person is friendly and the timing is reliable.
Good to know
Parking can be tricky on certain days, so plan ahead.
The restaurant does not have a bathroom available for customers.
There is plenty of seating available for dining in.
Small, hole-in-the-wall pizzeria with limited indoor seating and a covered outdoor area that feels warm and welcoming. The atmosphere is old school and homie, attracting those who appreciate classic New York-style pizza in a friendly setting.
Offers proper New York pizza with a classic thin crust and authentic style. The pizza captures the real New York flavor and texture well.
Delivery runs mostly fast and hot, with pizzas arriving in good condition. Scheduled deliveries sometimes run over half an hour late, showing some inconsistency in timing.
Good to know
A plain slice and canned soda cost under $5, which is pretty good for lunch.
The restaurant is a perfect spot to go before a movie.
Delivery from this restaurant is always fast.
Small pizzeria with a vintage rare pizza oven and classic atmosphere featuring black and white photos and red checkered tablecloths. The space feels cozy and old school, with tight seating inside and some outdoor tables. Live music and a home-like vibe create an inviting, authentic experience.
Offers authentic New York style pizza with a taste true to the city. Known for top-tier quality that draws people from far away.
Delivery offers fast and easy service with pizza that stands out for its quality. The owner shows personal care by addressing issues directly through calls and apologies.
Good to know
Mano's is closed on Mondays, making it impossible to get pizza that day.
They had a pop-up on Monday.
Call in to see if they are running out of dough before making a visit.
Old-style pizzeria offers hand-tossed pizza with thin crust and extra cheese in a clean, quiet setting. The atmosphere feels simple and welcoming, with a focus on classic New York pizza vibes. Prices are affordable, and the place operates on a cash-only policy.
Offers classic New York pizza with quality ingredients and an unmistakable old school vibe.
Pizza arrives hot and fresh every time. Delivery staff may insist on exact change when handling payments.
Good to know
The price for 2 huge slices of cheese pizza and a fountain drink is $6.50.
They only accept cash payments and do not accept debit card payments.
There is parking available in the back of the restaurant.
Old school NYC Italian pizza shop with classic tile walls and ample outdoor seating creates a homey, spacious vibe. TVs play loudly with sensational or nostalgic content, adding a distinctive, lively atmosphere. Seating is comfortable but arranged unpredictably, fitting a casual, relaxed dining experience.
Slices capture authentic New York style with a classic thin crust and balanced toppings. The Margarita pie stands out as a traditional favorite that reflects the original New York pizza by the slice.
Staff stay well-mannered and punctual during delivery. Ordering and payment go smoothly both in store and online. Food arrives looking and tasting good.
Good to know
Food will be hot if ordered in person.
The price of the simple plain slice is $3.88 when paying with a card.
The restaurant is open late.
Tiny counter service pizza spot with limited seating inside and a few tables outside creates an intimate setting. Buzzing atmosphere blends loud locals and tourists with old school New York charm and lively music. Late night energy keeps the vibe fun and inviting.
Cheese slices capture the old school charm of 1990s New York pizza. The style stays true to classic New York flavors and textures.
Delivery arrives fast and hot, often within 15 to 30 minutes. The same friendly delivery person handles orders, including to local hotels, keeping pizza quality consistent with dine-in.
Good to know
There is limited seating, but they have outdoor seating too.
The pizza delivered in 15 minutes from when I placed the order.
The prices were really affordable.
Pizza restaurant offers indoor and outdoor seating with big windows providing a spectacular view. Atmosphere feels cozy and well decorated, with a lively vibe supported by music and a dedicated party space. Guests enjoy a notable wine and beer selection alongside highly praised pizza.
Offers reasonably priced slices with a classic New York style crust and toppings. Pizza delivers the authentic thin, foldable experience typical of New York joints.
Fast delivery ensures hot, fresh pizza arrives quickly. The classic pepperoni pizza tastes fantastic with consistent quality.
Good to know
Happy hour runs from 4-6pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.
The breakfast pizza slice is available only until 12 PM.
You can get 5 large slices of a random variety of pizza for $5-6.
Pizza restaurant channels retro New York Brooklyn vibe with brown booths and a well-lit glass display showcasing menu options. Atmosphere feels cozy and inviting, blending nostalgia with relaxed energy. Affordable prices and excellent pizza varieties draw a steady crowd seeking classic flavors.
Offers authentic New York style pizza with a well-rounded flavor profile. Stands out as one of the few places serving classic New York pizza.
Delivery arrives fast and food stays hot with gooey cheese and beef patties. Prices can feel high compared to the value received.
Good to know
The pizza is affordable, with slices and soda costing less than $10.
The restaurant offers a wide variety of pizza, calzones, and beef patties.
Takeout is available for those who prefer to eat at home.
Small hole-in-the-wall pizza spot with few stools and a big front window for people watching. Atmosphere is clean and friendly, making it a great place for late night slices. Prices are affordable compared to other Midtown options, with delicious, crispy crust pizza and tasty garlic knots.
Good overall quality offers a decent representation of New York pizza. The crust is thinner than typical, lacking the usual thickness expected from New York style.
Delivery features Sal's Special Pizza with up to 4 toppings and extra cheese. This spot is a reliable choice for pizza delivery.
Good to know
The pizza costs $20 for a big size.
You can order by the slice to try different types of pizza.
The pizza takes 15 minutes to prepare fresh.
Narrow pizzeria with counter seating inside and a spacious outdoor patio in the back yard. Atmosphere is lively and inviting with crafted beers and unique wines enhancing the experience. Cozy, clean interior contrasts with a chill backyard perfect for enjoying pizza slices.
Slices offer classic New York style pizza with a great balance of crust and toppings. This spot ranks among the top for authentic NY pizza by the slice and delivers a satisfying experience for those seeking that style.
Delivery arrives mostly on time but can sometimes take up to an hour. Staff handle both in-store and delivery orders and occasionally prioritize delivery, which can overwhelm them.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended at DOP, especially on weekends.
The restaurant only offers takeout and does not provide delivery options.
Seating is very limited.
Small dining area with outdoor seating and a small bar creates a cozy setting. Atmosphere feels family friendly but can be hectic at times. Strong New York City vibes come from floors and wall art, complementing the aroma of fresh pizza.
Offers an authentic New York pizza experience with classic thin crust and traditional toppings. Stands out from overhyped spots with consistently amazing flavor and quality.
Delivery runs mostly fast and punctual with friendly service. Occasionally, orders can be delayed beyond the estimated time.
Good to know
The price of a cheese slice is $3.75.
Make sure you call ahead to place an order.
The restaurant offers late night slices.
Small, narrow space fills quickly, creating a crowded, humid atmosphere with limited seating indoors and a small patio outdoors. Pizza stands out as the best in Manhattan, drawing a lively crowd despite the tight quarters. Attention to gluten-free protocols adds a thoughtful touch to the busy vibe.
Thin, crispy, and chewy crust matches authentic New York style. Pizza offers tasty slices with a variety of choices.
Fast pickup and delivery happen even in heavy traffic. Orders arrive in less than 30 minutes with no delivery fee through the app. Communication about substitutions is clear and proactive.
Good to know
The restaurant is open all night.
They deliver after midnight.
The location is a good spot near lots of subway stops and Bryant Park.
Outdoor dining includes a trolley car-style hut with cozy booths and bar seating inside. Atmosphere blends warmth and thoughtfulness with occasional noise from a slamming door. Cocktails and pizza stand out for quality, offering a unique upscale sit-down experience.
Very thin and crispy crust shapes the classic personal pie that echoes New York slices. Innovative toppings add a creative and refined twist to the traditional style.
Delivery includes pizza and a brownie as a bonus. Orders arrive reliably and often.
Good to know
The price of a personal pizza pie is $25.
Pizzas come in a 12 inch pie, which is plenty for two people to share.
The bathroom is several flights down, but there is elevator access.
Small, crowded pizza spot with limited indoor seating and some outdoor standing tables creates a quintessential NYC vibe. Walls decorated with photos of movie and music stars add a pop culture touch. Atmosphere feels electric and hectic, best suited for quick bites or takeout.
Crusty texture and not too thick define the New York style pizza here. Cheese slices capture the classic feel, making it easy to grab and enjoy outdoors.
Delivery arrives in less than 30 minutes, often under 10. Staff handle issues quickly and sometimes offer free hot pizza. Orders come heated whole or in pieces with fast, efficient service.
Good to know
Expect long lines during peak hours, especially on weekends.
Takeout is recommended due to limited seating and high foot traffic.
Credit card payments incur an extra charge compared to cash.
Tiny, crowded pizzeria with no indoor seating and a cash-only policy creates a grab-and-go atmosphere. Outdoor seating spills into the street, accompanied by nostalgic music and an old-school vibe. The place feels like a family-run legacy with a genuine New York pizza shop energy.
Classic old school New York pizza shines here with its authentic look, feel, and taste. This spot delivers true New York style pizza that matches the legendary reputation and brings a nostalgic vibe.
Delivery includes both good and bad experiences. Drivers sometimes speak only Spanish, which may affect communication during delivery.
Good to know
The restaurant only accepts cash; no credit cards are accepted.
Pizza slices are priced at $2.75, and soda costs $1.50.
They are celebrating their 50th anniversary this year.
Small pizza spot offers warm, welcoming atmosphere with many locals and families. Pizza features good sauce-to-cheese ratio and soft, fluffy crust with a little crisp. Prices run on the higher side, but the place maintains a clean, well-kept look.
Crust comes out perfect with a great sauce. It nails the classic New York style pizza experience.
Delivery arrives fast with friendly staff handling orders quickly. Some issues appear with pizza handling causing uneven cheese, and missing items like marinara sauce are not replaced or redelivered.
Good to know
The price for pizza slices at Circle Pizza is now $3.25.
Circle Pizza offers pizza pies, garlic knots, and wings.
The restaurant does not provide chairs for customers eating there.
Pizza restaurant offers an authentic New York city pizza experience with super crispy crust and perfect ingredient balance. Atmosphere feels like a family-run, old school pizzeria with warm lighting and nostalgic decor. Staff speak with thick New York accents, adding to the traditional vibe.
Offers authentic New York pizza with an old school vibe. Serves quintessential NY slices that capture classic flavors.
Offers pizza delivery with estimated times that often run longer than expected. Delivery staff can be rude, and pizzas sometimes arrive well after the initial estimate.
Good to know
The estimated delivery time is always longer than stated.
The price of $28 for the order is pretty good compared to other places.
The special pie costs over 30 dollars.
Pizza restaurant with a self-serve counter and small space creates a laid back, no frills vibe. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming with loud hip hop music and lively conversations. Pizza is known for its thin, crispy crust and rich flavor.
Thin crust stands out with a classic New York style that appeals to fans of that pizza type. The pizza ranks among the top choices on the Upper East Side and holds a strong reputation in the city.
Delivery uses the restaurant's own drivers rather than third-party services. Pizza often arrives warm, avoiding the need for reheating, but some orders come late with soggy, cold crusts.
Good to know
The kitchen closes early, around 8 PM.
Expect long wait times, especially during peak hours.
The price of the specialty pizza is $7 a slice.
Nostalgic 1950s pizzeria vibe fills the space with cozy booths and an 80s movie playing on TV. The atmosphere is inviting and lively, often crowded with locals chatting and families with kids. Known for amazing Sicilian pizza, it offers a friendly, family-oriented setting with cash-only payment.
Classic New York pizza comes with a thin crust and a foldable slice. The pizza features a simple topping style that highlights the dough and sauce.
Delivery service runs quick and fast with many takeout orders handled. Delivery staff show mixed behavior, some are very nice while others can be rude and demanding.
Good to know
This place is cash only; an ATM is available on-site.
The price of the 16" plain pie is $12.50.
The restaurant offers $12 pies daily.