Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Carroll Gardens

Sandwich spots

A sandwich that is worth the trip instead of just being a convenient way to kill your hunger.

Based on 801 Opinions
+798
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Luana's Tavern image 1
Luana's Tavern image 2
Luana's Tavern image 3
View all
American restaurant

Old-timey bar with tin ceilings and a large patio offers live music that energizes the space. Families enjoy the kid-friendly play area while savoring crispy chicken sandwiches full of flavor and crunch. Perfect for casual meals or lively celebrations.

Steak and chicken sandwiches stand out here. The crispy chicken sandwich is especially notable for being full of flavor and saucy with a perfect crunch.

People are saying

"I found the tavern burgers delicious and the smash burgers out of this world."

"The outdoor seating area is huge and great."

"The crispy chicken sandwich was so delicious and full of flavor."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers discounted drinks and Smash Burgers from 4-6:30pm.

2

Reservations are not necessary for the outdoor space at Luana's Tavern.

3

The restaurant has both indoor and outdoor seating available.

02
Time 4 Bagels image 1
Bagel shop

Bagel shop shines with a crazy selection of sandwiches and bagels topped with fresh, stacked ingredients. Atmosphere is welcoming and casual, perfect for quick meals. Prices stay affordable, and vegetarians find solid options here.

A crazy selection of bagels and sandwiches stands out here. Sandwiches and wraps come with unique schmear options, making it more of a sandwich spot than a traditional bagel place.

People are saying

"The food choices here go far beyond bagels, with made-to-order options."

"I found the bagels here to be excellent."

"I thought the bagel sandwiches here were some of the best."

Good to know

1

The menu features a variety of bagels, sandwiches, and spreads.

2

Expect a casual dining atmosphere with both indoor and outdoor seating.

3

The place can get busy during weekend brunch hours.

03
La Bicyclette Bakery image 1

Brick oven creates a cozy atmosphere with authentic French baguettes. Sandwiches like Salami/Cornichon on baguette offer generous portions and hold up well after air frying. Early arrival is key due to limited hours and high demand for fresh items.

Baguette sandwiches stand out with freshly made bread and generous portions. The Salami/Cornichon on baguette offers a perfect pick-me-up and holds up well even after air frying.

People are saying

"The pastries here are authentic Parisian and simply heaven in the mouth."

"The baguettes here are thin, crispy, and the best I've had."

"The ham and comté sandwich was the best thing I had."

Good to know

1

The bakery does not have seating.

2

A baguette costs $2, while a ham and cheese croissant is $9.

3

Arrive early to have your pick of goods; the sugar brioche sells out by 10am.

04
Caputo's Fine Foods image 1
Italian grocery store

Italian grocery store shines with fresh mozzarella and homemade pasta sauces. Sandwiches boast big, tasty portions and fresh ingredients. Neighborhood gem offers authentic ingredients and legendary sandwich experience at reasonable prices.

Italian sandwiches stand out with freshest ingredients and big, tasty portions. The menu offers lots of tempting choices that deliver consistently delicious flavors.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were insanely delicious."

"I thought their Italian food, especially the vodka sauce, was fantastic."

"I found the fresh mozzarella here to be the best I'd had outside of Italy."

Good to know

1

The deli offers a great selection of meats, cheeses, and pastas.

2

Prices are reasonable compared to other Italian markets.

3

Bread is available fresh daily at the deli.

05
Cremini's image 1
Italian restaurant

Small Italian spot serves authentic Marche cuisine in a cozy, nonna-style setting with custom Italian decor. Sandwiches shine with thin, flaky Crescia flatbread and fresh flavors. Outdoor garden seating with Italian films adds a relaxed neighborhood vibe.

Sandwiches feature thin, flaky Crescia flatbread with a fresh, complex preparation that balances simple ingredients. The sandwiches pair well with spritzes and wine and leave a lasting impression.

People are saying

"The homemade pasta, especially the wild boar, is exceptional Italian food."

"The wine selection here is great, and the owners make you feel at home."

"Their Crescia flatbread sandwich was flaky, fresh, and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are a must on Fridays and Saturdays at Cremini's.

2

Customers should call beforehand for a table since the space is quite small.

3

If you don't make a reservation, you'll be waiting a while or may not get a table.

06
Emma's Torch Cafe image 1

Cafe blends a warm atmosphere with a strong mission to train refugees and survivors. Chicken sandwich shines with bold flavor while cozy indoor and spacious outdoor seating invite guests to relax. Staff stay attentive, making every visit feel welcoming.

Chicken sandwich stands out with strong flavor and quality. Other options include an omelette sandwich and a red pepper feta and egg sandwich with a nice taste.

People are saying

"I loved their breakfast burrito; it was truly incredible."

"The outdoor seating here is great and has a lovely atmosphere."

"I loved their omelette and chicken sandwiches."

Good to know

1

The cafe serves breakfast until 3pm, making it a great brunch spot.

2

Menu items include gluten-free and vegan options for dietary needs.

3

Prices are affordable, with pancakes costing $10 and oat lattes $4.50.

07
Cafe Cotton Bean image 1
Coffee shop

Small coffee shop shines with natural light and cozy seating. Bacon egg avocado sandwich offers rich flavors while fish sandwich is a fresh option at a good price. Calm music and fast Wi-Fi create a relaxed, focused spot.

Bacon egg avocado sandwich stands out with its rich flavors and fresh ingredients. Fish sandwich offers a fresh, delicious option at a reasonable price.

People are saying

"It's a nice, friendly, and cozy place to relax."

"The Cafe here doesn't offer WiFi on weekends."

"I thought the bacon, egg, and avocado sandwich was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Expect busy weekends; reservations are not required.

2

Wifi access requires a purchase; maximum of 2 hours allowed.

3

Prices for drinks range from $9 to $13 depending on size and type.

08
Brooklyn Bread Cafe image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop offers fresh baked bread and a bustling atmosphere with lively music. Creative sandwiches like chicken cutlet and bacon egg and cheese shine. Outdoor patio is huge but views are partly blocked by bread racks.

Freshness stands out with every bite. Creative options like chicken cutlet, bacon egg and cheese, and eggplant sandwiches deliver savory and amazing flavors.

People are saying

"The everything bagel is the best."

"The breakfast spread is fresh, abundant, and beautifully presented."

"You can customize sandwiches to your heart's desire."

Good to know

1

Brooklyn Bread offers reliable catering services for large orders.

2

Delivery is consistently on time for all orders.

3

A $2 service fee applies to all online orders.

09
Breakfast by Salt's Cure image 1

Small diner offers breakfast sandwiches with sausage, egg, and cheese, plus avocado and hash browns. Open kitchen and orderly counter service create a warm, lively vibe. Seating is cozy indoors and outdoors, perfect for families.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with sausage, egg and cheese combinations. Some include avocado and hash brown potatoes for extra flavor.

People are saying

"I found the pancakes to be amazing and tasty."

"The griddle cakes are unique, hearty, and have a great texture."

"The breakfast sandwich with egg and sausage is really good."

Good to know

1

Expect a 40 min. wait for a party of two.

2

You need to order at the counter and get a number to receive your food.

3

They don’t take numbers for the waitlist, so stay nearby to hear your name.

10
Bobbi’s Italian beef image 1

Retro Chicago decor and vintage wood paneling create a warm, casual vibe filled with 80s memorabilia and classic arcade games. Sandwiches feature tender roast beef with flavorful slices and sturdy bread, especially the spicy Italian beef. Family-friendly atmosphere with great music adds to the lively, inviting feel.

Steaming hot, tender roast beef fills the sandwich with super flavorful slices and a perfect amount of cheese. The bread holds up well, making the spicy Italian beef sandwich a standout choice.

People are saying

"I found the Italian Beef sandwich to be the best I ever had."

"I loved the classic Chicago hot dogs and Polish sausage."

"I thought the Chicken Parmigiana was outstanding."

Good to know

1

Weiner Wednesday offers $2 off hot dogs, making it a popular choice.

2

The sandwich shop is closed on Mondays, so plan accordingly.

3

Prices for sandwiches range from $15 to $23, depending on the selection.

11
The Scion Project image 1

Bright main room with natural sunlight and a spacious backyard filled with birds offers a laid-back vibe. Walls display bold artwork that sparks creativity. Sandwiches feature delicious flavors and pair well with pastries, all at reasonable prices around eleven dollars.

Sandwiches come with consistently delicious flavors and pair well with pastries. Prices hover around eleven dollars including tips for takeout.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the excellent, well-made coffee."

"The art here is bold and thought-provoking, really pushing boundaries."

"I enjoyed the sandwiches; they were delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $14-18 for sandwiches, typical for the area.

2

The backyard is a lovely spot to enjoy coffee during spring and summer.

3

WiFi is reliable, making it a good place to work or study.

12
Garden Gourmet Deli & Grill image 1

Deli shines with fresh hero sandwiches and a homey atmosphere. It offers a large grocery selection and many snacks in a clean space. Meals need no cooking, making it perfect for quick, quality bites.

Sandwiches feature very fresh ingredients and come with true passion and quality from the owner. Options like the falafel and pastrami sandwiches stand out for their taste and care in preparation.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were the best."

"I considered this the best deli in Brooklyn."

"I thought the food here was the absolute best for sandwiches."

Good to know

1

The deli has tons of grocery items and a bigger selection than your average deli.

2

The store is super clean.

3

There are many options for meals and snacks.

13
The Grape Leaf image 1
Halal restaurant

Authentic Middle Eastern architecture creates a comfy, quiet space with open windows and soft Arabic music. Large vegan options shine alongside amazing falafel and well-seasoned shawarma sandwiches on fresh pita. Spicy pickles and tahini add bold flavors.

Falafel sandwiches come with delicious tahini and spicy pickles. Shawarma sandwiches, including chicken and lamb, are well seasoned and served on fresh pita.

People are saying

"I loved the Mediterranean falafel sandwich; it made my heart happy."

"I found the shawarma to be amazing and perfectly seasoned."

"The falafel sandwich here is amazingly good."

Good to know

1

The establishment closes at 10 PM, not 10:30 PM as advertised.

2

The chicken shawarma pita costs $20.

3

Parking is hard to find, but there is paid street parking available.

14
​PLANTED CAFE image 1
Vegan restaurant

Space blends lush plants and wooden decor for calm and focus. Outdoor wellness features include infrared sauna and hot tub. Vegan egg sandwich is a delicious standout. Seating offers outlets for co-working indoors and outdoors.

The vegan egg sandwich stands out as a delicious option. The regular egg sandwich is available but less distinctive.

People are saying

"This cafe is a cute, relaxing spot surrounded by plants."

"The vegetarian food here is delicious and fresh."

"The sandwich here is surrounded by plants and a chill vibe."

Good to know

1

The kitchen closes at 6 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

2

Planted Cafe hosts networking parties and other events regularly.

3

The cafe is currently having a plant sale with 20% off purchases.

15
Nili image 1
Cafe

Bright high ceilings and lovely plants create a cozy vibe with live music energizing the space. Outdoor seating adds a community feel perfect for socializing or casual work. Breakfast pita sandwiches shine with well-portioned fillings like mushroom, egg, and cheese.

Breakfast pita sandwiches stand out with well-portioned fillings like mushroom, egg, and cheese. The schnitzel sandwich offers a distinct, flavorful option, while the sabich sandwich comes across as average.

People are saying

"The Mediterranean food here, especially the falafel and shawarma, is ridiculously good."

"The pita bread here is so soft and fresh."

"The pita breakfast sandwiches are amazing with just the right portions."

Good to know

1

During the summertime from 5-7pm, a live band plays music and sings.

2

The restaurant is a self-serve place where you need to clean up your table after finishing your meal.

3

The outdoor seating is preferable when the weather is good.

16
Court Street Grocers image 1

Sandwich shop offers over 30 options with fresh ingredients and generous sizes. Busy spot has a New York vibe with indoor and tidy outdoor seating. Known for distinctive flavors and balanced sauces like in the Italian combo and Ultimate Warrior.

Sandwiches feature fresh ingredients with a generous size and a great meat to bread ratio. Varieties like the Italian combo and Ultimate Warrior stand out for their tasty sauces and balanced flavors.

People are saying

"The sandwiches here are so good, I wanted to go back for more."

"The bread here is so fresh, it makes the sandwiches immaculate."

"The staff at the outdoor seating was so friendly."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of about 25 minutes for food orders.

2

It is recommended to call in for pick-up to avoid long waits.

3

Order ahead to minimize wait times, especially during busy hours.

17
Mister Cheeks image 1

Bright, clean space with vegetarian sandwiches like Squash and Radicchio offers fresh, flavorful options. Walk-up window and outdoor seating create a warm neighborhood vibe. Soft serve and coffee make it a friendly community spot near the park.

Vegetarian options like the Squash and Radicchio sandwich stand out for their flavor. Sandwiches serve as a grab-and-go lunch with good bread, though some fillings like the egg salad can be bland.

People are saying

"The coffee here is just great and reliably delicious."

"I enjoyed the soft serve, especially the seasonal flavor swirl."

"I found the coffee and egg sandwich to be really delicious."

Good to know

1

The small size of the soft serve is $5.

2

The regular size of the soft serve is $7.

3

The takeout window offers convenient coffee pickup.

18
Cubana Café image 1
Cuban restaurant

Bright pastel Cuban decor sets a cozy, authentic Afro-Latino vibe. The Cuban sandwich offers rich, delicious flavor that stands out. Refreshing mojitos and sangria enhance the casual, cheery atmosphere perfectly.

Cuban sandwich stands out with its rich, delicious flavor that keeps coming to mind. It pairs well with other items like Camarones de coco and buena vista pounded chicken with Mango.

People are saying

"The food here is excellent, with generous portions and good prices."

"The shrimp ceviche and coconut shrimp were delicious."

"You have to try the Cuban sandwich; it's delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant only accepts cash or Cashapp/Venmo.

2

Happy hour offers discounted drinks and appetizers.

3

Celebrating your birthday with a few people is recommended.

19
Cafe Luluc image 1
Brunch restaurant

Cozy spot with a lively vibe and friendly staff. Sandwiches shine with big portions and a standout cheese steak. Outdoor patio offers a pleasant garden view, perfect for a relaxed meal.

Big portions come with the fish sandwiches and the open-faced grilled chicken sandwich features a great sauce and is stuffed full. The cheese steak sandwich stands out, and most sandwiches come with outstanding French fries.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, especially the pancakes."

"I had the best pancakes I’ve ever had, perfectly crispy and soft."

"I found the grilled chicken sandwich to be heavenly."

Good to know

1

This restaurant only accepts cash payments; no credit cards or mobile payments.

2

Breakfast costs approximately $30 and dinner costs $50 per person.

3

The restaurant offers brunch on Saturday mornings and at 5 PM.

20
Baby Luc's image 1
Pizza restaurant

Spacious outdoor seating with a garden patio creates a relaxed vibe. Sandwiches like the chicken cutlet Caesar offer rich flavors on crispy sesame bread. Live piano music adds charm to the clean, open interior blending casual dining with barbershop style.

Chicken cutlet Caesar and chicken parm sandwiches stand out with crispy sesame bread and rich flavors. Sandwiches lean toward the pricier side, like a $20 three meatball option, but maintain high quality ingredients.

People are saying

"This pizza is delicious and decadent."

"It's great to grab a beer and enjoy the outdoor patio furniture."

"The chicken parm sandwich was killer and delicious."

Good to know

1

A slice of pizza costs $5.

2

Expect at least a one hour wait for takeout orders after opening.

3

There is no bathroom on-site for customers.

21
Frankies 457 Spuntino image 1
Italian restaurant

Rustic Italian spot shines with a secluded backyard courtyard that feels like Tuscany. Sandwiches like the meatball parm are rich and memorable, served on unique pizza dough bread. Cozy indoor space needs reservations due to limited seating and poor acoustics.

Meatball parm sandwich stands out with its rich flavor and is often highlighted as a favorite. The roast beef sandwich features tender meat but cannot be cooked well-done. Sandwich bread uses pizza dough from a nearby slice joint, giving it a unique texture.

People are saying

"The handmade pasta here is incredible and intentionally crafted."

"The staff made our wedding dinner feel effortless and ran like clockwork."

"The roast beef sandwich was next level."

Good to know

1

Reservations are necessary due to limited seating.

2

Expect occasional waits for the single bathroom.

3

Outdoor seating is available during the warmer months.

22
Food U Desire image 1

Corner deli buzzes with a lively atmosphere and offers a salad bar alongside a large menu. Sandwiches like spicy tuna pack bold flavors, though some find meat portions light. Prices stay reasonable, drawing a steady crowd for fresh, tasty wraps.

Spicy tuna and Charlie Brown sandwiches stand out with bold flavors and fresh ingredients. Sandwiches and wraps come with options like avocado add-ons, though some find the meat portions light for the price.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and delicious."

"I ate the best sandwiches I have ever had."

"I thought this deli was the best in the neighborhood."

Good to know

1

The deli has a larger than typical menu with fresh food options.

2

Expect a good variety of pre-made items like egg salad and macaroni salad.

3

The establishment is clean and well-maintained.

23
GG'S Fish & Chips image 1
Seafood restaurant

Small space with modern decor and a soda fountain counter offers a nostalgic vibe. Fried chicken and catfish sandwiches stand out, though bread can be dry. Loud old school hip-hop and spacious outdoor seating with heaters create a lively, family-friendly atmosphere.

Fried chicken and catfish sandwiches feature prominently with fried catfish po' boy noted, though the bread can be dry and crumby. Sandwiches sometimes include lettuce stem, which affects texture.

People are saying

"The American food, especially the mac and cheese and collard greens, is amazing."

"I found the fried fish and chips to be perfectly cooked and full of flavor."

"You have to try their fried fish sandwich; it's crispy and flavorful."

Good to know

1

GG's delivers catfish every Thursday.

2

Get there a little early to avoid selling out.

3

Parking on their block is tough; be prepared to drive around.

24
Le French Tart image 1

Cozy bakery offers authentic French pastries with a buttery aroma and soft French music. Sandwiches feature fresh baguettes that stay crisp, especially the ham and cheese with Dijon mustard. Space feels tight but home-like, perfect for genuine flavors.

Sandwiches come with fresh baguettes that stay crisp even after 15 minutes. The ham and cheese mini baguette stands out for its size and flavor, with Dijon mustard adding a sharp kick.

People are saying

"I thought the croissants here were the best I'd ever had."

"This sandwich was the best I've had in ages, with fresh ingredients."

"The bakery's caneles are divine, crunchy outside and mochi-like inside."

Good to know

1

Le French Tart Deli is closed on Monday and Tuesday.

2

The price of a croissant is $2.75, tax included.

3

There is sometimes a line out the door at the shop.

Discover more

Carroll Gardens, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...