Restaurant offers cozy, classy decor with an upbeat, inviting vibe and options for indoor or outdoor seating. The atmosphere balances relaxing music and energetic energy, creating a warm, engaging environment. Sophisticated touches and trendy design make it feel like an extension of a living room.
Food features high quality steak, chicken, and pork with generous portions. Pizzas, pigs in a blanket, salad, and pasta come out consistently well made and delicious.
Steak and eggs come out perfectly cooked. The lobster roll stands out, especially since it comes from a pizza spot. Pizza also shows up as exceptional alongside the seafood.
"The owner's passion for the pizza made me feel so special."
"The owner's passion for food made our dining experience wonderful."
"I thought the lobster roll was the best American food I ever had."
Good to know
Reservations are recommended for the popular Supper Club to secure a seat.
Expect longer wait times during weekend brunch hours due to high demand.
The restaurant accepts credit cards and mobile payments, but no personal checks.
Small, quaint restaurant with antique nautical decor creates a cozy, intimate atmosphere ideal for relaxed meals. Outdoor garden space offers a quiet retreat away from street noise. The setting feels romantic and charming, suitable for family, friends, or dates.
Food arrives after a short wait because everything is produced in-house. Dishes are consistently delicious and the outdoor dining space adds to the experience.
Meatloaf stands out as a solid choice, cooked to perfection alongside salmon and chicken. The New England Clam Chowder tastes light and fresh, while crab cakes rank as notably good.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended as the restaurant can get busy.
Tips are accepted in cash only; no credit card tips allowed.
The restaurant has a high credit card fee, so pay with cash to avoid it.
Waterfront dining offers an elegant and relaxing atmosphere with live music and dancers creating a lively vibe. The stunning decor and beautiful city and water views provide a backdrop that feels like an island escape. Guests arrive by yacht to enjoy a mix of entertainment and upscale ambiance.
Food features impeccable quality and outstanding service paired with 10/10 drinks. The dining experience blends great taste with a lively waterfront atmosphere.
Orzo mac and cheese comes with a soft texture but can be undercooked and needs more salt. Branzino and lobster mac and cheese offers a richer flavor option.
Good to know
Reservations are highly recommended due to high demand, especially on weekends.
A 20% service fee is automatically added to bills for parties of four or more.
The restaurant hosts a show at 7pm, which is a highlight of the evening.
Small pub with cozy atmosphere and friendly vibe feels like an Irish tavern. Quiet street location attracts a mix of locals, including many older patrons. Music can be loud, but overall the place stays warm and welcoming.
Food features fresh ingredients and generous portions with a generally tasty profile. Some dishes lean mild rather than spicy.
Cheeseburgers and fries come with a classic American vibe. Chili adds a rich, hearty touch, especially in the nachos. The secret menu offers specialty grilled cheese sandwiches and hot dogs, with two hot dogs served for mixing styles. Shepherd's pie features mashed potatoes over hamburger meat with peas and carrots, served without a crust.
Good to know
The price of the Shepherd’s pie is $20.
The restaurant is popular for lunch.
Latin American restaurant offers stunning decor and a vibrant energy with amazing live shows and music. Outdoor seating provides a beautiful ocean view, enhancing the lively atmosphere. Entertainment includes diverse performances and photo opportunities, creating a memorable experience.
Food here offers excellent quality with a focus on great taste and presentation. Service complements the dining with attentive staff ensuring a smooth experience.
Ribeye steak stands out for its rich flavor. Lobster Mac & cheese and surf and turf offer hearty options. T-bone steak and steak and eggs provide classic American choices.
Good to know
Reservations are required for events, especially during busy holiday seasons.
Brunch is the only meal served on Sundays, so plan accordingly.
A bottle purchase is mandatory for certain performances, like those by Sergio Vargas.
Cozy diner with a friendly, homey atmosphere and a community-focused vibe that feels like a vacation spot. Outdoor seating offers a water view patio, enhancing the relaxed energy. Known for comfort food classics and a welcoming environment run by a family.
Food here is exquisite and creative, standing out from typical diner fare. Comfort dishes come out just as ordered, with reasonable prices and a small town feel.
A cheeseburger deluxe stands out with solid flavor. Nachos get a boost from chili, making them hearty. Grilled cheese sandwiches feel rushed, with diced deli ham and undercooked onions.
Good to know
They charge extra for using a card.
The menu features home-style dishes including soup, burgers, and sandwiches.
The diner is the only one on City Island, so options are limited.
Modern, elevated BBQ setting creates a warm and welcoming atmosphere with a fun, lively vibe. The space feels cozy and clean, inviting guests to relax and enjoy meals at their own pace. Large, flavorful dishes like the dinosaur rib stand out in this casual smokehouse environment.
Food features perfect seasoning and smoking to perfection. Portions come abundant and flavors are consistently mouthwatering.
Brisket stands out with its tender, smoky flavor and perfect fat balance. Pulled pork blends slow-cooked pernil with BBQ sauce, creating a juicy, well-seasoned sandwich. BBQ chicken wings and sides like mac and cheese and collard greens complement the hearty American fare.
Good to know
The portions at Sammy's Smoke House are very large and generous.
Prices at Sammy's Smoke House are reasonable for the portion sizes.
Sammy's Smoke House is a family-friendly place, suitable for celebrations.
Restaurant combines cozy private booths with charming outdoor seating and offers free valet parking. Atmosphere ranges from lively and noisy on weekends to more intimate and relaxed during quieter times. Decor shows signs of age, giving a quaint but worn feel to the space.
Food comes fresh and cooked right with consistent quality and generous portions. Service matches the food with reliable attentiveness and prices stay reasonable.
Seafood shines with lobster tail, crabs, and crab cakes standing out. New England Clam Chowder pairs well with baked potatoes or a side salad with chunky blue cheese dressing.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended, especially for holidays and special events.
Valet parking is available, and tipping is expected.
Generous portion sizes mean you might take leftovers home.
Outdoor seating by the water offers scenic marina views and a pleasant atmosphere. Valet parking and warm towels add to the comfortable dining experience. The setting feels like a 1950s movie set with clean, well-maintained interiors.
Food here stands out for its great taste and consistent quality. The menu pairs well with excellent service and pleasant views.
Big, fresh Maryland crab cakes stand out alongside a lobster roll that balances rich butter flavor without sogginess. The lobster mac and cheese features huge lobster pieces and generous portions, while the Prime Rib steak and Lobster Tail offer hearty options.
Good to know
The restaurant is suitable for private events and celebrations.
Reservations are recommended for large parties to ensure seating.
Parking on-site is best as street parking is limited.
Small restaurant with vibrant colors and friendly staff creates a welcoming atmosphere. Clean, fresh decor combines with good music and family-friendly amenities to foster a comfortable, lively vibe. Booths and tables offer spacious seating that supports a relaxed dining experience.
Delicious food stands out with consistently excellent flavors. Fresh seafood dishes and tasty drinks make the menu appealing.
A basket of moist, buttery cornbread replaces traditional bread and stands out. Fried shrimp, salmon, and vegetables all come out delicious, paired with excellent drinks.
Good to know
The restaurant does not have a liquor license.
The restaurant is wheelchair, walker, and possibly small scooter accessible.
There is on-site parking available.
Seafood restaurant offers spacious interior with comfortable booths and outdoor patio seating featuring a water view. Atmosphere feels casual and welcoming, with a family-like vibe and occasional live DJ music. Guests enjoy colorful, clean surroundings and can have photos taken on site.
Food features rich flavors and great taste with consistently delicious dishes and well-paired drinks.
Thick New England clam chowder and Maine Lobster Newburg stand out alongside tender brisket that cuts with a spoon. Warm, tasty cornbread and sesame bread come with sides like pickled veggies and salad.
Good to know
Items that used to come with meals are now charged separately as side orders.
Pasta is no longer served, and the pilaf rice on the platter is smaller.
The menu no longer includes pickled appetizers or the big bread with cheese.
Waterfront setting offers beautiful ocean views and outdoor rooftop seating that create a serene backdrop for dining. Live music adds to the pleasant atmosphere, while valet parking and thoughtful amenities like warm hand towels enhance the experience.
Food here stays consistently delicious and the quality remains excellent even during busy times. The menu offers a satisfying variety that pairs well with the great service.
Cornbread comes out moist and flavorful. Clam chowders include a New England style loaded with clams and a Manhattan style with garlicky tomato base. Crab cakes stand out as a notable dish.
Good to know
They offer a Twin Lobster special every Wednesday in June for $35.
Expect longer wait times during special events like birthday celebrations.
Parking is easy at the restaurant, making it convenient for visitors.