Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of City Island

Dinner spots

A dinner that feels like a destination worth the trip rather than just a convenient place to eat.

Based on 567 Opinions
+564
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Sammy's Smoke House image 1
Sammy's Smoke House image 2
Sammy's Smoke House image 3
View all

Modern BBQ spot shines with dinosaur rib and a warm atmosphere. Cozy, clean space fits special occasions like birthdays. Lively vibe makes dinner feel fun and relaxed.

Dinner here offers a memorable experience with dishes that suit special occasions. The setting supports a perfect birthday dinner atmosphere.

People are saying

"The American Food here, especially the BBQ, is tender and delicious."

"I found the seafood here to be amazing and fresh."

"The dinner spots here are tender, juicy, and full of flavor."

Good to know

1

The portions at Sammy's Smoke House are very large and generous.

2

Prices at Sammy's Smoke House are reasonable for the portion sizes.

3

Sammy's Smoke House is a family-friendly place, suitable for celebrations.

02
The Black Whale image 1
American restaurant

Small, quaint restaurant with antique nautical decor offers a cozy, intimate atmosphere perfect for outdoor dining. Garden space provides a quiet retreat ideal for relaxed dinners with family, friends, or dates. Charming and romantic setting enhances every meal.

Outdoor dining offers a comfortable and attractive environment with beautiful decorations. It suits dinners with family, friends, or dates, especially on warm evenings.

People are saying

"The outdoor seating has a wonderful, quiet atmosphere."

"I found the atmosphere here to be so unique and special."

"The food at these dinner spots is delicious and tasty."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant can get busy.

2

Tips are accepted in cash only; no credit card tips allowed.

3

The restaurant has a high credit card fee, so pay with cash to avoid it.

03
Vistamar Restaurant & Lounge image 1
Latin American restaurant

Latin American restaurant shines with stunning decor and live shows that energize the space. Outdoor seating offers a beautiful ocean view perfect for celebrations. Attentive servers like Angel and Edgar ensure excellent service during dinner.

Excellent service stands out with servers like Angel, Edgar, Jocelyn, and Emanuel providing attentive care. The atmosphere suits celebratory dinners with family, enhanced by a live show that adds a special touch.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and well presented."

"The service during dinner was attentive and made the experience great."

"The atmosphere was lively with a live DJ and performances."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for events, especially during busy holiday seasons.

2

Brunch is the only meal served on Sundays, so plan accordingly.

3

A bottle purchase is mandatory for certain performances, like those by Sergio Vargas.

04
City Island Pizza Company image 1

Cozy, classy decor sets a warm vibe for dinner with family. Spontaneous reservations are easy, and seating is prompt. Indoor and outdoor options add to the inviting atmosphere with a perfect mix of relaxing music and energy.

Spontaneous dinner reservations work well here, even on a Sunday evening. Waiters seat groups promptly, making it easy to dine with family.

People are saying

"The owner's passion for the pizza made me feel so special."

"The Italian food here, especially the zeppoles and tiramisu, is a must-try."

"The dinner spots here make you feel like royalty."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for the popular Supper Club to secure a seat.

2

Expect longer wait times during weekend brunch hours due to high demand.

3

The restaurant accepts credit cards and mobile payments, but no personal checks.

05
Little Greece image 1
Greek restaurant

Small Greek spot serves authentic cuisine with bold flavors in a nautical-themed space. It fits groups well, offering flexible meal options for lunch, dinner, or snacks. Clean, fresh vibe makes it a calm place to enjoy dinner.

Dinner here suits groups well, with space for six or more people. Options cover lunch, dinner, and quick snacks, making it flexible for different meal times.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and fresh."

"I loved the huge lamb/beef gyro with potatoes."

"I recommend Little Greece as a favorite dinner spot on the island."

Good to know

1

The total cost for the luncheon special is $13.80.

2

The prices are extremely reasonable.

3

Expect generous portions with every meal.

06
ATIK Restaurant image 1
Restaurant

Waterfront dining offers an elegant atmosphere with attentive service enhancing cozy dinners. Live music and dancers create a lively vibe while stunning city and water views provide a beautiful backdrop for a perfect night out.

Service includes attentive servers who enhance the dinner experience. The setting offers a cozy lounge area with a fireplace for after-dinner relaxation. Atmosphere blends elegance and warmth, fitting for date nights or casual dinners.

People are saying

"The food at these dinner spots is delicious and beautifully presented."

"It's a beautiful view that makes the place perfect."

"The staff here are so attentive and make you feel truly welcome."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended due to high demand, especially on weekends.

2

A 20% service fee is automatically added to bills for parties of four or more.

3

The restaurant hosts a show at 7pm, which is a highlight of the evening.

07
The Original Crab Shanty image 1

Cozy private booths and charming outdoor seating create a warm atmosphere perfect for dinners. Full meals are well-priced with the millionaire drank as a standout. Free valet parking adds convenience for group occasions or quiet nights.

Full dinners come well-priced and excellent, with the millionaire drank standing out as a highlight. The setting suits a peaceful dinner and works well for group occasions like birthday meals.

People are saying

"I found the seafood here to be fresh and delicious."

"The bread here is warm and wonderful."

"I had an awesome dinner, the filet mignon was cooked to perfection."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for holidays and special events.

2

Valet parking is available, and tipping is expected.

3

Generous portion sizes mean you might take leftovers home.

08
City Island Lobster House image 1
Seafood restaurant

Outdoor seating by the water offers scenic marina views and a relaxed vibe for dinner. The BBQ feast features back ribs and lobster, perfect for groups. Valet parking and warm towels enhance comfort in a setting like a 1950s movie set.

Outdoor seating creates a relaxed vibe away from the city during dinner. The BBQ feast serves up back ribs, chicken, fried shrimp, and a large lobster packed with meat, suitable for groups.

People are saying

"The food portions were huge and delicious."

"The seafood here is wonderful, fresh, and served in great portions."

"The dinner portions are huge; I always take leftovers home."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is suitable for private events and celebrations.

2

Reservations are recommended for large parties to ensure seating.

3

Parking on-site is best as street parking is limited.

09
Archie's Tap & Table image 1

Small space buzzes with friendly energy and loud family groups. Cozy indoor and outdoor seating set to 70s and 80s R&B music create a warm, romantic yet lively vibe. Dinner shines with a distinct evening menu and popular weekend options.

Dinner service starts after a break following brunch, offering a distinct evening menu. The spot draws attention for its weekend dinner options and has been visited multiple times for both brunch and dinner.

People are saying

"The brunch food here is fantastic and made with attention to detail."

"The cod fish sandwich was mouth watering."

"The food at this dinner spot is fantastic and made with attention to detail."

Good to know

1

They offer specials during brunch.

2

Archie's prices are high, with cocktails pushing $20.

3

Frequent private parties affect the restaurant's availability.

10
Sammy's Fish Box image 1
Seafood restaurant

Outdoor seating under tents creates a lively atmosphere with live music enhancing the mood. Dinner here is memorable and perfect for special occasions like birthdays. Spacious layout supports laughter and celebrations without being noisy.

Dinner offers a memorable experience with dishes that stand out. The setting suits special occasions like birthdays.

People are saying

"I found the food here was always great."

"Parking is available and it's easy to find."

"The dinner portions here are plentiful and satisfying."

Good to know

1

Parking near the restaurant is difficult; street spots are the best option.

2

Be prepared to spend $50+ per person for a meal.

3

Expect to wait for a table on Friday, Saturday, or Sunday nights.

11
Sea Shore Restaurant image 1
Seafood restaurant

Waterfront setting offers ocean views and rooftop seating for a serene dinner. King Crab and lobster shine as seafood highlights. Live music and valet parking add to the pleasant atmosphere for groups and colleagues.

Seafood dinners focus on King Crab and lobster, served in a setting with a great atmosphere. Group dinners with friends or colleagues work well here.

People are saying

"I found the food to be amazingly fresh and excellent."

"I enjoyed the nice view of the water and skyline."

"The food at these dinner spots was delicious and well plated."

Good to know

1

They offer a Twin Lobster special every Wednesday in June for $35.

2

Expect longer wait times during special events like birthday celebrations.

3

Parking is easy at the restaurant, making it convenient for visitors.

Discover more

City Island, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...