Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Gramercy Park's best

Italian dinner spots

You are looking for a sit-down Italian meal that respects the ritual of a full dinner.

Based on 715 Opinions
+712
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
La Citta Pizzeria image 1
La Citta Pizzeria image 2
La Citta Pizzeria image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Spacious pizza joint with bright lighting and ample seating creates a lively, energetic atmosphere. The vibe blends a traditional NYC slice shop feel with a clean, modernized interior. Large, delectable pizza slices draw a crowd looking for quality and variety late into the night.

Crunchy, flavorful slices use good quality mozzarella and sauce. Baked pasta with meatballs and chicken parmesan with pasta stand out as unreal dishes. Pizza with pasta offers a rare, interesting twist on classic Italian food.

Dinners feature grilled chicken and fresh salads that stand out for their quality. Meals taste delicious and surpass typical slice shop offerings.

People are saying

"This is a great spot for a late-night slice of pizza."

"I loved the pizza and pasta here; it's the best Italian food."

"I've had this pizza sober and it's always great."

Good to know

1

The kitchen and full menu are available until 2am for late-night cravings.

2

Pizza slices are priced at $3, offering good value.

3

The restaurant has a wide variety of options including pizzas, salads, and desserts.

02
Isabelle's Osteria image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers beautiful, open interior with authentic French bistro tiles and soft lighting creating a pleasant atmosphere. Tables are often close, making it noisy during busy times, but outdoor seating provides a quieter option. A cozy private dining room is available at the back for more intimate gatherings.

Mushroom lasagna and shrimp fra diavolo stand out alongside exceptional focaccia. Pasta dishes, including gluten-free options, are consistently delicious with a cozy, authentic Italian vibe.

Dinner here offers consistently amazing meals with delicious dishes and great drinks. It suits both intimate occasions and group dinners, providing a reliable spot for a satisfying evening.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious."

"The service for dinner spots was fantastic and attentive."

"The Italian food here is always great."

Good to know

1

On weekends, some cocktails are bottomless for a fixed price.

2

The bar has a happy hour with great drinks and food.

3

Making reservations is recommended due to the crowd.

03
L'Angeletto image 1
Northern Italian restaurant

Small, cozy Northern Italian restaurant with well-lit, quiet atmosphere and ample space for conversation. Offers handmade fresh pasta and house-made limoncello in a setting that feels like a hidden gem rather than a crowded spot.

Fresh handmade pasta stands out with dishes like Cacio e Pepe and Roman pastas. The Ossobuco features tender veal shank in a hearty tomato sauce, while lamb ragu and sausage with lemon offer rich flavors.

Dinner here is quiet and well made, making it a reliable choice for an evening meal.

People are saying

"The lobster ravioli here is pure perfection."

"The Italian food and service here are fantastic."

"The dinner spots here have authentic Italian food, especially the lobster ravioli."

Good to know

1

Reservations can be made using Resy.

2

The restaurant offers good value, fairly priced for a Manhattan location.

3

Portions are on the large size, about 1.25 servings per order.

04
L’Express image 1
French restaurant

French bistro with cozy, authentic Euro feel and classic decor creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Outdoor seating offers a pleasant alternative to the often cramped indoor space. Drinks like espresso martinis stand out amid a setting free of gimmicks and consistent in quality.

Gnocchi stands out for its soft perfection and incredible flavor. The menu features pasta and steak, fresh salads, and seafood dishes like monkfish and mussels, alongside desserts such as panna cotta and creme brûlée.

Attentive service from staff like Carmen and Ayman enhances the dinner experience. The spot suits group dinners and late-night meals, with a lively bar scene featuring Carlos G. on Saturdays.

People are saying

"Our server was so attentive and took great care of us during dinner."

"The food at this Late Night Spot is always fresh and delicious."

"The Italian food, especially the gnocchi, was amazing and perfectly cooked."

Good to know

1

On weekends, the last seating is at 1:00 AM.

2

They do all day breakfast.

3

You will definitely need a reservation for brunch.

05
Carlotto image 1
Restaurant

Italian restaurant offers a classy interior with warm candlelight creating an elegant atmosphere. Drinks include sweet, coffee-flavored cocktails alongside a well-curated wine selection. The space includes a downstairs area for group events, blending intimacy with functionality.

Pasta dishes feature perfect portions and textures, like the spicy njuda and seafood pasta with a beautifully al dente dough. Large veal parmesan and flavorful risotto ai fungi porcini add variety, while desserts like affogato al caffe round out the meal.

Dinner here turns into an experience with warmth, wit, and knowledge from Sol and Zahira. It suits group dinners, like with coworkers in the East Village.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the pasta, is delicious."

"The desserts here are amazing, especially the sweet corn pasta."

"The pasta dishes at these dinner spots were phenomenal."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is from 5-6 pm.

2

The restaurant offers a restaurant week special menu with a 3-course meal.

3

Reservations are not necessary on weekdays as the restaurant isn't usually full.

06
Diner 24 NYC image 1

Classic diner design blends with cozy, comforting atmosphere and calm, happy energy. Music ranges from Frank Sinatra classics to a jukebox with personal selections, enhancing the nostalgic vibe. Seating includes comfy chairs with outlets, supporting relaxed meetings or work sessions.

Penne burrata pasta stands out with its rich, creamy texture. Staff like Alfredo provide attentive service and accommodate allergies with care.

Dinner offers a very good experience with special service that enhances the meal. Suitable for a family evening with quality food and attentive care.

People are saying

"The diner staff here is so friendly and attentive."

"The Italian food here is amazing, truly the best I've ever tasted."

"The food at these dinner spots was amazing."

Good to know

1

Brunch is available any day.

2

Happy hour offers $4 beers and $7 cocktails at the bar.

3

Breakfast is served all day.

07
Oceans image 1
Restaurant

Grand dining room combines majestic scale with an intimate feel through roomy wood booths and white tablecloth elegance. Atmosphere balances elevated style with occasional loudness, creating a lively yet refined energy. Cocktails and wine selections stand out for their quality and uniqueness.

Freshness stands out with the focaccia bread being notably fresh and surprising in quality. The rigatoni neri uses fresh pasta paired with a sauce that complements the seafood well.

Quiet, intimate setting suits celebratory dinners and annual traditions. Offers a three-course pre fixe menu during restaurant week for $60 on select days.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh, especially the black cod."

"The seafood at these dinner spots is so fresh and delicious."

"I'm still dreaming about this phenomenal Italian food."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for special events like the Japanese Hokkaido Scallop Festival.

2

Expect high prices, with over $250 per person for special menus on holidays.

3

Many guests reported food safety issues, including food poisoning.

08
Union Square Cafe image 1
New American restaurant

Spacious multi-level layout offers airy atmosphere with tasteful decor and comfortably spaced tables. Noise levels rise during busy hours, requiring louder conversation, while upstairs seating provides limited privacy. The setting balances laid-back vibes with a quietly sublime dining experience.

Spaghetti comes perfectly al dente with a sauce that has a thick soup texture and just the right heat. Pork chop and duck pasta dishes offer beyond tasty flavors.

Dinner offers memorable experiences with exceptional meals that stand out among many. The setting suits those seeking a noteworthy night out.

People are saying

"The food here is thoughtfully prepared and full of flavor."

"The food at these dinner spots was amazing and came in sizable portions."

"I thought the lasagna was amazing and immaculately put together."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to high demand, especially on weekends.

2

The restaurant offers a special menu during New York Restaurant Week.

3

Burgers are only available before 5 p.m. and not on the dinner menu.

09
Novitá image 1
Restaurant

Small, intimate restaurant with close seating and a masculine yellow sleek design in the basement area. Atmosphere ranges from romantic and cozy to hectic and overstimulating depending on seating location. Offers outdoor seating in a peaceful setting away from busy roads.

True Italian cuisine shines with Northern Italian dishes like veal parm and pappardelle with meat sauce. Unique pastas such as cacio e pepe and seafood pasta with black squid ink stand out for their freshness and flavor.

Dinner here suits both special occasions and casual nights out. The spot stays busy and impresses guests from out of town, making it a solid pick for date nights or group dinners.

People are saying

"The authentic Italian food here has amazing pasta and seafood."

"It's a cozy and intimate setting that feels like stepping back into Italy."

"The food at this dinner spot was delicious."

Good to know

1

Make sure to make a reservation a day or two in advance.

2

You have the option of sitting inside or outside, so specify when making your reservation.

3

The place is small, so reservations are a must.

10
Boucherie Union Square image 1
French restaurant

French restaurant offers an elegant Parisian-inspired decor with a beautiful high ceiling entrance and a long bar that draws people for cocktails. The atmosphere is lively and crowded, with pounding music that fills the space and creates a high noise level. Tables sit close together, adding to the energetic and bustling vibe.

Mushroom ravioli and a dish with mushrooms, asparagus, and butter pasta stand out for their flavors. The Papardelli Bolognese and bolognese sauce offer rich, classic tastes.

Dinner here offers excellent table seating and a consistently stellar experience. The food and service stand out as incredible, fitting for celebrations or quick meals.

People are saying

"The food here is awesome and top-notch."

"The service at dinner spots here is so attentive and friendly."

"The Italian food here is amazing, and the service is super helpful."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with half-price cocktails.

2

On Sundays, enjoy $10 glasses of wine during happy hour.

3

Monday happy hour features a selection of discounted drinks.

11
Eleni’s image 1
Greek restaurant

Interior design features white decor, stunning murals, and lemon trees that evoke a Greek island atmosphere. Outdoor seating includes a heated patio and sidewalk café area, offering a calm and soothing environment. Greek music plays softly, enhancing the authentic Mediterranean vibe.

Seafood shines with seared diver scallops, grilled octopus, and a lobster tail pasta called Sal Anthony's. Pasta dishes like fettuccine shrimp have a creamy yet fresh tomato sauce, and salmon linguine stays flavorful even after reheating.

Dinner here offers a quality experience with dishes that make the meal feel special and memorable.

People are saying

"This lunch spot's authentic Greek flavors were delicious."

"The Dinner Spots here have fantastic meatballs and amazing pita."

"The fettuccine with shrimp and creamy tomato sauce is amazing."

Good to know

1

The last seating is at 10 PM.

2

The lunch menu is priced at $31 each and includes dessert.

3

Eleni's can accommodate special requests for celebrations.

12
Pete's Tavern image 1
Restaurant

Oldest bar in New York with 19th-century woodwork and vintage decor creates a historic pub atmosphere. The space feels inviting and lively, often bustling with a fun crowd and occasional live bagpipers. Outdoor seating and a connected bar add variety to the experience.

Spaghetti bolognese stands out with its rich flavor, redeeming typical versions. Penne a la vodka shines as a best pasta dish, while gnocchi with spinach pesto offers a fresh, outstanding twist.

Making a reservation is essential for dinner here. The spot suits dates, anniversaries, and family dinners and sometimes features lively moments like bagpipers in full Scottish attire.

People are saying

"You have to see this bar's amazing Christmas decorations and holiday vibe."

"The Italian food here is amazing, especially with the holiday decorations."

"The Christmas decorations here are beautiful and festive for dinner."

Good to know

1

Make a reservation if you can, as it seemed busy during the visit.

2

Happy Hour is back at the bar.

3

Steak nights at Pete's Tavern are a bargain and delicious.

13
Follia image 1
Italian restaurant

Rustic Italian restaurant offers cozy indoor and outdoor seating with a warm, intimate vibe. Atmosphere suits casual hangouts and group gatherings with a beautiful, charming space blending old world Italy and historic New York.

Pesto pizza stands out with its perfect size and fresh flavor. The pesto pasta and Pasta Arrabiata deliver bold, well-executed tastes. Crostini offers three tasty varieties including burrata and whipped ricotta pesto.

Busy and lively atmosphere suits family dinners, date nights, and large reservations. Offers casual and fun dinner options with a good spot for night caps.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta, is the best I've ever eaten."

"The lemon ricotta pancakes are fluffy and delicious for brunch."

"The dinner spots here are so friendly and attentive."

Good to know

1

Follia offers an unlimited brunch paired with mimosas, Bellinis, or Bloody Marys.

2

The bottomless brunch has a 90-minute time limit starting with the first drink order.

3

Happy hour is a great option after work with discounted drinks.

Discover more

Gramercy Park, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...