Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Lenox Hill's best

Bagel sandwiches

A thick bagel sandwich is the only thing that will satisfy a serious hunger.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated
01
Alex Cafe & Deli image 1
Alex Cafe & Deli image 2
Alex Cafe & Deli image 3
View all

Cozy, family-owned deli with homey atmosphere and outdoor seating options. Offers quick tap-to-pay and customizable smoothie menu for convenience. Known for fresh bagels, hearty soups, and a wide variety of quality sandwiches.

Bagels come out fresh and toasted to perfection every time. Options like cream cheese with beef bacon and bagel with lox show great flavor and the right chew.

Chicken salad sandwich stands out for being fresh and reasonably priced. Hot sandwiches come out fresh and simple, with the egg sandwich and French toast not too greasy or sweet.

People are saying

"I love their fresh and tasty breakfast sandwiches."

"The bagels are fresh and taste great."

"The staff here is so sweet and always smiling when they make your sandwich."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for weekend brunch to avoid long wait times.

2

The restaurant has a happy hour from 4-6pm with discounted drinks.

3

Outdoor seating is available, but it fills up quickly on nice days.

02
Kossar's Bagels & Bialys image 1
Kossar's Bagels & Bialys image 2
Kossar's Bagels & Bialys image 3
View all

Bright, clean space blends bakery charm with bagel shop vibe and features cozy seating and black-and-white photos. Atmosphere ranges from quiet early mornings with jazz to crowded, lively weekends. Popular spot offers a polished setting uncommon for typical bagel shops.

Hand-rolled bagels come out fresh and huge with the right amount of bite and chew. A wide assortment of bagels and spreads includes classic combos like nova with cream cheese, tomato, capers, and onions.

Grilled chicken club and chicken cutlet with bacon stand out as very delicious sandwiches. Sandwiches come with generous portions and sometimes extra ones are given to fix orders.

People are saying

"These bagels are the freshest and most delicious I've ever had."

"The bagels and bialys are always fresh and tasty."

"I love the different bagel toppings and cream cheeses here."

Good to know

1

The prices for a bagel with lox are $15+.

2

The prices for a bagel with flavored cream cheese are $6+.

3

Kossars gets a little busy on weekend mornings.

03
B&B BAGELS image 1
B&B BAGELS image 2
B&B BAGELS image 3
View all

Bagel shop with immaculate cleanliness and steampunk/industrial lighting offers a quiet indoor space and covered outdoor seating. The atmosphere feels authentic with owners speaking Yiddish and Hebrew, creating a welcoming vibe. Bagels bake on-site, attracting those who appreciate fresh, well-crafted flavors.

Bagels here stand out for their perfect toasting and hearty toppings like lox spread and egg salad. The Everything Bagel and rye with grain bagel are especially notable for their flavor and texture.

Sandwiches come on bagels with options like turkey club and grilled chicken. Egg sandwiches get made on request and work well for an early lunch.

People are saying

"The bagels are fresh and taste amazing."

"These bagels are fresh, warm, and perfectly made."

"I believe these are the best bagels in NYC."

Good to know

1

B&B offers breakfast every morning.

2

B&B has only three indoor tables, so it is primarily takeout.

3

A bagel with cream cheese costs $6.50.

04
Go Bagels image 1
Go Bagels image 2
Go Bagels image 3
View all

Bagel shop offers fresh, crunchy bagels with endless smear options and custom toppings. Indoor seating includes air conditioning, complemented by a few outdoor tables. The atmosphere feels crammed but lively, with a great vibe throughout.

Bagels here have a perfect crunch and texture with great flavor. Freshness stands out, especially in options like the sesame bagel with avocado and the onion bagel.

Bagel sandwiches come in hearty portions that can serve as two meals. The vegan breakfast sandwich offers a satisfying taste, though cheese sometimes appears despite special requests.

People are saying

"The bagels are fresh, delicious, and perfectly chewy."

"The staff here are super friendly and welcoming."

"I really enjoy the bagels and their soft, chewy texture."

Good to know

1

A plain bagel costs over $3, with prices generally high.

2

Butter costs $1.50 extra but may not be added properly.

3

Seating is available both indoors and outdoors.

05
Bagels & Co. image 1
Bagels & Co. image 2
Bagels & Co. image 3
View all

Bagel shop offers freshly baked, large bagels with a variety of flavors in a warm, cozy atmosphere. Space inside feels cramped but inviting, with a friendly and casual vibe that becomes lively when busy.

Bagels come out fresh and delicious with a crunchy, fluffy texture. Staff toast and dress bagels with spreads, offering friendly, engaged service that makes the experience smooth and accurate.

Sandwiches come in generous portions with many low fat options. Ordering happens directly from the sandwich maker, not at a counter or digitally.

People are saying

"The bagels here are fresh and delicious."

"I found the bagels here to be great."

"I think the bagels are a bit pricey."

Good to know

1

Bagels & Co. is Kosher and has reliable certification ensuring high standards.

2

They’re not open on Saturdays.

3

The place won't toast and dress the bagels for you.

06
Bagel Express II image 1
Bagel Express II image 2
Bagel Express II image 3
View all

Bagel shop with clean, spacious interior and recent renovations offers a warm, friendly atmosphere. Bagels are fresh, flavorful, and crispy outside with soft inside. Ordering can be slow, so it's better suited for relaxed visits.

Bagels here stand out for their freshness and taste. Options like the garlic bagel with white meat chicken salad stay soft even after hours. Prices stay reasonable with occasional perks like free coffee.

Bagel sandwiches come with toasted whole wheat or rye bread and options like salmon with vegetable cream cheese or turkey. Prices vary, with some sandwiches costing more due to added toppings like lettuce and tomato.

People are saying

"The bagels here are fresh and delicious."

"These bagels are so fresh and perfectly chewy."

"Their bagel sandwiches are fresh and hit the spot."

Good to know

1

They charge 50 cents for a plastic cup of water.

2

$8.50 for a bagel is the price point.

3

They offer free coffee with a bagel purchase.

07
Tompkins Square Bagels | Upper East Side Bagels image 1
Tompkins Square Bagels | Upper East Side Bagels image 2
Tompkins Square Bagels | Upper East Side Bagels image 3
View all

Spacious bagel shop with an airy, bright interior and a large outdoor patio offering ample seating. The atmosphere carries a classic New York bagel energy, busy yet welcoming with friendly staff ready to assist. Open kitchen design lets patrons watch bagels being boiled and baked, adding to the lively vibe.

Bagels come fresh daily with a soft inside and crisp outside. Options like the toasted poppyseed with lox and capers offer a good texture and balanced flavors. The open kitchen shows bagels being boiled and baked, highlighting their commitment to freshness.

Sandwiches feature specialty options and make-your-own bagels. Egg sandwiches look delicious and brisket adds a rich, savory depth for a hearty bite.

People are saying

"These bagels are amazing and super fresh."

"The bagels are fresh, chewy, and flavorful."

"This place is known for having the best bagels around."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times, especially during busy mornings.

2

A blueberry bagel costs over $5, which some may find expensive.

3

You need to order drinks or other items separately when paying for a bagel.

08
Bagelworks image 1
Bagelworks image 2
Bagelworks image 3
View all

Small, old school New York-style bagel shop with visible bagel boiling and baking behind the counter creates an authentic, energetic vibe. Inside feels cramped and loud, while spacious outdoor seating offers a more relaxed option. The atmosphere captures a hectic NYC bagel shop experience with a gritty, local feel.

Bagels come out with a chewy inside and a crisp crust. The toasted poppyseed bagel with lox, plain cream cheese, and capers stands out. The bacon, egg, and cheese on a bagel offers a flawless combination.

Sandwiches feature generous smoked salmon, balanced with tomato and onion. Options include Thai chicken and breakfast varieties with egg salad and cream cheese, all consistently fresh.

People are saying

"The bagels are fresh, chewy, and full of flavor."

"I thought the bagels were heavenly and the best I ever had."

"Some sandwiches taste great but feel overpriced."

Good to know

1

Consider ordering ahead to avoid long lines on weekends.

2

They have a $5 minimum for credit card, so bring cash or plan to order a few bagels.

3

Expect to wait during weekend mornings.

09
Daily Bagel image 1
Daily Bagel image 2
Daily Bagel image 3
View all

Bright, spacious bagel shop with ample seating and a loud radio playing in the dining area. The atmosphere is quiet and empty, offering a comfortable spot to eat or grab and go. Bagels are often described as fresh and tasty, with a variety of spreads available.

Bagels come out fresh and soft with a variety of options like everything bagels and large, hearty sandwiches. Seating is available, making it easy to enjoy a breakfast sandwich or grab and go without long waits.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with egg & cheese options and hearty bagel bases. Coffee pairs well but sandwiches come at a higher price point around $13.50.

People are saying

"These bagels are so fresh and perfectly chewy inside."

"I love their fresh bagels and hearty breakfast sandwiches."

"The bagels were dry and lacked flavor."

Good to know

1

Parking is available on the street nearby.

2

The coffee shop has a minimum charge for credit card payments.

3

The bagel costs $1.75 for 5.22oz.

10
Breads Bakery - Upper East Side image 1
Breads Bakery - Upper East Side image 2
Breads Bakery - Upper East Side image 3
View all

Roomy bakery with varied seating options including sofas, high tops, and cushioned chairs creates a cozy atmosphere. Multiple music sources play simultaneously, contributing to a lively but sometimes noisy vibe. Pet-friendly space offers wifi and power outlets, supporting work and relaxation.

Jerusalem bagels stand out here, available only on weekends. Bread options include challah bread and other pastries like cinnamon rolls and black & white cookies.

Fresh sandwiches arrive daily with a great selection of vegetarian options. The egg breakfast sandwich stands out with an omelette cooked to perfection and overall, the sandwiches are very tasty.

People are saying

"The sandwiches taste good but feel small and pricey."

"I thought their sandwiches were incredible and heavenly."

"You can't go wrong with their fresh baked bagels."

Good to know

1

Cash is not accepted at the coffee stand.

2

You need to order while you are in line even if you don’t see what they offer.

3

The prices are on the high side, with croissants costing $5 to $6 each.

11
Sable's Smoked Fish image 1
Sable's Smoked Fish image 2
Sable's Smoked Fish image 3
View all

Smoked fish takes center stage with an incredible range and exceptional quality that draws locals. The atmosphere feels old school and family-owned, offering both indoor and outdoor seating. Bagels accompany the fish, though they lack the classic chewiness found elsewhere.

Smoked salmon and bagel sandwiches stand out with fresh, soft bagels that have a nice crust. Bagels come with eggs and cheese options and are known for being affordable and classic New York style.

Smoked salmon and bagel sandwiches stand out with rich flavors. The lobster and crab salad sandwiches offer unique, fresh fillings. Sandwiches cost around $12 and provide a substantial snack, often shared between two people.

People are saying

"I thought the bagels with smoked salmon were the best."

"I loved the bagels with their fresh smoked fish."

"The bagels felt dry, pricey, and lacked flavor."

Good to know

1

Breakfast is under $5 and lunch is under $15, including hot soup.

2

The price for a sandwich is $12.

3

The belly lox was $60 per pound, which is 50% more than at Zabar’s or Fairway.

12
Pick a Bagel image 1
Pick a Bagel image 2
Pick a Bagel image 3
View all

Bagel shop with recent renovation and outdoor seating offers a quiet atmosphere and freshly baked bagels known for crispy exteriors and fluffy interiors. Seating is comfortable and ordering is easy with a lowered counter. Prices are notably high compared to other options in the area.

Freshly baked bagels come out crispy on the outside and fluffy inside with a great variety to choose from. Toasting them lightly pairs well with light cream cheese or toppings like lox and butter.

Egg sandwiches and bagels stand out with solid bagels and flavorful fillings. Options include a salmon and sesame bagel sandwich and a roast beef sandwich with honey mustard sauce, mozzarella, and tomatoes.

People are saying

"The bagels are fresh and taste great."

"The bagels here are fresh and excellent."

"The bagels cost way more than expected."

Good to know

1

The bagel shop charges $20 for a bagel with lox and cream cheese.

2

A non-cash charge of $0.64 is added to the bagel price.

3

The restaurant offers outdoor seating for customers.

13
Gourmet Bagel image 1
Gourmet Bagel image 2
Gourmet Bagel image 3
View all

Bagel shop offers well-designed layout with counter seating and tables in the back. Atmosphere feels welcoming and modern, with loud music filling the space. Bagels stand out as excellent, paired with a good selection of cream cheese.

Bagels come out tasty and perfectly prepared, with options like the jalapeño bagel with scallion cream cheese standing out. Cream cheese portions are generous, and the service is consistently fast and friendly.

Custom sandwiches come with bagels and offer reasonable prices. Staff can be rushed, sometimes leading to order mistakes despite corrections.

People are saying

"Some say the bagels taste great, others find them stale and pricey."

"These bagels are simply delicious and fresh."

"The bagels cost a lot, but the cream cheese is generous."

Good to know

1

A regular bacon egg and cheese on a roll costs $9.30.

2

A basic chicken Caesar wrap with no add-ons costs $19.

3

Customers should order towards the back of the store.

Discover more

Lenox Hill, New York

Area guide