Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Midtown South

Italian sandwiches

A sandwich that respects the traditions of Italian cooking without being a quick, throwaway lunch.

Based on 727 Opinions
+724
User
User
User
Updated
01
Casa Toscana Bryant Park image 1
Casa Toscana Bryant Park image 2
Casa Toscana Bryant Park image 3
View all

Outdoor seating by the park creates a European café vibe with a warm, cozy atmosphere enhanced by background music and nearby trees. The spot offers easy-to-use kiosks for convenient ordering and serves authentic Italian pastries and coffee in a peaceful, charming setting ideal for relaxing or people watching.

Truffle prosciutto focaccia sandwich stands out with its rich flavor and soft, warm focaccia bread. Espresso coffee also shines, especially when served as a smooth affogato.

Sandwiches feature fresh ingredients like prosciutto, burrata, and arugula. Options include a truffle prosciutto focaccia and a miso glazed salmon sandwich with detailed presentation.

People are saying

"I loved the prosciutto truffle and burrata sandwich."

"The sandwiches are fresh, flavorful, and unforgettable."

"I can't get enough of the truffle prosciutto sandwich."

Good to know

1

The kitchen closes at 8 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

2

Only wireless payment methods are accepted; no credit card insertion available.

3

Expect to pay around $50 for two sandwiches and two coffee drinks.

02
The Rutherford image 1
The Rutherford image 2
The Rutherford image 3
View all

Rooftop terrace offers amazing views of Madison Square Garden and surrounding landmarks, creating a relaxing atmosphere ideal for pre-event gatherings. Music ranges from spectacular to very loud, influencing the vibe and conversation ease. Crowd energy suits casual drinks and business lunches, with notable food and drink options like spicy margaritas and standout wings.

Spicy rigatoni stands out with its bold flavor and includes chicken for added texture. The dish consistently delivers a well-seasoned taste.

Chicken sandwich features two pieces of chicken without being overwhelming. Steak sandwich stands out as very good and satisfying.

People are saying

"I love the tasty food and drinks here."

"I had a great steak sandwich."

"The spicy rigatoni here has a good flavor."

Good to know

1

The establishment serves drinks only and does not offer food.

2

The bar is a perfect place to grab a quick drink before getting on a train.

3

The venue is suitable for large work events with 17 people.

03
Marseille image 1
Marseille image 2
Marseille image 3
View all

French bistro style combines with classic, spacious layout and stunning panoramic views from a high floor. Atmosphere feels bougie and lively, with a warm ambiance and occasional loudness during dinner rush. Outdoor seating offers heated comfort for enjoying weather during lunch.

Pasta stands out with options like mushroom pasta and consistently good risotto. The menu also features unique dishes like frog legs alongside classic Italian staples.

Croque Madam and roasted turkey sandwiches stand out with rich flavors. Chicken curry sandwich offers a unique twist alongside classic options.

People are saying

"The pasta here is among the best I’ve ever had."

"I love how the pasta and risotto taste."

"The turkey sandwich was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Happy hour includes oysters for $1.50 until 5:30 PM daily.

2

Brunch includes bottomless Mimosas for $25.

3

Make reservations, especially if you are visiting prior to a theatre show.

04
Heritage Grand Bakery image 1
Heritage Grand Bakery image 2
Heritage Grand Bakery image 3
View all

Small bakery with Parisian-quality pastries and an in-store bakery visible from seating. Quiet, cozy atmosphere invites lingering away from city noise. Limited seating with high stools and narrow counters creates an intimate setting.

Prosciutto panini and pizza slices stand out with fresh Italian flavors. Warm olive bread and breadsticks offer a rich, savory touch alongside Mortadella mozzarella pinsza and lasagna.

Sandwiches offer amazing freshness and quality taste with options like turkey and brie baguette, prosciutto, and roast beef. Prices hover around $10, making them a great deal for a quick, satisfying meal.

People are saying

"The premade sandwiches are fresh and delicious."

"I loved the chicken salad sandwich on soft, golden bread."

"The Italian food, especially the pizzas and pasta, is delicious."

Good to know

1

During the soft opening week, customers can enjoy pre-opening 50% off.

2

Happy hour runs daily from 4-6pm with discounted drinks.

3

Expect to wait for a seat during busy hours, especially on weekends.

05
Bourbon and Branch image 1
Bourbon and Branch image 2
Bourbon and Branch image 3
View all

Spacious bar and grill with modern Deco decor and two-level layout offers a lively atmosphere with loud music and a great DJ. The vibe suits brunch and party moods, with an upstairs area providing quieter dining. Cocktails and elevated food complement the energetic setting.

Lamb sliders, prosciutto flatbread, and croque monsieur stand out with strong flavors. The fried risotto ball shines, especially with its accompanying sauce, while the burger slider stack offers a cheesy twist.

Chicken sandwiches come on brioche buns and offer spicy and crispy options with good flavor and portion size. Steak and lamb sandwiches also appear alongside burgers and sliders.

People are saying

"The food and drinks here are amazing and varied."

"The Italian food, especially the risotto ball, was ridiculously good."

"The chicken sandwich was well prepared and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7 PM daily with a limited menu.

2

Brunch ends at 3 PM, so arrive early to enjoy it.

3

Reservations are strongly recommended during events at MSG.

06
The Ragtrader & Bo Peep Cocktail and Highball Store image 1
The Ragtrader & Bo Peep Cocktail and Highball Store image 2
The Ragtrader & Bo Peep Cocktail and Highball Store image 3
View all

Small speakeasy with live jazz piano and retro decor reflecting its garment factory roots creates a cozy, intimate atmosphere. Upstairs dining offers a lively vibe with eclectic design and dim lighting. Staff and performers engage actively, enhancing the dynamic entertainment experience.

Large portions of meat and mushroom pasta stand out. Adults enjoy bolognese, cauliflower steak, and desserts like pistachio brûlée and sticky toffee pudding.

Hot prosciutto and chicken panini with smoked mozzarella stands out. Steak and chicken sandwiches deliver solid flavor. Creative grilled cheese and coconut shrimp sandwiches add variety.

People are saying

"The pasta and sandwiches here are delicious and filling."

"I loved the steak and chicken sandwiches."

"I loved the creative grilled cheese sandwich."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for the piano bar, especially on busy nights.

2

Happy hour offers half-price appetizers on weekdays from 4-7pm.

3

Wine is half price on Mondays.

07
Parker & Quinn image 1
Parker & Quinn image 2
Parker & Quinn image 3
View all

Historic decor and cozy booths create an intimate, lively atmosphere with live music enhancing the experience. Small, oblong space feels warm but can be noisy, making conversation challenging. Access to a rooftop bar offers city views and a quieter alternative to the main dining area.

Lamb ragu stands out with rich, deep flavors. The burrata offers a creamy, fresh start alongside warm olives and focaccia. Pasta dishes arrive hot and melt in your mouth with divine texture.

Breakfast sandwiches come with a little salad and pair well with a Cappuccino and freshly squeezed orange juice. The French dip sandwich offers a great size for hunger without feeling stuffed.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is cooked to perfection and seasoned just right."

"The lamb ragu and other mains blew me away."

"The grilled cheese sandwich was delicious and paired well with soup."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially on busy nights.

2

Expect a one-hour wait for tables during peak hours.

3

The last order is taken at 10:30 PM.

08
Pan d’oro Italian Cafe image 1
Pan d’oro Italian Cafe image 2
Pan d’oro Italian Cafe image 3
View all

Narrow, cozy space with bright lighting and a pastry display featuring Italian sweets like zeppole and cannoli. Warm, welcoming atmosphere with authentic Italian flavors and expertly prepared fresh pasta. Often quiet early, sometimes loud later, offering a charming spot for coffee or a meal.

Fresh pasta stands out with impeccable texture and flavor, clearly made with care. Pizza, focaccia, and Italian sweet pasta taste authentic, with freshly baked focaccia and top-notch prosciutto adding to the experience.

Soft, buttery sandwiches come fresh and big, often served alongside Italian pastries and croissants. Panini and other sandwiches taste delicious and pair well with cappuccino.

People are saying

"The focaccia and pasta taste just like Italy."

"I found the sandwiches here to be amazing and delicious."

"The cannolis were hit or miss, some good, some soggy."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $8 for a pastry at this café.

2

The café does not display prices on the menu, which can be confusing.

3

The total for two hot chocolates and a pastry can reach $35.

09
Roma Pizza & restaurant image 1
Roma Pizza & restaurant image 2
Roma Pizza & restaurant image 3
View all

Small, narrow space fills quickly, creating a crowded, humid atmosphere with limited seating indoors and a small patio outdoors. Pizza stands out as the best in Manhattan, drawing a lively crowd despite the tight quarters. Attention to gluten-free protocols adds a thoughtful touch to the busy vibe.

Lasagna stands out as exceptional here, with spaghetti with meat sauce also highly notable. The menu includes Margherita pizza and a pizza topped with ricotta and pesto, alongside delicious fettuccine Alfredo.

Philadelphia-style sandwiches stand out here, served alongside slices and Sicilian style options. The sandwiches come with a variety of fillings and pair well with soups and pastas.

People are saying

"The pizza and garlic rolls were delicious, the best ever."

"The pizza tastes good but not truly Italian."

"The food tastes like real Italian cooking."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open all night.

2

They deliver after midnight.

3

The location is a good spot near lots of subway stops and Bryant Park.

10
ALIDORO image 1
ALIDORO image 2
ALIDORO image 3
View all

Cozy sandwich shop with dim lighting and industrial charm creates a rustic, stylish vibe. Large wooden tables and open space invite casual dining or quick takeout. Crowds form quickly, often filled with energetic, urban clientele.

Porchetta offers an interesting bitterness from slightly burnt parts that contrasts with other flavors. Sandwiches use focaccia bread and combine sweet heat from peppers with savory prosciutto. Caprese salad comes with fresh arugula, and the Il Sole has a spicy kick that pairs well with bread.

Italian sandwiches stand out with focaccia bread and rich flavors like fresh cheddar and truffle cream. Portions are generous and the sandwiches offer a flavor explosion that redefines taste.

People are saying

"The sandwiches are tasty with generous portions."

"The sandwiches here have super fresh meats and great bread."

"Sometimes the wait for sandwiches feels too long."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times during lunch hours, especially on weekdays.

2

Prices are high, with sandwiches costing around $16 to $20.

3

Order ahead if you have a limited lunch time to avoid long lines.

11
BSTRO 38 image 1
BSTRO 38 image 2
BSTRO 38 image 3
View all

Warm, modern space combines dim lighting with intimate vibe and stylish comfort. Music complements a friendly, lively atmosphere that fills the busy room. Crowd enjoys a mix of cozy dinners and vibrant social gatherings.

Short Ribs and Pork Osso Buco stand out as rich entrées. Pasta is made in house, with the sea scallop pasta as a notable dish.

Short rib and steak sandwiches stand out here. The steak sandwich is extremely scrumptious and a common choice for lunch.

People are saying

"The food is delicious and the atmosphere is welcoming."

"The Italian food's osso buco is tender and flavorful."

"I had the steak sandwich; it was so good."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 3 to 8 PM, which is longer than usual for this area.

2

The restaurant can get busy, but there is usually not a long wait.

3

The menu offers great options for both vegetarians and meat lovers.

12
Isla & Co. - Midtown image 1
Isla & Co. - Midtown image 2
Isla & Co. - Midtown image 3
View all

Restaurant combines cozy, trendy atmosphere with Australian flair and a rooftop offering Empire State Building views. Music ranges from classical playlists to live DJs, creating a warm and intimate vibe. Seating options include outdoor, bar, lounge, dining area, and private room.

Spicy Shrimp Rigatoni offers a balanced kick without overwhelming heat. Lamb ragu served over Al dente pasta channels flavors from the Abruzzo region. The broccolini pasta and spicy vodka pasta with shrimp also stand out for their rich taste.

Breakfast and fish sandwiches stand out with great flavor and a phenomenal crispy chicken option. The fish sandwich earns praise as an all-time favorite and pairs well with fries.

People are saying

"I loved the spicy shrimp rigatoni and chicken parmesan."

"The spicy vodka pasta with shrimp was so good."

"I had the best breakfast sandwich I’ve ever had."

Good to know

1

Wine Wednesday means half price bottles all night long.

2

Happy hour is available every day of the week.

3

Daily specials include $20 chicken parm with a drink on Tuesdays.

13
Anas cafe image 1
Anas cafe image 2
Anas cafe image 3
View all

Small, clean space with plenty of inside seating and a family-owned vibe creates a friendly, welcoming atmosphere. Background music blends country and Spanish hits, adding to the cozy, local feel. The place fills up quickly, reflecting its popularity for affordable, hearty breakfasts.

Creamy chicken pasta with veggies and Chicken Bruschetta stand out on the menu. Pasta dishes pair well with cold beer, enjoyed by a variety of diners.

Fresh sandwiches include a Philly cheese steak with minced meat and a beef sandwich toast. Breakfast sandwiches have a New York deli style and come with coffee.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the sandwiches here; they were really great and a good price."

"The Italian food here has something for everyone, like pizza and pasta."

"The sandwiches and wraps here hit the spot."

Good to know

1

You can get a filling sandwich or lunch for under 10 bucks.

2

The prices are about half the price of restaurants 6 blocks away.

3

They open at 5 AM.

14
Angelina Bakery HSQ image 1
Angelina Bakery HSQ image 2
Angelina Bakery HSQ image 3
View all

Space combines intimate seating with a modern, classy vibe and a full bar offering craft cocktails. Music plays loudly, especially with a DJ on weekends, creating a lively atmosphere that suits dates and gatherings. Tables sit close together, enhancing a cozy but energetic feel.

Tiramisu and strawberry mini cannoli stand out among the desserts. The menu features bulgogi pizza, uni pasta, truffle pasta, seafood lasagna, and substantial focaccia for lunch.

Affordable and savory sandwiches stand out here. The spot offers good breakfast sandwiches in a cute setting.

People are saying

"The Italian pastries, especially the cannoli, were outstanding."

"The pasta and Italian dishes really hit the spot."

"I found the sandwiches here to be affordable and delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour specials are available on weekdays from 4-7pm.

2

The restaurant gets busy on Friday nights, so arrive early.

3

Nighttime parties happen on weekends with a DJ after 9pm.

15
Miss Nellie's image 1
Miss Nellie's image 2
Miss Nellie's image 3
View all

Restaurant offers themed decor with art-filled rooms that tell a story. Atmosphere stays friendly and lively with live music and a photo booth adding to the energy. Cocktails stand out, especially the espresso martini, alongside a menu featuring Nashville Chicken Bites and a dry aged burger.

Fresh pasta bursts with flavor, especially the spaghetti with shrimp. Breaded chicken meatballs and mozzarella sticks stand out, while ravioli can be a bit oily.

Spicy chicken sandwich stands out with its savory, crunchy, slightly spicy, and sweet flavors. Other sandwiches include a steak sandwich and a turkey sandwich, offering a variety of hearty options.

People are saying

"Jaime's recommendations for Italian food were next-level exceptional."

"I love the lemon ricotta tortellini and tasty pasta."

"I found the spicy chicken sandwich to be super saucy and juicy."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.

3

The restaurant is popular for pre-theater dining, so expect crowds.

16
Westway Diner image 1
Westway Diner image 2
Westway Diner image 3
View all

Classic American diner with nostalgic decor and big red banquettes creates a genuine, hardworking vibe. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming but can be uncomfortable due to noise from dishes. Seating is cozy with comfortable booths and some outdoor options.

Dinner features pasta dishes like fettuccini Alfredo. Desserts include tiramisu praised for its flavor.

Customizable sandwiches let you build your own with fresh ingredients. Options like the Pastrami on rye, Louisiana Panini, and French Dip offer hearty, flavorful choices.

People are saying

"My short rib sandwich was amazing."

"The sandwiches here are tasty and varied."

"The pasta, like the fettuccini Alfredo, is delicious."

Good to know

1

Arrive early for breakfast to avoid long queues.

2

Happy hour offers $4 beers and $6 cocktails on weekdays.

3

Expect busy breakfast hours on rainy Saturdays.

Discover more

Midtown South, New York

Area guide