Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Prospect Heights

Coffee and sandwiches

Coffee shops that put as much care into their sandwiches as they do into their beans.

Based on 715 Opinions
+712
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Mille-Feuille Bakery Cafe image 1
Mille-Feuille Bakery Cafe image 2
Mille-Feuille Bakery Cafe image 3
View all

Small French patisserie offers indoor and outdoor seating with comfortable chairs and free wifi. Atmosphere stays quiet in the morning and feels cozy and welcoming throughout the day. Displays feature colorful macarons and French pastries that draw attention.

Coffee here stands out for its amazing espresso and rich drip coffee. The cappuccinos and pastries pair well, making it a solid spot for a quick coffee break.

Ciabatta caprese sandwiches feature caprese bread with olives, smoked Mozzarella, pesto, and tomato. Baguette and ham sandwiches come fresh and pair well with pastries like macarons and flourless chocolate cookies.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be fresh and delicious."

"I found the coffee here to be amazing."

"I loved their BLT sandwich; it was the best I had."

Good to know

1

Visit in the morning when the croissants are fresh out.

2

Go early to avoid the pastries disappearing late morning or early afternoon.

3

$13.50 for 6 macarons was the price at the time we went.

02
Caffรจ De Martini image 1

Small indoor space offers a cozy, authentic European vibe with beautiful decor and inviting outdoor seating including a heated cabin. Atmosphere feels warm and friendly, welcoming people to relax or work. Frequented for real Italian coffee and pastries that stand out in quality and taste.

Espresso and lattes stand out for their thick Italian coffee quality and rich flavor. Pastries like cranberry pie complement the authentic Italian coffee experience.

Focaccia sandwiches stand out with good quality and yummy flavors. The arepa serves as an open sandwich option alongside other tasty choices like the Croissant Egg Sandwich.

People are saying

"I thought the coffee here was delicious."

"The outdoor seating is beautiful and gives the place a unique charm."

"The focaccia sandwiches here are great and yummy."

Good to know

1

Expect a 30-minute wait for takeout sandwiches during peak hours.

2

The cafe does not have a restroom for customers.

3

The cafe is usually busy on Sundays, but the line moves fast.

03
Penny House Cafe image 1

Cafe offers a cozy atmosphere with a home-like vibe and a dog-friendly space including a patio and dining shed. It attracts locals who appreciate friendly, chill energy and early opening hours. The place stands out for its specialty bagel sandwiches and exceptional pastries.

Coffee here stands out for its fantastic lattes and amazing flavor crafted by skilled baristas. The caramel latte pairs well with a tiny cup of chocolate milk, enhancing the experience.

Bagel sandwiches stand out with soft hot bagels and affordable specialty options. The chicken supreme and Russian sandwiches with capers offer distinctive flavors that many find delicious.

People are saying

"The coffee here is served with a warm, friendly smile."

"The bagels here are delicious and the staff is super friendly."

"I had the best breakfast sandwich Iโ€™ve ever had."

Good to know

1

Customers may have to wait 25 minutes for coffee and a bagel.

2

The price on the board was different than what I was charged.

3

Watch carefully what the restaurant charges you.

04
Ciao, Gloria image 1

Italian cafe offers rustic decor and bright, modern space with ample outdoor seating. Atmosphere blends lively italo disco music with a mix of people working, reading, and socializing. Space often fills up quickly, creating a bustling yet inviting vibe.

Drip coffee stands out with rich flavor and consistent quality. Pastries like chocolate babka pair well with iced lattes served in reusable mugs.

Breakfast sandwiches feature fluffy eggs, crispy bacon, and melted cheese on toasted rolls. Sandwiches like the Miss Mortazza stack three meats, shaved cheese, roasted peppers, arugula, and basil pesto for rich flavor. The AVEC sandwich includes crispy shallots and calabrese aioli for texture and taste.

People are saying

"The coffee here is delicious and smooth."

"I found the pastries here to be amazing and freshly baked."

"You have to try their breakfast sandwiches; the eggs are phenomenal."

Good to know

1

Expect a big cyclist crowd on Friday mornings from 8-9am.

2

Laptops are limited to bar seating and common tables from 11:30 AM to 2 PM.

3

Get there early to avoid long waits for tables.

05
Sit & Wonder Cafe image 1

Vintage 90s decor and garage sale kitsch create a cozy, retro vibe with a long barista counter and sidewalk-facing stools. A large backyard patio offers outdoor seating that suits warmer months. The atmosphere is relaxed and neighborhood-friendly, with a mix of people and dogs passing by.

Slamminโ€™ Colombe coffee defines the menu with a cold brew that packs a punch yet goes down smooth. Pastries complement the top notch coffee offerings in this friendly spot.

Sandwiches come with pastries from Colson Patisserie and are made on-site. The vegetarian curried muffuletta stands out as a flavorful option beyond typical cafe choices.

People are saying

"I had one of the best, most flavorful lattes ever."

"I found this cafe to be my favorite in the neighborhood."

"This curried muffuletta sandwich is insanely good."

Good to know

1

There is limited indoor seating, so arrive early for a spot.

2

Many pastries are made in-house, ensuring freshness.

3

Prices are reasonable for the quality offered.

06
Le Pistol Bar & Cafe image 1

French-American bar and bistro style blends with a Rock-a-Billy vibe in a chic space featuring small tables and outdoor street seating. Live jazz and DJ music create a hip atmosphere with great energy and good vibes. Creative cocktails and standout dishes add to the lively, stylish experience.

Coffee here is great and pairs well with snacks available at the cafe.

Oxtail French dip sandwich stands out with its rich flavor and juicy meat. Fried chicken Caesar sandwich features flavorful breading that stays crispy, while the Hangover Sandwich offers a satisfying, hearty bite.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the super creative cocktails here."

"The oxtail sandwich is out of this world."

"The coffee here is great."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs every day with great drink specials.

2

The happy hour burger and beer combo costs $17.

3

Trivia night takes place every Tuesday evening.

07
GERTIE image 1
Restaurant

Small restaurant with a beautiful back patio and colorful mural creates a cozy, lively atmosphere. It draws a neighborhood crowd enjoying traditional food with a modern twist and house-made items. Music and good vibes fill the space, making it a popular spot for breakfast and lunch.

Great coffee comes with friendly staff and options like in-house made sodas. Parlor coffee beans and bagels also feature alongside the drinks.

Sandwiches feature house made hot sauce and a variety of options like chicken schnitzel, pastrami, and a Turkey Club. Bagel sandwiches and a kale salad sandwich also appear on the menu.

People are saying

"I thought these bagels were the best I've ever had."

"I thought the pastrami sandwich was honestly amazing."

"I thought the coffee here was great."

Good to know

1

Gertie gets busy, especially on weekends, so expect long wait times.

2

Prices are on the higher side, with some sandwiches costing over $30.

3

Gertie smokes its pastrami in-house for a unique flavor.

08
Radio Bakery image 1

Busy bakery with a long line and early sellouts creates a bustling atmosphere. Outdoor seating offers a chance to enjoy fresh pastries in a lively setting. Known for exceptional sandwiches and standout focaccia, it draws a crowd especially during lunch hours.

Iced lattes come at a reasonable price with self-serve syrup options for sweetness or flavor. Coffee is aromatic and served quickly, making it a solid choice to pair with food.

Sandwiches feature focaccia bread and unique fillings like spicy chili tofu, burrata and ham, and mint and pea. Options include nourishing choices like kale turkey and turkey pesto with fresh kale.

People are saying

"I found their sandwiches to be large and flavorful."

"The focaccia here is worth waiting in line for."

"I thought the coffee here was great and aromatic."

Good to know

1

The line at Radio Bakery can be long, especially during lunch hours.

2

By 11:30, they often sell out of the Sweet Corn & Pecorino Foccaccia Slice.

3

Radio Bakery has no toilet available for customers.

09
Cheryl's Global Soul image 1
Soul food restaurant

Small soul food restaurant offers live jazz music and a cozy backyard garden for outdoor dining. Atmosphere feels safe and welcoming, especially for LGBTQ guests, with a rotation of local black and women artists enhancing the space.

Coffee here stands out for its great flavor and consistent quality. It ranks among the best coffee experiences in the city.

Fried chicken sandwiches stand out with crispy, flavorful chicken and get high marks for taste. Catfish and jerk pork sandwiches also appear as solid options with rich, satisfying flavors.

People are saying

"The pancakes here are fluffy and taste homemade."

"I had the best fried chicken sandwich I've ever had."

"The coffee here is amazing and truly exceptional."

Good to know

1

Brunch is served until 2pm on weekends with a special menu.

2

Live music is available on most Thursday evenings.

3

An automatic gratuity of 18% is added for parties of 2.

Discover more

Prospect Heights, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...