Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Unique Italian food in SoHo

Made for those who hunt for Italian menus that offer something beyond the standard neighborhood fare.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Odd Sister image 1
Odd Sister image 2
Odd Sister image 3
View all

Cozy and stylish interior with unique cocktails and a large covered backyard bar creates a calm, romantic atmosphere. Music stays phenomenal throughout, supporting intimate conversations and lively gatherings. Space fills up, so reservations help secure a spot in this iconic SoHo setting.

Gnocchi stands out as especially amazing and tasty. The crab pasta and truffle fries also get finished quickly, showing their appeal. Pizza tends to have a bit too much mozzarella.

Inventive cocktails stand out with the Odd Sister offering unique and delicious flavors. The menu features unique appetizers and food that add to the overall stunning experience.

People are saying

"The cocktails are inventive, unique, and delicious."

"The cocktails and vibe here are truly unique."

"The crab pasta here is so tasty, I considered it heaven."

Good to know

1

Making a reservation is advisable because the restaurant is busy.

2

Saturdays are busy but fun; expect a lively atmosphere.

3

Happy hour drinks have a great vibe and are popular.

02
Piccola Cucina Estiatorio image 1
Piccola Cucina Estiatorio image 2
Piccola Cucina Estiatorio image 3
View all

Small Italian restaurant with cozy, cramped seating and detailed interior decor resembling a trattoria. Atmosphere includes live music and dancing, creating a lively and energetic vibe. Known for authentic, highly praised pasta dishes and a well-curated wine selection.

Pasta stands out with rich, authentic flavors. The pesto and cannoli offer distinct, memorable tastes. Table side Caesar salad and tiramisu add classic touches to the Italian menu.

Spinach noodles and thick tube noodles offer a unique texture and flavor. Octopus with burrata stands out with a distinctive mix of sauces. Pasta dishes bring flavorful twists to traditional recipes.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the pasta and cannoli, is the best I've ever had."

"I love the authentic Italian food here."

"The Sicilian flavors and Italian vibe stand out."

Good to know

1

Make sure to make reservations in advance to avoid long wait times.

2

Happy hour offers half off the menu items.

3

The restaurant celebrates birthdays with songs and cannoli.

03
Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana image 1
Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana image 2
Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana image 3
View all

Small, cozy space offers a romantic, lively atmosphere with a distinctly authentic Italian vibe. Guests experience table-side tiramisu preparation and enjoy intimate outdoor seating despite tight indoor arrangements. The energy feels dynamic and truly transports diners to Sicily.

Sicilian cuisine shines with homemade tiramisu prepared right in front of diners. Pasta dishes like tagliatelle with boar ragu and maccheroni alla norma stand out for their authentic flavors and quality.

Flavors stand out with a unique twist in dishes like lasagna, calamari, and cod special appetizer. Presentation adds a distinctive touch, especially the table side tiramisu offering a non-traditional experience.

People are saying

"I could eat the Italian food here regularly; the lasagna was the best I ever had."

"I love how authentic the Italian food tastes here."

"It's a cozy spot with really good Italian food."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to limited seating.

2

There is a 2 hour time limit on your dinner.

3

Indoor seating is limited, so arrive early or reserve.

04
The Otter image 1
The Otter image 2
The Otter image 3
View all

Nautical 50s style space with lacquered navy walls, white wood-paneled ceilings, and curved banquettes creates a sexy, cozy atmosphere perfect for conversation. Outdoor dining area offers a quiet, comfortable patio setting. Signature cocktails like the Otter Dirty Martini complement the vibe.

Seafood platter and agnolotti pasta stand out on the menu. Desserts like pistachio tiramisu and rice pudding also catch attention.

Seafood dishes offer unique presentation and flavorful combinations like wedge salad with crabmeat and wasabi dressing. The atmosphere carries a nautical 50s vibe that feels quite sexy and distinct.

People are saying

"The food is amazing and the vibe is cozy."

"The Italian food here is amazing and incredible."

"The seafood here is unique and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends.

2

Expect a $100 tab for four cocktails, including tip.

3

The restaurant offers a variety of seafood dishes and options for non-seafood lovers.

05
Le Botaniste image 1
Le Botaniste image 2
Le Botaniste image 3
View all

Space combines botanical-apothecary theme with stylish accents creating a calm and fun atmosphere. Seating includes indoor and outdoor options with amenities like phone charging outlets. Music volume tends to be loud, balancing a unique vibe with casual and fancy elements.

Fresh salads and vegan pasta bolognese stand out here. The Pasta Bolo offers rich, flavorful bites, often paired with options like chili sin carne or squash soup for variety.

Food offers unique flavors and stays consistently fresh and flavorful. The setup and ambiance create a sophisticated and special dining experience.

People are saying

"I love the fresh, flavorful vegan food here."

"I found the pasta bolognese so delicious and flavorful."

"The food here has such unique, distinct flavors."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a 'free glass of wine with a bowl' deal during Happy Hour.

2

Customers need to order at the counter before seating themselves.

3

All menu items are vegan and gluten-free.

06
Lucia Pizza Of SoHo image 1
Lucia Pizza Of SoHo image 2
Lucia Pizza Of SoHo image 3
View all

Small, cozy pizza shop offers poblano style slices with a warm, intimate interior and standing counters for quick bites. The atmosphere is hectic and crowded, with most people grabbing pizza to go. A great playlist plays in the background, adding to the lively vibe.

Pizzas come in several styles like Sicilian corner, white with pesto, and sausage pie with Calabrian chiles. Slices such as vodka and spinach pesto offer warm, toasted, and cheesy bites.

Specialty pizzas stand out with unique flavors like the garlicky white slice and the distinctive spinach option. The drink selection also offers unique choices that complement the high-quality pizza by the slice.

People are saying

"The Italian food's crust is perfectly baked and delightfully chewy."

"The pizza here is unique, with a flavorful, cheesy, and crunchy crust."

"The vodka and spinach pesto slices are my favorites here."

Good to know

1

This place is strictly takeout with no seating available.

2

The pizza shop gets busy quickly, especially during late night and weekends.

3

Plan to grab and go as there is limited standing space.

07
Lure Fishbar image 1
Lure Fishbar image 2
Lure Fishbar image 3
View all

Interior resembles inside of a yacht with porthole-inspired windows and a semi-subterranean dining room. Atmosphere is lively and loud, requiring raised voices for conversation. Patrons enjoy fresh seafood and creative cocktails in a space that balances charm with a fun, ship-style vibe.

Uni bucatini pasta stands out with its hot and slightly spicy flavor. The menu includes crab pasta and vegetarian ravioli options, all served fresh and delicious.

The place offers a unique ambiance paired with high-quality food like the Asian snapper for two. It also provides excellent people watching, making for a distinct evening.

People are saying

"The Italian Food here, especially the seafood pasta, is amazing."

"I enjoyed the pasta, especially the uni bucatini."

"The interior design is unique, like being inside a ship."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers half-off oysters until 7pm.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially during peak hours.

3

Expect a minimum spend of $870 for a party of six.

08
Roscioli NYC image 1
Roscioli NYC image 2
Roscioli NYC image 3
View all

Cellar dining space with a rustic wine cellar vibe creates a lively, hip atmosphere that feels like an authentic Italian family gathering. Cramped seating and steep stairs lead to a subterranean enoteca where excellent wine pairings complement the experience.

Fresh pasta tastes just like in Rome, with rich, authentic flavors. The burrata comes fried or fresh, drizzled with golden olive oil and topped with concentrated tomatoes. The tiramisu stands out as fluffy and memorable.

Atmosphere blends Roman vibes with a cool shop feel. Menu offers carefully curated and unique dishes like the summer salad.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is amazing, especially the pasta."

"Some pastas were amazing, others small or not hot enough."

"The tiramisu was the best dessert Iโ€™ve had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required and can be made through Resy.

2

The tasting menu costs $170 per person and includes multiple courses.

3

Dinner seatings are at 6:00 PM and 8:30 PM daily.

09
Maison Close Restaurant image 1
Maison Close Restaurant image 2
Maison Close Restaurant image 3
View all

French restaurant offers modern yet elegant decor with dim lighting that creates an upscale atmosphere. Loud, lively energy builds by evening with classy dance music and live entertainment including magicians and burlesque dancers. The vibe suits date nights and social gatherings in a vibrant setting.

Linguine pasta stands out with its amazing texture and flavor. Appetizers like tuna tartare and potato gnocchi complement dishes such as lamb chops and chicken, showcasing solid Italian flavors.

Escargot stands out as a signature dish here. A roaming magician performs unique tricks that entertain the whole table, making the dining experience truly captivating.

People are saying

"The truffle pasta was absolutely delicious and unforgettable."

"The Italian Food, especially the truffle pasta, was delicious."

"The live burlesque shows here are amazing and electrifying."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to ensure a table, especially on weekends.

2

The best time to arrive is around 10 PM to catch the main show.

3

Expect the show to start later than the scheduled time; it may begin around 4 PM.

10
Balthazar image 1
Balthazar image 2
Balthazar image 3
View all

Stunning interior design evokes a Parisian feel with tiny, closely spaced tables that create a noisy, crowded atmosphere. Outdoor seating offers a pleasant alternative, and solo diners receive a complimentary glass of champagne. The bar serves excellent cocktails and wine selections.

Lobster pasta stands out with a solid flavor, while the seafood tower offers a variety of fresh options. Staff accommodate sharing by splitting dishes like risotto without fuss.

Offers a unique level of French gastronomy with each visit delivering a memorable experience. Breakfast includes distinctive dishes like a tasty banana tart.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the lobster spaghetti, is delicious."

"I loved the lobster spaghetti and steak frites."

"It's a unique Parisian brasserie vibe with warm wood and brass."

Good to know

1

Getting a reservation is advisable because the diner gets crowded.

2

Single diners receive a free glass of champagne.

3

There is a $60 no-show fee for reservations.

11
Fellini Coffee Soho image 1
Fellini Coffee Soho image 2
Fellini Coffee Soho image 3
View all

Small, intimate coffee shop with Carrara marble bar countertops and wood paneling creates a cozy, old-world atmosphere. Oldies music plays, setting a warm and inviting mood. Outdoor terrace offers a peaceful spot for relaxation when weather permits.

Tiramisu comes with balanced sweetness and neat presentation, tasting like a traditional recipe. Bruschetta features fresh, crispy bread with flavorful cherry tomatoes and rosemary.

Ambience feels like a small town in Italia with a unique charm in the bar area. Coffee options include Pistacchio Paradiso and Tiramisu Latte, both distinct and delicious in a petite, cozy setting.

People are saying

"The tiramisu latte tastes great but feels pricey."

"You have to try the tiramisu; it's perfectly sweet."

"The coffee here has unique flavors and great quality."

Good to know

1

The seating at the cafe is very limited, especially indoors.

2

A walk-up window is available for quick orders.

3

Expect long lines during peak hours, especially on weekends.

12
A Pasta Bar image 1
A Pasta Bar image 2
A Pasta Bar image 3
View all

Open kitchen with chef's counter seating creates an engaging and intimate dining experience. Outdoor heated seating and pleasant music contribute to a relaxed atmosphere. Attention to detail shows in customized glassware and modern, simple design elements.

Tagliatelle Tartufo stands out as a signature dish with rich truffle cream. The pasta dishes consistently deliver amazing flavor and pair well with attentive, five-star service.

Sitting at the counter offers a super entertaining view of kitchen activities. The menu features unique pasta dishes and a basil oil that tastes like smooth pesto.

People are saying

"I thought the pasta here was the best I'd ever had."

"I love how the pasta tastes truly Italian and delicious."

"Their pasta dishes and sauces taste unique."

Good to know

1

Reservations should be made at least a few days in advance, especially on weekends.

2

The kitchen closes at 10:30 PM.

3

The restaurant adds 20% gratuity to the bill.

13
Ladurรฉe Soho image 1
Ladurรฉe Soho image 2
Ladurรฉe Soho image 3
View all

Elegant pastry shop offers beautiful decor with a gorgeous garden patio featuring flowering trees and heaters for comfort. Atmosphere feels chic and grandiose, blending indoor dining rooms with a hidden terrace. Known for perfect macarons and a refined tea and cocktail service.

The lobster pasta dish stands out with fresh, soft lobster tail and a unique sauce. Risotto dishes are consistently excellent, and pasta is generally delicious despite limited variety.

Cherry blossom notes in the latte create a refreshing drink. The menu features unique dishes with amazing presentations and flavorful options. The atmosphere feels beautiful and welcoming.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and unique in taste and presentation."

"The lobster pasta tastes fresh and really stands out."

"Thereโ€™s only one pasta, and it tastes bland."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended at least two weeks in advance for brunch.

2

Expect long wait times during weekend afternoons without a reservation.

3

Afternoon tea costs $65 for two finger sandwiches, macarons, and champagne.

14
Raoul's image 1
Raoul's image 2
Raoul's image 3
View all

Small, elegant French restaurant with cramped seating and a high glass ceiling that adds ambient lighting. Atmosphere feels lively and loud, with live accordion music and classic soul tunes playing. Bar area offers top-notch cocktails and a limited, sought-after burger menu.

Pappardelle stands out as an excellent pasta dish. The menu also features lobster tortellini, truffle risotto with chicken, and rabbit gnocchi, all paired with notable cocktails.

Levain pancake offers a distinct taste not found elsewhere. The burger stands out with its unique flavor profile. Desserts also bring a different twist to the table.

People are saying

"The burger here is unique, with peppercorn in every bite."

"The lamb pasta tastes amazing, but carbonara's a gamble."

"Lobster tortellini is the best bite every time."

Good to know

1

Reservations are necessary to have a good experience at this place.

2

Burgers are only served at the bar and not in the dining area.

3

They only serve 20 burgers a night, only at the bar.

Discover more

SoHo, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...