Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Italian food in Sunset Park

You have no patience for anything less than authentic Italian food.

Based on 678 Opinions
+675
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
The Astarita image 1
The Astarita image 2
The Astarita image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Tuscan style vibe creates a cozy atmosphere perfect for families, despite small outdoor tables. Brick oven pizzas shine with vegan mozzarella options for lactose intolerance. Homemade tiramisu and Nutella pie add a sweet finish to the Italian menu.

Pizzas come with vegan mozzarella as an option, great for lactose intolerance. The menu includes homemade tiramisu and a variety of pastas and desserts like Nutella pie.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was first-rate and spectacular."

"The outdoor seating is perfect for a chill night."

"This Italian food is a wonderful neighborhood gem."

Good to know

1

Reservations are now accepted, especially important during winter months.

2

The restaurant allows guests to bring their own alcohol.

3

Vegan mozzarella is available for pizzas, catering to lactose intolerant guests.

02
Tasty Ribbon image 1
Gift basket store

Gift basket store shines with fresh pasta and classic truffles. Custom boxes blend savory and sweet treats like fresh cookies and pralines. Fast delivery and smooth website make ordering easy and quick.

Pasta stands out with a fresh, satisfying taste. Cookies also offer a sweet finish alongside the savory dishes.

People are saying

"I was so impressed with how fast the delivery was!"

"The pasta and sauces here were delicious."

"The pasta and sauces here are delicious."

Good to know

1

Delivery is typically completed within three days of placing an order.

2

Custom boxes can be created for unique gift options.

3

Shipping notifications are sent promptly after the order is placed.

03
Seafood Story image 1
Seafood restaurant

Boat-themed decor sets a cozy, ocean-inspired atmosphere that feels fresh and welcoming. Italian dishes like frutti di mare pasta shine with perfect seasoning and vibrant flavors. Regulars love the warm vibe paired with fresh, well-seasoned seafood.

Frutti di mare pasta and seafood pasta come packed with flavor and are perfectly seasoned. Tuscan pasta and avocado salad also stand out with fresh, vibrant tastes.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and full of flavor."

"The seafood here is delicious and so fresh."

"The seafood pasta here is packed with flavor and perfectly seasoned."

Good to know

1

The lunch special offers good value for the price.

2

The restaurant is clean and well-organized.

3

Reservations are recommended during peak hours.

04
Carreau Club image 1

Bright space with four outdoor pétanque courts offers lively competition and chill vibes. Italian dishes shine with perfect al dente pasta and a steak sandwich on ciabatta. Friendly crowd adds Brooklyn energy for casual hangouts or first dates.

Steak sandwich features soft yet slightly crunchy ciabatta bread with gooey cheese and tangy onions. Pasta cooks to perfect al dente and sandwiches like chicken parmesan use chopped deep-fried chicken with melted mozzarella on a toasted hero roll.

People are saying

"Learning pétanque here is a fun activity, and the instructors are so helpful."

"The outdoor space is perfect for epic celebrations and custom menus."

"The pasta here is cooked to a perfect al dente."

Good to know

1

Drinks and renting the court are quite affordable.

2

You can test the waters with hourly reservations.

3

Plan ahead for bigger groups, especially on a rainy day.

05
Zona Sur Bar Bistro image 1
New American restaurant

New American spot shines with authentic house-made pasta and burrata-topped pizzas. Cozy interior and backyard patio offer a warm, casual vibe. Small tables may limit space but add to the intimate feel.

House-made pasta tastes very authentic with dishes like Bolognese and spinach and cheese ravioli standing out. Pizzas feature toppings such as burrata cheese, sopressata, and jalapeño, complementing the Italian flavors well.

People are saying

"The Brunch service here is excellent and so welcoming."

"It's a cozy spot with string lights and a great atmosphere."

"I genuinely crave their delicious Italian food."

Good to know

1

Most mains are priced at $20, which is good value for NYC.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially during busy hours.

3

Happy hour offers strong drinks at reduced prices.

06
Orchid Tea cafe image 1

Cozy tea house offers a homey living room vibe with eclectic decor and a piano for kids. Italian dishes like seafood spaghetti come with unique Asian gratin style and cheesy crust. Quiet, cute spot suits dates and family gatherings perfectly.

Spaghetti comes in an Asian gratin style, slightly soupy with a crusty cheesy top. Dishes like walnut shrimp and sausage spaghetti and seafood spaghetti offer varied flavors.

People are saying

"It felt like hanging out in someone's cozy living room."

"The boba here is perfectly chewy and sweet."

"The owner's warm welcome made me feel right at home with the Italian food."

Good to know

1

This place is cash only; paying cash avoids the electronic service fee.

2

The space is small, so call ahead to ensure a table is available.

3

Customers should either order ahead or be patient due to limited staff.

07
空谷幽兰 (Orchid Tea Cafe 8 Ave) image 1

Dim sum spot offers a homey vintage vibe with soft jazz and live music. Shrimp spaghetti shines as a flavorful Italian dish. Comfortable seating suits solo diners and outdoor fans, making it a cozy, relaxed hangout.

Spaghetti dishes stand out with options like shrimp pasta, beef spaghetti, and sausage varieties. The shrimp spaghetti gets consistent praise for being very good and flavorful.

People are saying

"It's so cozy here with the soft lighting and calming music."

"I tried the spaghetti with shrimp and it was delicious."

"The Italian food, especially the shrimp pasta, is very good."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has live music most nights starting around 7pm.

2

The prices are expensive, with dishes like roasted pork chop costing almost $20.

3

There was no wait to sit on a Sunday afternoon.

08
Cafe 58 Pizzeria & Grill image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy spot with crispy pizza and a peaceful vibe. Popular for penne vodka and Chicken Parm pasta dishes. Friendly crowd includes local workers and medical staff, making it feel authentic and welcoming.

Penne vodka with chicken stands out as a popular dish served in a rich vodka sauce. The menu also features Chicken Parm with spaghetti and a variety of well-made pasta options.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was excellent."

"The food here is incredible, fresh, and full of flavor."

"I loved their penne vodka with chicken in vodka sauce."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a variety of preprepared food and salads.

2

The place is clean and has outdoor seating available.

3

They use top-quality ingredients in their dishes.

09
Gravesend Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza spot shines with large portions of classic Italian dishes like spaghetti and meatballs and grandma pizza. Cramped indoor seating contrasts with ample outdoor space filled with bistro chairs. Lively music fuels a warm, family-friendly vibe.

Pizza and pasta stand out with large portions and good value. Dishes like spaghetti and meatballs, lasagna, grandma pizza, and chicken parmesan offer solid Italian flavors. Freshly made focaccia bread comes with meals and adds a nice touch.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing."

"The food here is really good and delicious."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza and pasta, is amazing."

Good to know

1

The lunch time special is available from 2:00 p.m. to 5:00 p.m.

2

The 2pm-5pm special includes 2 slices and a soda for 5 bucks.

3

Bring cash as they charge a fee for credit cards.

10
Luigi's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Tiny, crowded pizzeria offers fresh mozzarella and pesto for authentic Italian flavor. Outdoor seating spills into the street with nostalgic music and a cash-only grab-and-go vibe. Feels like a family-run New York pizza spot with old-school charm.

Fresh mozzarella slices stand out with perfect texture and rich flavor. The addition of pesto enhances the creamy freshness on the pizza.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best in New York."

"It's a true vintage New York pizza joint with old school charm."

"I thought the fresh mozzarella slice was the best Italian food I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The restaurant only accepts cash; no credit cards are accepted.

2

Pizza slices are priced at $2.75, and soda costs $1.50.

3

They are celebrating their 50th anniversary this year.

11
Brothers Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Space has a Brooklynish vibe with a casual, authentic feel. Italian dishes shine with rich lasagna sauce and tasty Penne Alla Vodka pizza. Gluten-free cauliflower crust and halal pepperoni show care for diverse tastes.

Lasagna stands out with rich sauce worth scraping from the tin. Pizzas like Penne Alla Vodka and Sicilian Square offer solid, tasty options alongside good pasta dishes such as spaghetti with Red Clam Sauce.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be hot, fast, and delicious."

"This place offers an authentic New York pizza experience."

"I loved their amazing pizzas and lasagne; it's the best Italian food."

Good to know

1

Brothers Pizza offers gluten-free pizza with cauliflower crust.

2

The restaurant is open late at night for late-night cravings.

3

You can choose to eat in or take your food to go.

12
Battle Hill Tavern image 1
Pizza restaurant

Classic corner tavern offers a cozy vibe with wood fire pizza and mushroom ravioli as a favorite dish. Sports on TV create a loud atmosphere while outdoor seating welcomes dogs, adding to the friendly energy.

Mushroom ravioli stands out as a favorite dish, ordered every time. Large salads, pecorino cauliflower, and various pizzas also feature prominently alongside pasta and garlic knots.

People are saying

"The bar food is amazing, especially the mac and cheese."

"The salads here are huge and surprisingly well thought out."

"The Italian food, especially the mushroom ravioli, was my favorite."

Good to know

1

The kitchen closes at 9:30 PM.

2

The restaurant has outdoor seating, making it a great spot for people with dogs.

3

Happy hour runs from 4-6 PM with discounted drinks.

13
Mexique Cafe image 1
French restaurant

Cozy spot shines with airy interior and back patio perfect for relaxed dining. Pasta dishes boast rich flavor and great texture. Live music during brunch adds a lively touch to the intimate vibe.

Pasta stands out with rich flavor and great texture. Dishes like coq au vin and the burger also show strong kitchen skills.

People are saying

"The dinner spots here serve hearty, yummy food like steak frites."

"I found the French food here to be a hidden gem."

"The pasta here is crazy good, I couldn't stop eating it."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is BYOB during dinner time.

2

The kids menu only has 2 very basic items: chicken tenders and butter pasta.

3

The restaurant is now open for dinner on Fridays and Saturdays.

14
Giuseppina's image 1
Pizza restaurant

Brick oven and exposed brick walls create a cozy, romantic vibe with old school music setting the tone. Large pizzas have a crispy thin crust and calzones come with marinara and parmesan sides. Atmosphere shifts from chill to lively with groups and kids, making it family-friendly.

Large pizzas come with a crispy thin crust and excellent mozzarella. Calzones include marinara and parmesan as standard sides.

People are saying

"The pizza here is outstanding, with a great crust and fresh toppings."

"I'm still dreaming of their delicious dessert calzone."

"This Italian food's pizza crust is delicious and thin."

Good to know

1

They only accept cash for payment.

2

The restaurant only serves pizza and calzones.

3

The price of the pizza is $30.

15
Dominick's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Old school pizzeria offers crispy New York-style pizza and a family-owned vibe. Homemade lasagna with gooey mozzarella shines alongside unique penne a la vodka. Small booths near the pizza oven create a chill atmosphere with quiet TV shows playing.

Homemade lasagna comes with gooey mozzarella and plenty of sauce. Penne a la vodka with cheese stands out as a unique dish. The menu also offers calzones and carry-out items like rolls and mozzarella sticks.

People are saying

"The food here, especially the pizza, is delicious and varied."

"I thought Dominick's Pizza had the best pizza in this area."

"I was addicted to their Penne a la vodka with cheese."

Good to know

1

2 slices and a can of soda cost $7.

2

The price of a slice of pizza is $3.50.

3

The pizzeria offers much more on the menu than just pizza.

16
Raíces Argentinas image 1

Family-run spot shines with authentic Argentinian wines and live acoustic music in a warm, homey setting. Italian dishes like mouthwatering gnocchi and perfect cheese ravioli add rich flavors. Outdoor seating and dim lighting create a cozy vibe.

Mouthwateringly delicious gnocchi stands out with great texture and flavor. The cheese ravioli delivers pure perfection, while the Pasta Shrimp dish offers a notable seafood pasta option.

People are saying

"The food here is authentic and the service is warm and professional."

"I found the empanadas so delicious and flavorful."

"The Italian food, especially the gnocchi, is mouthwateringly delicious."

Good to know

1

Wine is half price on Wednesdays.

2

Brunch and live jazz are available on weekends.

3

Tango occurs once a month.

17
Rob's of Brooklyn – Sunset Park image 1

Pizza shines with thin, crunchy crust and a perfect cheese-sauce blend. Pasta serves are generous portions, ideal for sharing. Cozy sunset vibe adds warmth to the Italian dining experience.

Pasta dishes come in generous portions, enough for two people. The menu also includes pizza options and sandwiches, offering variety within Italian food.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best tasting in the neighborhood."

"I enjoyed their delicious, fresh, and flavorful salads."

"The Italian food here, especially the pizza, is so good and fresh."

Good to know

1

The prices are reasonable.

2

The pizza is affordable.

3

An order of pasta is enough for 2 people.

18
𝗦𝘂𝗻𝘀𝗲𝘁 𝗣𝗶𝘇𝘇𝗮 (Brooklyn) image 1

Small space with only three tables creates an intimate setting. Friendly staff and cozy decor add to a casual yet stylish vibe. Known for thin, crispy wood-fired crusts and Truffle Mushroom pizza, it offers authentic Italian flavors and big slices perfect for quick bites or gatherings.

Rich earthy flavors come through in the Truffle Mushroom pizza with melted mozzarella and parmesan. Classic options like the Margherita with marinara sauce and mozzarella pies with vodka sauce also stand out.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be amazing."

"The Italian food here has amazing, flavorful pizzas with a wood-fired crust."

"I received great pizza from this delivery."

Good to know

1

Prices are slightly higher than average, but the quality justifies the cost.

2

Customers can purchase pizza by the slice or as a whole pie.

3

Seats could be limited during busy hours.

19
Siren Restaurant & Bar image 1
Seafood restaurant

Modern seafood spot shines with fresh oysters and outstanding cocktails in a cozy, elegant setting. Lobster ravioli offers rich flavor and pasta is always well-prepared. Perfect for casual meals or special occasions with a welcoming vibe.

Lobster ravioli stands out with rich flavor. The pasta is consistently outstanding and well-prepared.

People are saying

"The oysters here are so fresh and flavorful."

"I found the cocktails to be delicious and worth trying."

"The Italian food here, especially the linguine and clams, is perfectly cooked and flavored."

Good to know

1

Siren provides $1 oysters during Happy Hour.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays.

3

The bottomless brunch offered at the restaurant is amazing.

20
Jey Diner image 1

Small, cozy space with mismatched furniture creates a peaceful vibe. Family-run warmth shines through friendly energy and soft background music. Pasta dishes impress with solid quality spaghetti, though lasagna falls short.

Pasta dishes stand out with solid quality, especially the spaghetti. The lasagna does not meet expectations.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and fresh."

"The eggs here are fluffy, rich, and fresh."

"The pasta here is really good."

Good to know

1

The diner has a large menu with a variety of different options.

2

The prices are reasonable and offer good value.

3

You can take away food or place orders by phone.

Discover more

Sunset Park, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...