Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in the West Village

Italian food and cake

Ending a long meal with a slice of cake feels like the only way to properly close the night.

Based on 862 Opinions
+859
User
User
User
Updated
01
L’industrie Pizzeria West Village image 1
L’industrie Pizzeria West Village image 2
L’industrie Pizzeria West Village image 3
View all

Small space with very limited seating creates a crowded, loud atmosphere where most people stand or eat quickly. Long lines form regularly, drawing a steady flow of pizza lovers. The show of slice assembly adds an engaging visual element to the busy environment.

Pizza with burrata stands out here. The burrata slice offers a creamy, rich topping that defines the Italian food experience.

Pistachio tres leches and olive oil cake stand out with rich, unique flavors. The carrot cake and ice cream offer a satisfying, sweet finish.

People are saying

"The burrata slice is amazing, with a thin, crispy crust."

"The burrata slices are absolutely amazing and a must-try."

"The tiramisu is tasty with a nice coffee flavor."

Good to know

1

Expect a line, especially during peak hours.

2

To avoid long waits, visit on weekdays from 2-4 pm.

3

Seating is very limited, making it unsuitable for large groups.

02
Osteria Nonnino image 1
Osteria Nonnino image 2
Osteria Nonnino image 3
View all

Italian restaurant offers tableside pasta preparation and live culinary shows in a cozy, beautifully decorated space with outdoor seating. Atmosphere is lively but can be noisy due to cramped seating and sound reverberation. Guests enjoy a warm, inviting vibe with a mix of contemporary and rustic design elements.

Spicy rigatoni and gnocchi stand out among the pastas served. The tiramisu is noted for its exceptional quality. All dishes come with a consistently high level of flavor and care.

Pistachio lava cake stands out as a dessert highlight. The tiramisu is prepared tableside, adding a fresh touch to the dessert options.

People are saying

"The tableside Cacio e Pepe pasta is phenomenal."

"I love the cozy vibe and real Italian flavors."

"I highly recommend this spot for real Italian food."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended due to high demand.

2

Expect long wait times for walk-ins, especially during peak hours.

3

Happy hour runs until 7pm with discounts on drinks and snacks.

03
The Mary Lane image 1
The Mary Lane image 2
The Mary Lane image 3
View all

Outdoor seating offers a large covered area suitable for any weather, while indoor spaces feature dark wood and muted colors with perfect lighting. Atmosphere ranges from romantic and cozy to lively, though noise levels can be high due to room layout causing echoes. A private event space downstairs accommodates larger groups or meetings.

Burrata appetizer stands out for its quality. The chicken cacciatore ravioli shows clever preparation and good execution. The menu also features white truffle risotto, halibut, oysters, and fries.

Olive oil cakes stand out here, especially the versions with candied rhubarb and almond. These cakes offer a delicate finish that complements the meal well.

People are saying

"I loved the flavorful dishes, especially the ravioli and burrata."

"The Italian food's olive oil almond cake is the perfect ending."

"The olive oil almond cake was a surprising and perfect ending."

Good to know

1

Make reservations because the restaurant gets busy.

2

Expect to pay about $70 per person if you have some wine, appetizers, and entrees.

3

The kitchen at the Mary Lane closes between 9:30 PM and 10:30 PM.

04
OLIO E PIÙ image 1
OLIO E PIÙ image 2
OLIO E PIÙ image 3
View all

Italian restaurant offers beautiful interior with close tables creating a loud, lively atmosphere. Outdoor seating provides a laid-back, cozy patio experience with plants and heating. Crowds fill the space, making it energetic and bustling.

Carbonara stands out as a signature dish, praised for its rich flavor and perfect texture. The spaghetti with clams also offers a fresh and satisfying pasta option.

Olive oil cake stands out as a frequent dessert choice, often served with complimentary generosity. Other sweet options include flourless chocolate cake and panna cotta, all prepared with care by the staff.

People are saying

"I thought the Italian food, especially the carbonara, was delicious."

"I think the Italian food here is some of the best around."

"The food tastes truly Italian and the portions are generous."

Good to know

1

Happy hour starts at 3 PM and offers great deals.

2

Reservations are highly recommended, especially on weekends.

3

Olio offers a three-course dinner during New York restaurant week.

05
4 Charles Prime Rib image 1
4 Charles Prime Rib image 2
4 Charles Prime Rib image 3
View all

Steak house offers an intimate, clubby interior with classical music and a snug patio that extends the dining experience outdoors with air-conditioned seating. The atmosphere feels quaint and charming, perfect for quiet conversation and special occasions. Limited seating creates a cozy vibe without feeling cramped.

Spaghetti carbonara stands out as an unexpected highlight. The Cacio e Pepe pasta also impresses, offering a strong Italian flavor despite the broader menu.

Coconut cake stands out with its unreal flavor and texture. The chocolate cake topped with whipped cream and ganache also draws attention as a rich dessert option.

People are saying

"The coconut cake was an absolute standout and so good."

"The Cacio e Pepe Carbonara Pasta here is amazing."

"I love the rich chocolate cake and sundaes here."

Good to know

1

Reservations need to be booked 30 days in advance.

2

Reservations open on their website 7 days ahead and refresh at 9am ET daily.

3

The market price for the porterhouse was $350.

06
L'Artusi image 1
L'Artusi image 2
L'Artusi image 3
View all

Stylish Italian restaurant with two floors including a skylit upper level and a wine cellar private room for groups. Atmosphere is loud and crowded, with tables placed close together, making conversation challenging. Outdoor seating offers heating but can be affected by nearby trash bins.

Pasta takes center stage here, with dishes like the crab pasta standing out for their flavor. The menu focuses heavily on Italian pasta specialties that appeal to pasta lovers.

Olive oil cake stands out with its rich flavor and is a consistent favorite. Salted chocolate cake offers a balanced texture combining cake, popcorn, and gelato.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is delicious, especially the pasta dishes."

"You have to try the olive oil cake; it's wonderful."

"The olive oil cake is a unique and delicious treat."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended and should be made at least two weeks in advance.

2

Expect long wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

A minimum 20% tip is expected for service.

07
Realmuto: Italian Pastry & Gelato image 1
Realmuto: Italian Pastry & Gelato image 2
Realmuto: Italian Pastry & Gelato image 3
View all

Elegant, spacious coffee shop channels authentic Italian café vibes with stylish, luxurious interior and live jazz music. Atmosphere feels lively and inviting, reminiscent of historic Italian piazzas. Offers homemade pasta and a refined pastry display, creating a genuine Italian dining experience.

Homemade pasta stands out with dishes like herb tortellini and pappardelle ragu. Risotto, lightly fried calamari, crostini with caponata, and gelato add variety to the Italian menu.

Hazelnut chocolate sponge cake stands out with its perfectly balanced flavors and moderate sweetness. Italian master baker crafts a variety of beautiful pastries and cakes displayed in large cases, all priced reasonably for celebrations.

People are saying

"You have to try their Italian pastries; they're the best I've ever had."

"I love how authentic and Italian this place feels."

"The chocolate sponge cake with hazelnut mousse is superb."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required for lunch or dinner service.

2

Expect a casual atmosphere suitable for both quick visits and formal dining.

3

Desserts are highly recommended, especially the gelato.

08
Roey's image 1
Roey's image 2
Roey's image 3
View all

Woodfire oven and open kitchen create a gorgeous interior with cozy seating and beautiful decor. Outdoor space offers lovely summer seating ideal for people watching and enjoying drinks. Atmosphere ranges from peaceful indoors to lively and loud when crowded, with a strict one-hour seating limit.

Chicken parmigiana features a spectacular sear and comes with a small salad but lacks a larger pasta portion. The truffle pasta and Soppressata pizza with Calabrian chili and fennel honey offer bold, complementary flavors.

Olive oil cake stands out with its spongy, juicy texture and melts in the mouth. It comes with complimentary ice cream and serves as a delicious end to the meal.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the chicken parmesan, is so cheesy and saucy."

"I thought the olive oil cake melted in my mouth."

"I love the authentic Italian food here."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially on busy nights.

2

Happy hour runs from 4 PM to 6 PM on weekdays.

3

The happy hour offers $6 Margherita pizzas and $5 spritz’s.

09
Wild image 1
Wild image 2
Wild image 3
View all

Small restaurant with cozy indoor and heated outdoor seating creates a beautiful, relaxed atmosphere ideal for gluten-free dining. Tables are tightly spaced, which may feel cramped for taller guests. Outdoor patio offers pleasant sidewalk seating with heat lamps that keep the space warm even in cooler weather.

Gluten free pasta stands out with expert craftsmanship and great flavor. The burrata prosciutto pizza features fresh ingredients and a perfectly baked crust.

Flourless chocolate cake stands out and is available on the menu alongside pizza. Gluten-free options include a small cake gifted by the staff. Birthday visits come with a free slice of cake.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is amazing, especially the gluten-free pasta."

"The flourless chocolate cake is the best dessert."

"You have to get the chocolate cake; it's perfect."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is fully gluten-free, which is a key aspect.

2

The restaurant does not honor reservations.

3

Happy hours are from Monday to Friday, 12-7 pm, with $5 off any drink.

10
Little Ruby's West Village image 1
Little Ruby's West Village image 2
Little Ruby's West Village image 3
View all

Two-level layout with two bars and indoor and outdoor seating creates a dynamic, cozy vibe filled with plants and modern decor. Loud music often fills the space, making conversations challenging but adding to the energetic atmosphere. Cocktails like the Yuzu Jalapeño Margarita stand out among the offerings.

Vodka pasta stands out with its special, flavorful taste and creamy texture. The creamy chicken pasta cooks to al dente perfection, making the pasta dishes consistently delicious and affordable.

Chocolate cake stands out with its gluten-free recipe and rich flavor. Hot cakes also deliver a satisfying, well-executed option for dessert.

People are saying

"The pasta dishes are mostly tasty and well cooked."

"I kept coming back for the amazing shrimp pasta."

"The menu has great variety with standout pasta options."

Good to know

1

Having a reservation is recommended due to the restaurant's popularity.

2

Breakfast is served until 4pm at this Ruby's location.

3

Dinner only starts at 5 PM.

11
Felice on Hudson image 1
Felice on Hudson image 2
Felice on Hudson image 3
View all

Italian restaurant offers understated sophistication in a cozy, dimly lit setting with beautiful interior design and an attentive bar. The atmosphere feels romantic and casual, attracting locals and creating a relaxed vibe. Tables near the kitchen corridor add a unique spatial dynamic to the dining experience.

Carbonara rivals dishes from Rome. Ricotta with honey and gnudi pasta stand out alongside a unique burger. Liver mousse and salami work well as an appetizer or bread topping.

Pistachio cake stands out with its rich flavor and pairs well with pistachio ice cream or gelato. Desserts here include a notable tiramisu as well.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is stellar, and the service is impeccable."

"The pistachio cake here is among the best I've ever had."

"I always choose this place over new Italian spots."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended in advance to secure a table.

2

Happy hour offers a variety of drinks and snacks at reduced prices.

3

The happy hour menu is available until 8pm, so arrive early.

12
Rosemary's image 1
Rosemary's image 2
Rosemary's image 3
View all

Spacious Italian restaurant with rustic yet fresh atmosphere and gorgeous interior decor. Noise levels rise due to high ceilings and closely set tables, making conversation challenging. Features a rooftop garden growing herbs and greens, with covered outdoor seating that allows pets.

Pasta dishes shine with creamy carbonara and fresh, salty Chitarra Alla Carbonara. Exceptional focaccia with prosciutto and burrata complements the menu, alongside fantastic whipped burrata and cacio e Pepe polenta.

Olive oil cake stands out with its distinct flavor and often sells out. Staff offer a cake cutting service when you bring your own birthday cake.

People are saying

"You have to try the focaccia; it's outstanding and super light."

"The Italian food here tastes fresh and authentic."

"I always crave the olive oil cake for dessert."

Good to know

1

Reservations are a must on weekends due to high demand.

2

Happy hour runs from 4 PM to 6 PM with $9 cocktails.

3

Bottomless mimosas are available for one hour during brunch.

13
Sant Ambroeus West Village image 1
Sant Ambroeus West Village image 2
Sant Ambroeus West Village image 3
View all

Italian cafe blends modern and old-fashioned styles with close tables in a cozy, romantic atmosphere. Indoor and outdoor seating sit on a quiet street corner, creating a relaxed vibe despite occasional unruly guests.

Pasta delivers a flavor explosion with every bite and comes perfectly cooked and rich. Gluten-free options taste just as good, and plates often arrive pre-split for easy sharing.

Princess cake stands out as a highly praised dessert, described as exceptional and the best cake ever had. Surprise birthday cakes come with berries and add a special touch to celebrations.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the pasta, is incredibly flavorful."

"The Italian food tastes authentic and classy."

"The Princess cake is the best cake I ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended at the restaurant to secure a table.

2

The restaurant is often full, making walk-ins difficult.

3

Prices are on the higher side, so budget accordingly.

14
Saint Theo's image 1
Saint Theo's image 2
Saint Theo's image 3
View all

Interior showcases gorgeous decor and cozy lighting with comfortable booths and corner banquettes. Atmosphere turns loud and lively as the evening progresses, making conversation challenging. Bar offers exceptional cocktails crafted by skilled bartenders, adding to the energetic vibe.

Fresh focaccia starts the meal, followed by ricotta pasta with chili oil and mozzarella in carrozza. Main dishes include perfectly cooked shellfish pasta, lamb chops, and flavorful braised short rib.

Warm, rich chocolate lava cake features velvety chocolate oozing from the center. Olive oil cake offers a great, delicious dessert option alongside tiramisu.

People are saying

"The pasta here is unreal; I'd reorder the short rib ragu."

"Some say the Italian food feels average and not traditional."

"The dishes mix Italian flavors with a modern twist."

Good to know

1

Reservations are needed, especially for dinner service.

2

The restaurant only has tables available at 5:30 PM or 10 PM.

3

The bar scene is packed on Friday nights.

15
Barbuto image 1
Barbuto image 2
Barbuto image 3
View all

Spacious dining area with riverviews and an open kitchen creates a lively yet cozy atmosphere. The crowd tends to be mature, favoring relaxed nights out over trendy scenes. Natural light and a stainless steel pizza oven add distinctive touches to the setting.

Gnocchi stands out with a creamed corn sauce and pairs well with chicken and salsa verde. Carbonara, meatballs, and shrimp spaghetti also deliver solid Italian flavors.

Pistachio nut cake stands out with rich flavor and pairs well with pistachio gelato. Coconut cake offers a divine taste, while chocolate hazelnut cake feels light and finishes the meal smoothly.

People are saying

"The Italian food here has amazing, attentive, and knowledgeable staff."

"I think it's a solid Italian spot."

"The pistachio cake here is amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for parties of three or more due to high demand.

2

The restaurant keeps a few seats open for walk-ins.

3

The restaurant does not provide a menu before 5:00 PM.

16
I Sodi image 1
I Sodi image 2
I Sodi image 3
View all

Courtyard seating and a small bar with candlelight create an intimate setting with cozy ambiance and dark wood decor. The space hosts a diverse crowd, offering a quiet weeknight atmosphere with a slight view into the kitchen. Italian cocktails, especially Negronis crafted with precision, complement the elegant yet simple dining experience.

Lasagna stands out with versions like artichoke and sugo that impress deeply. Pasta dishes, including broken noodle and pesto pasta, deliver strong, memorable flavors.

Flourless chocolate cake offers the right thickness and richness. It stands out as a superb dessert option.

People are saying

"I always look forward to their lasagna and pasta."

"The homemade Italian food, especially the pasta, just melts in your mouth."

"Some desserts like tiramisu can really hit the spot."

Good to know

1

Reservations are competitive as they open at midnight and are only available for 2 weeks in advance.

2

You need to put your name on the list upon arrival.

3

Expect a 3-hour wait for a table during peak times.

17
Perry St image 1
Perry St image 2
Perry St image 3
View all

Sleek, modern space with big glass windows offering water views and natural light. Atmosphere feels chic and upscale yet maintains a cozy, relaxed vibe with comfortable seating and elegant decor. Layout includes lounge couches, booths, and a bar area near the entrance, suited for dates or work dinners.

Butter Poached Maine Lobster comes with potato garlic ravioli and lemongrass broth, offering a tender and buttery taste. Pasta dishes vary, with some being delicious and others bland and lacking seasoning.

Molten Chocolate Cake features a moist cake with hot fudge and a chocolate crumble served alongside vanilla ice cream. Chocolate cake pairs well with ice cream and tastes rich.

People are saying

"The molten chocolate cake is a reliable, tasty choice."

"The molten chocolate cake is moist and delicious."

"The pasta dishes really hit the spot."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for the tasting menu.

2

The total cost for the tasting menu is $200 per person, including tips.

3

Parking is available and not a problem at this restaurant.

18
Dante West Village image 1
Dante West Village image 2
Dante West Village image 3
View all

Bar offers beautifully designed interior with candlelit booths and live piano music creating a perfect vibe. Outdoor seating provides a comfortable, relaxed atmosphere slightly removed from street noise. Bartenders craft cocktails visibly, adding to the engaging energy.

Risotto with mushrooms and oysters stands out as a signature dish. Burrata and arancini also feature prominently, alongside fresh oysters, trout salad, chicken alla diavolo, and tiramisu for dessert.

Flourless chocolate cake offers a slightly bitter, not too sweet flavor and pairs well with cocktails. The carrot cake stands out as notably good, while tiramisu also appears on the menu.

People are saying

"I loved the fresh burrata and perfect tiramisu."

"The mushroom risotto was rich, comforting, and cooked to perfection."

"I enjoyed drinks and the burrata here."

Good to know

1

Making a reservation for Friday Martini Hour is highly recommended.

2

Martini hour is from 3 PM to 5 PM with $10 martinis.

3

Expect to wait for a seat if you don’t have a reservation.

19
Bobo image 1
Bobo image 2
Bobo image 3
View all

French restaurant occupies a brick townhouse with multiple seating areas including a cozy downstairs bar, classic main dining room, and a garden patio for outdoor dining. Atmosphere shifts from warm and intimate in private spaces to lively and bustling on busy evenings. Known for excellent espresso martinis and a relaxed yet vibrant vibe.

Unbelievable gnocchi stands out, especially the Parisian Gnocchi which ranks among top dishes. Mushroom gnocchi and chicken fricasse also deliver strong Italian flavors.

Chocolate lava cake appears often as a dessert choice, sometimes served cold. The molten chocolate cake and lemon tart also stand out as dessert options.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the gnocchi and appetizers, is rich and tasty."

"I love how rich and tasty the gnocchi and risotto are."

"The molten chocolate lava cake was decadent and stole my heart."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4 PM to 7 PM with $2 oysters.

2

Bobo offers a $30 dinner deal during restaurant week.

3

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant is very popular.

20
Jack & Charlie’s No. 118 image 1
Jack & Charlie’s No. 118 image 2
Jack & Charlie’s No. 118 image 3
View all

Space blends old and new world charm with cozy dark wood and warm decor, creating an atmosphere like a modern country club. Energy ranges from romantic and approachable to lively, with guests often speaking loudly. A wood-fired oven and a Bloody Mary cart add unique touches to the dining experience.

Bolognese stands out with a rich, hearty flavor that often leads to ordering seconds. Homemade pastas highlight the chef's skill and define the Italian offerings here.

People are saying

"The Italian Food here is outstanding, especially the bolognese."

"Some pasta dishes were good but forgettable."

"I loved the bolognese and their homemade pastas."

Good to know

1

Reservations are honored promptly, especially for early dinner times.

2

A 3% surcharge is added to the check, which can be waived upon request.

3

Credit card payments incur a service charge; cash is recommended to avoid fees.

21
Via Carota image 1
Via Carota image 2
Via Carota image 3
View all

Italian gastroteca offers communal dining tables and a carefully curated menu that honors traditional roots. Atmosphere shifts from noisy indoors to quiet back room and a heated outdoor terrace perfect for people watching. Drinks include an amazing Negroni menu and unique spritzes.

Meyer Lemon Risotto stands out as a signature dish. The cacio e pepe offers a simple yet rich flavor. The affogato provides a sweet finish to the meal.

Chocolate lava cake offers a rich, indulgent experience with a molten center. Olive Oil Cake comes moist and fragrant, with a subtle sweetness that pairs well with espresso.

People are saying

"The cacio e pepe here is the best Italian food I've ever had."

"I think the Italian food here is truly authentic and delicious."

"This place feels cozy and serves real Italian dishes."

Good to know

1

To avoid the wait, go right before peak lunch or dinner dining hours.

2

The wait time at the restaurant is over 45 minutes.

3

Walking in on a less busy day is recommended.

Discover more

West Village, New York

Area guide