Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Port Jefferson

Date spots

Made for those who believe a shared meal is the only way to properly gauge chemistry on a first date.

Based on 542 Opinions
+539
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Ditch -- Port Jefferson image 1
Ditch -- Port Jefferson image 2
Ditch -- Port Jefferson image 3
View all

Restaurant offers beachy vibes with live music at a volume that allows conversation. Decor includes surfboards and bicycles hanging from the ceiling, creating a chill atmosphere reminiscent of California. Tacos and margaritas stand out as popular choices among diners.

Food here is consistently fresh and flavorful with a variety of dishes that impress. The menu pairs well with a large bar setup and friendly service, making meals enjoyable and satisfying.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and fantastic."

"The tacos and drinks here are outstanding for Date Spots."

"The seafood here is amazing, and the staff is so accommodating."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm with great drink specials.

2

Tacos are reasonably priced at around $5 each.

3

Reservations are not required but recommended during peak hours.

02
Black Pearl Seafood Chophouse image 1

Outdoor dining on a waterside deck offers amazing marina views and a breezy atmosphere. Live music and occasional DJ sets create a lively energy, with guests enjoying drinks and dancing. The space balances comfort and class, making it welcoming and memorable.

Food here offers great taste paired with impeccable service. Dining delivers a top-tier experience with well-prepared dishes and attentive staff.

Steaks like the Porterhouse cooked to perfection create a memorable meal. Sharing dishes like a feta salad adds a fresh touch to the night.

People are saying

"The food here is great, and the service is attentive."

"The staff here is so attentive and makes you feel welcomed."

"The service here makes it a great spot for a date."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for special events like New Year's Eve.

2

Parking is easy and available near the restaurant.

3

Expect limited dessert options; only three crรจme brรปlรฉes were available on a Monday night.

03
Muse Paintbar - Port Jefferson image 1

Painting studio offers a relaxed upbeat vibe with step-by-step instructions and a bar serving food and drinks. Walls display staff creations and themed decor, creating an artsy yet welcoming space. Suitable for families, groups, and date nights, it encourages creativity without pressure.

Delicious food and drinks come with a bar serving tasty appetizers and finger foods. The beverage and food bites offer a satisfying mix during visits.

Couples enjoy paint nights like "Starry Night" for a creative and engaging date. The setting works well for both small groups and pairs looking for a unique night out.

People are saying

"The instructors here make the fun activities so easy and engaging."

"The instructors here are so helpful and knowledgeable for Date Spots."

"The staff here are so helpful and encouraging."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for special events like paint your pet night.

2

The venue has a no cancel policy for classes with fewer than four sign-ups.

3

All painting supplies are included in the session price.

04
Tara Inn image 1

Small pub with old school tavern appeal and outdated dรฉcor creates an authentic dive bar vibe. Atmosphere stays unpretentious and super chill, fostering easy conversation and a friendly crowd. Features include pool table, jukebox, and pinball machines, with affordable food and drinks that attract a loyal community.

Bar-style food includes a marinated Porterhouse steak and seasonal lobsters cooked well. Meals come at reasonable prices and are made to order with quick delivery.

A cool spot for dates with great lobsters that stand out. Couples find it worth trying after casual visits.

People are saying

"The food here is pretty good and great for the price."

"I thought the lobster was great and the prices were reasonable."

"The food here is great, especially the lobster."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm with great drink deals and appetizers.

2

Tara Inn is cash only; an ATM on-site charges $3 per transaction.

3

Food is available until 3am, perfect for late-night cravings.

05
Grumpy Jack's image 1
Bar & grill

Sports bar with loud, lively atmosphere and small, cozy interior filled with multiple TVs showing games. Crowd is friendly and energetic, especially near the bar during busy times. Unique buttery wing sauce stands out among food offerings.

Offers a very large selection of pub food with consistently excellent quality. Prices stay reasonable while delivering delicious meals.

Later dinners feature a burger with Swiss cheese and pastrami that looks and tastes great. Drinks accompany the meal well for a relaxed birthday dinner vibe.

People are saying

"The food here is always great and delicious."

"The bar food here is unpretentious and amazing."

"The food here is amazing, especially the perfectly cooked burger."

Good to know

1

Happy hour drinks are half price, making it a popular time to visit.

2

Reservations are recommended as the place gets busy, especially on weekends.

3

Parking can be difficult to find on busy nights, so plan ahead.

06
Prohibition Port Jefferson image 1
American restaurant

Small space with nostalgic ambiance and excellent sound system sets a lively, inviting mood. Music spans all decades, creating a fun, energetic vibe. Seating includes a bar area and cozy booths, offering both social and private options.

Food includes a chicken sandwich, great fries, and a notable pretzel. Vegan options taste good. Service is quick.

Incredible food sets the tone with a standout chicken sandwich and the best pretzel around. Cocktails and brunch options like a Belgian waffle add variety, while the staff offers attentive service even on busy nights.

People are saying

"I thought the cocktails were really tasty and balanced."

"I thought the food here was super good and delicious."

"The Mediterranean platter at these Date Spots is a nice, shareable assortment."

Good to know

1

Expect a 40-minute wait during busy dinner hours.

2

Gift cards are not accepted due to new ownership.

3

The menu features a variety of locally sourced food options.

07
Barito Tacos & Cocktails image 1
Mexican restaurant

Open space with large windows offers harbor views and a loft ceiling on the second floor. Atmosphere is loud and vibrant, filled with young people and lively energy, making it suited for parties and gatherings. Decor combines wood and steel for a cool, inviting vibe.

Mexican food tastes great and stays consistent. Both food and drinks come at good prices and maintain high quality.

Affordable plates like a burrito, tostones, and tacos make sharing easy. Drinks include martinis and Jarritos, fitting for a casual afternoon date.

People are saying

"I loved the tacos and margaritas here."

"I found the food here to be really tasty."

"The food here is so tasty, it's perfect for Date Spots."

Good to know

1

Taco Tuesday offers half-off tacos and $5 margaritas.

2

Happy hour features $5 margaritas and runs from 4-7pm on weekdays.

3

The restaurant offers the full menu during brunch, which is uncommon in the area.

08
PJ Lobster House image 1
Seafood restaurant

Upscale nautical decor combines with two bars and a fresh fish market under one roof, creating a lively setting. The atmosphere is casual and laid-back but can get noisy when busy. Seating includes booths, tables, and elevated spots offering varied views.

Food offers excellent quality and generous portions with great value. Service complements the dining well despite parking challenges.

Friendly, attentive bartenders create a welcoming atmosphere for couples dining at the bar. Desserts like creme brulee add a sweet touch to special occasions such as anniversaries and birthdays.

People are saying

"I thought the sushi here was the best in the area."

"I found the lobster here to be spectacular and perfectly done."

"The seafood here is amazing, especially the shrimp scampi."

Good to know

1

Parking can be tricky, especially during busy times.

2

There is a paid parking lot available nearby.

3

Happy Hour offers discounts on drinks and appetizers.

Discover more

Port Jefferson, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...