Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Wantagh

Food and seafood spots

Fresh seafood deserves a setting where the meal is the main event.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Ole's Fajitas - Supreme Mexican image 1
Ole's Fajitas - Supreme Mexican image 2
Ole's Fajitas - Supreme Mexican image 3
View all

Mexican restaurant with laid-back atmosphere and upbeat Mexican music creates a warm, welcoming vibe. Clean, casual interior resembles a fast food spot with simple seating. Known for large portions and fresh, flavorful Tex-Mex dishes like birria and carne asada tacos.

Quality Mexican cuisine comes with great food and large portions served right on time. The dishes consistently taste delicious and offer good value for the price.

Corn fried shrimp tacos stand out with a unique sauce and plenty of shrimp. Dishes often combine shrimp with other flavors like steak or veggies, offering fresh, flavorful options.

People are saying

"This Mexican food is so fresh and flavorful, it's like a trip to Mexico."

"I found the food here to be delicious."

"The shrimp tacos here are fresh and stuffed with plenty of shrimp."

Good to know

1

BOGO deals are available on Tuesdays and Thursdays.

2

Lunch specials are offered during the week.

3

Portion sizes are large and provide good value for the price.

02
New Wave Seafood image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant combines cozy atmosphere with an attached fresh seafood market offering both raw and prepared options. The space fills with a loud, lively vibe that challenges quiet conversation, attracting mostly couples and an older crowd. Clean and neat interior supports a casual dining experience with standout fresh seafood dishes.

Food features exceptional freshness and excellent quality with dishes like sole stuffed with crab meat. Portions are generous and prices fair, creating a consistently satisfying dining experience.

Seafood here is consistently fresh and cold with a great selection including baked clams and lobster raviolis. The Manhattan Chowder stands out as a notable dish among the offerings.

People are saying

"The seafood staff here is so friendly and helpful."

"The seafood at this market is always fresh and cooked perfectly."

"I found the food here to be excellent."

Good to know

1

There is ample parking available in the paved lot out front.

2

The restaurant maintains a high standard of cleanliness.

3

Expect to wait as there are no reservations accepted.

03
The Original Salpino of Wantagh image 1

Small deli space feels cramped and old with a cold atmosphere that causes condensation on salads. Shelves resemble an exaggerated convenience store with a large variety of pre-packaged foods made in-store. Sandwiches and prepared foods often impress with great recommendations and ample, fresh presentation.

Food arrives hot and on time with a large variety of fresh, pre-packaged items made in-store. Everything tastes delicious and consistent.

Shrimp dishes stand out with perfect cooking and full flavor. Stuffed shrimp comes with a fresh, ample fruit platter and sides like broccoli and potatoes.

People are saying

"The stuffed shrimp were beautifully presented and fresh."

"The sandwiches here are amazing, especially the chicken parm sub."

"I found the food here to be absolutely delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect 20-30 minute wait times at the deli during peak hours.

2

Parking can be challenging, especially during busy times.

3

Delivery services are reliable, with food arriving hot and on time.

04
Gatsby On The Ocean image 1

Outdoor space features a tented area with ocean views and an outdoor bar with a nice breeze. Indoor areas include a sushi station and a seafood bar, supporting lively events with music from a DJ and band. The venue suits intimate ceremonies and celebrations with a fun, special atmosphere.

Lobster rolls come with butter and stand out alongside shrimp tacos and baked clams. A seafood bar offers a strong selection with crab cakes, wontons, and carving stations.

People are saying

"The staff here are attentive and make sure you have everything you need."

"The food here was delicious and everyone raved about it."

"Elyse and her team made our wedding day absolutely magical."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for events to ensure availability.

2

The venue offers beautiful ocean views, perfect for wedding photos.

3

Expect a smooth operation with attentive staff during events.

05
North Shore Farms image 1
Grocery store

Narrow aisles hold high stacks of glass-filled items, creating a compact shopping space. The atmosphere feels welcoming with a strong fresh fish scent and a well-stocked deli and bakery offering fresh bread and quality produce. Prices run higher than most markets, reflecting the emphasis on high-quality foods and specialty items.

Fresh fruits and vegetables come in large quantities with a separate organic area. Italian food is excellent and fresh, alongside a huge selection of bakery bread and prepared foods.

Fresh fish and a wide selection stand out at the seafood counter. Shrimp and crab salad are common picks, and the fish department consistently offers very fresh options.

People are saying

"The deli here has excellent meats and prepared foods."

"You'll find a huge selection of fresh food, especially great breads and baked goods."

"I found the seafood here to be super fresh."

Good to know

1

Prices are higher than most other markets.

2

The store has a wide selection of fish and a decent selection of meat.

3

Sales in the circular are usually very good.

06
The Irish Poet Restaurant Bar image 1

Irish pub combines spacious interior with multiple TVs lining the walls for watching various games. Atmosphere stays laid back and friendly, with genuine American country music playing instead of traditional Irish bands. Seating options include a large bar and dining area, supporting both casual drinks and group gatherings.

Food here is consistently great and delicious with a menu that offers exceptional dishes like steak tidbits. Drinks complement the meals well, and the service is friendly and welcoming.

Shrimp and potatoes come out well-prepared. Fish and chips feature three pieces of fresh fish on a plate loaded with fries, though the fish could be crispier.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be terrific and consistently fresh."

"This Irish pub has friendly staff and wonderful food."

"I had the fish and chips with three pieces of fresh fish."

Good to know

1

Karaoke night happens every Tuesday at 8pm with no cover charge.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially on busy nights like St. Patrick's Day.

3

Parking is available in both front and back lots, making access easy.

07
Wantagh Inn image 1
American restaurant

Old Irish style fills the space with cozy, warm decor and heavy, sturdy furniture. A lively, loud atmosphere dominates, especially near the large bar area with an enormous TV. Separate dining rooms offer quieter spots for private gatherings amid a friendly local crowd.

Food offers excellent quality with a spectacular taste. Separate dining areas create a private yet lively atmosphere enhancing the meal experience.

Baked clams stand out with a crunchy texture but have mild flavor. Fish and chips offer a crisp coating but contain little fish.

People are saying

"The dinner spots here have delicious appetizers and perfectly cooked entrees."

"The food here was really good."

"The seafood here has a great atmosphere."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for steak night on Thursdays.

2

Steak night offers a choice of flat iron, skirt, or sirloin steak for $30.

3

The lunch prix fixe includes salad or soup, dessert, and coffee at a great price.

08
DJ's Clam Shack Wantagh image 1
Seafood restaurant

Small seafood shack with seaside charm and limited indoor seating creates a chill, hometown vibe. The space feels cozy but simple, with decorative touches that highlight its character. It stays quiet during off-peak times and offers a focused menu centered on lobster and clam dishes.

Food comes out hot and fresh with perfect portion sizes for lunch. Staff brings orders promptly to the table, and the dishes feature fresh fish prepared to perfection.

Fresh fish and seafood shine here with shrimp tacos, lobster rolls, and stuffed clams standing out. Fried clams, coconut shrimp, and grilled garlic shrimp rolls add variety, though the overall selection stays limited.

People are saying

"I thought the lobster roll was done just right."

"The food here is delicious and cooked to perfection."

"I thought the seafood roll was good and buttery."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in the lot, but it can be tight.

2

Consider parking on nearby side streets or at the train station parking lot.

3

The menu includes Mahi Mahi tacos for $14, served with two big tacos and a side.

Discover more

Wantagh, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...