Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Wantagh

Salad and food spots

A salad that actually leaves you full instead of just serving as a light appetizer before the real meal.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Otto's Delicatessen image 1
Otto's Delicatessen image 2
Otto's Delicatessen image 3
View all

Deli with authentic German-style potato salad and specialty sandwiches featuring thinly sliced ingredients. Atmosphere is clean and convenient, with early hours and a steady pace. Prices tend to be higher than nearby spots, reflecting detailed charges for components like bread and credit card use.

Potato salad stands out with its authentic German-style and thinly sliced potatoes that soak up all the juices, avoiding any dry spots. Macaroni salad also impresses with a creamy texture that is not pasty.

Food here is consistently fresh and delicious with generous portions. Meals never disappoint and offer solid flavor.

People are saying

"I'll be back for pounds of their potato salad."

"I found this deli to be the best on Long Island."

"Their potato salad is the best I've had, not pasty at all."

Good to know

1

Expect a 20-minute wait for pickup orders during lunch hours.

2

Prices for sandwiches start around $7.80, with additional charges for extras.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but there is a surcharge for using them.

02
Ole's Fajitas - Supreme Mexican image 1

Mexican restaurant with laid-back atmosphere and upbeat Mexican music creates a warm, welcoming vibe. Clean, casual interior resembles a fast food spot with simple seating. Known for large portions and fresh, flavorful Tex-Mex dishes like birria and carne asada tacos.

Salads feature super fresh ingredients and come in large portions, especially the steak salad and southwest salad. Some salad bowls are very watery and heavily dressed, which can cause the container to leak.

Quality Mexican cuisine comes with great food and large portions served right on time. The dishes consistently taste delicious and offer good value for the price.

People are saying

"This Mexican food is so fresh and flavorful, it's like a trip to Mexico."

"I found the food here to be delicious."

"I got the salad with steak; it was very good and fresh."

Good to know

1

BOGO deals are available on Tuesdays and Thursdays.

2

Lunch specials are offered during the week.

3

Portion sizes are large and provide good value for the price.

03
Uncle Frank's image 1
Food and drink

Modern space combines warm lighting and soft textures for a relaxed yet refined atmosphere. Separate bar and dining areas support conversational noise levels and a welcoming vibe. Guests often gather around a visible pizza oven, adding to the cozy, inviting energy.

Salads come with well dressed greens and include options like beet salad and mixed salad. Portions are small and priced around $14, with limited diet choices available.

Italian dishes come with perfect portions and fresh ingredients. The kale Caesar stands out as crisp and well dressed, paired with excellent service throughout the meal.

People are saying

"The cocktails here are citrusy and on the sweeter side."

"The food here is outstanding, especially the thin, crispy pizzas."

"The pizzas were thin, crispy, and delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

2

Parking in the attached lot can be tight, but nearby municipal lots are available.

3

The menu includes gluten-free items, but cross-contamination is possible.

04
Posh Deli Wantagh image 1

Bright, clean deli with ample seating and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Offers a dedicated vegan section with separate grills and fryers to prevent cross-contact, featuring an extensive and growing vegan menu. Includes a small supermarket of organic foods alongside a cafe menu with vegan goodies and dairy-free ice cream.

Selection includes vegan Macaroni Salad cooked perfectly and a new Tuna Salad that tastes fine. Salads come with intentional, thoughtful details alongside other vegan options.

Fresh, flavorful food comes with a huge selection of vegan options and organic choices. The deli counter separates meat and plant-based foods to avoid cross-contact, and prices stay low for organic fare.

People are saying

"They have an extensive vegetarian menu with many top-notch options."

"The vegan food options here are endless and out of this world."

"The vegan Macaroni Salad was perfectly cooked and super yummy."

Good to know

1

The deli offers a wide variety of both regular and vegan options.

2

They have a separate vegan grill and fryer for vegan items.

3

Parking is available in a big lot next to the deli.

05
Snaps American Bistro image 1
American restaurant

Cozy local bar and restaurant with a modern rustic design and a lively, friendly atmosphere that gets noisy when full. Seating includes picnic tables outside and a spacious interior that feels larger than it appears. Known for craft burgers and a casual vibe suited for nights out rather than quiet dinners.

Salads feature crispy kale prepared by air frying, giving a unique texture and crunch. The wedge salad also stands out as a solid choice alongside other fresh options.

Food features chicken teriyaki wontons and a lobster knuckle sandwich as standout appetizers. Burgers serve as main courses with enough quality to order more for home, all at a reasonable price with quick service for kids' meals.

People are saying

"You have to try the burgers; the meat is the best part."

"The crispy kale salad is satisfying with its unique texture."

"I thought the food here was amazing."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with half-price appetizers.

2

Taco Night occurs every Tuesday with special pricing on tacos.

3

Parking is available in front and extra in the back, but can be hit or miss.

06
New Wave Seafood image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant combines cozy atmosphere with an attached fresh seafood market offering both raw and prepared options. The space fills with a loud, lively vibe that challenges quiet conversation, attracting mostly couples and an older crowd. Clean and neat interior supports a casual dining experience with standout fresh seafood dishes.

Lobster salad stands out with its freshness and generous chunks of real lobster. Asian Ahi Salad and Italian seafood salad offer distinct flavors, while Caesar salad includes a unique ancho twist.

Food features exceptional freshness and excellent quality with dishes like sole stuffed with crab meat. Portions are generous and prices fair, creating a consistently satisfying dining experience.

People are saying

"The seafood staff here is so friendly and helpful."

"I found the food here to be excellent."

"The lobster salad is so fresh and full of real lobster."

Good to know

1

There is ample parking available in the paved lot out front.

2

The restaurant maintains a high standard of cleanliness.

3

Expect to wait as there are no reservations accepted.

07
The Original Salpino of Wantagh image 1

Small deli space feels cramped and old with a cold atmosphere that causes condensation on salads. Shelves resemble an exaggerated convenience store with a large variety of pre-packaged foods made in-store. Sandwiches and prepared foods often impress with great recommendations and ample, fresh presentation.

Chicken Caesar pasta salad stands out with frequent orders and strong preference. Other options like the Italian Salad, Stuffed Shrimp, and Fruit Platter come fresh and ample. Some cold salads show condensation due to the deli's low temperature.

Food arrives hot and on time with a large variety of fresh, pre-packaged items made in-store. Everything tastes delicious and consistent.

People are saying

"The stuffed shrimp were beautifully presented and fresh."

"I found the food here to be absolutely delicious."

"I want the chicken Caesar pasta salad every day."

Good to know

1

Expect 20-30 minute wait times at the deli during peak hours.

2

Parking can be challenging, especially during busy times.

3

Delivery services are reliable, with food arriving hot and on time.

08
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings image 1

Spacious pizza restaurant with a sports bar vibe and a cool looking bar area. Atmosphere ranges from family-friendly to loud and busy on weekend nights. Known for flavorful coal-fired pizzas and a selection of unique drinks like honey margaritas and espresso martinis.

Salads come with fresh ingredients like celery and eggs, often paired with a homemade dressing. Croutons vary, sometimes homemade and amazing, other times absent.

Food here stays consistently fresh and delicious with a variety of options including some newer items to try. Service complements the excellent quality of the dishes well.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was delicious and flavorful."

"The salad here is so good, especially the dressing."

"I found the food to be fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $3 knots, $4 meatballs, and $5 wings.

2

Reservations are not required but recommended during peak hours.

3

Parking is available on-site, but can fill up quickly.

09
Circle M Diner image 1

Diner offers a classic vibe with small town charm and a clean, family-oriented atmosphere. Booths feel narrow, and warm hospitality creates a welcoming energy. Free chocolate chip cookies add a simple, sweet touch.

Salads feature grilled chicken and feta cheese with homemade dressing. The Mykonos salad stands out with well-cooked chicken and a tasty mix of ingredients.

Food here is consistently fresh and delicious with a high quality that stands out. Prices stay reasonable while the dishes remain tasty and satisfying.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, delicious, and generously portioned."

"The diner staff are so nice and attentive."

"Their salad with homemade dressing is excellent."

Good to know

1

Tips can only be paid in cash; there's an ATM on-site.

2

A turkey burger deluxe costs $13.50, and a salad is $16.00.

3

Expect a long wait during special events like the 50th anniversary.

10
Gatsby On The Ocean image 1

Outdoor space features a tented area with ocean views and an outdoor bar with a nice breeze. Indoor areas include a sushi station and a seafood bar, supporting lively events with music from a DJ and band. The venue suits intimate ceremonies and celebrations with a fun, special atmosphere.

Fresh, cold salads stand out with crisp textures and vibrant flavors. The chicken Milanese salad offers a tasty, satisfying option among the especially tasty appetizers.

People are saying

"The staff here are attentive and make sure you have everything you need."

"The food here was delicious and everyone raved about it."

"The staff's advice on the salad was amazing and professional."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for events to ensure availability.

2

The venue offers beautiful ocean views, perfect for wedding photos.

3

Expect a smooth operation with attentive staff during events.

Discover more

Wantagh, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...