Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Sandwich spots in Wantagh

Made for those who have specific standards for their bread, fillings, and ratios and refuse to settle for a mediocre sandwich.

Based on 530 Opinions
+527
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
South Shore Bagels image 1
South Shore Bagels image 2
South Shore Bagels image 3
View all

Soft, doughy bagels with a crusty exterior shine alongside loaded egg sandwiches packed with bacon and cheese. Upbeat staff create a lively vibe, drawing many regulars for quick, tasty breakfasts. Fair prices and easy parking make visits smooth and affordable.

Breakfast sandwiches come with fresh bagels and are often loaded with bacon, egg, and cheese. Egg sandwiches stand out for their excellent taste and quality.

People are saying

"These bagels are authentic, crusty on the outside and soft inside."

"The egg sandwiches here are excellent and loaded."

"The food here is always great and delicious."

Good to know

1

Different bagels have varying prices, so check the menu before ordering.

2

Bulk bagel purchases offer great deals for larger orders.

3

The commuter special is perfect for a quick breakfast on the go.

02
Wantagh Bagels image 1
Bagel shop

Seven tables fill a modest space with a rear parking lot and a fogged TV. Egg sandwiches shine with fresh delivery and fair prices. Fresh, hand-rolled bagels and a variety of cream cheeses offer tasty options despite a less friendly vibe.

Egg sandwiches stand out with fresh delivery and fair prices. A wide variety of cream cheeses and sandwich options complements the menu.

People are saying

"The bagels here are served with a warm smile and friendly demeanor."

"Ayisha makes the food taste amazing and her service is great."

"Ayisha makes the best bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich."

Good to know

1

Prices at Wantagh Bagels are reasonable, typically under $4.50.

2

The shop offers a variety of bagels and cream cheeses.

3

Expect a clean and well-organized store environment.

03
Bunker Hill American Taproom image 1

Pub-style spot buzzes with 90s music and multiple TVs for sports fans. Lunch shines with Hot Honey Fried Chicken and spicy sandwiches like George Washington. Affordable, fresh food like juicy burgers and quality wings keeps the vibe friendly and lively.

Lunch specials offer affordable sandwiches like burgers or chicken with fries for $10. The menu includes Hot Honey Fried Chicken and spicy chicken sandwiches named George Washington and Thomas Jefferson.

People are saying

"The food at this bar is delicious and well-plated."

"The burgers here are juicy and made with fresh chop meat."

"I found the lunch special sandwich to be crazy affordable."

Good to know

1

Lunch specials are available for $10, including a burger or chicken sandwich with fries.

2

Cowboy Karaoke happens regularly, providing a fun night out.

3

The parking lot is small but usually has available spots.

04
Jones Beach Delicatessen & Catering image 1

Deli offers a friendly atmosphere with a four-seat window counter and TV. Breakfast sandwiches shine with bacon, egg, and cheese loaded generously. Menu supports quick service despite high prices and stays busy mid-morning.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with bacon, egg, and cheese loaded generously. Italian and deli sandwiches come with plenty of ingredients and taste very good.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, fresh, and delicious."

"I thought the deli sandwiches here were delicious."

"I loved their breakfast sandwiches, especially the bacon, egg, and cheese."

Good to know

1

The deli closes at 7 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

2

Expect high prices, with two tuna sandwiches costing $27.

3

The deli can get crowded, especially around 11 AM.

05
The Parkview image 1
Restaurant

Newly renovated spot shines with modern design and a large bar for a relaxed vibe. Sandwiches like the French Dip with Ribeye and Nashville Bang Chicken pack rich, bold flavors. Fresh ingredients and quick service make dining smooth and enjoyable.

French Dip with Ribeye and Nashville Bang Chicken sandwiches stand out for their rich flavors. The chipotle chicken sandwich also delivers a spicy kick that impresses.

People are saying

"The food and drinks here are delicious."

"The cocktails here are friendly and knowledgeable."

"The Nashville Bang Chicken sandwich was absolutely delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour features great deals and live music on weekdays.

2

Expect a wait for high top tables during busy hours.

3

The restaurant serves large portion sizes for all meals.

06
Posh Deli Wantagh image 1

Bright deli offers a dedicated vegan section with separate grills ensuring no cross-contact. Vegan sandwiches shine with great variety and fresh, tasty flavors. Small organic supermarket and cafe serve dairy-free ice cream and vegan treats in a warm atmosphere.

Vegan sandwiches stand out with great variety and quality. Every sandwich feels fresh, tasty, and clean, made with thoughtful attention to detail.

People are saying

"They have an extensive vegetarian menu with many top-notch options."

"I found so many organic and natural products here."

"Their vegan chicken and bacon sandwich was perfect."

Good to know

1

The deli offers a wide variety of both regular and vegan options.

2

They have a separate vegan grill and fryer for vegan items.

3

Parking is available in a big lot next to the deli.

07
The French Workshop image 1

Upscale bakery offers warm sandwiches like salmon on baguette and an Italian Sub. Full-service coffee bar and vegan options complement the menu. Large seating with beach views and jazz music creates a lively, inviting spot.

Warm sandwiches like the salmon with cream cheese on a flavorful baguette stand out. The Italian Sub comes heated, and the overall sandwich selection pairs well with pastries and coffee for lunch.

People are saying

"I thought the coffee always hit the spot."

"The desserts here are always fresh and delicious."

"The staff's friendly service made my sandwich experience feel special."

Good to know

1

The French Workshop offers a variety of vegan and gluten-free options.

2

Expect a wait during busy hours, especially on weekends.

3

The place is known for its clean environment and well-maintained facilities.

08
Otto's Delicatessen image 1

Deli offers authentic German-style potato salad and specialty sandwiches with thinly sliced cold cuts and fresh veggies. Early hours and clean, convenient atmosphere make it easy to visit. Prices are higher due to detailed charges for bread and card use.

Specialty and breakfast sandwiches feature custom combinations with cold cuts, tomato, lettuce, and cheese often charged separately. Sandwiches come on hero bread and include egg options that are popular.

People are saying

"I'll be back for pounds of their potato salad."

"I found this deli to be the best on Long Island."

"Their egg sandwiches are always a hit."

Good to know

1

Expect a 20-minute wait for pickup orders during lunch hours.

2

Prices for sandwiches start around $7.80, with additional charges for extras.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but there is a surcharge for using them.

09
Becks Deli image 1

Deli near train station offers convenient access for quick stops. Breakfast sandwiches feature bacon, egg, and cheese on a roll, ideal for bike rides. Atmosphere feels mediocre with small portions and higher prices.

Breakfast sandwiches come on a roll with bacon, egg, and cheese as common fillings. Some orders miss ingredients like bacon, but sandwiches work well for taking on trips like bike rides.

People are saying

"Their bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich on a roll is delicious."

Good to know

1

The deli is conveniently located next to the LIRR station for easy access.

2

Expect higher prices compared to other delis in the area.

3

Portion sizes may be smaller than average, so consider ordering extra.

10
Snaps American Bistro image 1
American restaurant

Cozy bar with a modern rustic design offers lively vibes and picnic tables outside. Craft burgers shine alongside lobster knuckle sandwiches that add a seafood twist. Grilled chicken sandwiches bring rich flavor, making it great for casual nights out.

Lobster knuckle and grilled chicken stand out as key sandwich options. The grilled chicken sandwich offers rich flavor, while the lobster knuckle sandwich delivers a unique seafood twist.

People are saying

"You have to try the burgers; the meat is the best part."

"The crispy kale salad is satisfying with its unique texture."

"I finished the best tasting grilled chicken sandwich I have ever had."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with half-price appetizers.

2

Taco Night occurs every Tuesday with special pricing on tacos.

3

Parking is available in front and extra in the back, but can be hit or miss.

Discover more

Wantagh, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...