Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Ohio's best

Authentic pizza places

Made for those who judge a pizzeria by the integrity of its crust and the refusal to deviate from time-honored preparation methods.

Based on 764 Opinions
+761
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Pastizza's Pizza and Pasta image 1
Pastizza's Pizza and Pasta image 2
Pastizza's Pizza and Pasta image 3
View all
Italian restaurant

Thin crust New York-style pizza defines the menu in a cozy space with old school vibes and a family atmosphere. The setting feels like a grandma's kitchen, simple and inviting, with small tables and fun decorations. The place draws a steady crowd who appreciate authentic flavors without fuss.

Pizza offers an authentic New York style with a fresh, delicious taste and texture. The atmosphere matches the New York vibe, making it feel like a genuine pizza joint from the city.

Classic New York-style pizza shines here with a thin crust that is foldable and has the right crunch. The dough offers a wonderful airy texture that melts in your mouth, making the pizzas consistently excellent and authentic.

People are saying

"I had the best New York style pizza I've ever had."

"I thought this pizza was the best I ever had."

"I found the pizza to be authentic New York style."

Good to know

1

Parking is easy and available near the restaurant.

2

The restaurant primarily offers takeout service.

3

A large pizza costs $23, making it an affordable option.

02
Napoli's Pizza Beavercreek image 1

Small dining area with cozy atmosphere and quaint seating creates a peaceful, clean environment. Authentic New York style pizza draws a loyal crowd seeking genuine Italian flavors. Community-focused spirit shows through unique gestures like a food-for-those-in-need board.

Pizza features an authentic foldable crisp New York style crust with flavors close to those found in Italy. Food is made fresh daily, capturing authentic Italian style and delivering a true taste of New York style pizza.

New York style pizza stands out with authentic taste and well-executed crust. Toppings stay firmly on the pizza, and the meat lovers pizza comes out perfectly balanced.

People are saying

"This pizza is considered the best in the area."

"I found the calzone to be huge and very good."

"I found the authentic Italian pizza here to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Parking can be challenging during rush hour; plan accordingly.

2

Pizzas take about 20-25 minutes to prepare after ordering.

3

The restaurant is small, so dining in may be limited.

03
Calabria Pizza image 1
Pizza Takeout

New York style pizza defines the menu with crispy, crunchy crust and generous portions that often leave leftovers. The atmosphere stays friendly and clean, creating a welcoming spot for quick takeout. Popularity leads to sold-out items early, showing strong demand despite some parking challenges.

Pizza features authentic New York style with rich, zesty meaty sauces. Everything served tastes delicious and authentic.

New York style pizza stands out with a great taste that matches East Coast quality. Options like Chicken Alfredo pizza and bruschetta add variety, all served with welcoming service.

People are saying

"This New York Style Pizza is the real deal, just like back home."

"I discovered my new favorite pizza here; it's amazing."

"I found the pizza here to be authentic New York style."

Good to know

1

Expect a 15-minute wait for pick-up orders during peak hours.

2

Parking can be challenging; arrive early to secure a spot.

3

Prices are reasonable, with a large pizza costing around $20.

04
Rossville Pizza Company image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza restaurant with a historic steel mill theme and wood-fired oven set outdoors. Cozy indoor seating and a covered patio with heaters create a welcoming atmosphere connected to a local brewery. The vibe is relaxed with fresh, high-quality pizza and a selection of craft beers and cocktails.

Pizza features an authentic Italian style with great taste. The team shows passion and an energetic, genuine vibe in their work.

Wood-fired pizzas come out hot and fresh with an artisanal touch and unique Blast Furnace option. The quality and passion behind each pie make the price feel worth it.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was hot and delicious."

"The salad here is fresh and flavorful."

"I found the pizza here to be truly authentic and delicious."

Good to know

1

Rossville Pizza Company is reservation-only, so plan ahead.

2

Parking can be tricky, so arrive early or be prepared to walk.

3

The restaurant does not offer online ordering or call-in takeout.

05
Veliโ€™s Pasta and Pizza image 1

Takeout and delivery spot with a family-owned friendly atmosphere and very clean interior. Food features authentic New York style pizza and large calzones praised for quality and flavor. No indoor seating, emphasizing convenience and fast service.

Fresh Cannoli delivers authentic Italian flavor. Pizza and pasta come out hot and fresh with a genuine taste at fast food prices.

Pizza features a to die for crust and tastes distinctly home-made with incredibly fresh ingredients. Specials like Ziti pizza and Bruschetta add variety to the menu.

People are saying

"This pizza is incredible, like the kind I grew up eating."

"I found the taste here to be hot, fresh, and authentic."

"It's a great family owned pizza joint."

Good to know

1

Veliโ€™s Pasta and Pizza only offers takeout and delivery options.

2

The restaurant is closed on Sundays.

3

One calzone easily covers dinner for two.

06
Tony's Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Tiny, cozy space with Italian atmosphere and limited indoor seating plus outdoor tables. Energy feels family-oriented and authentic, attracting those who appreciate New York/New Jersey style pizza and hearty subs. Offers pizza by the slice, making it convenient for varied tastes in a small, quaint setting.

Real NY/NJ style floppy pizza stands out here, capturing authentic Italian flavors. Salads also match the genuine taste, making the food consistently delicious and authentic.

Offers authentic NY/NJ style floppy pizza with a variety of toppings by the slice. The pizza is allergy friendly and delivers a real Italian taste with every bite.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I'd had in years."

"The meatball parm sub was exceptional and a great value."

"I loved the authentic NY style pizza here."

Good to know

1

Tony's Corner Deli sells pizza by the slice, which is convenient for families.

2

The meatball sub costs under $11, offering good value.

3

Portions are generous, making it easy to share meals.

07
Napoli's Pizza Miamisburg image 1

Cozy dine-in area with 90s Italian diner style and authentic neighborhood pizza parlor feel creates a welcoming atmosphere. Walls display Italy artwork and soft classic music plays, enhancing the family-friendly vibe. Small patio offers outdoor seating, complementing the neat and clean environment.

Fresh ingredients create authentic Italian flavors in pizza and lasagna. The spot has a neighborhood pizza parlor feel with authentic Italian music and friendly staff.

NYC style pizza stands out with fresh ingredients and quick service, delivering pies in about ten minutes. The pizza shows consistent quality and a genuine passion from the staff.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and amazing."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza and pasta, is delicious."

"I loved the authentic Italian food and neighborhood feel."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers generous portions, often enough for two or three people.

2

Takeout service is popular, with many customers picking up food during peak hours.

3

The restaurant maintains a clean and neat environment for diners.

08
Roma's Pizza & Pasta image 1
Italian restaurant

Small space offers authentic Italian energy with friendly atmosphere and plentiful portions. Seating includes intimate indoor tables and outdoor picnic spots. Known for high-quality, flavorful pizza that stands out in the region.

Pizza features a very authentic NY style with a genuine Italian taste. Tomato sauce stands out as authentic Italian, delivering classic flavors throughout the menu.

New York style pizza stands out with unique toppings like basil and ricotta, rarely seen outside New Jersey and NYC. The grandma's pizza ranks among the best, with consistently great service and timely carryout options.

People are saying

"This pizza is amazing, truly authentic Italian style."

"The pasta dishes here are huge and taste amazing."

"I found the pizza to be truly authentic Italian."

Good to know

1

Roma's offers pizza slices from 11 AM to 3 PM.

2

The restaurant has a community giveaway event today.

3

Carryout orders can be timed for pickup when the pizza is in the oven.

09
Venecia Italian Restaurant image 1
Italian restaurant

Small Italian restaurant with ambient lighting and soft Italian music creates a cozy, laid-back atmosphere. Decor is simple and family-owned, featuring Italy-themed visuals on TVs. Quiet during lunch, it fills quickly at dinner, welcoming families and casual diners alike.

Dishes showcase authentic Italian flavors with fresh ingredients, avoiding frozen or processed options. The cuisine stays true to traditional recipes, delivering a genuine Italian dining experience.

Excellent pizza crust stands out with a delicious, well-made base. The meat lovers pizza and garlic knots also receive strong praise for flavor and quality.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is amazing, with huge, tasty portions."

"I thought the pizza here was fantastic and way better than I expected."

"I found the food to be authentic and excellent."

Good to know

1

The establishment is a cash-only place that offers a 3% discount for cash payments.

2

I had a reservation for 12 and they were all set for us.

3

When I visited on a Saturday evening, there was no wait.

10
Taste of India Cuisine image 1
Indian restaurant

Space blends warm, inviting atmosphere with an unexpected bar-like feel and pleasant outdoor patio. Meals arrive on large silver compartmentalized trays, offering generous portions with many vegetarian and vegan options. Energy stays calm and accommodating, suitable for groups and casual dining.

Dishes feature authentic flavors with perfect spice balance. Food stays fresh and is consistently well presented.

Indian-style pizzas stand out with options like Chicken Tikka Masala and Curry pizza during dinner. Halal pizzas are available, and the house special pizza is notably good.

People are saying

"I found the Indian food here to be authentic and full of flavor."

"The food here is authentic, fresh, and filled with flavor."

"I was surprised they had Indian-style pizzas like curry."

Good to know

1

Lunch combos are priced at $16 each and include garlic naan, rice, and two main courses.

2

Halal meat is served, making it suitable for those with dietary restrictions.

3

Expect reasonable prices with generous portion sizes, often enough for leftovers.

11
Bella Sorella Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Open fire wood-fired pizza oven creates a rustic and modern dining space with gorgeous indoor and outdoor decor. Atmosphere feels warm and family-friendly but can be noisy due to hard surfaces and tight seating. Outdoor patio offers a casual Italian vibe that complements the overall experience.

Wood-fired pizzas feature a perfect crust and base that captures true Italian style. The pizza stands out as authentic Italian food with flavors matching those found in Italy and nearby regions.

Wood-fired pizza stands out with phenomenal flavor and a deluxe style that impresses every time. Service is timely and efficient, making the dining experience smooth and enjoyable.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be spectacular and amazing."

"You have to try the meatballs; they're truly next-level."

"I found the most authentic Italian pizza with a perfect crust."

Good to know

1

The restaurant gets crowded quickly, especially during dinner hours.

2

Reservations are not accepted, so expect possible wait times.

3

The menu features 11 specific pizza combinations with no customization allowed.

12
Troni Brothers Italian Restaurant image 1

Spacious Italian restaurant with modern decor and a family-friendly atmosphere. The vibe is laid back and welcoming, featuring generous portions and a menu with solid Italian choices.

Food comes from scratch Italian recipes with a taste that matches what you'd find in Italy. The menu offers excellent authentic Italian cuisine including pizza that feels truly genuine.

Perfectly cooked pizza features a perfect sauce and includes a cauliflower crust option. Garlic rolls and boneless Garlic Parm Chicken wings complement the Italian-style pies.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was excellent and delicious."

"I considered this pizza one of the best I've ever had."

"The Italian food here is so authentic, it's like being in Italy."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, and tables are usually available for lunch.

2

The restaurant offers large, shareable portions ideal for families.

3

Lunch prices are reasonable, making it a budget-friendly option.

13
KANTINE Biergarten Wine Bar Eatery image 1

German pub-style restaurant offers an authentic Bavarian atmosphere with natural wood and exposed brick in a rustic setting. The vibe is laid back and friendly, with live jazz music that complements the crowd without overpowering. Outdoor seating under string lights invites casual mingling and enjoyment of crisp beers on tap.

Authentic German dishes stand out with traditional flavors and classic recipes. The setting feels like a genuine German pub inside a historic red brick building.

Thin crust pizza stands out here, especially the Diablo with its perfect heat. The menu focuses on pizza and flatbread only, featuring options like the flavorful Tunfisch and a decent cheese pizza.

People are saying

"I found the German food here to be very authentic."

"I enjoyed the casual outdoor urban setting and atmosphere."

"I tried the fungi pizza and it was delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for later evening dining.

2

Happy hour on Friday and Saturday starts at 3pm.

3

Thursdays feature half-priced bottles of wine.

14
Flying Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Old school pizza parlor with open kitchen where dough tossing happens in full view. Atmosphere feels small-town cozy and low key, suited mainly for pickup with limited seating. Known for authentic East Coast style pizza with scratch-made crust and quick service.

Ovens produce authentic east coast style pizza with excellent quality and reasonable prices. Neighborhood spot serves New York-style pizza true to its roots.

New York style pizza features a scratch-made crust and huge slices. The pizza offers authentic east coast flavor with top notch quality and taste.

People are saying

"I thought this was the best NY style pizza in the area."

"You can get pizza by the slice for a quick lunch."

"I found authentic New York-style pizza with great flavor."

Good to know

1

A single slice of cheese pizza costs $4, and a 16-inch pizza is $24.95.

2

The wait time for pizza is about 10 minutes, which is reasonable for quality.

3

Flying Pizza offers pizza by the slice during lunchtime.

15
Istanbul Grill image 1
Turkish restaurant

Spacious setting offers a family-friendly atmosphere with live music sessions featuring top-notch singers. Decor varies from simple and tidy to well-decorated and fresh after renovation. The vibe feels authentic and inviting, creating a sense of being in another country.

Turkish dishes like Beef Adana, Adana Wrap, and Beef Iskander come out with authentic flavors. Humus and Pida bread match traditional recipes closely, delivering a genuine taste of Turkey.

Mediterranean-style pizzas feature thin crust and pita bases with a flavorful pizza sauce. Turkish pizza options appear alongside generous portions, sometimes upgraded without extra charge.

People are saying

"The chicken kebab here is perfectly seasoned and tender."

"I found the food here to be delicious and authentic."

"I loved the pizza here; it had a perfectly chewy crust and fresh toppings."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers halal options for all dishes.

2

Expect higher prices for authentic Turkish cuisine.

3

The dining area is clean and well-maintained.

16
Casa Del Sabor image 1
Mexican restaurant

Mexican restaurant with colorful decorations and a chill, authentic atmosphere that supports easy conversation. It draws lively crowds during celebrations, sometimes featuring a DJ outside. Known for excellent margaritas and flavorful dishes like fajitas and tacos with spicy tomatillo sauce.

Mexican food here stays true to tradition with authentic flavors that are delicious and not overly spicy. The house salsa and atmosphere also keep things genuine.

Unique birria pizza stands out with rich, flavorful toppings and a crispy crust. It works well as a starter or main course and draws repeat visits.

People are saying

"I found the best Mexican food in the area."

"You have to try the birria pizza; it's like a pizza-sized quesadilla."

"I found the Mexican food here to be authentic and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but arriving early is recommended for larger parties.

2

The restaurant offers a lunch menu with affordable prices for families.

3

Expect a busy atmosphere during peak hours, especially on weekends.

17
Vittles & Grits image 1
Breakfast restaurant

Small, cozy restaurant with a homey atmosphere and friendly vibe filled with local regulars. It offers a family-style setting that feels welcoming and down-to-earth. Known for authentic Southern breakfast and big flavors despite its size.

Southern breakfast here delivers comfort food with deep roots in tradition. The dishes offer soulful Southern cuisine that feels genuine and true to its origins.

Offers pizzas on weekends alongside subs and lunch options. The pizza tastes very good and stands out among the menu items.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, truly homemade comfort cooking."

"I found the most authentic Southern comfort food here."

"I found the pizza here to be very good."

Good to know

1

Daily specials are offered, providing great value for meals.

2

Expect a short wait time, even on busy days like Fatherโ€™s Day.

3

Prices are reasonable, making it an affordable dining option.

18
Jimmy's Italian Kitchen image 1
Italian restaurant

Small, cozy dining room with dim lighting and tables crowded closely together creates an intimate setting. Atmosphere blends relaxing, romantic vibes with occasional loudness that can challenge conversation. Outdoor patio offers a different feel but can be noisy due to nearby traffic.

Food tastes like homemade Italian cuisine with plenty of garlic. Chicken Alfredo and other dishes show authentic chef skills.

Fresh cheese and perfect crust stand out on the pizza. The sauce and cheese balance well, making it the highlight of the meal.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and always top-notch."

"I loved the authentic Italian food, especially the eggplant parmesan."

"The pizza was the real star of the meal."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for weekend dining to avoid long wait times.

2

Expect to pay around $70 for an average meal for two.

3

A 4% surcharge applies for credit card payments.

19
Gina's Italian Kitchen & Tavern image 1

Bar-like Italian restaurant with loud music and crowded seating creates a lively but noisy atmosphere. Entertainment includes karaoke and a DJ, adding to the energetic vibe. Outdoor patio offers a cozy alternative for dining away from the indoor bustle.

Offers authentic Italian food with a strong focus on traditional flavors. Combines a sports bar atmosphere with genuine Italian dishes.

Pizza comes loaded with cheese and toppings and stands out for its rich flavor. Varieties like the burger-pizza and classic options deliver a satisfying meal.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, especially the Chicken Alfredo."

"I thought the pizza was delicious and loaded with cheese."

"I found the authentic Italian food really great."

Good to know

1

Parking can be tough, especially during busy times.

2

The restaurant is located behind a florist, making it easy to miss.

3

Karaoke happens on weekends, adding to the lively atmosphere.

20
Al'Lupo Ristorante image 1

Dining inside an old pottery mill with tables in historic kilns creates a unique setting. The atmosphere is lively and loud, yet guests can still converse easily. Outdoor seating offers city views, and the bar curves around the kiln, adding to the distinctive vibe.

Offers great Italian food with a focus on authentic cuisine. Dishes reflect traditional Italian flavors and preparation.

People are saying

"I love the Italian food here; it feels like a blessing."

"The pizza crust has a perfect chew-and-char."

"I thought this was authentic Italian cuisine."

Good to know

1

Reservations are definitely recommended to ensure a table.

2

Being able to pay by the QR code on the receipt allows for quick departures.

3

The restaurant offers a non-fried option for calamari, which is a rare choice.

21
Tandoor India & Pizza image 1
Indian restaurant

Large dining area combines with beautiful furniture and clean, well-lit space to create a comfortable, peaceful atmosphere. Cozy seating invites relaxed meals while a bar adds a casual touch. The setting balances authentic Indian decor with a fresh, inviting feel.

Food features authentic North Indian dishes with some South Indian options. Ingredients stay fresh and the flavors remain delicious and true to tradition.

Butter chicken pizza stands out with rich flavors that many enjoy. The menu also includes tandoori pizza and traditional options for those who prefer classic tastes.

People are saying

"The food here is so delicious and flavorful."

"I found the food here to be delicious and authentic."

"I was obsessed with the butter chicken pizza."

Good to know

1

Tandoor India & Pizza offers a buffet from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM.

2

The restaurant allows customization of spice levels from 0 to 6.

3

Online ordering is available for convenience.

22
Tuscany's Italian Restaurant image 1

Italian restaurant offers an authentic atmosphere with cozy, homey decor and bistro lights creating a relaxing vibe. Italian music plays softly, enhancing the genuine dining experience. The space includes a bar and tables suited for all party sizes.

Authentic Italian food shines here with authentic sauce and a genuine Italian atmosphere. The restaurant feels like a family-run spot serving true Italian cuisine rarely found in the area.

Thin, crispy dough lets the cheese, sauce, and toppings stand out. The pizza tastes light and flavorful, making it a solid choice for pickup or dine-in.

People are saying

"The food at these Date Spots is perfection, truly delicious."

"I found the pizza to be thin, crispy, and simply delicious."

"I found the authentic Italian food here to be great."

Good to know

1

A 3.5% surcharge is added to bills for credit card payments.

2

Reservations are recommended for larger groups, especially on weekends.

3

The restaurant has a private party room for at least 30 people.

23
West Social Tap & Table image 1

Multiple dining options share a modern space with plenty of indoor and outdoor seating and a great patio. Live bands provide loud, energetic music that fills the atmosphere, creating a fun and lively vibe. A small bar offers drinks, adding to the social and inviting environment.

Fresh ingredients deliver authentic Caribbean flavors that stand out in Ohio. The dishes capture the true taste of the islands without compromise.

Wood fired pizzas come with hot honey and fresh, amazing toppings. The crust stays thin and airy, and turkey pepperoni offers a pork-free option.

People are saying

"This lunch spot's jerk chicken is perfectly spiced with a satisfying heat."

"I thought the pizza here was delicious and fresh."

"I finally found Authentic Caribbean food in Ohio."

Good to know

1

Karaoke night is every Monday, starting at 7 PM.

2

Brunch is served on weekends, but check availability beforehand.

3

Parking is available on the street or in the back of the venue.

24
El Asadero Mexican Bar & Grill image 1

Large, colorful space with Day of the Dead decorations and a long bar creates a festive setting. Loud music and live entertainment, including a dancing robot and balloon artists, make the atmosphere lively and energetic. Popular for celebrations, it draws crowds especially on busy nights like Taco Tuesday.

Food features authentic Mexican cuisine with a menu full of traditional dishes. The place also offers good tequila to complement the meals.

Menu includes birria pizza alongside traditional and trendy options. Cheese pizza scores high but could use more cheese.

People are saying

"I found their Mexican food to be the best around."

"I found the food here to be very authentic Mexican."

"I found the birria pizza to be excellent."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for Taco Tuesday due to high demand.

2

Expect long wait times on Saturday evenings, especially around 5:30 pm.

3

The restaurant hosts a dance show featuring a robot every Friday at 8pm.

Discover more

Ohio

Area guide
Loading Map...