Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Cincinnati

Pie

There is a specific kind of satisfaction in cutting into a slice of homemade pie.

Based on 432 Opinions
+429
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Lobsta Bakes of Maine image 1
Lobsta Bakes of Maine image 2
Lobsta Bakes of Maine image 3
View all
Seafood market

Small seafood market buzzes with a laid-back coastal vibe and fresh catches. Blueberry and apple pies offer rich flavors that pair well with shrimp and lobster rolls. Friendly staff make it a great spot for seafood lovers and pie fans alike.

Blueberry and apple pies stand out with their rich flavors. The lemon pie offers a bright, tangy option. Pies often pair with seafood dishes like shrimp and lobster rolls.

People are saying

"I thought the fish and chips were excellent and crispy."

"I loved the crab cakes; they were amazing."

"I found the blueberry and apple pies to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Fish & chips are available every Friday night from 5-7pm.

2

The restaurant closes Friday afternoon and reopens for fish & chips.

3

Expect a line if arriving before 5pm on Fridays.

02
Red Leprechaun image 1

Irish pub shines with authentic decor like a wood bar from Ireland. Shepherd's Pie offers rich flavor and hearty filling. Live acoustic music creates a vibrant atmosphere where performers take requests, making it fun and welcoming.

Shepherd's Pie stands out with its rich flavor and hearty filling. Fish and chips also pair well, offering a classic complement to the pie.

People are saying

"The pub has delicious food and the best Guinness pour."

"I thought their beer cheese burger was great."

"I'd definitely order the Shepherd's Pie again."

Good to know

1

Happy hour on Thursdays offers discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

On 'Toasty Tuesday,' enjoy free grilled cheeses with any beer purchase.

3

Bingo night occurs every Tuesday, providing a fun social atmosphere.

03
Tino's Greek-American Family Restaurant image 1

Cozy spot with family atmosphere serves hearty Greek comfort food. Pumpkin pie shines as a special dessert alongside popular pecan and cherry pies. Clean, simple decor keeps energy calm and welcoming for all ages.

Greek pumpkin pie appears as a special request and comes out well. Pecan and cherry pies serve as common dessert choices, often taken to go along with baklava.

People are saying

"The dinner spots here serve up delicious gyro platters and open-faced roast beef."

"The Greek food here, especially the gyro, is the best I've ever had."

"The pie here is always fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

The portions are large, often enough for two people.

2

Prices are reasonable for the quality of food served.

3

The menu includes a variety of Greek and American dishes.

04
Holzman Meats image 1
Butcher shop

Family-run butcher shop offers unique cuts like oxtail and rare bones. Pot pies feature fresh fillings with a homemade touch. Knowledgeable staff create a wholesome atmosphere with a wide selection of meats, cheeses, and deli products.

Pot pies stand out with freshly prepared fillings and a homemade touch. The menu includes a large variety of pies alongside soups and sides made in house.

People are saying

"Their pot pies are delicious and made in house."

"The service here is so kind and patient, I'll be back."

"I found their selection of sausages to be excellent and flavorful."

Good to know

1

During BurgerWeek, they offer a special Red Barron burger with fries or onion rings.

2

Prices at Holzman Meats are generally high, with sandwiches around $10.

3

Cash is recommended for payment as some vendors may not accept cards.

05
The Pub - Rookwood image 1

English pub-style spot shines with authentic woodwork and a masterpiece bar for drinks. Shepherd's pie stands out with a cheesy top layer and hearty filling. Live Celtic music livens the vibe while outdoor, pet-friendly space offers calm.

Shepherd's pie features a cheesy top layer with a mix of potatoes and a small amount of meat filling. It tastes above average to phenomenal depending on the visit.

People are saying

"The fish and chips here were delicious and a good-sized portion."

"This pub really feels like you're in England."

"The fish and chips here are amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for busy nights, especially on weekends.

2

The pub is pet-friendly, allowing dogs in the patio area.

3

Parking can be tricky; a nearby garage offers free parking.

06
Perkins American Food Co. image 1

Old school diner dive offers a vintage atmosphere with a cozy, homey vibe. French silk pie is a favorite dessert, though slices are small and sometimes pricey. Peaceful setting attracts older folk enjoying quiet conversations and coffee.

French silk pie stands out as a favorite. Pies come in many varieties and taste delicious, but slices can be small and sometimes feel overpriced.

People are saying

"The food service here is fast and attentive."

"Their pancakes are the best breakfast around."

"I thought the French silk pie was still the best."

Good to know

1

Breakfast is served all day, including lunch items.

2

Expect a wait for larger groups, especially on weekends.

3

Parking can be challenging during peak hours.

07
Hitching Post Kellogg - World's Best Fried Chicken image 1

Small diner with a cozy vibe and friendly staff feels like a hometown gem. Homemade pies, especially blackberry and chocolate cream, offer rich flavors. Warm, nostalgic charm makes it a laid-back spot for comfort food and community.

Homemade pies offer a decadent experience with every slice. Options like blackberry and chocolate cream stand out for their rich flavors.

People are saying

"This fried chicken is perfectly crispy and juicy."

"The mashed potatoes and gravy were perfection."

"I found the pie here to be delicious."

Good to know

1

The diner has limited seating for about 12-15 people, so plan for carry-out.

2

Parking can get busy during lunch and dinner rushes, so arrive early.

3

Carry-out is recommended for a quick meal at a good price.

08
Newtown Farm Market image 1
Produce market

Rustic charm and handwritten signage create a serene vibe. Amish pies and fresh breads shine at the deli counter. A talkative parrot and a patio add unique local touches to this quiet market.

Racks along the back wall hold fresh breads, cookies, and pies. Amish pies stand out among the wide variety available. The market regularly stocks delicious pies that draw attention.

People are saying

"This market has a huge variety of fresh produce and delicious baked goods."

"I had a great sandwich for lunch with top quality ingredients."

"I loved the fresh baked pies they had available."

Good to know

1

The market offers fresh produce and a variety of local products.

2

Expect long lines at the deli counter during peak hours.

3

They have seasonal plants, flowers, and unique Amish goods.

09
Frisch's Big Boy image 1

Diner offers a classic atmosphere with comfortable seating and a lively lunchtime vibe. Chicken pot pie is a standout classic loved by many. Coconut cream and pumpkin pies are also popular and available for preorder.

Chicken pot pie stands out as a great classic, often considered better than similar options elsewhere. Coconut cream pie and pumpkin pie also receive consistent praise and are available for preorder.

People are saying

"The food here is always fresh, hot, and tastes wonderful."

"I found the breakfast bar to be killer, especially the goetta."

"I thought the chicken pot pie was great."

Good to know

1

The breakfast bar is available until 11 am.

2

The cost of the early morning breakfast increased from $6.00 to $11.00, excluding drinks and tips.

3

The dining area is clean and the salad bar is well maintained.

10
Montgomery Inn The Boathouse image 1
Barbecue restaurant

Barbecue restaurant offers stunning riverfront views and a relaxed vibe with live music. Key Lime Pie shines with its ginger snap crust and balanced sweet-sour custard. Guests savor highly praised ribs alongside strong bourbon cocktails in a casual, scenic setting.

Key Lime Pie features a ginger snap crust and a homemade custard that tastes like pudding with a balanced sweet and sour flavor. Peanut Butter Pie also appears as a notable dessert option.

People are saying

"The food here was incredible, tender, and juicy."

"The ribs here have a gorgeous view of the Ohio River."

"The key lime pie is amazing, perfectly balanced sweet and sour."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially for weekend dining.

2

Happy hour offers specials on drinks and appetizers from 4-7pm on weekdays.

3

Cigar Night occurs every Thursday with a relaxed atmosphere.

Discover more

Cincinnati, Ohio

Area guide
Loading Map...