Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Wisconsin's best

Watch and necklace stores

Made for those who view jewelry as a deliberate investment and refuse to settle for anything less than a curated selection of timepieces and pendants.

Based on 653 Opinions
+650
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Rogers & Hollands Jewelers image 1
Rogers & Hollands Jewelers image 2
Rogers & Hollands Jewelers image 3
View all

Jewelry store offers a huge selection of diamonds and custom orders in various styles and gold colors. Atmosphere feels welcoming and comfortable with caring customer service focused on client happiness. Pricing is resourceful with strong warranty plans, making shopping smooth and easy.

Watch fitting is fast and easy with staff like Mark, Janice, and Sophie who ensure a perfect fit. They offer watch repairs such as band fixing at no charge and provide a solid selection including brands like Citizen and Hamilton at decent prices.

Staff provide detailed guidance on necklace options and charm pairings. Necklaces can be set aside for quick pickup, supporting last-minute needs.

People are saying

"This jewelry store's staff patiently helps you design your dream ring."

"Lisa made my ring dreams come true and brought my ideas to life."

"Mark and Becky are so helpful and knowledgeable at the Watch Store."

Good to know

1

The store offers a huge selection of diamonds and jewelry.

2

They provide special orders for any style, color of gold, or sizes.

3

The pricing is competitive, with many protection plans available.

02
Paul's Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Cozy jewelry store with a welcoming, party-like atmosphere and a cute shop dog. Staff offer in-house repairs, custom designs with 3D modeling, and quick turnaround times. Unique, elegant pieces and personalized service set it apart from typical jewelers.

Experts perform quick watch repairs like battery replacements and clasp swaps in minutes. Adjustments happen fast, but some repairs can affect wearability.

Custom necklaces by local artists and skilled jewelers stand out here. Repairs take about a week and come back looking brand new. Shipping is quick and necklaces arrive well protected.

People are saying

"I had my ring fixed and it was done very fast."

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so helpful and kind."

"The watch repair was a 5-minute fix by the experts."

Good to know

1

Paul's Jewelers offers in-house repairs and custom designs for jewelry.

2

Repairs are completed within 24 hours, much faster than typical jewelers.

3

They provide in-house appraisals for jewelry, ensuring quick service.

03
KAY Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry store offers a wide selection of men's and women's pieces including diamond bracelets and brand watches. Atmosphere feels stress free and pressure free, with staff providing helpful care advice. Sizing and servicing processes are efficient and straightforward.

A wide selection of watches from Movado, Bulova, and Citizens stands out here. Staff explain details about each watch and limited editions, helping pick out the right one.

Staff spend time helping find the right necklace and explain how to care for it. Customers can browse at their own pace and often discover Disney necklaces and other special occasion pieces.

People are saying

"Sandy was so helpful finding the perfect ring."

"The staff here take their time helping you find the perfect necklace."

"Kelly helped me pick out a great watch."

Good to know

1

The store has a wide selection of men's and women's diamond jewelry and watches.

2

Ring sizing typically takes less than a week.

3

The repair process may take a few months as items are shipped to headquarters.

04
Pawn America image 1
Pawn shop

Pawn shop offers a clean, quiet atmosphere with a wide selection of jewelry and tools. Staff provide knowledgeable assistance and the process for buying or selling is fast and fair. Prices tend to be affordable and competitive compared to other sources.

Staff provide accurate and consistent information on high-end watches. They assist with finding watches for different needs and offer services like watch band cleaning and fitting.

Staff provide detailed info on necklace weights and types of gold. They assist in finding necklaces for special occasions and offer options within different budgets.

People are saying

"Angela at the Ring Store was so knowledgeable and helpful."

"Bri helped me find the perfect watch at the Watch Store."

"I found the perfect necklace with the wonderful help of the associates."

Good to know

1

Ask for Bri or Michelle for excellent service and jewelry advice.

2

The pawn process is quick and efficient, making it easy to sell items.

3

They offer layaway options and protection plans for jewelry purchases.

05
Powers Jewelry Designers image 1

Jewelry store offers a large selection with more options for men than typical jewelers. Atmosphere is pressure-free and focused on high-quality craftsmanship and affordable pricing. Repairs and custom work happen smoothly, often exceeding expectations with quick turnaround and exceptional care.

Tim Metzenheim helps with watch repairs and shows several watch options. A vintage Gucci watch was serviced for water damage but stopped working after pickup, with no clear solution provided.

Repairs happen quickly, like fixing a gold chain necklace in about 5 minutes. The store offers stone necklaces and handles appraisals with a smooth process and reasonable prices.

People are saying

"Tim at this Ring Store is so knowledgeable and helpful."

"The Necklace Store staff remembers you by name and helps find the perfect piece."

"Tim's friendly, knowledgeable service at the Watch Store is excellent."

Good to know

1

Repairs are completed quickly and often free of charge.

2

Expect a turnaround time of less than two weeks for ring repairs.

3

The appraisal process is reasonable and straightforward.

06
Jared Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry store offers a welcoming atmosphere with in-house repairs and resizing for most pieces. Staff provide transparent sourcing and maintain strong customer relationships through easy account management and a rewards program.

Staff like Heidi Avello and Dorena provide helpful and patient service when selecting or adjusting watches. The store offers in-house watch sizing and repairs, making it a reliable spot for watch purchases and maintenance.

Staff provide free necklace repairs like chain fixes and clasp replacements. They offer attentive service focused on timely repairs and help with selecting rings and necklaces for special occasions.

People are saying

"The Ring Store staff are warm, patient, and genuinely fun to work with."

"They fixed my necklace chain for free and saved me another trip."

"Jennifer was so quick and efficient helping me at the Watch Store."

Good to know

1

Jared Jewelers offers in-house repairs and resizing for most jewelry.

2

A lifetime warranty is available for jewelry purchases at Jared.

3

Bring your jewelry in for inspection every six months for maintenance.

07
The Jewelry Center image 1
Jewelry store

Bright setting with surrounding windows and interior-lit jewelry boxes creates an elegant and dazzling atmosphere. The space feels warm and welcoming, with a relaxed vibe and friendly, unhurried service. Jewelry selection appears carefully curated, enhancing a personalized shopping experience.

Watch batteries get replaced quickly and affordably with friendly service. Staff also handle watch resizing and band replacements efficiently without pressure.

They create custom necklaces using personal diamonds and pearls. Staff help pick out matching pieces like necklaces and earrings. They also handle repairs like attaching new clasps and rings.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are friendly and real experts."

"I got my watch battery replaced quickly and easily here."

"The staff at this Necklace Store are so friendly and helpful."

Good to know

1

The Jewelry Center offers custom ring making services.

2

Watch battery replacement is affordable and quick.

3

They have a great selection of estate jewelry.

Discover more

Wisconsin

Area guide
Loading Map...