Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Wisconsin

Watch stores

Finding the right watch or a piece of jewelry is about choosing something that lasts.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Schwanke-Kasten Jewelers image 1
Schwanke-Kasten Jewelers image 2
Schwanke-Kasten Jewelers image 3
View all

Beautifully designed space offers a comfortable atmosphere with private lounges and thoughtful presentations. The environment feels calm and genuine, attracting those seeking high-quality jewelry and watches with attentive, straightforward service.

Offers an amazing selection of the finest jewelry with everything needed from a jewelry shop.

Luxury watches like Tudor and Rolex are available and accurately described online. Staff members such as Karen, Charlie, and Kailyn assist with sourcing and finding specific models. They handle special orders efficiently, delivering watches on time for occasions.

People are saying

"Rich was so helpful and patient finding my first luxury watch."

"I felt calm, comfortable, and truly special during my luxurious experience."

"I considered this the best jewelry store in southeast Wisconsin."

Good to know

1

Schwanke-Kasten Jewelers offers custom engraving options for personalized gifts.

2

Expect a wide selection of luxury watches and fine jewelry available.

3

The store provides quick shipping for online orders, ensuring timely delivery.

02
CRAIG HUSAR Fine Diamonds & Jewelry Designs image 1

Store offers a comfortable, relaxing atmosphere with a welcoming, no-pressure vibe. It features a beautiful, well-curated space filled with stunning jewelry and premium watches. Staff demonstrate deep expertise, especially in watch knowledge and repairs, creating a friendly, family-like environment.

Staff provide immediate greeting and detailed attention when selecting jewelry. Custom work includes delicate scrolling duplication and adjustments on various pieces.

Staff show deep knowledge of high-end and vintage watches. They offer premium brands like Breitling and handle repairs and battery replacements with care. The watch buying experience includes personalized service and quick delivery options.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so friendly and knowledgeable."

"Dom at the Watch Store is so knowledgeable and helpful."

"The staff at this Ring Store are so wonderful and kind."

Good to know

1

Gem tasting events are held regularly; check the schedule for dates.

2

Sales events offer discounts on select items; inquire for details.

3

The store has a wide selection of new, pre-owned, and vintage timepieces.

03
Paul's Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Cozy jewelry store with a welcoming, party-like atmosphere and a cute shop dog. Staff offer in-house repairs, custom designs with 3D modeling, and quick turnaround times. Unique, elegant pieces and personalized service set it apart from typical jewelers.

Offers in-house repairs and custom designs with a unique and personal touch. Provides a wide selection of jewelry, especially for engagement and wedding rings, matching visions exactly.

Experts perform quick watch repairs like battery replacements and clasp swaps in minutes. Adjustments happen fast, but some repairs can affect wearability.

People are saying

"I had my ring fixed and it was done very fast."

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so helpful and kind."

"The watch repair was a 5-minute fix by the experts."

Good to know

1

Paul's Jewelers offers in-house repairs and custom designs for jewelry.

2

Repairs are completed within 24 hours, much faster than typical jewelers.

3

They provide in-house appraisals for jewelry, ensuring quick service.

04
Rogers & Hollands Jewelers image 1

Jewelry store offers a huge selection of diamonds and custom orders in various styles and gold colors. Atmosphere feels welcoming and comfortable with caring customer service focused on client happiness. Pricing is resourceful with strong warranty plans, making shopping smooth and easy.

Staff like Becky, Mark, and Michael offer patient, knowledgeable service and help design custom pieces. The store carries an excellent watch selection and wedding rings.

Watch fitting is fast and easy with staff like Mark, Janice, and Sophie who ensure a perfect fit. They offer watch repairs such as band fixing at no charge and provide a solid selection including brands like Citizen and Hamilton at decent prices.

People are saying

"This jewelry store's staff patiently helps you design your dream ring."

"Lisa made my ring dreams come true and brought my ideas to life."

"Mark and Becky are so helpful and knowledgeable at the Watch Store."

Good to know

1

The store offers a huge selection of diamonds and jewelry.

2

They provide special orders for any style, color of gold, or sizes.

3

The pricing is competitive, with many protection plans available.

05
Mixa jewelers.Sell/Buy,custom orders,engraving,pawn jewelry. image 1

Jewelry designer shop offers custom orders, engraving, and pawn services with reasonable prices. The atmosphere is practical and focused on quality repairs and resizing. Customers find fast turnaround and excellent value compared to other jewelers.

Staff focus on detailed ring care and provide watch and jewelry services. Repairs come at reasonable prices.

Watch repairs and battery replacements happen quickly here. Staff handle battery changes and watch repairs with care and efficiency.

People are saying

"I got exactly what I wanted from this Ring Store."

"I got my ring soldered perfectly at this jewelry store."

"I was in and out of the Watch Store in less than 10 minutes."

Good to know

1

The repair was reasonably priced compared to other jewelers.

2

Prices for resizing services are very reasonable.

3

The quality of the custom ring was fantastic.

06
The Jewelry Center image 1
Jewelry store

Bright, well-lit space showcases immaculate glass cases filled with beautiful jewelry and offers on-site watch battery replacement. Atmosphere feels inviting and warm, with friendly service and a relaxed, professional vibe. Chocolates and up-to-date music add a subtle touch of comfort and care.

Exceptional customer service stands out with personalized attention from staff like Vicki and Dean Murphy. High quality jewelry, including wedding bands and watch restoration, comes with a personal touch and fair pricing.

Quick watch battery replacements happen in about 5 minutes here. They handle watch repairs, including crystal replacements and link adjustments, and also sell vintage men's watches that run well.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so friendly and helpful."

"Vicki's patience and honest help made choosing the perfect ring a pleasant experience."

"The associates at this Watch Store are so friendly and helpful."

Good to know

1

The Jewelry Center offers watch battery replacements on-site.

2

Expect a wide selection of estate jewelry during special sales events.

3

Custom jewelry is crafted in-house, ensuring quality control.

07
Powers Jewelry Designers image 1

Jewelry store offers a large selection with more options for men than typical jewelers. Atmosphere is pressure-free and focused on high-quality craftsmanship and affordable pricing. Repairs and custom work happen smoothly, often exceeding expectations with quick turnaround and exceptional care.

Wedding bands get resized, polished, and soldered with care. Staff provide professional service and help with jewelry identification and valuation. The store offers a beautiful selection and stands out for customer service.

Tim Metzenheim helps with watch repairs and shows several watch options. A vintage Gucci watch was serviced for water damage but stopped working after pickup, with no clear solution provided.

People are saying

"Tim at this Ring Store is so knowledgeable and helpful."

"The Necklace Store staff remembers you by name and helps find the perfect piece."

"Tim at the Jewelry Store was so helpful and honest."

Good to know

1

Repairs are completed quickly and often free of charge.

2

Expect a turnaround time of less than two weeks for ring repairs.

3

The appraisal process is reasonable and straightforward.

08
Lake Country Jewelers Ltd. image 1

Jewelry store occupies a remodeled barn on a tree-lined drive, creating a cozy boutique atmosphere. Energy feels welcoming and expert, with skilled craftsmanship evident in repairs and custom work. Customers come for fair pricing, quick turnaround, and a wide selection of gems and watches.

Offers jewelry repairs, custom pieces, and watch services. Staff provides reliable service for future purchases and repairs.

Jeff handles watch repairs and sizing with care and precision. He offers expert advice on watch maintenance and performs authentications and diagnostics on various watch brands.

People are saying

"They fixed my watch in minutes and were super friendly."

"Jeff at the Ring Store has decades of experience and shares his wisdom."

"Jeff's knowledge and skills at this Jewelry Store are incredible."

Good to know

1

The store is located just off Highway 16 in Pewaukee, near Sussex.

2

You should look for the red barn to find the store.

3

The turnaround for repairs is quick.

09
Aladdin jewelry image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry store showcases luxury custom designs alongside a stunning selection of unique pieces. Atmosphere balances expert craftsmanship with affordable prices and reliable repair services. Business maintains steady growth with a focus on quality and value.

Custom pieces show expert craftsmanship and unique designs. Jewelry repairs and resizing happen with precision and fast turnaround.

Staff handle watch repairs and adjustments with quick service and careful attention. Tasks include resizing bands, replacing batteries, and fixing watch faces.

People are saying

"I saw beautiful custom jewelry pieces at this Jewelry Store."

"Aladdin at the Watch Store was super nice and helpful."

"I found the jewelry here to be super cool and affordable."

Good to know

1

Aladdin Jewelry offers quick and affordable jewelry and watch repairs.

2

They provide custom jewelry pieces tailored to individual preferences.

3

The quality of repair work is consistently high and reliable.

10
Kelvin Schroeder Jewelers image 1

Jewelry store offers custom work and on-site appraisals with a huge selection of settings. Atmosphere is family-friendly with a focus on quality craftsmanship and fair pricing. Repairs and restorations return pieces in like-new condition with attention to detail and conflict-free sourcing.

Jewelry repairs include engagement and wedding rings, with pieces returning looking brand-new. An on-site gemologist appraisal saves extra costs and adds convenience.

Watch resizing happens quickly, even just hours before events. The store offers dress watches and options to restore old watches to working condition.

People are saying

"My ring looked brand new after their amazing repair work."

"The staff at this jewelry store are so friendly and knowledgeable."

"This watch store's service is pleasant, quick, and top-notch."

Good to know

1

Kelvin is a gemologist who can appraise jewelry on site, saving you appraisal costs.

2

The ring was completed within a week as promised.

3

They had a huge selection of settings for you to pick from.

11
Pawn America image 1
Pawn shop

Pawn shop offers a clean, quiet atmosphere with a wide selection of jewelry and tools. Staff provide knowledgeable assistance and the process for buying or selling is fast and fair. Prices tend to be affordable and competitive compared to other sources.

Staff like Bri and Angela provide detailed knowledge about jewelry cuts and materials. Services include jewelry cleaning and hassle-free selling or pawning of gold and diamonds.

Staff provide accurate and consistent information on high-end watches. They assist with finding watches for different needs and offer services like watch band cleaning and fitting.

People are saying

"Angela at the Ring Store was so knowledgeable and helpful."

"Bri helped me find the perfect watch at the Watch Store."

"The staff at this jewelry store are so kind and helpful."

Good to know

1

Ask for Bri or Michelle for excellent service and jewelry advice.

2

The pawn process is quick and efficient, making it easy to sell items.

3

They offer layaway options and protection plans for jewelry purchases.

12
Jared Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry store offers a welcoming atmosphere with in-house repairs and resizing for most pieces. Staff provide transparent sourcing and maintain strong customer relationships through easy account management and a rewards program.

Staff like Melissa spend time assessing and cleaning jewelry without charging. Jewelry repairs and purchases include rings and earrings. Insurance policies for jewelry come with good coverage and no issues.

Staff like Heidi Avello and Dorena provide helpful and patient service when selecting or adjusting watches. The store offers in-house watch sizing and repairs, making it a reliable spot for watch purchases and maintenance.

People are saying

"The Ring Store staff are warm, patient, and genuinely fun to work with."

"The service at this jewelry store is warm, kind, and extremely helpful."

"Jennifer was so quick and efficient helping me at the Watch Store."

Good to know

1

Jared Jewelers offers in-house repairs and resizing for most jewelry.

2

A lifetime warranty is available for jewelry purchases at Jared.

3

Bring your jewelry in for inspection every six months for maintenance.

13
Harry Glinberg Jewelers image 1

Small space offers a wide range of luxury watches and jewelry, including one-of-a-kind pieces. Atmosphere feels clean and luxurious with a warm, personable vibe. Quick services like resizing happen within minutes, and pricing is fair and reasonable.

A wide range of jewelry and watches fills the store, including several Rolex watches and rings. Staff offer friendly, warm conversation and provide fair prices when buying or selling jewelry.

Luxury brand watches fill the store with a wide selection. Staff handle watch resizing quickly and provide attentive, efficient service for fitting and adjustments.

People are saying

"I'll be back for all my jewelry needs; the service was great."

"I got my watch resized quickly and easily here."

"The Ring Store staff were the nicest and most accommodating people."

Good to know

1

Harry Glinberg Jewelers offers resizing services, often completed within an hour.

2

They provide fair prices for selling jewelry, with competitive offers.

3

One-of-a-kind pieces are available, making it a unique shopping experience.

14
KAY Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry store offers a wide selection of men's and women's pieces including diamond bracelets and brand watches. Atmosphere feels stress free and pressure free, with staff providing helpful care advice. Sizing and servicing processes are efficient and straightforward.

Staff like Sandy, Kelly, and Tina provide honest guidance and help with selecting and caring for jewelry. The store offers a wide selection of diamond bracelets, watches from Movado, Bulova, and Citizens, tennis chains, and men's rings with 3 carats or more.

A wide selection of watches from Movado, Bulova, and Citizens stands out here. Staff explain details about each watch and limited editions, helping pick out the right one.

People are saying

"Sandy was so helpful finding the perfect ring."

"The staff at this jewelry store are so helpful and patient."

"Kelly helped me pick out a great watch."

Good to know

1

The store has a wide selection of men's and women's diamond jewelry and watches.

2

Ring sizing typically takes less than a week.

3

The repair process may take a few months as items are shipped to headquarters.

15
North Shore Jewelers image 1

Jewelry store offers excellent craftsmanship and seamless repair services with quick turnaround and reasonable prices. It carries a varied selection including unique, sourced pieces and handles repairs others decline. The atmosphere reflects trustworthiness and attention to detail.

Helpful staff provide knowledgeable resizing for platinum rings. Jewelry repair includes expert soldering that restores necklaces to look like new. Prices stay fair while offering beautiful pieces.

Repairs come at a fair price with quick turnaround. Services include battery replacement, resealing, and fixing metal bands with pin replacements.

People are saying

"This jewelry store does beautiful restoration and repairs on your pieces."

"I had my rings restored and they looked brand new."

"This watch store fixed my dad's old watch quickly and for a fair price."

Good to know

1

They quoted me a fair price to redo the channel set, resize, and re-plate my ring.

2

My ring was ready in 24 hours and now sparkles like new.

3

They repaired items that other jewelers said couldn't be fixed.

16
Scott's Jewelry Shop image 1

Shop offers reasonable pricing and quick repairs with a wide selection of jewelry. Atmosphere feels pleasant and reliable, attracting those seeking quality service and polished results.

Repairs come at a reasonable price and cover resizing, stone replacement, and clasp fixes. The shop offers authentic watches and handles delicate tasks like joining vintage rings with care.

Battery replacements happen in just a few minutes. Watch bracelets get resized quickly and accurately on the first try. Authentic Fossil watches in great condition are available here.

People are saying

"I got my jewelry repaired quickly and at a fair price."

"I got my watch battery replaced in minutes."

"The Ring Store staff, especially Scott, were super friendly and helpful."

Good to know

1

The repair service is quick and reasonably priced.

2

Battery replacement costs are competitive compared to other shops.

3

Expect high-quality work with beautiful results.

Discover more

Wisconsin

Area guide
Loading Map...