Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Wisconsin

Jewelry stores

You are looking for a jeweler who treats the purchase of a piece as a significant, long-term investment.

Based on 776 Opinions
+773
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
The Jewelry Center image 1
The Jewelry Center image 2
The Jewelry Center image 3
View all
Jewelry store

Bright setting with interior-lit jewelry boxes creates an elegant vibe. Friendly, unhurried service makes shopping relaxed and personal. Trusted appraisals and expert repairs by an onsite jeweler ensure quality and care.

Offers trusted appraisals and expert repairs with an onsite jeweler. Provides a personalized selection and competitive prices for buying or selling jewelry.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are friendly and real experts."

"I got my watch battery replacement done quickly and affordably."

"I found their merchandise beautiful and affordable."

Good to know

1

The Jewelry Center offers custom ring making services.

2

Watch battery replacement is affordable and quick.

3

They have a great selection of estate jewelry.

02
Cival Jewelry Studio image 1

Shop offers handmade jewelry with a curated aesthetic that feels unique and creative. Staff provide personalized care making wedding and engagement ring selection easy. Pieces are ethically sourced and one of a kind, perfect for those seeking personal style.

Jewelry here is custom made on site, offering unique, one of a kind pieces. Staff provide personalized care that makes selecting wedding and engagement jewelry easy and enjoyable.

People are saying

"This jewelry store has beautiful, unique, and handmade pieces."

"I designed my custom ring here and the process felt magical."

"I wanted something completely unique for my wedding band."

Good to know

1

The jewelry is handmade on-site, ensuring unique and exquisite pieces.

2

Custom and heirloom jewelry creations are available for personalized gifts.

3

Prices are reasonable, making it accessible for various budgets.

03
Kesslers Diamonds - Downtown Milwaukee image 1

Jewelry store shines with customizable rings and magnetic stone try-ons. Staff like Ryan and Kris offer exceptional service that makes choosing easy. Enjoy free cleaning and resizing plus quick delivery and lifetime guarantees.

Engagement rings and fine jewelry receive careful attention here. Staff like Ryan and Kris provide exceptional service to help find pieces that customers cherish.

People are saying

"Ryan was so patient helping me find the perfect ring."

"Ryan at this jewelry store was so patient helping us find the perfect ring."

"They were so patient helping me pick out the perfect rings."

Good to know

1

They offer free ring resizing for purchases made in-store.

2

The customization process allows you to create a ring exactly as you want it.

3

They provide a lifetime guarantee program for all purchases.

04
Paul's Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Cozy store buzzes with a party-like atmosphere and a friendly shop dog. Staff excel in custom designs using 3D modeling and offer in-house repairs with quick turnaround. Unique, elegant pieces shine, especially for engagement rings.

Offers in-house repairs and custom designs with a unique and personal touch. Provides a wide selection of jewelry, especially for engagement and wedding rings, matching visions exactly.

People are saying

"I had my ring fixed and it was done very fast."

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so helpful and kind."

"I got the most beautiful custom necklace made here."

Good to know

1

Paul's Jewelers offers in-house repairs and custom designs for jewelry.

2

Repairs are completed within 24 hours, much faster than typical jewelers.

3

They provide in-house appraisals for jewelry, ensuring quick service.

05
Kalina & Co. Jewelry image 1

Spacious boutique shines with a warm atmosphere and high-quality jewelry. Offers permanent bracelets and customized necklaces perfect for matching family sets. Space feels cozy and modern, inviting visitors to explore unique, dainty pieces.

Offers permanent jewelry and a great selection of bracelets and necklaces. Provides personalized design input and matching pieces for family members.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so friendly and welcoming."

"Getting permanent jewelry made matching bracelets with my sister was a fun activity."

"It's so kid friendly; my daughter felt pampered and called the staff a queen."

Good to know

1

Appointments are recommended for getting permanent jewelry.

2

The application process for permanent jewelry is quick and easy.

3

Bracelets are high quality and won't tarnish.

06
J.P. Haase Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Family-oriented store offers custom jewelry with a personal touch from family pieces. Staff build trust through a smooth, clear process. Find rare ring sizes like 13 and high-quality diamond earrings at good prices.

Stock includes rare ring sizes like size 13. Jewelry crafted from family pieces offers a personal touch. Selection features high-quality diamond earrings available at good prices.

People are saying

"The people at this Jewelry Store are so friendly and caring."

Good to know

1

They offer custom jewelry creation with unbeatable prices.

2

The jewelry shop has rare size 13 rings in stock.

3

Resized rings show no seams or signs of alteration.

07
KAY Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry store shines with excellent quality earrings and beautiful rings in a calm, clean space. Staff offer personalized service and expert advice, including repairs and protection plans. Customers enjoy professional care and easy access to fine jewelry.

Staff provide knowledgeable service and help find specific pieces like earrings and wedding bands. Jewelry receives professional care including cleaning and updates, even with issues like loose diamonds.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so helpful and patient."

"The Ring Store staff is so patient and knowledgeable when helping you choose."

"The staff here is so welcoming and made my daughter's ear piercing pain-free."

Good to know

1

KAY Jewelers offers personalized service and assistance with jewelry purchases.

2

They provide help with jewelry repairs, including Bulova watches.

3

The store runs sales periodically, making it a good time to shop.

08
Lulu Jewelry image 1
Jewelry store

Offers a wide selection of elegant gold jewelry with custom options. Staff provide honest service and quick, affordable repairs. Atmosphere is kid friendly and pressure-free, making shopping easy and pleasant.

A wide selection of modern and elegant yellow and white jewelry stands out here. Staff are honest and knowledgeable, offering fair prices and helpful service for purchases and repairs.

People are saying

"This is the best jewelry store I've ever visited."

Good to know

1

They fix watches in under 5 minutes.

2

Custom jewelry pieces can be made to your specifications.

3

Repair fees for jewelry are very reasonable.

09
Custom Bridal Jewelry Inc image 1

Appointment-only visits offer private consultations with expert staff who explain custom jewelry creation and value. Rare stones like green sapphires are sourced locally, ensuring unique pieces. Decades of experience guarantee high-quality craftsmanship at fair prices.

Staff spend time explaining the creation, quality, and value of custom pieces. They source rare stones like green sapphires through local contacts. Experience spans decades with a focus on quality jewelry at reasonable cost.

People are saying

"David helped me design the perfect custom ring with his knowledge."

"This place's date spots are perfect for custom engagement rings."

"This jewelry store's owner is a master of his craft and explains everything clearly."

Good to know

1

David works by appointment only, ensuring personalized service for each client.

2

He has extensive experience in the jewelry business, specializing in custom pieces.

3

David can source unique stones like green sapphires that are hard to find elsewhere.

10
A Trio Jewelry Design Studio image 1

Family-run shop offers warm atmosphere and exceptional craftsmanship. Staff provide patient service and create custom wedding rings from heirlooms. Free cleaning keeps jewelry shining and customers coming back.

Helpful, kind, and patient service defines the experience here. Custom pieces like wedding ring sets from heirloom rings are crafted with care. The shop operates as a family-run business that genuinely cares about customers and supports ongoing jewelry upkeep.

People are saying

"This jewelry store creates beautiful custom pieces with personal, local touches."

"Working with Amy and Noah at the Ring Store was a joyful, patient experience."

"This Local Spot brought my custom vision to life with amazing craftsmanship."

Good to know

1

The store has limited hours, so plan your visit accordingly.

2

No structured appointments are available, which may lead to a busy atmosphere.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted for purchases.

11
Stein's Jewelry & Loan image 1

Pawn shop offers beautiful decoration and a comfortable atmosphere with excellent customer service. Staff provide individual care for jewelry needs, including buying, selling, and repair. Fair prices and options like layaway and trade-in make it easy to find hard-to-find rings.

Excellent customer service stands out with patient staff helping find hard-to-find items and beautiful rings at fair prices. Services include buying, selling, honest valuations, and jewelry repair with individual care.

People are saying

"Renee at this jewelry store was so patient and helpful finding beautiful rings."

"The Ring Store staff, especially Renee, are so patient and helpful."

Good to know

1

They offer buying, selling, and jewelry repair services with personalized attention.

2

They pay competitive prices for old gold and jewelry compared to other places.

3

Layaway options are available, and they work with customers on payments.

12
Aladdin jewelry image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry store offers custom designs with expert craftsmanship and unique pieces. Repairs and resizing are precise with a fast turnaround. Prices stay affordable while quality remains high, making it a trusted spot for luxury and value.

Custom pieces show expert craftsmanship and unique designs. Jewelry repairs and resizing happen with precision and fast turnaround.

People are saying

"I saw beautiful custom jewelry pieces at this Jewelry Store."

"Aladdin at the Watch Store was super nice and helpful."

"I found the jewelry here to be super cool and affordable."

Good to know

1

Aladdin Jewelry offers quick and affordable jewelry and watch repairs.

2

They provide custom jewelry pieces tailored to individual preferences.

3

The quality of repair work is consistently high and reliable.

13
CRAIG HUSAR Fine Diamonds & Jewelry Designs image 1

Store offers a welcoming vibe with expert staff who excel in custom jewelry work and watch repairs. Space is beautifully curated with stunning pieces and premium watches. Atmosphere feels like a friendly family gathering.

Staff provide immediate greeting and detailed attention when selecting jewelry. Custom work includes delicate scrolling duplication and adjustments on various pieces.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so friendly and knowledgeable."

"Dom at the Watch Store is so knowledgeable and helpful."

"The staff at this Ring Store are so wonderful and kind."

Good to know

1

Gem tasting events are held regularly; check the schedule for dates.

2

Sales events offer discounts on select items; inquire for details.

3

The store has a wide selection of new, pre-owned, and vintage timepieces.

14
North Shore Jewelers image 1

Jewelry store shines with expert soldering and knowledgeable resizing for platinum rings. Offers unique sourced pieces and handles tough repairs others decline. Staff ensure quick turnaround and fair prices in a trustworthy setting.

Helpful staff provide knowledgeable resizing for platinum rings. Jewelry repair includes expert soldering that restores necklaces to look like new. Prices stay fair while offering beautiful pieces.

People are saying

"This jewelry store does beautiful restoration and repairs on your pieces."

"I had my rings restored and they looked brand new."

"This watch store fixed my dad's old watch quickly and for a fair price."

Good to know

1

They quoted me a fair price to redo the channel set, resize, and re-plate my ring.

2

My ring was ready in 24 hours and now sparkles like new.

3

They repaired items that other jewelers said couldn't be fixed.

15
Sienna Moon image 1
Gift shop

Space glows with crystals by chakra and handmade jewelry crafted by local artisans. Separate rooms for incense and tarot add to the peaceful vibe. Classes and healing sessions build community and invite exploration.

Handmade jewelry stands out with custom designs and attention to detail. The store offers a wide selection of crystals and metaphysical items alongside jewelry crafted by local artisans.

People are saying

"I found the jewelry and crystals here so beautiful."

"I always discovered something new and interesting here."

"I always leave feeling lighter and calmer than when I entered."

Good to know

1

Monthly healing community classes include breathwork and reiki circles.

2

Monday afternoon crystal happy hour offers tea samples in a chill yoga room.

3

Regular workshops and events are hosted throughout the month.

16
Kesslers Diamonds - Greenfield image 1

Classy store offers custom ring design and smooth jewelry repair. Staff provide free soda and snacks in a calm, welcoming space. Customers enjoy an unmatched warranty with no pressure to buy.

Excellent customer service and jewelry repair stand out here. They handle resizing and fixing wedding rings smoothly and offer custom ring design using family heirlooms.

People are saying

"The Ring Store staff listened and worked within my budget."

"The staff here makes couples feel seen, respected, and welcomed."

"The staff at this jewelry store are so helpful and knowledgeable."

Good to know

1

Kesslers Diamonds requires customers to make an appointment for repairs.

2

They offer a warranty that covers resizing and repairs on jewelry.

3

You can customize your ring to fit your exact preferences.

17
Schwanke-Kasten Jewelers image 1

Beautifully designed space with private lounges creates a calm, genuine atmosphere. Offers an amazing selection of the finest jewelry. Service is attentive and straightforward, perfect for those seeking high-quality pieces.

Offers an amazing selection of the finest jewelry with everything needed from a jewelry shop.

People are saying

"Rich was so helpful and patient finding my first luxury watch."

"I felt calm, comfortable, and truly special during my luxurious experience."

"I considered this the best jewelry store in southeast Wisconsin."

Good to know

1

Schwanke-Kasten Jewelers offers custom engraving options for personalized gifts.

2

Expect a wide selection of luxury watches and fine jewelry available.

3

The store provides quick shipping for online orders, ensuring timely delivery.

18
Kesslers Diamonds - Germantown image 1

Bright, organized space offers a relaxed atmosphere with complimentary drinks and no-pressure service. Staff provide attentive help for special occasions and quick, reliable repairs with lifetime maintenance.

Offers a wide selection of fine jewelry including diamond rings with lifetime maintenance and cleanings. Staff provide attentive service and help with upgrades and purchases for special occasions.

People are saying

"The staff at this Ring Store are so friendly and welcoming."

"They made me feel comfortable and calm during the process."

"The staff at this jewelry store are so friendly and welcoming."

Good to know

1

Free mimosas are offered on Saturdays.

2

Kesslers Diamonds provides lifetime maintenance and cleaning for wedding rings.

3

Repairs and cleaning are covered under the ring's warranty.

19
Kesslers Diamonds - Brookfield image 1

Jewelry store shines with diamond jewelry and a calming vibe. Staff offer thoughtful presentation with champagne and custom packaging. In-house goldsmith crafts custom rings backed by a lifetime warranty for repairs and replacements.

Offers diamond jewelry with strong customer loyalty. Provides ring repair and cleaning services that satisfy long-term customers.

People are saying

"The staff at this Ring Store are so knowledgeable and helpful."

"The staff made the whole experience easy and special."

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so friendly and knowledgeable."

Good to know

1

Kesslers offers a lifetime warranty that includes free repairs for lost diamonds.

2

Free resizing is available for wedding rings and anniversary bands.

3

Expect quick turnaround times for ring adjustments and custom jewelry.

20
Banter by Piercing Pagoda image 1

Jewelry store shines with affordable prices and warranty options. Piercing services are quick and clean, with clear aftercare guidance. Staff show expertise in style and offer helpful discounts, making shopping smooth and friendly.

Staff provide clear explanations about jewelry products and processes. They offer warranty options and discounts on earrings, helping find the right pieces with kindness and expertise.

People are saying

"Tammy at the Jewelry Store is so kind and knowledgeable."

"This place is so kid friendly; Tammy made my daughter feel happy and less nervous."

"The mall employees were great and helpful during my visit."

Good to know

1

Ask for Tammy for great customer service.

2

Dane is recommended for safe and professional piercings.

3

Prices are affordable for jewelry and services.

21
Powers Jewelry Designers image 1

Offers a large selection with more men's options than usual. Staff provide professional service and help with jewelry ID and valuation. Repairs and custom work are done with exceptional care and quick turnaround in a pressure-free atmosphere.

Wedding bands get resized, polished, and soldered with care. Staff provide professional service and help with jewelry identification and valuation. The store offers a beautiful selection and stands out for customer service.

People are saying

"Tim at this Ring Store is so knowledgeable and helpful."

"The Necklace Store staff remembers you by name and helps find the perfect piece."

"Tim at the Jewelry Store was so helpful and honest."

Good to know

1

Repairs are completed quickly and often free of charge.

2

Expect a turnaround time of less than two weeks for ring repairs.

3

The appraisal process is reasonable and straightforward.

22
Robert Haack Diamond Importers image 1

Offers custom jewelry with a wide selection of rings and earrings at fair prices. Provides reliable repairs and appraisals that restore items like new. Atmosphere feels honest and trustworthy, fitting various budgets well.

Selections include diamonds, gold, silver, and custom jewelry with quality pieces at great prices. Repairs cover soldering and fixing, returning items like new. Market value is given for selling jewelry.

People are saying

"Leslie at this Jewelry Store was so helpful and knowledgeable."

"Leslie was so helpful and patient finding my perfect ring."

Good to know

1

They have the largest selection of all the places we visited.

2

I found Robert Haack Diamond Importers to have the absolute best jewelry pricing in the Midwest.

3

They handled soldering, pawning, diamonds, gold, silver, and custom jewelry.

23
Tobin Jewelers - New Berlin image 1

Jewelry store offers custom rings with high-quality materials and unique design features like European shank bands. Staff shows deep care and pride, providing good prices and reliable repairs in a welcoming atmosphere.

Custom rings get made exactly as requested with high quality materials. Staff shows deep care and pride in both the jewelry and customer experience, offering good prices and reliable repairs.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so helpful and friendly."

"I had my ring custom made exactly how I wanted it."

Good to know

1

Tobin Jewelers offers high-quality, one-of-a-kind jewelry pieces.

2

Prices at Tobin Jewelers are competitive and budget-friendly.

3

You don't need to be wealthy to receive excellent service at Tobin.

24
JRS Jewelry Repair Shop image 1

Shop offers a quiet, clean environment with high-quality gold jewelry at great prices. Owner provides clear explanations and fast, professional repairs. Modest setting reflects integrity and local support for buying and selling.

High-quality gold jewelry is available at great prices. The owner is very knowledgeable and explains jewelry details clearly. Repairs and renewals happen quickly and professionally, with authentic pieces and thorough appraisals.

People are saying

"The owner at this jewelry store is so nice and helpful."

Good to know

1

The shop specializes in jewelry repair and offers custom design services.

2

Expect competitive pricing for both buying and selling jewelry.

3

Appointments are recommended for repair services to ensure timely assistance.

25
Sullivan Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Offers unique, intricate jewelry with a great selection and fair prices. Provides fast, easy resizing that keeps rings looking new. Ideal for those seeking one-of-a-kind pieces and reliable value.

Unique, intricate jewelry pieces fill the display with a great selection and fair prices. Services include ring resizing and quality watches for special occasions.

People are saying

"They resized my wedding band quickly and it was a great experience."

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so friendly and helpful."

Good to know

1

The resizing process is quick, often completed in just 15 minutes.

2

Prices for jewelry repairs and resizing are fair and competitive.

3

Satisfaction is guaranteed with every purchase or service.

26
Costa's Fine Jewelry & Coins image 1

Opulent showroom with blue curtains creates a high-end feel. Jewelry features intricate designs and custom rings with expert craftsmanship. Friendly staff assist with buying, selling, and repairs, making shopping seamless and fair.

Jewelry includes masterpieces with intricate designs and options for custom-made rings. Staff offers friendly, knowledgeable service and help with buying, selling, and repairs.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so helpful and patient."

"The staff at this Ring Store went above and beyond to help."

Good to know

1

Costa's Fine Jewelry & Coins offers secure shipping for all purchases.

2

They provide fair market prices for buying and selling coins.

3

Costa's specializes in custom jewelry restoration and design.

27
Mid Continental Gems image 1

Family-owned jeweler offers custom pieces with exceptional craftsmanship and competitive pricing. Repairs on rings are seamless with no visible damage. Service by appointment ensures focused attention in a kind, welcoming atmosphere.

They offer custom jewelry that big box stores do not. Repairs on rings are seamless, with no visible signs of damage. Pricing is competitive, especially for fixing sentimental pieces.

People are saying

"This Ring Store created the ring of my dreams."

"This Family Owned place offered great prices and quality work."

"I got my engagement ring from the owners; they are amazing people."

Good to know

1

They are open by appointment only.

2

Their prices are reasonable for the quality received.

3

They offer custom jewelry pieces not found in big box stores.

28
Gold Creations Ltd image 1

Offers Midwest nice atmosphere with unmatched craftsmanship in custom gold jewelry. Visitors trust expert appraisals and enjoy prompt repairs and excellent hospitality. Rings often increase in value, showing skill and care.

Custom gold jewelry features outstanding quality and prompt repairs. Appraisals are trusted, and hospitality is excellent when handling precious pieces.

People are saying

"This jewelry store crafts custom pieces and offers reliable repairs."

"The Ring Store's service is always personable and they're happy to help."

Good to know

1

Appointments are recommended for personalized jewelry consultations.

2

The store offers a 30-day return policy on unworn items.

3

Credit cards and cash are accepted; no checks allowed.

Discover more

Wisconsin

Area guide
Loading Map...