Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Wisconsin

Reubens

You have a specific expectation for a Reuben that most places fail to meet. You only seek out the version that balances the meat, kraut, and bread exactly as it should be.

Based on 432 Opinions
+429
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Kurt Schulz Deli & Pastry Shoppe image 1
Kurt Schulz Deli & Pastry Shoppe image 2
Kurt Schulz Deli & Pastry Shoppe image 3
View all

Deli blends old school charm with a cozy vibe perfect for reading or studying. Kids enjoy classic toys like Rock Em Sock Em Robots while loyal customers savor homemade sandwiches. The Reuben shines with crunchy bread and lean corned beef topped by a special dressing.

Crunchy bread holds thinly sliced, super lean corned beef, Swiss cheese, and kraut. A homemade thousand island dressing adds a classic touch to this true-to-form Reuben.

People are saying

"The pastries here are outstanding and out of this world."

"The staff here is super friendly during breakfast."

"I highly recommend the Reuben; it's among the best I've had."

Good to know

1

Half-price deli salads are available on Saturdays.

2

The shop closes at 3:00 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

3

The bakery offers fresh donuts made by the owner on Saturday mornings.

02
O'Sullivan's Public House image 1

Irish pub offers classic Wisconsin bar comfort with a quiet, spacious atmosphere and Packer memorabilia on the walls. The Reuben sandwich is large and flavorful, fitting perfectly with the cozy vibe. Dining feels like a basic supper club, ideal for calm, welcoming crowds.

The Reuben sandwich impresses with its large size and satisfying flavor. It fits well in an Irish pub setting and stands out among other menu options.

People are saying

"The pub food here is delicious, especially the ribs."

"I felt so at home with their soup."

"The Reuben sandwich was great and impressive in size."

Good to know

1

O'Sullivan's offers a variety of Irish food and drink options.

2

Prices at O'Sullivan's are very affordable for both food and drinks.

3

The bar is fully stocked and tends to be busy during peak hours.

03
Benji's Deli & Restaurant image 1

Old school Jewish deli offers a warm, lively atmosphere with classic diner feel and natural light. Corned beef in the Reuben sandwich is perfectly cooked, paired with tangy sauerkraut and creamy Swiss cheese on marble rye. Generous portions make every bite satisfying.

Corned beef cooks perfectly and pairs with tangy sauerkraut and creamy Swiss cheese on marble rye bread. The sandwich is generously portioned and the flavors meld beautifully with each bite.

People are saying

"I loved the flavor and portion of their corned beef sandwich."

"I thought the Reuben sandwich was excellent and amazing."

"I enjoyed a great breakfast with delicious, ample portions."

Good to know

1

Parking is limited and first come, first serve, making street parking a better option.

2

The current price for a Reuben sandwich is $20.

3

The deli opens at 10am, which is later than typical breakfast spots.

04
Deli 1614 | “That Corned Beef Place” image 1

Small lobby opens to a lively sandwich shop known for hand-cut meats and made-to-order sandwiches. Corned beef in the Reuben sandwich is flavorful and not too fatty, served on toasted bread. Prices stay affordable, making it a top spot for quality deli fare.

Corned beef shines in the Reuben sandwich with great flavor and toasted bread. It stays not too fatty and pairs well with fries.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and fresh."

"The corned beef at this deli is tender, flavorful, and delicious."

"I thought the Reuben was one of the best corned beef sandwiches I had."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of 30 minutes or more during peak hours.

2

All meats are hand cut and sandwiches are made to order, typically within 10-15 minutes.

3

The menu is all a la carte with a variety of delicious items to choose from.

05
O'Lydia's Bar and Grill image 1

Irish pub offers spacious seating indoors and out with a friendly atmosphere that invites chat. Reuben sandwiches come with homemade fries and sometimes as egg rolls, perfect with a bloody or solo. Donation shuttles add event convenience despite nearby train noise.

Reuben sandwiches come with homemade fries and sometimes appear as egg rolls. They pair well with a bloody or stand alone before events.

People are saying

"The pub food here is fantastic and reasonably priced."

"I thought the burgers here were amazing and delicious."

"I had a fabulous Reuben sandwich with tender corned beef."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs all day on Sundays with special drink prices.

2

Saturday Steak Night features discounted steak options and drink specials.

3

Daily food and drink specials are available throughout the week.

06
Benji's Deli image 1

Small deli with hand-carved corned beef shines in its Reuben sandwich, offering a solid lunch choice. Cozy, local favorite vibe draws steady crowds. Outdoor seating adds charm to enjoying the classic deli flavors like the best matzo ball soup.

Corned beef stands out in the Reuben sandwich here, making it a solid choice for lunch. The sandwich offers a pretty good balance of flavors.

People are saying

"This deli's pastrami sandwich is loaded with meat."

"I recommend this American food for a great corned beef or Reuben sandwich."

"I remember the corned beef being better seasoned."

Good to know

1

Arriving early increases your chances of getting a seat; indoor seating is limited.

2

Parking is plentiful in the outdoor shopping plaza.

3

Prices can be on the higher side; a meal for four can cost around $50.

07
Bobby's Bar Great Place Good Times image 1

Bar buzzes with upbeat atmosphere and friendly crowds. Reuben sandwich boasts large corned beef chunks but can be cold inside. Multiple TVs and an upstairs patio offer great spots for sports fans and gatherings.

Large chunks of corned beef fill the Reuben sandwich. The meat is sometimes cut into cubes, which can cause it to be cold in the middle after reheating.

People are saying

"The food here is fantastic, especially the prime rib."

"The food at this bar is fantastic and flavorful."

"I really enjoyed the Reuben sandwich with large chunks of corned beef."

Good to know

1

During local sporting events, Bobby’s Bar offers signed sports memorabilia giveaways.

2

Don't miss the chicken wing special on Mondays.

3

The prime rib special on Saturdays is a highlight.

Discover more

Wisconsin

Area guide
Loading Map...