Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Pie spots in Milwaukee

Finding a slice of pie that actually tastes like it came from a kitchen instead of a factory line.

Based on 469 Opinions
+466
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Foltz Family Market & Commission Row Produce image 1
Foltz Family Market & Commission Row Produce image 2
Foltz Family Market & Commission Row Produce image 3
View all

Brick-style pizza oven creates a lively scene while diners enjoy cozy bar area with market views. Chicken pot pie offers rich, savory flavors, and top-quality sausages deliver quick, satisfying bites. Paninis add a tasty, fresh touch to the menu.

Chicken pot pie stands out with a rich, savory filling. The spinach and feta pie offers a great blend of flavors.

People are saying

"The Philly pizza here is amazing."

"The sausage here is S Tier, among the best I've ever had."

"I found the chicken pot pie to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect long lines during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

Freshly ground burgers are available daily.

3

You can order any steak you see in the case.

02
Bread House | Mediterranean Bakery & More image 1

Rustic decor and fragrant aromas create a cozy vibe perfect for casual dining. Meat pies shine with golden crusts and rich, savory fillings like beef and spinach. Fresh, flavorful pastries and breads add authentic Middle Eastern flair to every bite.

Golden crusts and rich, savory fillings define the meat pies here. The potato pie, hot dog pie, and beef and spinach pies offer delicate, complex flavors that stand out.

People are saying

"You have to try the honeycomb bread; it's phenomenal."

"The falafel with hummus and fluffy bread tasted amazing."

"The spinach pie is fresh, delicious, and a must-try."

Good to know

1

Prices are very reasonable, making it a great value for money.

2

The bakery offers a large variety of vegetarian options, including falafel and eggplant.

3

Expect a family-friendly atmosphere, perfect for dining with kids.

03
Palomino Bar image 1

Long bar offers a strong bourbon selection and a quiet atmosphere perfect for locals. Strawberry rhubarb and cubano hand pies deliver excellent flavor, while pie making classes add a fun, hands-on touch. Great spot for a relaxed night with homemade desserts.

Strawberry rhubarb and savory cubano hand pies stand out with excellent flavor. Homemade oatmeal cream pies offer a tasty dessert option. Pie making classes happen in a dedicated kitchen.

People are saying

"The fish fry here is delicious and plentiful."

"I found the homemade oatmeal cream pie to be one of the best."

"I thought the vegan hot chicken sandwich was fantastic."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the bar gets busy, especially on weekends.

2

The menu has limited options with only four entrees available.

3

The kitchen closes early, so arrive before the last orders are taken.

04
Oakland Gyros (Oakland Ave) image 1

Old building offers a laid back vibe with friendly atmosphere and lively nights. Spinach pies shine with crispy crusts and perfect fillings. Dining area stays clean with plenty of tables and booths for comfort.

Spinach pies have crispy, flaky crusts and fillings that are always perfectly delicious. They stand out as a consistent favorite alongside other dishes like gyros.

People are saying

"I found the Greek food here to be the best gyros I've ever had."

"This late night spot always has great gyros, especially after the bars."

"The spinach pie has a perfectly crispy, flaky crust."

Good to know

1

Parking at Oakland Gyros can be challenging due to the busy intersection.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted, but cash is recommended for quick service.

3

Expect larger serving sizes for a reasonable price compared to other places.

05
SmallPie image 1

Small cafe offers hand pies with savory and sweet choices like chicken herb pie and pistachio pie. Relaxed vibe with covered patio surrounded by plants creates a cozy spot. Quiet outdoor area welcomes dogs, making it perfect for casual visits.

Offers small hand pies with both savory and sweet options. Favorites include the chicken herb pie, pistachio pie, and hashbrown sausage hand pie.

People are saying

"I found the pies here to be so delicious."

"I loved the blueberry turkey sandwich; it became my favorite."

"The outdoor seating area is beautiful and serene."

Good to know

1

Parking can be challenging in the area, so plan accordingly.

2

Hand pies are priced at $10 each, which may be considered expensive.

3

SmallPie is dog-friendly, allowing pets on the outdoor seating.

06
Oakland Gyros on Layton image 1

Gyro spot offers a comfortable hometown feel with quaint Greek music and decorative grapes overhead. Spinach pie shines with rich flavor and fast service. The clean, lively space serves generous portions that keep guests coming back.

Spinach pie features a rich flavor and a satisfying taste that stands out. Service is fast, making it easy to enjoy this dish quickly.

People are saying

"I thought the gyro meat was solid and the best I've ever had."

"This gyro platter is huge, easily enough for two meals."

"I thought the spinach pie was exceptional and delicious."

Good to know

1

Portions are generous, often enough for leftovers.

2

Prices have increased by about $4 in the past three years.

3

The drive-thru service is convenient, especially in bad weather.

07
Omega Restaurant image 1

Greek diner blends Mediterranean flair with a cozy, family vibe. Spinach pie delivers rich, savory flavor that pairs well with lamb chops. Open layout and plentiful booths create a lively yet intimate setting.

Spinach pie stands out with outstanding flavor and pairs well with lamb chops. The pie offers a rich, savory taste that complements hearty meals.

People are saying

"You get huge portions with your breakfast here."

"The Greek salad here is great, especially with toasted anchovies."

"The spinach pie here is heaven on earth."

Good to know

1

The restaurant closes early on Saturday nights, with the kitchen shutting down at 8:30 PM.

2

Prices are reasonable, making it a budget-friendly option.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

08
O'Lydia's Bar and Grill image 1

Irish pub offers spacious seating indoors and out with a friendly atmosphere that invites chat. Shepherd's pie stands out with a unique style among hearty dishes. Donation-based shuttles add convenient transport to events despite nearby train noise.

Shepherd's pie here has a unique style that differs from typical versions. It appears on the menu alongside other hearty options like chili and Reuben sandwiches.

People are saying

"The pub food here is fantastic and reasonably priced."

"I thought the burgers here were amazing and delicious."

"I tried the shepherd's pie and it was different than others."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs all day on Sundays with special drink prices.

2

Saturday Steak Night features discounted steak options and drink specials.

3

Daily food and drink specials are available throughout the week.

Discover more

Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Area guide
Loading Map...