Family-run Italian deli with authentic Sicilian recipes and homemade sausages creates a warm, welcoming atmosphere like an Italian cafe. Large portions and reasonably priced take-and-bake pizzas attract locals seeking quality and value. The vibe is cozy and inviting, making it a standout spot for Italian specialties.
Take-and-bake pizzas stand out for being top tier and reasonably priced. Sicilian-style slices and specialty pizzas offer authentic flavors with solid local appeal.
Famous homemade sausages stand out with high quality and authentic flavors from Bagheria. Sandwiches feature mild Italian sausage and grilled sausage patties that appeal to sausage lovers.
"I loved the spicy Italian sandwich with the perfect amount of giardiniera."
"I found the take and bake pizza to be a great value."
"I thought their Italian sausage was the best in Milwaukee."
Good to know
Street parking is available, but it can be limited during peak hours.
Expect a wait time during busy lunch hours, especially on weekends.
The deli offers a variety of sandwiches, including hot ham and rolls on Sundays.
Old school pizza joint with Italian American kitsch and takeout only setup creates a cozy, no frills atmosphere. Family-run operation draws those seeking authentic, thin and chewy crust pizza with fresh toppings. Calls ahead are common due to busy nights and limited hours starting at 4 PM.
Pizza features a crispy crust, spicy and flavorful sauce, and generous toppings like sausage, mushroom, and onion. The thin crust style stands out, with hot, fresh delivery and nostalgic, no-frills vibes.
Sausage appears in several dishes like the sausage, mushroom, and onion pizza and the cheese and sausage calzone. It also features alongside pepperoni and mushrooms on a pizza and stands out in a simple sausage and cheese pizza.
Good to know
The restaurant is takeout only; no seating is available.
They open at 4 PM daily, so plan your visit accordingly.
Expect longer wait times during busy nights, especially on weekends.
Hole-in-the-wall pizzeria with authentic thin crust pizza and fresh filled cannoli. Atmosphere is cluttered and takeout-only, focusing on quick service and delivery. Known for consistent pizza quality despite a modest, no-frills setting.
Thin crust pizza comes with plenty of toppings and a nicely baked, homemade crust. The sauce has a tangy flavor, and the pizza is cooked perfectly every time with an authentic taste.
Sausage here has a unique flavor not found elsewhere. The sausage sandwich is ample in size and the supreme pizza features yummy sausage alongside mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, and pepperoni.
Good to know
Pietro's Pizza only offers to-go orders and delivery, with no dine-in options.
Expect longer delivery times; my pizza arrived one and a half hours late.
The price of the lasagna was great, making it an affordable option.
Brick-style pizza oven sits behind the counter, letting diners watch pizzas being made. Cozy bar area offers a warm corner with a nice market view and a relaxed vibe. Sausages and paninis stand out as top-quality offerings with quick service.
Brick-style pizza oven lets you watch pizzas being made fresh at the counter. The Philly pizza and BBQ chicken pizza come out quickly and have a delicious, fresh taste that appeals to all ages.
House made sausages cook quickly in about 15 minutes and come served hot. The hot Hungarian Sausage stands out with mustard on the side and no bun, while sausage platters and sandwiches pair well with fries for a perfect combination.
Good to know
Expect long lines during peak hours, especially on weekends.
Freshly ground burgers are available daily.
You can order any steak you see in the case.
Cozy neighborhood restaurant with old school Italian decor and comfortable booths creates a laid-back, inviting atmosphere. Bright yellow walls and soft music mix with lively chatter, making it easy to relax and catch up. Known for best pizza in town and a brisk takeout business, it draws families and locals alike.
Thin crust pizza stands out with fresh sausage and hand tossed dough. Pepperoni and sausage toppings come together for a fabulous flavor that many consider the best pizza in the area.
Fresh sausage features on the pizza with flavorful Italian sausage and crisped pepperoni. The Italian sausage sandwich stands out with its rich sauce, crust, and cheese combination.
Good to know
Filippo's does not accept same-day reservations.
The restaurant offers generous portion sizes for a fair price.
Prices at Filippo's are very reasonable, making it affordable for families.
Pizza restaurant offers peaceful atmosphere with inviting interior and generous portions. Menu features unique wings and thin crust pizzas praised for freshness and quality. Prices remain very reasonable compared to similar premium options.
Pizza features high quality ingredients like fresh mushrooms and amazing cheese. Options include unique flavors such as chicken tikka and jerk chicken, plus classic sausage and pepperoni on thin crust. Prices are very cheap for the quality and taste.
Sausage appears as a key topping on pizzas, paired often with pepperoni on thin crusts. Orders include combinations like pepperoni and sausage pizzas priced around $15, showing sausage as a common choice.
Good to know
The prices at D'sign Pizza are reasonable, especially for the quality of ingredients.
D'sign Pizza offers a menu that includes pizza, pasta, wings, and burgers.
Delivery is available through DoorDash and Uber Eats.
Pizza restaurant offers excellent pizza with fast delivery and a popular Tuesday deal. Atmosphere feels nice despite some cleanliness issues. Stays open late when others close, serving a hungry late-night crowd.
Pizza stands out for its amazing flavors and balanced toppings. The Buffalo chicken pizza is especially notable, and the service and delivery are consistently great.
Sausage comes meaty and flavorful on pizzas, paired often with pepperoni and bacon. It appears finely sliced and adds a solid savory punch to the hand-tossed crust pies.
Good to know
Bennets Pizza offers a special for a 3-topping pizza and a 2-liter soda for $20.99 plus tax.
Delivery from Bennets Pizza is fast.
Bennets Pizza has a buy-one-get-one deal on Tuesdays.
Thin crust pizza with crispy edges and generous cheese defines the menu, featuring pork-free meats like beef and turkey options. Atmosphere stays basic and relaxed, focusing on takeout and fast delivery rather than dine-in. Consistent quality and reasonable prices make it a favored local choice.
Offers tavern style pizza with options like turkey and beef bacon, pepperoni, and ham for those avoiding pork. Pizzas come with real meat and include varieties like chicken buffalo, all at low prices.
Offers beef sausage, beef pepperoni, and turkey ham for those avoiding pork. Sausage pairs well with cheese and veggies on pizzas of various sizes.
Good to know
Delivery time is usually 30-35 minutes, even when estimated at an hour.
The 16-inch cheese and sausage pizza costs $20.
Street parking is available for quick pickup.
Small takeout and delivery spot with no seating and fast delivery. Pizza features generous toppings and a balanced crust with a slightly sweet sauce. Prices tend to be on the higher side, nearing $30 per pizza.
Pizza features a slightly sweet sauce, great tasting sausage and pepperoni, and a crust that feels just right. Toppings come in good amounts, creating a classic old school flavor with a unique twist.
Sausage comes in huge pieces on pizzas and rolls, offering a great tasting and incredible flavor. It pairs well with toppings like pineapple and mushrooms, making the sausage a standout ingredient.
Good to know
The place only offers takeout and delivery.
The pizza costs around $30.
Delivery service is fast and reliable.
Small, walk-in pizza spot with old school charm and pick-up only service. Offers Brooklyn-style pizza with generous toppings and a recipe that stays consistent. Atmosphere is straightforward with no dine-in, focusing on quick, to-go orders.
Pizza here features a Brooklyn, NY style with a sauce considered the best ever tasted on a pizza. Pizzas come with an amazing amount of toppings and arrive consistently hot and fresh.
Sausage here is mildly spiced and greasy, not Italian style. It appears on a thin crust pizza and a pepperoni special with mushrooms and onions, though sometimes the pizza toppings get mixed up.
Good to know
The restaurant is pick-up only with no dine-in options.
They stop accepting phone orders 30 minutes before closing.
The food is ready in about 25 minutes after ordering.