Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Wauwatosa's best

Sandwich spots

You want a sandwich that is substantial enough to be your main meal.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Cosmos Cafe image 1
Greek restaurant

Small, casual deli-style restaurant with cozy patio and friendly, laid-back atmosphere. Space feels warm and welcoming, like being in someone's kitchen, often filled with heavenly smells. Known for authentic Greek food with generous portions and well-seasoned dishes.

Fresh, authentic Greek food offers great portions and reasonable prices. The dishes taste absolutely delicious and the staff is relaxed and eager to discuss the menu.

Chicken jerk pita wrap stands out as a top sandwich choice. Options like the Pork Souvlaki Pita and falafel pita offer solid variety, all priced around $10 and delivering strong flavor.

People are saying

"The Greek food here is amazing, especially the gyros."

"The food here is seriously delicious."

"I ate both sandwiches because they were so good."

Good to know

1

You order at the counter and pay when finished.

2

Each sandwich costs about $10 and is worth every penny.

3

The portions are generous, often enough for two meals.

02
Cafe Blue image 1

Tiny, quaint space filled with local art and indie music creates a calm, cozy vibe. Friendly atmosphere suits casual chats or quiet reading. Offers affordable, filling breakfast and lunch with standout sandwiches and quiche.

Food comes fresh and tastes like a lovingly homemade meal. Staff treat everyone with dignity, even those who cannot pay, while serving delicious coffee and breakfast foods.

Breakfast sandwiches come freshly made and very good with a breakfast bagel sandwich standing out. The grinder sandwich pairs well with coffee, and all sandwiches are consistently delicious.

People are saying

"I found the coffee here to be strong and delicious."

"The food here is delicious and fresh."

"I found the breakfast sandwich to be one of the best."

Good to know

1

Ordering by text is available for quick service.

2

Wifi is available for customers, making it a good work spot.

3

The cafe offers large portions at reasonable prices.

03
Dave's Hot Chicken image 1
Chicken restaurant

Chicken restaurant offers a buzzing atmosphere with Tosa-themed graffiti art and a clean, minimalistic interior. Music plays loudly, creating a lively and energetic vibe. The dining area is comfortable and spacious, attracting a cheerful crowd.

Food arrives hot and fresh, ready for takeout. Service stays consistently great, matching the amazing flavors every time.

Chicken sandwiches stand out with spicy heat levels like Reaper hotness that really pack a punch. Ingredients blend well for a perfect flavor mix, and cauliflower sandwiches offer a tasty alternative.

People are saying

"The food here is always fresh, hot, and tastes amazing."

"These sliders are so juicy and full of flavor."

"I thought the spicy chicken sandwich was the best I had."

Good to know

1

They serve Halal meat.

2

You can ask for the fries without salt if you’re watching your sodium.

3

The restaurant is clean and sanitary.

04
Cuppa Tosa Kitchen & Cafe image 1
Breakfast restaurant

Cozy space with warm, welcoming vibe feels like walking into someone's home. Offers indoor and dog-friendly outdoor seating with a peaceful atmosphere ideal for conversation or work. Regulars enjoy fresh, flavorful breakfast options and a community-focused environment.

Food features excellent quality and has improved over time. Staff maintain cleanliness and provide friendly service alongside great coffee.

Breakfast sandwiches come large with egg, bacon, and cheddar on croissants. Options include egg and cheese croissant sandwiches and solid egg sandwiches. Leftovers often remain from one order.

People are saying

"I found the coffee to be amazing, rich, and bold."

"The food here is great and delicious."

"The breakfast sandwiches here are made to order and super yummy."

Good to know

1

The cafe hosts a cookie walk event, perfect for sweet lovers.

2

Brunch specials are available on weekends, offering unique menu items.

3

The menu features a variety of sweet and savory options at reasonable prices.

05
Delicious Bites image 1

Cozy cafe with a warm, inviting vibe and quiet, peaceful atmosphere offers street view seating and wifi. Family-run feel supports community and small businesses. Known for variety of baked goods and healthy, reasonably priced options including dairy-free and vegan choices.

Food here is consistently delicious and made with care. Options include healthy choices at reasonable prices, with attention to matching presentation details.

Thai Turkey sandwich features fresh, tasteful ingredients. Vegan tuna sandwich stands out with its unique flavor and presentation. Tea sandwiches come beautifully presented.

People are saying

"The staff here is so sweet and welcoming."

"The food here is delicious and full of flavor."

"I found the turkey sandwich here to be second to none."

Good to know

1

Delicious Bites offers catering services for events of various sizes.

2

The bakery provides dairy-free and vegan options for diverse dietary needs.

3

Expect beautifully packaged deliveries that arrive on time.

06
Idyll Coffee Roasters image 1
Coffee roasters

Space opens up with two floors featuring ample seating and live plants throughout. Atmosphere stays cozy and inviting with natural light and a double-sided fireplace enhancing comfort. Setting suits both small groups and solo work with accessible design including an elevator and ramp.

Food includes breakfast and lunch options that are tasty and satisfying. Coffee and teas come with great flavor, and mugs replace to-go cups for dining in.

The egg and cheese sandwich stands out for its tasty flavor and reasonable price. The garlic mayo adds a nice touch, making the breakfast sandwich a solid choice.

People are saying

"I loved the coffee here; it was absolutely great."

"The food here is super tasty and delicious."

"The egg and cheese sandwich is genuinely tasty and a great value."

Good to know

1

Expect limited seating on weekends, so arrive early.

2

Restrooms are located on the first floor only.

3

They roast their own beans and make most syrups in-house.

07
Jackson's Blue Ribbon Pub of Wauwatosa image 1

Gastropub with a lively atmosphere and loud music that turns it into a club-like space on weekend nights. Outdoor patio with live music and a shuttle service to local events add to the experience. Crowd includes locals enjoying casual dining and affordable drinks.

Food here is consistently excellent with a great atmosphere. Service is prompt and prices are reasonable.

Brisket sandwiches stand out with their rich flavor. Cheese curds and chicken sandwiches also feature among the great sandwich selections. A BLT can be made even if it is not on the menu.

People are saying

"The pub's servers are so friendly and make you feel happy."

"I thought the food here was amazing."

"I thought the brisket sandwich was great."

Good to know

1

The pub offers free parking and a $2 shuttle to the game.

2

Happy hour specials are available every day.

3

Expect food delays of about 15 minutes during busy times.

08
The Honey Baked Ham Company image 1

Honey baked ham stands out with its sweet and savory flavors and fresh spiral ham offerings. The environment is clean and efficient, with quick service that suits holiday rushes. Prices tend to be higher than typical fast food, reflecting the quality and specialty of the products.

Food features excellent quality and great taste. Options include plain ham slices suitable for kids.

The Honey Baked sandwich stands out with its sweet and savory mix and consistent quality. Sandwiches come pre-made and tend to be expensive, with the ham sandwich priced around $12.

People are saying

"I thought the Honey Baked Ham was out of this world good."

"This food is delicious, especially the honey baked ham."

"The honey baked sandwich is an excellent, sweet and savory choice."

Good to know

1

The ham sandwich costs $12, which some may find high.

2

Expect a 10-minute wait for ham if not in stock.

3

A $10 off coupon is available on the website for orders.

09
Rocket Baby Bakery image 1

Small bakery with rustic vibes and a lively atmosphere filled with the aroma of fresh bread. Limited indoor seating contrasts with a large outdoor pavilion featuring heaters and family-friendly space. Popular spot known for top-notch baked goods like savory danishes and fresh bread.

Food here is consistently amazing and extremely delicious. Breakfast items stand out with great quality and care in preparation.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with lemon aioli and bacon options scoring high ratings. The grilled cheese with goat cheese offers a unique twist, and the Full Montagu sandwich rates very well.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the sourdough bread; it's the best in the city."

"Their rye bread was dense, moist, and deeply flavorful, perfect for a sandwich."

"The food here is really tasty, especially the bakery items."

Good to know

1

The bakery has a walk-up window for ordering.

2

Expect a 45-minute wait for pick-up orders.

3

The bakery often runs out of popular baked goods.

10
Drunken Cobra image 1
Bar & grill

Bar and grill with unique decor and an architect-designed interior featuring a nice outdoor patio. Atmosphere ranges from loud and energetic with live music and DJs to laid-back and comfortable. Offers sports on TV, dog-friendly spaces, and activities like extreme bingo.

Food comes out cooked to order and consistently delicious. Many options pair well with a selection of great beers and IPAs.

Chicken sandwiches stand out with options like a gluten-free bun and the Ryan Tamer variety. Cod and club sandwiches also appear on the menu, offering a range of classic choices.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be pretty nice."

"The bar staff were so friendly and attentive."

"I thought the chicken sandwich on a gluten-free bun was good."

Good to know

1

Bingo game starts at 7pm on Mondays with a lively atmosphere.

2

Trivia night occurs every Tuesday at 8pm, attracting a fun crowd.

3

Reggae brunch happens every Sunday, featuring live music and a vibrant vibe.

11
Suburpia on Bluemound image 1

Old-school sandwich shop with worn decor and a 1970s vibe. Atmosphere feels charming yet run-down, creating a unique, slightly odd energy. Known for distinctive spices and sauces that set sandwiches apart from others.

Food arrives quickly and tastes consistently good. Discounts are available, and the service complements the meal well.

Sandwiches stand out for their secret sauce and spices that create a unique flavor. They offer a messy, satisfying experience with solid quality under $10, different from typical chains.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were top-notch and delicious."

"I found the subs and soups to be great."

"I loved the food; it was great and arrived quickly."

Good to know

1

Prices are generally under $10, making it an affordable lunch option.

2

Look at the menu ahead of time to avoid long wait times during busy hours.

3

They charge extra for additional toppings, so consider your order carefully.

12
Panera Bread image 1

Cafe offers a clean, peaceful atmosphere suited for meetings and casual dining. Dining room design supports business conversations while a drive-thru adds convenience. Younger crowd frequents the spot, creating a lively yet relaxed vibe.

Food comes out quickly and stays consistently fresh and delicious. Quality matches well with fast casual standards and leaves no sluggish feeling after eating.

Breakfast sandwiches come with coffee and muffins, while lunch offers a grilled cheese and three soup options. Turkey and cheddar sandwiches arrive packed with fresh veggies, but order mistakes and missing items happen sometimes.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be fresh and delicious."

"The coffee here is always fresh and delicious."

"I found the sandwiches here to be fantastic and fresh."

Good to know

1

Day-old cookies are sold before fresh cookies are available for dine-in customers.

2

The restaurant has a drive-thru for convenient ordering.

3

Prices have increased, with a bagel now costing $2.11.

13
Potbelly image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop offers a laid back atmosphere with a spacious dining area and warm environment. Customers appear happy, enjoying fresh ingredients and a variety of sandwiches and salads.

Food here is consistently great and delicious with a focus on healthy options.

Great sandwiches come with a fresh, tasty vibe and a healthy side. The vegetarian options stand out as excellent and consistently good.

People are saying

"Alik makes the best sandwich; he's my guy."

"I found the healthy foods here to be fresh and tasty."

"I thought the food here was great and delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking is available at the mall with easy access to Potbelly.

2

Expect to spend around $18 for a sub, chips, and a drink.

3

Credit cards are accepted for payment.

14
Denny's image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers cozy booths and a warm, welcoming atmosphere with kid-friendly activities and clean, well-managed spaces. It stays quiet and comfortable, creating a home-like feeling for diners. Background music adds to the relaxed vibe.

Food arrives fast, fresh, and tasty with 5-star quality. Service matches the food with quick and attentive delivery.

Sandwiches include options like BBQ bacon chicken served with onion rings. Preparation can take up to an hour with only two staff in the back. Substitutions may be agreed to initially but not always fulfilled.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, hot, and tasty."

"The staff's kindness and happiness made my Pancake experience great."

"Billy was so friendly and efficient with our sandwich order."

Good to know

1

Denny's is open 24/7/365 for dining.

2

Parking is ample and accessible for all guests.

3

The restaurant is wheelchair accessible with ramps.

15
Bruegger's Bagels image 1

Bagel shop offers soft, chewy bagels with varied flavors and toasted perfection. Atmosphere feels welcoming but lacks in-house seating, creating a quick-service vibe. Busy location near a campus draws steady crowds despite some operational quirks.

Food comes out with a crispy outside and soft, fresh inside. Service matches the quality with friendly conversation and smiles during ordering.

Bagel sandwiches stand out with consistently delicious flavors. The farmhouse breakfast and Sriracha breakfast sandwiches get special mention for their taste and quality.

People are saying

"The staff here makes you feel so welcome, like family."

"Chris is the friendliest person, always attentive and fast."

"I found the bagel sandwiches here to be always delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in the side or back lot.

2

Expect to wait during busy hours, especially near the Froedert campus.

3

The dining area and bathrooms are clean.

16
Subway image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop features a clean, well-maintained dining area and a neatly stocked Sandwich Bar with no old ingredients. The atmosphere is respectful and orderly, with reasonable prices and acceptance of coupons.

Food comes out fresh and is assembled quickly at a clean and well-stocked sandwich bar. The dining area stays well maintained, supporting a good overall eating experience.

Sandwich Bar stays clean and well stocked with no old, dry ingredients. Sandwiches come out neatly made and fresh, showing clear care in preparation.

People are saying

"The staff here is so friendly and helpful with your sandwich order."

"The food here is fresh and of good quality."

Good to know

1

The restaurant maintains a clean and well-stocked sandwich bar.

2

Coupons are accepted for purchases.

3

Prices are reasonable for the quality of sandwiches offered.

Discover more

Wauwatosa, Wisconsin

Area guide
Loading Map...