Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Wisconsin

Cookie bakeries

A cookie that hits the right balance of texture and sweetness without tasting like it came from a mass-produced factory batch.

Based on 776 Opinions
+773
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Bread House | Mediterranean Bakery & More image 1
Bread House | Mediterranean Bakery & More image 2
Bread House | Mediterranean Bakery & More image 3
View all

Rustic decor and fragrant aromas create a cozy, warm atmosphere with clean, spacious seating. The vibe feels inviting and authentic to Middle Eastern culture, welcoming casual dining. Food offerings stand out with fresh, flavorful pastries and breads that define the experience.

Food here is consistently amazing and delicious, with a focus on nourishing Mediterranean dishes. Service matches the quality of the food, making every meal feel like home.

Cookies come warm and delicious with dates and walnuts flavors standing out. They hold up well for dipping into hot tea without falling apart and pair nicely with mint tea.

People are saying

"You have to try the honeycomb bread; it's phenomenal."

"The food here is fresh, flavorful, and perfectly seasoned."

"I found the dessert and tea cookies to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Prices are very reasonable, making it a great value for money.

2

The bakery offers a large variety of vegetarian options, including falafel and eggplant.

3

Expect a family-friendly atmosphere, perfect for dining with kids.

02
Wioletta's Polish Market image 1

Small grocery store offers authentic Polish deli and fresh bakery with wide variety of meats and traditional foods. Bright, clean, and quiet atmosphere feels like stepping into an old Polish neighborhood. Friendly environment highlights exceptional Polish food and pastries.

Offers a wide range of authentic Polish foods including meats, perogies, cabbage rolls, and fresh sauerkraut. The selection also features fresh bakery items, desserts, and a curated liquor section with Polish and European beverages.

Packaged pistachio pirouette wafer cookies stand out here. Assorted kolache cookies also come in good variety and quality.

People are saying

"This grocery store has authentic Eastern European foods and delicious kielbasa."

"I thought the food was great and authentic."

"I was so excited they sell packaged pistachio pirouette wafer cookies."

Good to know

1

The store offers fresh bread on Wednesdays and Fridays.

2

Parking is limited, especially during peak hours.

3

The deli counter has a variety of authentic Polish meats.

03
Safadi Coffee image 1
Coffee shop

Space showcases traditional Palestinian decor with curated photography highlighting resilience and spirit. Atmosphere feels calm and welcoming, enhanced by good music and sunlight streaming through. Seating and art create a cultural escape that invites lingering and reflection.

Food stands out with amazing coffee and delectable toast. Pastries and drinks also complement the delicious menu well.

Cookies come fresh and warm with macadamia nuts and chocolate chips standing out. They taste decadent and show no shortcuts in preparation.

People are saying

"The coffee shop's atmosphere is beautiful, cozy, and calming."

"The food here is amazing, especially the toast."

"The cookies here are warm, gooey, and amazing."

Good to know

1

Safadi Coffee closes at 9pm.

2

The menu features unique Palestinian-themed items.

3

The establishment is family-friendly and accommodating to children.

04
North Shore Boulangerie image 1

Medium-sized bakery with Parisian cafe design and natural light from large windows creates a cozy, neighborhood vibe where people enjoy quiet conversations without laptops. Two seating areas offer a charming atmosphere that feels like a spot in Europe. Music and energy keep the space inviting and relaxed.

Food comes out fresh and delicious with perfect temperatures. Bread selection stands out, alongside well-priced French cuisine and tasty sandwiches and salads.

Ginger cookie stands out with a strong, spicy flavor. Other cookies are delicious and match the quality of the amazing pastries.

People are saying

"I loved their French toast with raspberry spread for brunch."

"The food here is delicious and fresh."

"I thought the ginger cookie was the best I had ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for brunch on weekends due to high demand.

2

The online menu may not accurately reflect current offerings or prices.

3

Parking can be challenging, so consider arriving early.

05
Discourse Coffee | Downtown image 1

Mid-century modern decor shapes a cozy, intimate space with window nooks and comfortable seating suited for studying or quiet chats. Warm lighting and an inclusive atmosphere create a welcoming vibe, though music volume varies from good to blaring. Pastries and handcrafted beverages complement the relaxed, friendly energy.

Food features excellent flavor combinations and high quality sides. Drinks include creative lattes and well-made pour-overs.

Miso butter and chocolate chip cookies stand out here. The orange latte pairs well with the cookies, making a solid combo.

People are saying

"I thought the coffee here was the best I've ever had."

"The food here has excellent flavor combinations."

"I loved the miso butter cookie."

Good to know

1

Discourse Coffee offers freshly roasted coffee beans for purchase.

2

The coffee menu features unique flavors and innovative combinations.

3

WiFi is unreliable, so consider using your mobile hotspot.

06
Discourse Coffee | Radio Milwaukee image 1

Old industrial building with big windows and natural light creates a spacious, modern vibe. Eclectic décor and a record collection set a nostalgic, music-driven atmosphere. Music plays constantly, supporting a creative, relaxed energy ideal for hanging out or working.

Food comes out made to order with an incredible smell that fills the air. Both beverages and dishes maintain consistent quality every time.

Brown butter miso cookie blends sweet and savory in a fun way, rated 4.5 out of 5. Bunny's bite chocolate lavender cookie offers a unique flavor, alongside almond croissant and bacon scone options.

People are saying

"The coffee drinks here are like delicious, innovative cocktails."

"I found the coffee and lattes to be amazing and unique."

"The brown butter miso cookie's sweet and savory mix is so fun."

Good to know

1

Discourse Coffee offers an innovative menu of coffee cocktails worth trying.

2

Parking can be challenging, so plan accordingly.

3

They host community events and art showcases regularly.

07
Avenue Coffeehouse image 1

Small coffee shop with intimate seating inside and a charming outdoor patio creates a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Music mixes classic tunes that add to the peaceful, cottage-like vibe. Features like a fish tank with axolotls and games offer unique touches for visitors.

Food here is healthy and beautifully presented. Options are solid and pair well with the great vibes.

Cookies balance crispiness and softness well, making them enjoyable alongside coffee. Some have sprinkled sugar, which may not suit all tastes.

People are saying

"I thought their latte was the best I ever tried."

"The food here is delicious, healthy, and made from scratch."

"I always got a cookie and they were perfect."

Good to know

1

They offer delightful drink specials and delicious toasts at the end of the week.

2

They now have a punch card program for free coffee or pastries.

3

There are lots of parking options available nearby.

08
Crumbl image 1
Cookie shop

Bright, clean space with open layout and pink signage creates a welcoming vibe. Small lobby area can feel rushed and crowded during busy times. Weekly rotating selection offers unique cookie flavors with a focus on freshness.

Food consistently delivers great taste and impressive options. Quality remains solid across visits.

Cookies come out warm and soft with a perfect size. They offer unique and flavorfully delicious options that stand out.

People are saying

"I thought the cookies here were the best I've ever eaten."

"This place is so Kid Friendly, my kids were always happy."

"I found the food here to be great."

Good to know

1

Crumbl offers a rotating menu with new cookie flavors every week.

2

The pickup and drive-thru options make grabbing cookies quick and easy.

3

Crumbl has a kiosk for placing orders, which can speed up the process.

09
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Milwaukee - Brookfield by IHG image 1

Building showcases modern design with spacious, quiet rooms featuring darkening shades for restful sleep. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, with a large breakfast area and continuous fresh cookies in the lobby. Amenities include a pool, outdoor seating, and coffee always available in the lounge.

Breakfast offers a good range of food with well-prepared dishes and clean dining areas. Kitchen staff stay busy keeping food stations full and tidy, and the coffee is consistently good.

A cookie jar in the lobby stays filled with warm, fresh cookies including decadent double chocolate varieties offered free at check-in.

People are saying

"The hotel staff were so kind and accommodating during my stay."

"You can get warm, fresh cookies at check-in."

"The food here is always well prepared and the dining area is kept very clean."

Good to know

1

The hotel is close to many attractions and restaurants.

2

Parking is safe and secure on the premises.

3

Rooms include a mini fridge, coffee K-cups, and a microwave.

10
Delicious Bites image 1

Cozy cafe with a warm, inviting vibe and quiet, peaceful atmosphere offers street view seating and wifi. Family-run feel supports community and small businesses. Known for variety of baked goods and healthy, reasonably priced options including dairy-free and vegan choices.

Food here is consistently delicious and made with care. Options include healthy choices at reasonable prices, with attention to matching presentation details.

Cookies include Orange Dreamsicle and chocolate chip and pecan varieties. Kids enjoy the cookies and even participate in cookie decorating classes.

People are saying

"The staff here is so sweet and welcoming."

"The jerk salmon salad was so fresh and tasty."

"The food here is delicious and full of flavor."

Good to know

1

Delicious Bites offers catering services for events of various sizes.

2

The bakery provides dairy-free and vegan options for diverse dietary needs.

3

Expect beautifully packaged deliveries that arrive on time.

11
Beach Bum Bakery image 1

Bakery offers beachy decor with beautiful lake views and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. The space suits families, with areas for kids to run and spots to watch the water. Fresh, decorative desserts draw attention, especially cupcakes and donuts that combine taste with visual appeal.

Great food comes with friendly staff and reasonable prices.

Cookies come in custom designs that match specific visions and occasions. Varieties like kitchen sink, p.b. cup, and salted caramel are soft, tasty, and receive many compliments.

People are saying

"The bakery items, especially the donuts and cupcakes, are so delicious."

"I found the cookies delightful and they tasted great."

"The hot ham food here is delicious and sells out fast."

Good to know

1

Hot ham and fresh rolls are served on Sundays.

2

It's best to schedule orders ahead of time through the DoorDash app due to high demand.

3

Doughnuts are only available on Saturdays and Sundays.

12
Fitzy's Cafe image 1

Modern take on an old school pharmacy soda fountain with a clean art deco vibe and plenty of seating creates a bright, cozy atmosphere. Space feels welcoming and elegant, suitable for socializing or working quietly. Unique view of a pharmacy from inside adds to the distinct character.

Food features high quality ingredients and outstanding flavor with beautiful presentation. Dishes include a notable basil vinaigrette dressing and halal options, all prepared with care and attention to detail.

Chocolate chip cookies come warmed up and taste excellent. They pair well with coffee or hot chocolate.

People are saying

"Their coffee and specialty lattes are made with exceptional care and attention to detail."

"The food here is delicious and beautifully made with care."

"I found the chocolate chip cookie to be excellent."

Good to know

1

Lunch costs approximately $20 per person with large portions.

2

Tips are cash only at Fitzy's Cafe.

3

The new chef makes all bakery items fresh in the morning.

13
Grebe's Bakery image 1

Small, old-fashioned bakery with a classic American donut shop vibe and cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Regulars come early for fresh, highly praised donuts and ham and rolls, which sell out quickly. The setup resembles a deli with counter service and a 4th generation family-owned tradition since 1923.

Food features delicious doughnuts and a classic bakery style with excellent service. Prices stay cheap while quality remains consistently good.

Smile cookies stand out with a long history of popularity. Other notable treats include Sentry cookies and hard rolls, all consistently enjoyable.

People are saying

"I thought the donuts here were amazing."

"I thought the food here was delicious and fresh."

"I enjoyed their amazing smile cookies."

Good to know

1

Grebe's Bakery closes at 3:00 PM every day.

2

The bakery is usually busy, with a line forming by 7 AM.

3

Arrive early to get the best items, as they sell out quickly.

14
Subway image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop offers spotless cleanliness and a welcoming atmosphere with fresh baked cookies and soft, fresh bread. Outdoor seating with small tables adds a relaxed touch. Staff provide friendly, attentive service that stands out from typical chain locations.

Food comes out fresh and well made every time. Staff show genuine care in their work, keeping quality consistent and prices reasonable.

Fresh baked cookies come out consistently delicious and spot-on every time.

People are saying

"The staff here is so friendly and welcoming, it makes the sandwich experience great."

"The staff here is so friendly, they even knew my cookie order."

"I thought the food was fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

The Subway location is known for its cleanliness and friendly service.

2

Expect a welcoming atmosphere with attentive staff.

3

The seating area is consistently clean and well-maintained.

15
DoubleTree by Hilton Hotel Milwaukee Downtown image 1

Spacious corner suites feature double bathrooms and a large living room with matching decor. The atmosphere balances a clean, upscale bar and restaurant area with some harsh lighting and cool temperatures in public spaces. Valet parking, complimentary laundry, and warm cookies at check-in add convenient, welcoming touches.

Delicious food comes with careful attention to dietary restrictions and allergies. The attached restaurant offers reasonably priced and well-prepared food and drinks.

Warm cookies greet guests upon arrival, often paired with water. Staff sometimes offer extra cookies as a friendly gesture.

People are saying

"The hotel staff's kindness and professionalism made my stay amazing."

"The beds here are so comfortable."

"The food here is really good and impressive."

Good to know

1

The last call at the hotel bar during the week is at 10:30 pm.

2

The Sundeck lounge is open on Fridays from 3 pm to 10 pm and Saturdays from 11 am to 10 pm, weather permitting.

3

There was no breakfast or coffee offered in the morning.

16
National Bakery & Deli | East – Milwaukee image 1

Traditional bakery with a nostalgic atmosphere and friendly vibe offers quality baked goods like standout cakes and donuts. Regulars enjoy ham with free rolls and special orders for unique items. Bright and cheerful setting feels like a hometown staple.

Baked goods here are dangerously delicious with a variety of fun seasonal treats. The bakery offers items like frosted angel food cake and many other great foods.

Sugar cookies come out crisp at the edges and soft in the middle. The bakery offers a wide variety of specialty cookies including convention-themed ones that look cool and attract attention.

People are saying

"The cake here is beautiful and delicious."

"The donuts here are phenomenally delicious."

"The sugar cookies are crisp at the edge and soft in the middle."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers ham with free rolls every day they are open.

2

The special rolls are now only available through special order.

3

They are frustratingly closed on Sundays.

17
Greige Pâtisserie image 1

Bakery space offers a quiet atmosphere suited for work or calls, with a vibe reminiscent of European cafes. Pastries and cakes feature unique flavors and beautiful presentation, attracting those seeking creative and delicious baked goods.

Food includes wonderful pastries and tea dining experiences priced around $20. Some items can be stale, but overall the offerings are phenomenal.

Oatmeal creme cookie stands out with its captivating flavor and irresistible texture. Other pastries and cookies also offer delicious variety.

People are saying

"The wedding cake was perfect, with amazing flavors and beautiful presentation."

"I was captivated by the oatmeal creme cookie; I couldn't stop eating it."

"The food here was wonderful and phenomenal."

Good to know

1

Street parking is readily available on weekdays.

2

The closest bus stop is a 6-minute walk away for routes 15, green, and 18.

3

High tea costs $55 per person, which may not be worth it.

18
Casera Cafe & Bakery image 1

Bright, spacious cafe with natural lighting and indoor-outdoor seating creates a calm, relaxing atmosphere. The space feels open and well-curated, suitable for working alone or socializing. Attention to detail and friendly vibe make it welcoming and enjoyable.

Food comes fresh and delicious with pastries, coffee, and an amazing cookie standing out.

A sea salt cookie stands out with a flavor that hooks you instantly. Watching bakers through the window while enjoying a hot chocolate and this cookie adds to the experience.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the coffee; it was perfectly made."

"I thought the food here was really good."

"I was hooked on that sea salt cookie."

Good to know

1

The food side of the kitchen closes an hour before the cafe closes.

2

They provide super strong WiFi, making it a good spot for work.

3

Expect a long line on weekends, especially around noon.

19
Kurt Schulz Deli & Pastry Shoppe image 1

Deli combines old school charm with a nostalgic atmosphere that feels welcoming and inclusive. Quiet spaces invite reading or studying while kids engage with classic toys like Rock Em Sock Em Robots. The place offers homemade sandwiches and pastries with a loyal lunchtime crowd despite a worn building.

Food comes fresh and delicious with reasonable prices. Staff and service stand out as amazing, often noted as even better than the food itself.

Cookies come in several varieties including molasses, homemade peanut butter, and oatmeal raisin that are notably large. The bakery makes all cookies from scratch alongside donuts and other treats.

People are saying

"The pastries here are outstanding and out of this world."

"I found the food to be delicious and reasonably priced."

"The cookies here are awesome with nice crunchy bread."

Good to know

1

Half-price deli salads are available on Saturdays.

2

The shop closes at 3:00 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

3

The bakery offers fresh donuts made by the owner on Saturday mornings.

20
Likewise Coffee - Milwaukee image 1

Airy space filled with natural light and abundant plants creates a bright, inviting atmosphere. Seating includes a community table and outdoor options, supporting both socializing and focused work. Background music plays softly, contributing to a peaceful vibe with a strong sense of community.

Coffee pairs well with citrus scones and chocolate chip cookies. Food quality stays consistently great alongside the drinks.

Chocolate chip cookie stands out as a favorite, often paired with lattes. The Ranger cookie offers a solid vegan option, while the Rodeo cookie earns praise for its distinct flavor.

People are saying

"I found the coffee here to be high quality and delicious."

"The coffee and food here are excellent."

"The atmosphere here is so inviting and filled with plants."

Good to know

1

Parking is available nearby, but you may need to walk a block or two.

2

The coffee shop specializes in pour-over coffee rather than drip coffee.

3

Free water and bathrooms are available for customers.

21
SmallPie image 1

Small cafe with cute indoor and outdoor seating, including a covered patio surrounded by plants for sale. Atmosphere feels relaxed and inviting, with a quiet outdoor area that welcomes dogs. The space offers a charming, neighborhood vibe ideal for casual stops.

Food features Midwestern-inspired dishes made with homegrown Wisconsin ingredients. The menu offers honest, handcrafted foods and desserts with straightforward, delicious flavors.

Cookies come in massive, soft, and dense varieties like the toffee cookie. Options include double chocolate and lemon poppyseed, with some chocolate chip cookies available too.

People are saying

"I found the pies here to be so delicious."

"I loved the delicious handcrafted food and desserts here."

"The chocolate chip and toffee cookies were great."

Good to know

1

Parking can be challenging in the area, so plan accordingly.

2

Hand pies are priced at $10 each, which may be considered expensive.

3

SmallPie is dog-friendly, allowing pets on the outdoor seating.

22
Gather Bakehouse | Bay View image 1

Bakery space feels plain and dark with a full-blown espresso machine inside. Atmosphere suits an upper-class clientele with limited selection but high-quality croissants and cheese pockets. Energy is calm, focusing on fancy cakes and vegan options.

Offers vegan sandwiches and operates as a vegan bakery, which is uncommon. Food quality is generally okay with friendly staff.

Large, moist cranberry-white chocolate cookies stand out here. The cookies generally pair well with croissants and other baked goods.

People are saying

"I thought the donuts here were the best in town."

"I loved the cookies; they were perfection."

"The vegan hot ham on a roll reminded me of childhood."

Good to know

1

The ham and rolls are only available on Sundays.

2

Parking may be tricky during events like the Milwaukee Marathon.

3

Vegan items, including sandwiches, are available during Vegan Dining Week.

23
Matilda bakehouse image 1

French-inspired bakery offers a cozy, welcoming atmosphere with a spacious seating area and a beautifully curated collection of local artisan home wares. The space feels comfortable and well kept, inviting guests to relax and enjoy expertly made pastries and creative croissants.

Food tastes very good and delicious here. Staff sometimes hide dead rats with trash bags while preparing food.

Chocolate cookies and almond croissants come in boxes here. The cookies impress with their flavor, but chocolate chip cookies contain a strong chocolate presence that some may not prefer.

People are saying

"I found the almond croissant to be buttery and flaky."

"I found the cookies here amazing."

"The food here is really delicious."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a variety of sweet and savory baked goods.

2

Expect limited signage, which may make it hard to find the location.

3

The bakery is family-friendly and has a welcoming atmosphere.

24
Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop image 1

Cozy bakery with large windows that fill the space with natural light and delicate hand-painted florals enhancing a romantic vibe. Comfortable seating and a small Stone Creek Coffee bar create a welcoming atmosphere. Known for elegantly decorated cakes and a charming, intimate setting.

Food here stands out with amazing bakery items and a wide food array that feels unique compared to big box bakeries. Staff handle food allergy requests carefully, ensuring safety and satisfaction.

Cookies feature tender dough and balanced sweetness, like the french raspberry cookie. The Peanut Butter Cookies have a perfect crumble and the Maple Long Johns stand out among other treats.

People are saying

"The cake looked amazing and tasted even better."

"Their wedding cakes and dessert array were amazing and a hit."

"I loved their french raspberry cookie; it had tender dough."

Good to know

1

Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop customizes wedding cakes at fair prices.

2

The 10-inch cake serves approximately 24 to 30 people.

3

Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop is open late on Fat Tuesday.

25
Potbelly image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop offers a laid back atmosphere with a spacious dining area and warm environment. Customers appear happy, enjoying fresh ingredients and a variety of sandwiches and salads.

Food here is consistently great and delicious with a focus on healthy options.

Oatmeal chocolate chip cookies come out slightly crisp outside and chewy inside. They pair well with drinks like cherry coke or a cup of chili.

People are saying

"Alik makes the best sandwich; he's my guy."

"I found the healthy foods here to be fresh and tasty."

"I thought the food here was great and delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking is available at the mall with easy access to Potbelly.

2

Expect to spend around $18 for a sub, chips, and a drink.

3

Credit cards are accepted for payment.

26
MMSUPPS Supplements & Smoothies image 1
Vitamin & supplements store

Vitamin and supplements store combines full service smoothie bar with a wide variety of protein-packed foods like bowls, shakes, and cookies. Clean layout supports easy browsing through extensive supplement selection. Prices are reasonable, supporting local business while offering popular protein treats that often sell out.

Smoothies and healthy food options taste good and feel fresh. Bowls come with a variety of protein options and cold coffee drinks include added proteins for a healthy boost.

Protein cookies sell out regularly, showing strong demand. Ice cream and cookies offer a quick, tasty protein snack option alongside waffles and shakes.

People are saying

"You have to try their amazing protein cookies; they sell out fast!"

"I thought the smoothies here tasted amazing."

"I found the food and smoothies to be fresh and tasty."

Good to know

1

The store offers a variety of protein options, healthy foods, and cold coffee drinks with proteins.

2

The protein shake costs $9.

3

MMSUPPS now offers protein bowls, smoothies, and shakes.

27
Rocky Rococo Pizza and Pasta image 1

Large dining area offers a nostalgic 90s-early 00s vibe with a classic pizza joint feel. Atmosphere is comfortable and clean, with a lively energy as people wait for fresh pizza. Kids enjoy the color a picture and get a cookie activity, adding a family-friendly touch.

Food arrives quickly and tastes consistently delicious. Quality stands out compared to most fast food pizza chains, with great flavors and satisfying meals.

Kids get cookies through a color a picture and get a cookie offer. The manager often gives cookies to children after pizza. Holiday cookies come with some orders, making kids happy.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was great."

"The Italian food here, especially the pizza and breadsticks, is perfectly seasoned and delicious."

"I found the food here to be delicious."

Good to know

1

There is ample inside seating available for diners.

2

Many people seem to order takeout pizza at Rocky's.

3

The super slice daily deals are popular among customers.

Discover more

Wisconsin

Area guide
Loading Map...