Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Wisconsin

Cookie and sandwich shops

You are looking for a lunch spot that pairs a solid sandwich with a fresh cookie.

Based on 751 Opinions
+748
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Discourse Coffee | Radio Milwaukee image 1
Discourse Coffee | Radio Milwaukee image 2
Discourse Coffee | Radio Milwaukee image 3

Old industrial building with big windows and natural light creates a spacious, modern vibe. Eclectic décor and a record collection set a nostalgic, music-driven atmosphere. Music plays constantly, supporting a creative, relaxed energy ideal for hanging out or working.

Brown butter miso cookie blends sweet and savory in a fun way, rated 4.5 out of 5. Bunny's bite chocolate lavender cookie offers a unique flavor, alongside almond croissant and bacon scone options.

Pimento bacon croissant sandwich stands out with rich flavors and flaky bread. Breakfast sandwiches pack a flavorful punch, especially the disco breakfast sandwich.

People are saying

"The coffee drinks here are like delicious, innovative cocktails."

"The brown butter miso cookie's sweet and savory mix is so fun."

"I would drive half an hour for that pimento bacon croissant sandwich."

Good to know

1

Discourse Coffee offers an innovative menu of coffee cocktails worth trying.

2

Parking can be challenging, so plan accordingly.

3

They host community events and art showcases regularly.

02
Bread House | Mediterranean Bakery & More image 1

Rustic decor and fragrant aromas create a cozy, warm atmosphere with clean, spacious seating. The vibe feels inviting and authentic to Middle Eastern culture, welcoming casual dining. Food offerings stand out with fresh, flavorful pastries and breads that define the experience.

Cookies come warm and delicious with dates and walnuts flavors standing out. They hold up well for dipping into hot tea without falling apart and pair nicely with mint tea.

Sandwiches come generously filled and packed with bursting flavor. The falafel sandwich features farm fresh ingredients and arrives straight to the table.

People are saying

"You have to try the honeycomb bread; it's phenomenal."

"I found the dessert and tea cookies to be delicious."

"I had the best falafel sandwich I ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Prices are very reasonable, making it a great value for money.

2

The bakery offers a large variety of vegetarian options, including falafel and eggplant.

3

Expect a family-friendly atmosphere, perfect for dining with kids.

03
Avenue Coffeehouse image 1

Small coffee shop with intimate seating inside and a charming outdoor patio creates a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Music mixes classic tunes that add to the peaceful, cottage-like vibe. Features like a fish tank with axolotls and games offer unique touches for visitors.

Cookies balance crispiness and softness well, making them enjoyable alongside coffee. Some have sprinkled sugar, which may not suit all tastes.

Big sandwiches come with very fresh veggies. Breakfast sandwiches taste fresh and good. Options include baked goods and hot sandwiches.

People are saying

"I thought their latte was the best I ever tried."

"I always got a cookie and they were perfect."

"The sandwiches here are big and really fresh."

Good to know

1

They offer delightful drink specials and delicious toasts at the end of the week.

2

They now have a punch card program for free coffee or pastries.

3

There are lots of parking options available nearby.

04
Delicious Bites image 1

Cozy cafe with a warm, inviting vibe and quiet, peaceful atmosphere offers street view seating and wifi. Family-run feel supports community and small businesses. Known for variety of baked goods and healthy, reasonably priced options including dairy-free and vegan choices.

Cookies include Orange Dreamsicle and chocolate chip and pecan varieties. Kids enjoy the cookies and even participate in cookie decorating classes.

Thai Turkey sandwich features fresh, tasteful ingredients. Vegan tuna sandwich stands out with its unique flavor and presentation. Tea sandwiches come beautifully presented.

People are saying

"The staff here is so sweet and welcoming."

"The jerk salmon salad was so fresh and tasty."

"I found the turkey sandwich here to be second to none."

Good to know

1

Delicious Bites offers catering services for events of various sizes.

2

The bakery provides dairy-free and vegan options for diverse dietary needs.

3

Expect beautifully packaged deliveries that arrive on time.

05
Fitzy's Cafe image 1

Modern take on an old school pharmacy soda fountain with a clean art deco vibe and plenty of seating creates a bright, cozy atmosphere. Space feels welcoming and elegant, suitable for socializing or working quietly. Unique view of a pharmacy from inside adds to the distinct character.

Chocolate chip cookies come warmed up and taste excellent. They pair well with coffee or hot chocolate.

Sandwiches feature bold and great flavor with options like the horsey beef sandwich and a breakfast sandwich close to NYC style. Salads and sandwiches both stand out for their taste.

People are saying

"Their coffee and specialty lattes are made with exceptional care and attention to detail."

"The sandwiches here have bold and great flavor."

"I found the chocolate chip cookie to be excellent."

Good to know

1

Lunch costs approximately $20 per person with large portions.

2

Tips are cash only at Fitzy's Cafe.

3

The new chef makes all bakery items fresh in the morning.

06
Subway image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop offers spotless cleanliness and a welcoming atmosphere with fresh baked cookies and soft, fresh bread. Outdoor seating with small tables adds a relaxed touch. Staff provide friendly, attentive service that stands out from typical chain locations.

Fresh baked cookies come out consistently delicious and spot-on every time.

Freshest sandwiches come out fast with perfect build every time. Orders are remembered and made exactly as requested, creating a consistent experience.

People are saying

"The staff here is so friendly and welcoming, it makes the sandwich experience great."

"The staff here is so friendly, they even knew my cookie order."

"The bread here is always so fresh and soft."

Good to know

1

The Subway location is known for its cleanliness and friendly service.

2

Expect a welcoming atmosphere with attentive staff.

3

The seating area is consistently clean and well-maintained.

07
North Shore Boulangerie image 1

Medium-sized bakery with Parisian cafe design and natural light from large windows creates a cozy, neighborhood vibe where people enjoy quiet conversations without laptops. Two seating areas offer a charming atmosphere that feels like a spot in Europe. Music and energy keep the space inviting and relaxed.

Ginger cookie stands out with a strong, spicy flavor. Other cookies are delicious and match the quality of the amazing pastries.

Sandwiches come on miche bread and pair with sides like salad or tomato soup. Outdoor seating enhances the experience, especially with a tuna sandwich and drinks during lunch.

People are saying

"I loved their French toast with raspberry spread for brunch."

"The tuna sandwich on miche bread was fresh and delicious."

"I thought the ginger cookie was the best I had ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for brunch on weekends due to high demand.

2

The online menu may not accurately reflect current offerings or prices.

3

Parking can be challenging, so consider arriving early.

08
Kurt Schulz Deli & Pastry Shoppe image 1

Deli combines old school charm with a nostalgic atmosphere that feels welcoming and inclusive. Quiet spaces invite reading or studying while kids engage with classic toys like Rock Em Sock Em Robots. The place offers homemade sandwiches and pastries with a loyal lunchtime crowd despite a worn building.

Cookies come in several varieties including molasses, homemade peanut butter, and oatmeal raisin that are notably large. The bakery makes all cookies from scratch alongside donuts and other treats.

Deli sandwiches stand out with fresh and flavorful tuna and a nostalgic atmosphere. Breakfast sandwiches and a unique beer selection add to the variety.

People are saying

"The pastries here are outstanding and out of this world."

"The sandwiches here feel like home, thanks to the warm owner."

"The cookies here are awesome with nice crunchy bread."

Good to know

1

Half-price deli salads are available on Saturdays.

2

The shop closes at 3:00 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

3

The bakery offers fresh donuts made by the owner on Saturday mornings.

09
SmallPie image 1

Small cafe with cute indoor and outdoor seating, including a covered patio surrounded by plants for sale. Atmosphere feels relaxed and inviting, with a quiet outdoor area that welcomes dogs. The space offers a charming, neighborhood vibe ideal for casual stops.

Cookies come in massive, soft, and dense varieties like the toffee cookie. Options include double chocolate and lemon poppyseed, with some chocolate chip cookies available too.

Sandwiches feature interesting combinations like cheddar and apple or blueberry turkey. Options include breakfast sandwiches and a bacon biscuit sandwich that stands out for flavor.

People are saying

"I found the pies here to be so delicious."

"I loved the blueberry turkey sandwich; it became my favorite."

"The chocolate chip and toffee cookies were great."

Good to know

1

Parking can be challenging in the area, so plan accordingly.

2

Hand pies are priced at $10 each, which may be considered expensive.

3

SmallPie is dog-friendly, allowing pets on the outdoor seating.

10
Simply Cinnamon Bakery image 1

Warm aroma of freshly baked goods fills a small space with no indoor seating, encouraging quick grab-and-go visits. Popular items include homemade cinnamon rolls with balanced sweetness and honey-glazed ham known for rich flavor. Rustic decor adds a cozy touch despite limited dining options.

Selection features cinnamon rolls, holiday cookies, and pumpkin spice treats. Cookies, bars, and flatbreads all taste delicious.

Breakfast sandwiches feature bacon, egg, and cheese combinations. Opinions vary, with some finding them excellent and others rating them as sub-par.

People are saying

"These cinnamon rolls have amazing frosting and aren't too dense."

"The hot ham and rolls were the best I've ever had."

"I'll definitely be returning for more of their fantastic cinnamon rolls."

Good to know

1

To enjoy the Sunday ham, arrive early to avoid it selling out before noon.

2

Customers need to grab and go since there is no indoor seating available.

3

The cinnamon rolls are prepackaged and priced very reasonably.

11
National Bakery & Deli | West – Brookfield image 1

Cozy bakery with fresh-made goods and a quiet atmosphere. Early arrival is key to find the best selection, including custom decorated cakes and renowned Pączki. Offers a traditional vibe with fair pricing and a century-long presence.

Cookies here have a nostalgic, childhood feel. They include Brewers jersey cookies and pair well with pumpkin pie.

Sandwiches here have a nostalgic taste that reminds of childhood. The ham sandwich stands out as a quick lunch option alongside fresh bakery items.

People are saying

"I found this bakery to be delicious and second to none."

"I thought their cakes were fantastic and delicious."

"I thought the cookies were wonderful."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but arriving early is recommended for the best selection.

2

The bakery offers a variety of breads, pastries, and deli meats.

3

Expect limited availability of ham salad, especially early in the day.

12
Casera Cafe & Bakery image 1

Bright, spacious cafe with natural lighting and indoor-outdoor seating creates a calm, relaxing atmosphere. The space feels open and well-curated, suitable for working alone or socializing. Attention to detail and friendly vibe make it welcoming and enjoyable.

A sea salt cookie stands out with a flavor that hooks you instantly. Watching bakers through the window while enjoying a hot chocolate and this cookie adds to the experience.

Baked bread comes out supple yet crisp, making sandwiches stand out. Options include the Melt Beef, Chicken BLT, and Millie Cheesesteak**, all well made with attentive service checking in on orders.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the coffee; it was perfectly made."

"I was hooked on that sea salt cookie."

"The sandwiches here are excellent and mouth-watering."

Good to know

1

The food side of the kitchen closes an hour before the cafe closes.

2

They provide super strong WiFi, making it a good spot for work.

3

Expect a long line on weekends, especially around noon.

13
Grebe's Bakery image 1

Small, old-fashioned bakery with a classic American donut shop vibe and cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Regulars come early for fresh, highly praised donuts and ham and rolls, which sell out quickly. The setup resembles a deli with counter service and a 4th generation family-owned tradition since 1923.

Smile cookies stand out with a long history of popularity. Other notable treats include Sentry cookies and hard rolls, all consistently enjoyable.

Sandwiches come with a fluffy bun and are not greasy. Options include custom sliced sandwiches around $6.50 and a bacon egg and cheese variety that stands out.

People are saying

"I thought the donuts here were amazing."

"The sandwiches here are super yummy and not greasy."

"I enjoyed their amazing smile cookies."

Good to know

1

Grebe's Bakery closes at 3:00 PM every day.

2

The bakery is usually busy, with a line forming by 7 AM.

3

Arrive early to get the best items, as they sell out quickly.

14
Gather Bakehouse | Bay View image 1

Bakery space feels plain and dark with a full-blown espresso machine inside. Atmosphere suits an upper-class clientele with limited selection but high-quality croissants and cheese pockets. Energy is calm, focusing on fancy cakes and vegan options.

Large, moist cranberry-white chocolate cookies stand out here. The cookies generally pair well with croissants and other baked goods.

Offers vegan sandwiches and hot ham rolls on Sundays. Sandwiches include options like the Canfora Chop and come with locally made sides such as tots and lumpia. To-go sandwiches provide a quick and tasty lunch option.

People are saying

"I thought the donuts here were the best in town."

"I loved the cookies; they were perfection."

"The vegan hot ham sandwich reminded me of childhood."

Good to know

1

The ham and rolls are only available on Sundays.

2

Parking may be tricky during events like the Milwaukee Marathon.

3

Vegan items, including sandwiches, are available during Vegan Dining Week.

15
Potbelly image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop offers a laid back atmosphere with a spacious dining area and warm environment. Customers appear happy, enjoying fresh ingredients and a variety of sandwiches and salads.

Oatmeal chocolate chip cookies come out slightly crisp outside and chewy inside. They pair well with drinks like cherry coke or a cup of chili.

Great sandwiches come with a fresh, tasty vibe and a healthy side. The vegetarian options stand out as excellent and consistently good.

People are saying

"Alik makes the best sandwich; he's my guy."

"I found the healthy foods here to be fresh and tasty."

"The cookie is slightly crisp on the outside and chewy inside."

Good to know

1

Parking is available at the mall with easy access to Potbelly.

2

Expect to spend around $18 for a sub, chips, and a drink.

3

Credit cards are accepted for payment.

Discover more

Wisconsin

Area guide
Loading Map...