Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

American ice cream in Wisconsin

Made for those who believe a meal of American classics is incomplete without a serving of ice cream.

Based on 653 Opinions
+650
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Fitzy's Cafe image 1
Fitzy's Cafe image 2
Fitzy's Cafe image 3
View all

Modern take on an old school pharmacy soda fountain with a clean art deco vibe and plenty of seating creates a bright, cozy atmosphere. Space feels welcoming and elegant, suitable for socializing or working quietly. Unique view of a pharmacy from inside adds to the distinct character.

Grilled cheese with avocado stands out as a consistent favorite and is served with care. Avocado toast, hot chocolate, and warmed chocolate chip cookies also feature as notable American comfort foods here.

Malt ice cream with chocolate chunks stands out as a unique flavor here. The ice cream selection includes a couple of other distinctive flavors that pair well with coffee or tea.

People are saying

"Their coffee and specialty lattes are made with exceptional care and attention to detail."

"I tried the ice cream, and it was worth the calories."

"The American Food here is great, and the staff is so friendly."

Good to know

1

Lunch costs approximately $20 per person with large portions.

2

Tips are cash only at Fitzy's Cafe.

3

The new chef makes all bakery items fresh in the morning.

02
바위 Bawi Korean BBQ Mequon image 1
Korean barbecue restaurant

Korean barbecue restaurant with built-in grills at each table and strong ventilation to manage smoke. Atmosphere is inviting and calm, often featuring unique market products in a mini mart at the back. Music adds to the vibe while guests grill their own meat using stainless steel plates and cups.

New York strip stands out as a highlight with its rich flavor. Crispy fried chicken wings and cheese corn dogs also feature prominently, alongside various bulgogi options and unmarinated pork belly.

Finishing meals with Melona ice cream or the moon pie ice cream dessert is common here. The ice cream options add a sweet touch to the dining experience.

People are saying

"The food here was amazing and very fresh."

"The New York strip and fried chicken wings are amazing."

"You have to save room for the moon pie and melona ice cream."

Good to know

1

The all-you-can-eat meat costs $40 per person, excluding drinks.

2

Expect long wait times on Friday nights and weekends during dinner.

3

Bawi Korean BBQ offers unique items like yellow radish at their all-you-can-eat service.

03
Leon's Frozen Custard image 1

Classic roadside custard stand with vintage 1950s neon signage and a nostalgic diner vibe. Atmosphere feels casual and homey, often enjoyed outside in a parking lot setting with friends and family. Known for best-in-area frozen custard, especially butter pecan and blue moon flavors.

Spanish hamburgers stand out with a seasoned, sloppy-joe-style flavor similar to loose meat or made-rite burgers. Hot dogs and sloppy joes also feature as hot dishes alongside fresh custard.

Creaminess stands out in the ice cream here, especially in the butter pecan and maple nut flavors. The ice cream is not too sweet, making it smooth and enjoyable for a quiet afternoon.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was the best I've ever had."

"This place is a nostalgic classic, just like I remember it."

"You've got to try the Spanish hamburgers; they're seasoned and sloppy-joe-style."

Good to know

1

Parking might be tricky because it can get pretty busy.

2

Expect long lines, but wait times are usually short.

3

There is no inside seating; enjoy your treat outside.

04
Golden Gyros image 1
Fast food restaurant

Fast food spot with drive-thru only service and cash-only payments. Outdoor seating includes a few picnic tables exposed to weather. Known for large portions and generous gyros with toasted buns and flavorful meat.

Cheeseburgers come fresh and need to be eaten right away. The fried chicken sandwich tastes somewhat greasy. Prices run over $7 for a plain cheeseburger.

Cherry cheesecake flavor stands out as a top choice. The owner makes the ice cream extra special and the quality remains amazing despite other menu changes.

People are saying

"The food here is top-tier and never disappoints."

"I experienced the best American food gyros I've ever had."

"I thought the ice cream here was the best I had."

Good to know

1

Cash is the only accepted payment method; an ATM is available on site.

2

Golden Gyros has no dine-in option and is drive-through only.

3

Portions are large and offer good value for the price.

05
Gilles Frozen Custard image 1
Dessert restaurant

Small ice cream shop with an old carhop vibe and nostalgic atmosphere that feels like stepping back in time. Busy and cozy space offers both indoor and outdoor seating, creating a classic ice cream shop energy. Known for being a local staple with a friendly, welcoming environment.

Sloppy Joe and grilled cheese stand out as solid choices. The double cheeseburger meal often comes with just one slice of cheese and melted mayo, making it a bit messy.

Classic frozen custard serves up big servings made with real ingredients and no fake stuff. Options include rich flavors like Butter Pecan and Chocolate Oreo, often paired with brownies and fudge.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be delicious and great."

"The ice cream here is creamy, flavorful, and just a little bit of heaven."

"The American food's custard is seriously amazing and not that sweet."

Good to know

1

Gilles Frozen Custard has been in business since 1938, showcasing their experience.

2

Catering services are available for events, accommodating up to 150 people.

3

Parking is plentiful, even during busy times like Saturday nights.

06
Georgie Porgie's Treefort Restaurant - Oak Creek image 1

Indoor space centers on a charming treehouse with memorabilia tables that double as display cases. Atmosphere feels family-friendly and kid-oriented, lively and sometimes noisy when busy. Outdoor seating includes covered and uncovered patios, adding seasonal variety.

Hamburgers stand out with options like a tasty cheeseburger and a solid patty melt. The Mac and cheese chicken sandwich on a pretzel bun offers a unique twist. Kids find the burger and corn dog bites enjoyable.

Large selection of ice cream desserts stands out, with options to buy and take home. Samples highlight the yummy flavors, and medium cups with nuts and toppings offer a filling treat for all ages.

People are saying

"I thought their burgers were the best in the city."

"Their ice cream is delicious and a star attraction."

"The American Food here, especially the burgers, is really tasty."

Good to know

1

Car shows occur regularly on Saturday nights across the street from the restaurant.

2

Expect a 40-minute wait during busy hours for food orders.

3

The restaurant does not offer table service; customers must pick up their orders.

07
Bubba's Frozen Custard image 1
Fast food restaurant

Fast food restaurant with an old school vibe and immaculate dining room offers a fun, warm atmosphere where people feel at home. The place stands out for being super kid friendly and maintaining cleanliness consistently.

Chili cheese fries stand out with a strong reputation and great taste. Burgers come in large sizes with high-quality buns and toppings like brown mustard and pickles. Hot dogs include Chicago style and Texas style, both noted for their flavor.

Scoops come in consistent portions whether one or two are ordered. Ice cream often arrives partially melted in a cone. The menu pairs ice cream with hamburgers and curly fries.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers here were juicy and delicious."

"I'll keep coming back for the great American food, especially the chili cheese fries."

"I really enjoyed the delicious ice cream here."

Good to know

1

The Fat Elvis burger is available only during the week of January 8th.

2

Cheese curds are priced at $7, and missing items can add to your bill.

3

Free fountain refills are available, making it a great value.

08
IVR Restaurant & Bar image 1

Space combines contemporary and retro design with an upscale bar area and modern industrial dining room. Atmosphere feels cool and lively, with many TVs showing sports and a spacious patio for warmer days. Cocktails stand out alongside diverse Indian-inspired dishes.

Chicken nachos come with naan bread giving a unique twist and a pita chip texture. Buffalo wings are classic with no Indian flavors added.

Mango ice cream stands out with a rich, fruity flavor. It pairs well with savory dishes like Chicken Malia Tikka.

People are saying

"The food here is flavorful, unique, and delicious."

"I loved the American food; the pizza was full of flavor."

"You have to try the mango ice cream, it's so yummy!"

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers different deals daily, including cocktails and food pairings.

2

On certain nights, four different $5 martinis are available with entree orders.

3

The happy hour includes two tacos for free with a cocktail purchase.

09
A&W Restaurant image 1
Fast food restaurant

Retro diner style with table service and classic booths creates a vintage atmosphere reminiscent of the 1950s. The dining room feels clean and spacious, offering a relaxed and cozy vibe. Regulars enjoy affordable breakfast and fresh burgers in a setting that blends nostalgia with comfort.

Hamburgers stand out with solid flavor. Mini-corn dogs offer a fun snack option. The root beer floats come tall, overflowing, and served with ice cream on the side.

Root beer floats come with rich and creamy ice cream served on the side. Large vanilla shakes sometimes arrive with a lot of melted ice cream in a big cup.

People are saying

"I thought the fast food burger was juicy and full of flavor."

"The American Food here, especially the root beer floats, is wonderful."

"The root beer floats with creamy ice cream are a classic treat."

Good to know

1

Breakfast is served until noon, making it a great morning option.

2

Expect quick service with an average wait time of 10 minutes.

3

Prices are generally affordable, with meals costing around $16.

10
Murf's Frozen Custard & Jumbo Burgers image 1

Small dining space combines with a lively, all-American atmosphere and friendly smiles. Burgers are large and flavorful, often topped with a fried egg, while frozen custard stands out as a local favorite. Patio seating offers a pleasant alternative to the cozy, sometimes crowded indoor area.

Grilled cheese features classic Velveeta cheese and hits the spot. Cheeseburgers come big as your head and taste solid. Cajun grilled chicken sandwich offers a flavorful twist.

Frozen custard stands out with its creamy texture and rich flavor. The ice cream pairs well with burgers and sometimes comes with extras like fries or even free servings during long waits.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"The jumbo burgers here are massive and juicy."

"The ice cream here is especially good."

Good to know

1

Expect a 25-minute wait for pick-up orders of two burgers.

2

The restaurant can get very crowded, especially during busy hours.

3

Prices have increased, but the quality of food has declined.

11
Big Deal Burgers & Custard image 1
American restaurant

Huge space with spacious seating and great outside area offers a lively, inviting atmosphere where people gather for card and board games. Interior shows signs of wear with rundown booths and dim lighting, creating a warm but somewhat dated vibe. Drive-thru service adds convenience to the casual, energetic setting.

Huge hamburgers stand out here, including a Bacon cheeseburger that impresses. The coleslaw is very delicious, and shakes, custard, and malts complement the classic American menu.

Large topping portions highlight the ice cream, especially the banana split. Options include pints, and the ice cream pairs well with burgers for a solid treat.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers here were among the best I ever had."

"I loved their American Food burgers and yummy onion rings."

"I loved the ice cream and the food here."

Good to know

1

Drive-through fish fry happens every Friday evening.

2

Expect long wait times during busy Friday nights.

3

The meal costs under $10, offering good value.

12
B52 Bombers , Gyro and frozen custard image 1

Plane-themed decor with model aircrafts lining the walls creates a unique setting. Atmosphere is quiet and simple, sometimes noisy at peak hours, with a vibe between fast food and aviation memorial. Offers outside seating and a casual place to watch sports.

Cheeseburgers stand out for their consistent quality and flavor. The menu also features Philly cheesesteak, Chicago hot dogs, gyros, and frozen custard, covering classic American comfort foods.

A large selection of ice cream and custard is available, including a blue moon ice cream shake that is bright blue. Strawberries sometimes get added to ice cream, tasting like strawberry ice cream even though strawberry flavor is not sold.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be fresh, tasty, and great."

"The American food, especially the cheeseburger, was excellent."

"The ice cream here is delicious and very good."

Good to know

1

Breakfast starts at 7 AM daily.

2

The restaurant offers a daily seniors menu with combo options.

3

Prices are affordable, with good quality food.

13
Ted's Ice Cream & Restaurant image 1
American restaurant

Classic diner with red and white decor and M-shaped seating creates a vintage, family-oriented vibe. Small, cozy space features a retro counter with swivel stools encouraging interaction. Atmosphere feels nostalgic and fun, standing out from trendier spots nearby.

Breakfast includes classic eggs over medium, crispy bacon, hash browns, and toast served with black coffee in a ceramic cup. Grilled cheese sandwiches come with minimal cheese and bacon, paired with cheese curds and root beer.

Old-fashioned ice cream parlor vibe with a small, cute interior. Ice cream quality varies, with some batches being incredibly good and others having soggy fruit pieces.

People are saying

"It's a fun, nostalgic place with an old school diner feel."

"It's got this cool, old-school ice cream parlor vibe."

"I love their classic American diner breakfast with eggs, bacon, and hash browns."

Good to know

1

The menu features typical diner items, including a must-try fish fry.

2

Prices are reasonable, with meals averaging around $15.

3

Parking is easy and available near the restaurant.

14
Kraverz Frozen Custard image 1
Fast food restaurant

Fast food restaurant offers comfortable indoor and outdoor dining with a clean environment. Lunchtime brings a loud atmosphere with Fox News on TV adding to the background noise. Lines can extend outside during busy times, reflecting steady customer flow.

Chicago style hot dogs and Italian beef sandwiches stand out here. The menu also features grilled cheese sandwiches with deep fried mozzarella sticks and bacon, plus large pot roast sandwiches and classic cheeseburgers.

Plentiful ice cream options include a flavor of the day. The ice cream tastes like prepackaged custard and pairs with burgers and fries.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was really tasty and top-notch."

"I thought the American Food, especially the grilled cheese, was the best ever."

"The ice cream here was pretty good."

Good to know

1

On Thursdays, their special is the pot roast sandwich.

2

Kraverz has its own parking lot, making parking very convenient.

3

You order and pick up at the counter, but the food is prepared to order.

Discover more

Wisconsin

Area guide
Loading Map...