Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
West Allis' best

Mexican food

Mexican food that prioritizes traditional recipes over the usual heavy-handed adaptations.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
ODB's Classy Dive image 1
ODB's Classy Dive image 2
ODB's Classy Dive image 3
View all

Small space with multiple seating areas including an outdoor patio with fire pit creates a cozy setting. Music plays loudly, often featuring a DJ, contributing to a chill dive bar vibe with a classy touch. Younger crowd enjoys craft cocktails and a menu of flavorful, homemade dishes.

Food comes in large portions with big flavor and uses fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Dishes are cooked to perfection and offer a varied menu with consistently high quality.

Birria Short Rib Nachos come in massive portions with incredible flavor. Tortillas get fried to order, and the short rib birria sandwich stands out for its rich taste.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was delicious and homemade."

"The bar staff here are amazing and make you feel like family."

"You have to try the Mexican food; the short rib birria is amazing."

Good to know

1

Wing night offers $1 wings every Wednesday.

2

Industry night features special discounts for service workers on Mondays.

3

The menu includes homemade sauces and dishes priced between $15 and $20.

02
Gus' Deli image 1
Restaurant

Hole-in-the-wall eatery with dim lighting and walls covered in punk and grunge memorabilia creates a warm, friendly vibe. Spacious and clean interior feels more like a club than a traditional deli. Full bar and cooler with drinks add to the relaxed atmosphere.

Food comes out fresh and made to order with excellent quality. Staff greet everyone like friends and prepare meals exactly how you want them.

Generous portions stand out with a $15 chorizo burrito as big as a forearm. The cilantro and chorizo breakfast burrito and perfectly done quesadilla highlight strong flavors. Enchiladas come in hearty servings, enough for lunch the next day.

People are saying

"The Greek food here, especially the gyro, is huge and delicious."

"The food here, especially the gyro, is huge and fantastic."

"This Mexican food is massive; you'll take half home."

Good to know

1

Gus' Deli closes at 2 PM on days other than Friday.

2

Gus' Deli is tucked away in an office building, making it difficult to find.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but cash is preferred for smaller purchases.

03
Romero’s Taco Truck West Allis Wi image 1

Food truck offers quesabirria tacos, pastor tacos, and quesadilla pizza with fresh salsas and flavorful meats. Atmosphere is casual and busy, especially during events where service stays efficient. Prices remain reasonable, making it a popular spot for groups and gatherings.

Food comes out hot, fresh, and of amazing quality. Service handles large groups smoothly with no long waits, and the staff is notably nice and attentive.

Tacos come with four meats and all the fixings, served quickly even at large events. The pastor and birria tacos stand out for their amazing flavor, and the friendly staff adds to the experience.

People are saying

"These birria tacos are delicious and have great flavor."

"The food here is authentic and flavorful, especially the tacos."

"I loved the birria tacos; they were so delicious."

Good to know

1

This taco truck is great for larger events, serving over 50 people efficiently.

2

I paid $15 per plate for the entire menu, which is reasonably priced.

3

The tacos cost about $8 for three tacos, which is a good deal.

04
Schotskis West Allis image 1

Bar offers a casual, homey atmosphere with fun movies playing and a joyful vibe. It stays quiet most days but fills up during live music and special events. Taco Tuesday stands out as a popular draw.

Food here is consistently excellent and tasty. Dishes come out delicious and satisfying every time.

Tacos stand out here, especially on Taco Tuesday with steak tacos that get a lot of attention. The chef treats taco making like a science, crafting each one with care and pairing them with sides like Puerto Rican rice and corn soup.

People are saying

"You gotta try the tacos on Taco Tuesday."

"You have to try the tacos; they're amazing."

"The food, especially the tacos, is amazing and perfect."

Good to know

1

Karaoke night happens every Thursday with DJ Drew starting at 10pm.

2

Expect a lively atmosphere during karaoke nights with a regular crowd.

3

The venue can get busy on weekends and during live music events.

05
Brass Monkey Pub image 1

Pub offers large outdoor patio and spacious indoor seating with a lively, noisy atmosphere driven by bingo, karaoke, darts, and billiards. Crowd is social and energetic, making it unsuitable for quiet conversations. Music and games create a busy, casual, and sometimes chaotic vibe.

Food comes out hot and features unique recipes with a greasy but tasty profile. Burgers stand out as particularly sensational and well worth the price.

Tacos stand out with beef, fish, and fried shrimp options cooked well. Chimichangas also come out amazing and pair well with the taco specials on Tuesdays and Fridays.

People are saying

"The fish fry here is light, crispy, and very fresh."

"The food here is fantastic, especially the fish fry."

"I loved the tacos; they were fried perfectly."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Tuesday at 8pm with a $5 entry fee.

2

Music bingo takes place on Tuesday nights, offering a fun game experience.

3

Karaoke starts at 10pm on Thursdays with a two-drink minimum.

06
McCoco's | The Best Caribbean Family Restaurant & catering image 1

Caribbean restaurant offers a fun atmosphere with phenomenal live music and a beautiful back patio. The space features island-themed decor and TVs showing island views, creating a welcoming vibe. Guests enjoy refreshing mojitos and authentic dishes like mofongo and empanadas.

Offers authentic Caribbean, Central, and South American cuisine with consistently delicious food and great service.

Tacos come with delicious sides and a notable salsa Verde that adds flavor. Chicken tacos stay consistently delicious across visits.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious."

"These empanadas are absolutely perfect, the best I've ever had."

"The Mexican food here is delicious, especially the tacos."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.

2

Expect long wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

The restaurant adds an automatic gratuity for parties of two or more.

07
Caribbean Jaacs image 1
Jamaican restaurant

Small restaurant with vibrant decor and comfortable indoor and outdoor seating creates a lively atmosphere with loud TV and friendly energy. Locally run spot offers authentic Jamaican flavors with standout dishes like jerk chicken and oxtail, attracting those seeking genuine Caribbean cuisine.

Food here is consistently delicious with excellent presentation and great service. The menu includes exclusive dishes brought by the owner to try out.

Tacos here come with sweet, tangy flavors and unique twists like Caribbean jerk and spicy shrimp options. Dishes like ox tails and curry chicken add variety, with about a 16-minute wait time.

People are saying

"This food blew me away; it was seriously great."

"The Seafood here had me nodding my head like I was in church."

"The jerk chicken here is smoky, flavorful, and perfectly seasoned."

Good to know

1

The oxtail platter comes with two sides for $28.

2

Expect no long waits during peak hours.

3

Portion sizes are large and generally good for the price.

08
La Salsa 2 | West Allis image 1
Mexican restaurant

Small space blends Mexican and diner style with a comfortable, lively atmosphere. Menu offers authentic dishes including rare breakfast options and flavorful tacos. Drinks feature tasty margaritas that balance flavor without being too strong.

Food arrives fast and stays very tasty without being greasy or old. Staff ensures quick service and keeps the experience excellent.

Soft corn tortillas hold seasoned pork with cilantro and onion in the pork tacos. Enchiladas come in mole and guacamole styles, both rich and flavorful. Chips and salsa have a good kick, and margaritas are tasty and mild, fitting for lunch.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was delicious and incredible."

"The salsa here is incredible, like a fiesta in my mouth."

"I thought the Mexican food here was delicious."

Good to know

1

The menu offers a variety of traditional Mexican dishes and combos.

2

Prices are reasonable, with most items around $10-$15.

3

Expect a casual atmosphere with no dress code.

09
Las Cazuelas Chilaquiles & Taco Bar image 1

Modern Mexican restaurant offers a welcoming atmosphere with large TV screens showing music performances and sports. Music plays at a comfortable volume, creating a fun yet relaxed vibe. The space feels clean and attractive, drawing in fans of Mexican cuisine and casual dining.

Offers authentic Mexican cuisine with consistently delicious and tasty dishes. The food stands out for its genuine flavors and excellent quality.

Chilaquiles stand out with a large variety of sauces and authentic flavors. The menu features genuine Mexican cuisine including excellent pork dishes and margaritas, all served with friendly service.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was delicious."

"The housemade salsas are bold and worth sampling."

"The Mexican food here is delicious, especially the chilaquiles."

Good to know

1

The establishment adds a 3% surcharge for non-cash payments.

2

Happy hour offers $5 margaritas and beers from 11 am to 6 pm on weekdays.

3

Taco Tuesday features $2.50 tacos all day long.

10
Manny's bourbon grill and pub image 1

Patio with firepit and live DJ sets a casual, lively vibe that grows more energetic in the evening. The space feels open and friendly, welcoming a mix of guests who enjoy varied music styles. Reasonable prices complement the locally owned, family-run atmosphere.

Food features delicious and fresh-tasting dishes with a focus on steak chimichangas that stand out for their flavor. The menu consistently delivers excellent quality and pairs well with drinks in a lively atmosphere.

Steak chimichangas offer a strong steak flavor despite being deep-fried. Birria tacos and Quesibirria Tacos stand out as scrumptious options priced around $13.00 each.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and perfectly balanced."

"The staff made my son super happy and felt very welcomed."

"I loved the spicy garlic wings, they were perfectly cooked."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers dollar rail drinks from 4-6pm on weekdays.

2

The menu lists tacos at $13, with extra charges for meat.

3

Expect a 30-minute wait for food during peak hours.

11
Al Pastor image 1
Restaurant

House-style setting with outdoor seating and festive decor creates a quiet, welcoming atmosphere that suits friends or dates. Rap music plays nearby, adding an urban edge to the vibe. Space feels roomy inside with clean, inviting design.

Mexican food here is consistently delicious and reasonably priced. The menu features great dishes paired with pineapple margaritas that complement the flavors well.

Authentic tacos shine here, including birria and carne asada nachos that stand out for flavor and quality. Homemade salsa, flavorful mole, and pineapple margaritas complement the tasty Mexican dishes.

People are saying

"The Mexican food here is always delicious and flavorful."

"I loved the pastor tacos with that pineapple flavor."

"I found the food here to be delicious and very flavorful."

Good to know

1

There is a 4% service charge added to the bill that is not clearly reflected on the menu.

2

Tacos cost $3.50 each, not $2.00.

3

Al Pastor has been closed during their listed hours on three separate occasions.

12
JC King’s Tortas | West Allis image 1
Mexican torta restaurant

Mexican torta restaurant offers spacious indoor seating and a small outdoor area with a cozy, clean atmosphere and great music. The place draws people who appreciate large, flavorful tortas with generous ingredients like seasoned steak and avocado. It maintains a quiet, inviting vibe suitable for enjoying a meal without rush.

Food arrives fast and fresh with great taste. Options suit a quiet setting and work well for takeout.

Massive king size tortas come with fresh lettuce, onion, avocado, and mayo. A variety of 20 tortas and tacos de canasta offer solid Mexican food options.

People are saying

"I thought the tortas were amazing and the best."

"I found the food here to be absolutely delicious."

"These tacos are bite-sized, so you'll need more than one order."

Good to know

1

Expect prices around $3 per taco, which some may find high.

2

The portions are generous, making it a good value for the price.

3

The restaurant maintains a clean environment throughout.

13
Taqueria Buenavista image 1
Mexican restaurant

Small dining space feels cramped and outdated with a neglected interior. Atmosphere is quiet and lacks entertainment, creating a subdued mood. Known for authentic Mexican food with notable birria tacos and chimichangas, it draws those seeking traditional flavors despite the modest setting.

Authentic Mexican food stands out with traditional flavors and delicious quality. The menu offers consistently amazing dishes at great prices.

Authentic Mexican food shines with birria tacos that pack rich flavor and steak chimichangas that stand out. The menu also features chicken enchiladas with flour tortillas and tortas that many find memorable.

People are saying

"The food here is always fresh, hot, and super delicious."

"I thought the Mexican food here, especially the tacos, was excellent."

"The salsa here is the real deal, just like I remember from my youth."

Good to know

1

All menu items are in Spanish without English translations.

2

Expect higher prices than those listed on the menu.

3

The portion size is generally enough for one adult.

14
Fat's image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Open space filled with lots of TVs positioned for easy viewing creates a bright, clean environment. Live music adds energy while friendly staff maintain a welcoming vibe. Burgers stand out as huge and tasty, complementing the perfectly cooked fries.

Burgers and fries stand out as excellent, cooked correctly and tasting great. Food matches the menu visuals and appeals to a wide range of tastes.

Good salsa and chips come with the meal. Mexican corn quesadillas are on the menu and get positive mentions. Prices cover a variety of dishes including quesadillas and burgers.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, fast, and delicious."

"You have to try the trash can nachos; they're huge and amazing."

"I loved the good salsa and chips here."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is clean, bright, and has amazing staff.

2

There is plenty of parking available at Fat's.

3

Fat's does not have a drink menu available.

Discover more

West Allis, Wisconsin

Area guide
Loading Map...