Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Indiana

Italian food

Italian food that reflects a specific regional tradition instead of the standard menu found at every chain restaurant.

Based on 579 Opinions
+576
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
The NY Slice image 1
The NY Slice image 2
The NY Slice image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza spot with a friendly, homey atmosphere and a quiet, welcoming vibe. One person handles all orders and cooking, creating a personalized experience. Known for authentic New York-style pizza and reasonable prices, it feels like a local favorite rather than a busy chain.

Offers authentic New York-style pizza with a taste and style that closely matches what you'd find in New York. Few places come close to this level of authenticity in the region.

Phenomenal cannoli stands out alongside pizza and garlic knots. Sliced Italian sausage adds a perfect touch to many dishes.

People are saying

"I found authentic New York style pizza here."

"I found the pizza here to be authentic New York style."

"This Italian food is the best New York style pizza I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The NY Slice is primarily a carry-out restaurant with limited dine-in options.

2

Prices are very affordable, with family meals available for around $30.

3

The restaurant is usually not busy, allowing for quick service.

02
Velly Pizza & Indian street food image 1

Space combines clean, orderly design with a calming, inviting atmosphere enhanced by good music and welcoming energy. Crowd enjoys authentic Indian-inspired pizza and street food with customizable spice levels and halal options. Setting suits quick, flavorful meals with a friendly vibe.

Authentic Punjabi street food shines here with perfectly balanced spices in the fish curry. The pizza tastes well-cooked and genuine, capturing real, authentic flavors.

Butter chicken pasta stands out with rich Indian flavors. The Tandoori Chicken Pizza and Velly style breadsticks add unique twists to classic Italian dishes.

People are saying

"I've never tasted pizza this good; it's the best I've ever had."

"I tasted authentic street food from Punjab, perfectly cooked."

"I ordered the butter chicken pasta and it was a 10/10."

Good to know

1

They offer halal options and allow you to customize the spice level.

2

The pricing is reasonable with a 2 large pizza, 3 toppings deal.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

03
Macizo Restaurant image 1

Cozy, minimalist space offers a homey, warm atmosphere with friendly, personable energy from owners. Casual, lived-in vibe contrasts with more upscale local spots. Bright, fruity cocktails and sangria complement exceptional Mexican dishes like tiradito and chorizo tacos.

Menu features authentic Mexican and Peruvian flavors that taste genuine and homemade. Dishes bring traditional South American tastes to life with a strong sense of culinary authenticity.

Sweet and spicy pasta stands out alongside exquisite spaghetti served as an appetizer. Fresh bread and focaccia come with various sauces for dipping, complementing dishes rich in beef, potatoes, and pasta.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and some of the best."

"I experienced authentic Mexican and Peruvian flavors here."

"The Italian food here is amazing, with a unique flavor."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for larger groups to ensure seating.

2

The restaurant offers a unique blend of Mexican and Peruvian cuisine.

3

Tamales are made in-house, showcasing a commitment to quality.

04
Mia pizzaria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Family-owned pizza restaurant offers New York style pizza in a cozy atmosphere with a huge TV for sports. The place serves both meat and plant-based options, with food made from scratch and handled delivery. Cleanliness and friendly staff contribute to a welcoming environment.

Crust strikes a balance between not too thin and not too thick with an authentic taste. Pizza captures the true New York-style flavor found rarely outside the city.

New York style pizza and breadsticks come with a margarine-garlic glaze on the crust and sticks. The calzone features plant-based mozzarella with a cheese pull, though the Italian sausage could be better.

People are saying

"This New York Style Pizza has a perfectly thin, flavorful crust."

"This pizza has that authentic New York-style crust."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza, is massive and delicious."

Good to know

1

They currently have a $10 lunch special that includes a slice of NY pizza, 3 breadsticks, and a 20 oz drink.

2

The restaurant is clean and well-maintained.

3

Mia Pizzaria is a family-owned local business with a focus on quality.

05
Bugambilias Mexican Cuisine image 1
Mexican restaurant

Small dining room offers a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere with colorful, festive decor and authentic character. Background features quiet Spanish music and TVs showing sports, creating a warm, welcoming vibe. Tables sit close, encouraging a lively but comfortable energy.

Flavors here are incredibly authentic with a focus on traditional Birria and other Mexican dishes. Portions come at a reasonable price while maintaining genuine taste.

Spaghetti con pollo stands out with rich flavors, while the Mexican spaghetti offers a unique twist on classic pasta. The menu also features tacos that complement the Italian dishes well.

People are saying

"I thought their Mexican food was the best I've ever had."

"The food here is authentic, delicious, and full of flavor."

"You have to try the spaghetti; it's the best I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Bugambilias is closed on Tuesdays.

2

There was hardly any parking at Bugambilias.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted, but cash is preferred for tips.

06
Rosemary & Olive Italian Restaurant image 1

Small interior with chic modern design and an art deco twist creates an intimate setting. Warm, inviting atmosphere contrasts with a high noise level due to minimal sound barriers. Outdoor seating offers a pleasant alternative for quieter dining.

Fresh ingredients create rich flavors in the dishes. Big portions deliver authentic Italian tastes with a genuine vibe throughout.

Rigatoni Bolognese has a scrumptious look and is described as fantastic by those who tried it. Pesto gnocchi with chicken delivers impactful flavor and stands out on the menu.

People are saying

"The Dinner Spots here are authentic Italian with huge portions."

"The Italian food, especially the pasta, was perfectly tender and flavorful."

"The food tastes fresh and has authentic Italian flavors."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially during busy hours.

2

Expect a wait if visiting during peak dining times.

3

The restaurant participates in Devour Downtown with special menus.

07
Tony's Italian Deli image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian deli with an immaculate layout and a warm, homey atmosphere creates a sense of community. Family-owned vibe welcomes guests with authentic Italian offerings and fresh sandwiches. Cleanliness and attention to detail stand out throughout the space.

Cannoli here matches what you'd find in Italy. The meatball sandwich tastes like homemade, and the deli stocks authentic Italian ingredients for cooking at home.

Cannolis stand out as authentic and better than many in major Italian neighborhoods. The Italian sausage and ricotta cheese are also top quality, making sandwiches and stuffed shells worth trying.

People are saying

"I loved the huge, flavorful Italian beef sandwich."

"I thought the Italian food's cannoli were the freshest, crunchiest, and tastiest."

"The authentic Italian beef and sausage here is amazing."

Good to know

1

Tony's Italian Deli opens at 11 am on weekdays.

2

Tony's Italian Deli opens at 10 am on weekends.

3

The restrooms and dining area are clean.

08
Petos Greek Grill&Pasta image 1
Greek restaurant

Greek restaurant with authentic atmosphere and modern, artistic decor offers spacious interior and outdoor seating with umbrellas. The vibe is cozy and inviting, often filled with friendly, family-owned warmth. Acoustics can be challenging, but the setting feels like a real Greek tavern with local music.

Greek dishes come with fresh ingredients and authentic flavors. The menu features lamp chops, Greek salad, and lemon rice soup made from scratch.

Seafood pastas and Santorini pasta stand out with fresh, flavorful ingredients. The tiramisu is made fresh daily and complements the meal well.

People are saying

"The gyros here are traditional and amazingly delicious."

"The Greek food here is so authentic and homemade."

"The seafood pastas here were delicious and outstanding."

Good to know

1

Call for reservations for 6 or more people is highly recommended.

2

I had difficulty finding parking in the Artsy Pedestrian-Friendly neighborhood.

3

Expect high prices for small portions.

09
Brooklyn Char image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small space with limited seating and a laid-back vibe creates a casual, echoey atmosphere. The place focuses on carry-out service, attracting those seeking authentic New York-style pizza with a thin crust and high-quality ingredients.

Pizza features a crust with authentic East Coast NY swag and delivers authentic East Coast pizza flavors. It matches the style of New York pizza closely.

Stuffed breadsticks come soft and buttery, loaded with delicious cheese and baked to perfection, served with marinara sauce. Garlic knots have the right amount of garlic and fresh parmesan, while mozzarella rolls add another tasty option.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was fantastic, the best I've had."

"The pizza here has an incredible flavor and a perfect crust."

"I found the pizza here to be as close to authentic New York as you can get."

Good to know

1

It is recommended to order ahead due to limited seating.

2

The restaurant is small with only about 20 seats available.

3

Brooklyn Char is primarily a carry-out place.

10
Portofino image 1
Italian restaurant

Small, intimate setting with dim lighting and comfy booths creates a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels distinctly Italian. Quiet and cozy energy suits those seeking a high-end, relaxed dining experience without rush. Reservation-only policy ensures tables are held for the night, enhancing the unhurried vibe.

Small setting serves excellent Italian food with a true culinary experience. Dishes deliver authentic flavors consistently.

Osso buco comes out fall-off-the-bone tender and the pappardelle Bolognese is rich and hearty. Standouts include baked fontina, Quattro formaggio pasta, crab and salmon roulade, cannoli, and an incredible risotto.

People are saying

"The handmade pasta dishes are cooked to perfection."

"The food and wine here were incredible."

"The food here is outstanding and truly authentic Italian."

Good to know

1

Dinner is reservation only, especially on weekends.

2

Opting for the 5-course tasting menu allows full experience of the culinary offerings.

3

Asking the server for wine pairing recommendations is advised, as they are experts.

11
Magoo's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy, clean space with a family-friendly atmosphere and thoughtful design creates a welcoming environment. Casual vibe suits relaxed evenings with friends or family. Known for homemade pizza featuring unusual toppings and standout wings, it offers a fresh alternative to typical pizza spots.

Gourmet style pizzas deliver an authentic taste that stands apart from typical chains. Top quality ingredients create a flavor profile that feels genuine and distinct.

Lasagna stands out with its exceptional flavor and consistent quality. Mozzarella sticks and cheese breadsticks offer classic sides, though the sticks sometimes taste like old freezer items.

People are saying

"This pizza is so tasty with an amazing cheese pull."

"I found the pizza to have a top quality, authentic taste."

"The Italian food here, especially the lasagna, is really good."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of 20-30 minutes during busy dinner hours.

2

Parking is available on-site, but it can fill up quickly during weekends.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

12
Sangiovese Ristorante image 1
Food and drink

Cozy restaurant with a classy, hip vibe and lively atmosphere featuring music and bustling street views. Indoor seating can be loud and crowded, while outdoor tables offer a quieter setting. Semi-private room available for larger groups adds flexibility.

Food tastes like it comes straight from Italy with authentic Italian dishes that deliver wonderful flavors.

Lasagna stands out with rich layers and above-average flavor. The cannoli and tiramisu are both delicious, with the cannoli especially surprising in quality. Pasta dishes like Spaghetti Shrimp Diavlo offer a perfect amount of spice.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is great, and the staff makes you feel welcome."

"The Italian food here is amazing, especially the lasagna."

"I tasted authentic Italian food that made me feel like I was in Italy."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends to avoid long wait times.

2

Half-price wine is available on Mondays, making it a great day to visit.

3

Expect a wait for food during peak hours, especially on Fridays.

13
Amore! Italian Kitchen image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers a warm, relaxing atmosphere with old Italian charm and Edison bulb lighting. The vibe is calm and friendly, filling up without feeling crowded, though it can get loud. Live music and a thoughtful playlist add to the experience.

Food features authentic Italian dishes with fresh ingredients and a clear focus on homemade flavors.

Roast Pork Ragu stands out with rich flavors. Lasagna comes with a sweet sauce that pairs well with the homemade marinara, which is rich and flavorful.

People are saying

"The Italian food service here is fantastic and makes it an experience."

"The cannoli here are huge and delicious."

"The authentic Italian food here is outstanding and drenched in homemade love."

Good to know

1

On Tuesdays, wine is half price and there are specials on bolognese.

2

Wednesdays feature live music at the restaurant.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially on busy nights.

14
Fiori Italian image 1
Restaurant

Elegant interior with gorgeous decor and fireplace seating creates a pleasant, artistic atmosphere. The vibe is calm and perfect for date nights, featuring a cute outdoor area. Drinks include expertly crafted cocktails and well-paired wines, enhancing the overall experience.

Italian dishes show authentic flavors and traditional preparation. The chef's personal interaction and humor add a genuine Italian touch to the experience.

Pasta dishes feature perfectly cooked noodles with sauces that have depth and a mild kick. Veal piccata stands out as a notably well-prepared option.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta, is super yummy and cooked perfectly."

"The ribs here are meaty and tender, a top-tier dining experience."

"The food here is so authentic and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for large parties to ensure proper accommodation.

2

The restaurant allows outside cakes for special occasions with no additional fee.

3

Expect small portion sizes relative to the high prices charged.

15
Bella Pizzeria - Noblesville image 1

Small footprint restaurant offers New York-style pizza with perfectly cooked crust and large portions. Atmosphere feels casual and clean, with a fast-paced service style. Early closing and limited late options shape the dining patterns.

Authentic NY pizza arrives in a box that matches the real deal. Some find it tasty and similar to New York style, while others feel it does not match the authentic experience.

Fresh and flavorful pasta dishes come with various toppings beyond traditional spaghetti sauce. The pizza and pepperoni breadsticks stand out, and the cannolis offer a sweet finish.

People are saying

"I found Bella Pizzeria's New York Style Pizza to be the closest to authentic."

"The Italian food here, especially the pizza, is delicious and reasonably priced."

"I finally found authentic NY pizza that tastes like home."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted; call ahead for availability.

2

Expect limited menu options close to closing time due to early shutdown.

3

Combo meals are priced around $9, offering good value.

16
Da Blue Lagoon: Jamaican Kitchen image 1

Cozy space with soft reggae music and Jamaican-inspired decor creates a relaxing, homey vibe. The atmosphere feels inviting and calm, with an outdoor area that adds to the chill experience. Regulars enjoy the consistent energy and the sense of being on a mini vacation.

Jamaican dishes deliver authentic flavor with rich spices and traditional preparation. The food stays true to classic recipes, offering a genuine taste experience.

Jerk chicken Alfredo stands out with a rich, flavorful sauce that invites licking the bowl. The menu also features smoked Alfredo pasta and sides like mac & cheese, blending Italian with bold, spicy twists.

People are saying

"The Jamaican food here is amazing, especially the jerk chicken."

"The authentic Jamaican food here is amazing and packed with flavor."

"The jerk chicken Alfredo sauce was so good I was literally licking the bowl."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required but recommended during peak hours.

2

The restaurant offers a lunch special that provides good value.

3

Takeout is available, making it convenient for those on the go.

Discover more

Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...