Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Indiana's best

Cookies and pie

A craving for something sweet often lands right between a warm cookie and a slice of pie.

Based on 518 Opinions
+515
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Bakes of Carmel image 1
Bakes of Carmel image 2
Bakes of Carmel image 3
View all

Bakery showcases beautifully decorated cakes and party-ready cupcakes with buttercream icing that impress both kids and adults. Atmosphere feels festive and custom orders are handled efficiently with clear storage instructions. Dedication to quality and artistry stands out in every item.

Cookies here have a rich, perfect texture with standout flavors like double chocolate chip and red velvet. Options include chocolate chip walnut and apple pie varieties, all consistently delicious.

Apple and pecan pies stand out for their rich, nostalgic flavors. Butterscotch pie appears as a special, off-menu treat made fresh on request. Pies arrive beautifully presented and are ready on time.

People are saying

"The cake here is amazing and beautifully decorated."

"The pie here is delicious and tasted amazing."

"I found the cookies here to be rich and delicious."

Good to know

1

Bakes of Carmel can accommodate custom cake orders with short notice.

2

Cakes are packaged securely for easy transport to events.

3

They provide clear instructions on how to store and serve cakes.

02
Taylor's Bakery image 1

Bakery filled with beautiful cake creations and delicious baked goods creates a fun, clean atmosphere packed with people. Known for best cakes and donuts in the area, it draws families and special occasions consistently.

Cookies come with iced sugar decorations and custom designs for events. The chocolate chip cookie with icing in the middle stands out among the selection. Seasonal decorated cookies add variety and visual appeal.

Cherry pie stands out as a favorite, often described as the best and a nice treat. Pot pies and quiches add savory options, while pies arrive delivered safely and promptly for events. Rewards programs offer chances to get pies for free.

People are saying

"I drive 1.5 hours for their Mardi Gras King Cakes."

"These cookies and cupcakes are delicious!"

"I thought the cherry pie was the best pie I ever had."

Good to know

1

The parking situation at the 116th Street location can be problematic.

2

Expect limited stock later in the day; arrive early for best selection.

3

Taylor's Bakery does not offer gluten-free cookies.

03
Please & Thank You "INDY" image 1

Small space filled with plants and a record machine creates a hipster vibe. Atmosphere feels cool and welcoming, attracting a laid-back crowd. Limited seating and dog-friendly touches add to the cozy, casual energy.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with a chewy texture and a light crunch on the edges. Gluten-free options are exceptional and considered among the best in the region.

People are saying

"I found the chocolate chip cookies here to be amazing."

"It's a cute little cafe, really cozy and small."

"I thought their gluten-free cookies were outstanding."

Good to know

1

Parking can be difficult to find, so plan ahead.

2

Limited seating is available, especially during peak hours.

3

Outdoor seating is an option when the weather is nice.

04
FoxGardin Kitchen & Ale image 1
American restaurant

Exposed plaster, lathe, and old brickwork create an eclectic, cozy setting with heated indoor patio and rooftop dining options. The atmosphere stays laid back and inviting, suitable for conversations without raising voices. A huge full bar offers variety, drawing groups to cozy tables upstairs.

Chocolate chip cookies come hot with ice cream and often arrive as a complimentary treat on first visits. Skillet cookies also feature as a popular dessert option.

Bourbon pecan pie and key lime pie stand out as popular choices. Pies come homemade and are often recommended to save room for after meals.

People are saying

"Ben made the lamb steak sound so delicious, I had to try it."

"Ben made everything sound so delicious, I wanted to try it all."

"You should save room for the homemade pie."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially during peak hours.

2

Parking can be challenging; allow extra time to find a spot.

3

Expect longer wait times for food during busy dinner hours.

05
Café Babette image 1
Pastry shop

Pastry shop offers over 15 uniquely crafted baked goods with a simple, unadorned layout featuring old mismatched tables and no labels. Atmosphere feels laid-back and comforting with a bustling, positive energy especially on busy days. No eat-in service or coffee is available, and waiting or preordering is common due to high demand.

Cookies here stand out for their incredible taste and quality. Varieties like the sea salt chocolate chip and s'mores cookie offer rich, memorable flavors that keep people coming back.

Blueberry hand pie features a crunchy outside and soft inside with orange icing. Cherry sumac pie lacks quality compared to cheaper options. Other desserts like croissants and brownies also stand out.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be amazing and thoughtfully executed."

"I thought the cookies here were the best I have ever had."

"The blueberry hand pie is high quality and crunchy."

Good to know

1

Pre-ordering is recommended to avoid long waits on weekends.

2

Expect long lines, especially on Saturdays and holidays.

3

Arrive early to secure pastries before they sell out.

06
Pots & Pans Pie Co. image 1

Small bakery with open kitchen view and minimal seating offers a clean, cozy atmosphere highlighted by the smell of flaky pie crusts. Energy stays easygoing and welcoming, with a focus on homestyle pies sold by the slice and rotating flavors that invite frequent visits.

Shortbread chocolate chip cookies have a heavenly crust and a rich buttery flavor. Oatmeal cream pies taste like oatmeal cookies with a buttery center but lack sweetness.

Pies here come in both sweet and savory varieties with a flaky crust and creamy, smooth filling. The Beef & Mushroom pot pie stands out, and the sugar crème pie features a crème brûlée-like topping that adds a special touch.

People are saying

"I found Bruce's Lemon Pie to be the best pie I had ever had."

"I found the pastry here to be fresh and delightful."

"These cookies are the best I have ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Pie slices are available for $7 each, with whole pies starting at $13.

2

Parking is limited, so arrive early to secure a spot.

3

They offer unique pie flavors that change frequently.

07
Rise’n Roll Bakery-Schererville image 1

Corner bakery with big windows and an old school carriage inside offers a calm, welcoming atmosphere. Freshly baked donuts and pastries draw a crowd, often paired with free coffee. Seating is limited but comfortable for chatting and enjoying treats.

Freshness stands out with fresh doughnuts, cookies, and pastries available. The fry pies and cookies at the counter draw attention consistently.

Fresh pies include apple, pumpkin, and pecan varieties. The pumpkin pie stands out as especially flavorful. The pie maker consistently delivers great quality pies.

People are saying

"I thought the donuts were fresh and delicious."

"I thought the cookies were amazing and fresh."

"I found the donuts and pie to be amazing."

Good to know

1

The shop opens at six a.m.

2

They offered free coffee with a donut.

3

The cherry danishes are available only while supplies last.

08
Homemade Ice Cream & Bakery Café image 1

Cozy café with a fireplace wall and comfortable seating creates a calm, welcoming atmosphere. Guests enjoy watching cakes being decorated, adding to the relaxed vibe. Known for huge ice cream scoops and exceptional desserts, it offers a down-to-earth, low-key experience.

Sugar cookies stand out for their homemade quality and size relative to price. They often become favorites, with options like graduation cap sugar cookies adding a special touch.

Chocolate Silk Pie and Reese's pie stand out with rich, smooth textures. Pecan pie ala mode and caramel pie offer fantastic flavor with melting sugar granules and fresh apple notes. Whipped peanut butter pie feels light, almost like a cloud.

People are saying

"The cakes here are out of this world delicious."

"I found the pies, like the caramel apple, absolutely delicious."

"These homemade sugar cookies are amazing, truly the best."

Good to know

1

The café offers a lunch combo of croissant and soup for $28 before tip.

2

A bowl of soup costs nearly $8, which may not be adequate for some.

3

Expect to pay extra for gluten-free options on the menu.

Discover more

Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...